This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Remind me of the 'classy' stuff he did.? Read the game well, worked hard, made good passes, kept the ball moving, good delivery from set pieces (way better than Punch or Townsend on Saturday), good effort on goal, broke up play well and worked nicely with Ledley and McArthur.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Well that's my point,to me he is one of the eleven. He needs to impress me first to get called 'classy'. Bit harsh. Eusebio's dead.
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Read the game well, worked hard, made good passes, kept the ball moving, good delivery from set pieces (way better than Punch or Townsend on Saturday), good effort on goal, broke up play well and worked nicely with Ledley and McArthur. OK Cheers.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
OK Cheers.
Things Jedinak always struggled with. I seriously don't understand what people expect of Cabaye or why he is judged as he is. In terms of the way he looks after the ball and makes his interceptions, he offers something we don't have otherwise. With him in the team, I think we win the ball back quicker, and we switch play much more effecitvely. I love Jimmy Mac, but he's a different player, he doesn't do the same things. Comparing them is pretty pointless in my opinion.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
OK Cheers. Sometimes I think that areas of Selhurst Park must contain parallel universes. Cabaye was excellent on Saturday. Worked his socks off, held the ball well, tackled fiercely, sprayed it around and was the centre of all we did. This has not always been so in his time with us. I love Jedi and he can stop attacks and hold the ball. With the best will in the world he can't distribute anywhere near as well as Cabaye and McArthur. You seem to be out there on your own Alan.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace_Jack
Yo' has been better for the past two games - I thought he and Flamini worked very well together in the first half against United. It can't pass without comment that he got dominated by Pogba for the United winner and ran through by a couple of Chelsea players on Saturday. Yes his stats over the two games were good and he did have a touch of the Cabaye we expect to see but he epitomises Palace at the moment - moves the ball well at times, doesn't really threaten the opposition goal enough, never looks like winning a 50/50 but makes the occasional decent last ditch tackle. I think that's pretty fair. I also think Pogba will do that to better players this season than Cabaye!
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Sometimes I think that areas of Selhurst Park must contain parallel universes. Cabaye was excellent on Saturday. Worked his socks off, held the ball well, tackled fiercely, sprayed it around and was the centre of all we did. This has not always been so in his time with us. I love Jedi and he can stop attacks and hold the ball. With the best will in the world he can't distribute anywhere near as well as Cabaye and McArthur. You seem to be out there on your own Alan.
I agree he pips Jedi on distribution. Personally I preferred the McJedley midfield, plus Jedi scored the occaisional free kick. Has Cabaye.? Plus there is that nagging stat that we do not win with Cabaye on the pitch at 90 minutes. Still must win or draw at Watford. COYP
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace_Jack
Yo' has been better for the past two games - I thought he and Flamini worked very well together in the first half against United. It can't pass without comment that he got dominated by Pogba for the United winner and ran through by a couple of Chelsea players on Saturday. Yes his stats over the two games were good and he did have a touch of the Cabaye we expect to see but he epitomises Palace at the moment - moves the ball well at times, doesn't really threaten the opposition goal enough, never looks like winning a 50/50 but makes the occasional decent last ditch tackle. Palace threaten plenty enough. We are not that far from 2 a game. What matters is turning up with spadefuls of controlled aggression and defensive organisation at Vicarage Road so we don't do our usual trick of conceding 3-5 goals. He's integral to that as the best hope of shielding the back 4 and giving them an easy out ball. Perdu needs his man to show up more than ever.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Palace threaten plenty enough. We are not that far from 2 a game. What matters is turning up with spadefuls of controlled aggression and defensive organisation at Vicarage Road so we don't do our usual trick of conceding 3-5 goals. He's integral to that as the best hope of shielding the back 4 and giving them an easy out ball. Is he ? Shame he did not manage it against Burnley , Swansea etc, as for the easy out ball he seems to give it back to them more often than and put them under more pressure than they were as the oppo have closed them down. It would be nice if he did turn up for once and actually make a difference in game against a team he should be able to.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Well that's my point,to me he is one of the eleven. He needs to impress me first to get called 'classy'. ..he has been bloody awful considering who he is and has only showed very small glimpses of the greatness Mr Pardew hoped he would bring to this team, but against Chelsea he actually looked classy for the entire time he was on the pitch and it was probably the first time he has managed to keep it up without losing his head and throwing his toys out of his pram ..which sadly then filters around to upset the whole team, but he behaved himself didn't allow the opposition to wind him up and contributed to a good solid performance against the best side in all the leagues in this country...well done Mr Cabaye and lets have more.
|
|
|
Because Fryers looks utterly out of his depth and can't cope with football at this level. Originally posted by Salford eagle
It might help if we play him from the start try and get some form going! Punch needs to be in the centre and Chungy is not the answer. Why he doesn't start Fryers is another frustration! It can't hurt to have two naturally left footers on that side. We need a natural balance to the team, it's clear to see that as soon as the ball goes down the left it slows down the play as people need to cut in to put it on their favoured foot.
If only it were White, rather than Yellow! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Sometimes I think that areas of Selhurst Park must contain parallel universes. Cabaye was excellent on Saturday. Worked his socks off, held the ball well, tackled fiercely, sprayed it around and was the centre of all we did. This has not always been so in his time with us. I love Jedi and he can stop attacks and hold the ball. With the best will in the world he can't distribute anywhere near as well as Cabaye and McArthur. You seem to be out there on your own Alan. So basically Cabaye did his job and that's class and excellent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rossboss29
Needs to play on the right. I think pardew has fallen out with the player- and pardew wont drop zaha when in such good form, creating and scoring. Perhaps zaha on the left might help townsend floriush but then may make zaha not as effective. I agree though, very disappointed with how townsend has turned out. In hindsight i imagine we would of not purchased and kept bolasie. At this moment of time i would excercise the recall on Kaikai as another option on the left, he doesnt appeared injured as often as sako and has shown great promise on the odd occasion he has appeared for us, and shrewsbury. Not so much at brentford, but just like townsend, it doesnt always work at a particular club.
He isn't technically gifted enough to play on the right, but he's a very fast and witty left wing
|
|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
before i start...i agree hes has been dissapointing since joining. but... there are obvious reasons for this as hes played almost every minute for us on wrong side of the pitch...whenever he has played well in his career he has played on the right hand side of the pitch and been effective cutting in. all of a sudden hes been asked to play out of position and he cant do it well, some players can easily adapt but he cant. also i would point out if you watch our games this season it almost seems to me that we are making more space for wilf to play in on the right hand side of the pitch and whenever andros gets the ball it seems to be very congested on the left hand side and its harder to operate in. he needs to perform better thats probably the only thing every fan on this site 100% agree on at the mo, but also he needs more minutes on the pitch, and maybe him & wilf swap sides for the watford game and lets see what he can do. he is a very very good player, and it will work at palace given time. Dissapointing! Townsend has been totally crap of late. Firstly he is a footballer and should be capable of putting a decent shift in any position he's told to play in! Wilf is playing probably the best football of his career at present so Townsend isn't going to get a look in on the right at the moment. But he could have made the left hand side his own by now, had regular switches during matches with Wilf and the possibility of a run on the right if Wilf goes to the Afcon in January. As a £13m purchase Andros doesn't need more time he is or was an international footballer! We have less gifted players at the club but they put far more effort, drive, physicality and determination into playing for Palace than he ever does or will! So what is he doing at the moment just sulking like he did at Spurs when Pochattino put him out. Lets recoup our money or loan him out and get a decent winger, who has a left foot (who doesn't want to always cut in) and has tenacity, grit and wants to play for the team!
|
|
| ParchmoreEagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
..these are not little boys, in your world they may be but they are fully grown up men, are you suggesting Mr Townsend needs to be motivated to play his football by the manager who he plays for, I actually imagine the players to be motivating themselves to attract personal interest and a feeling of well being from being all together during training and whilst doing so encouraging each other to do this and that on the pitch to achieve the result they all want, I doubt very much Mr Pardew has very much to say in this department because why would Mr Townsend cut his own feet off to spite Mr Pardew and whilst doing so let his team mates down and flushing his own career down the toilet and all his non footballing mates and family thinking ..what are you doing? So we don't need managers?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Can't think of a signing that I've expected so much from that has delivered so little. The free kick at the end summed up his Palace career so far, imagine doing that in Sunday football, you'd get slated and rightly so. Cabaye fits the bill more than AT. I think it's a confidence thing, we have seen it before, notably with wilf - going to a new club, it can take time to gel, but this seems different. He obviously has lost his preferred spot to Wilf, he must be able to get wind of fans being disappointed at the comparisons.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by MKCPFC
So basically Cabaye did his job and that's class and excellent. He did his job and did it well. What's wrong with praising someone for it? Honestly, some people on here would only be happy if he was banging in two goals a game from 40 yards.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.