You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gomez challenge on benteke
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gomez challenge on benteke


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 27 Dec 16 11.00pm

Originally posted by Inapickle

If he was going for the ball and was just beaten to it he cannot be accused of dangerous play.

Of course he can. You're just embarrassing now. He took out Benteke at the knee. He is lucky it wasn't a career ending injury.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Inapickle Flag South West 27 Dec 16 11.08pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


Take your blinkers off and Look where the incident took place, The keeper didn't have to go out to Benteke.

You do know a player can be carded whether intentional or not?

Of course you do, or if you don't, do what you normally do and google it. you just like being a bit (lot) of a dick when it comes to Clattenburg.

..actually another Watford player had passed it back to Gomes to clear the ball upfield if you bother to watch it and in fact Benteke got in the way of Gomes trying to do this, the keeper had only one thought and that was to boot the ball..he had to suddenly hurry because the back pass was awful and Benteke was onto it, but Gomes was never in a million years fouling anyone or trying to stop Benteke, it was just an honest coming together brilliantly reffed.

Zaha deliberately trailed his leg and body out and anyone can see it clear as rain in this incident.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 27 Dec 16 11.27pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Of course he can. You're just embarrassing now. He took out Benteke at the knee. He is lucky it wasn't a career ending injury.

So I'm embarrassing now, hows that? I'm just trying to analyse the points that many on here I believe have got wrong, your being too forceful in your writing.

You try kicking a ball without your foot going above another players knee level, it was a clean 50/50.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 27 Dec 16 11.37pm

Do you actually go to Palace matches sounds as if you havn't a clue what you are talking about most of the time...think you are the sort of person that if someone said thats white shirt you would say no it isn't its black...that is so sad.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 27 Dec 16 11.46pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Do you actually go to Palace matches sounds as if you havn't a clue what you are talking about most of the time...think you are the sort of person that if someone said thats white shirt you would say no it isn't its black...that is so sad.

..you mean that blue/black, white/gold dress thingy.

[Link]

I see gold and white, what do you see?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Dec 16 11.59pm

Originally posted by Inapickle

..actually another Watford player had passed it back to Gomes to clear the ball upfield if you bother to watch it and in fact Benteke got in the way of Gomes trying to do this, the keeper had only one thought and that was to boot the ball..he had to suddenly hurry because the back pass was awful and Benteke was onto it, but Gomes was never in a million years fouling anyone or trying to stop Benteke, it was just an honest coming together brilliantly reffed.

Zaha deliberately trailed his leg and body out and anyone can see it clear as rain in this incident.

An excellent post.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 28 Dec 16 12.35am

Originally posted by Willo

An excellent post.

Thank you sir.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Dec 16 12.49am

Originally posted by Inapickle

..everyone against Willo are having an absolute laugh, it's like putting him on a rack and stretching him until he confesses, why should he admit something against his beliefs just to shut you lot up and anyway it is great entertainment and Willo stand up for yourself because on this occasion you are absolutely right, Clatterburg got every single decision correct in this match and only people who have an agenda cannot see this and I never normally stand up for this ref, he was very fair and honest during this game.

I don't think any ref has ever done this and Mr C certainly didn't yesterday.

The penalty decisions were all correct, fairplay on that, it really irks me when Zaha looks for the foul...just do your thing and get properly fouled when you bamboozle them.

Gomes was a yellow all day long, whether he meant it or not it's a poor timed challenge which could have been nasty. In addition Benteke's touch was a good one and he had a good chance of slotting it away (...shame his next touch was not better).

The thing that annoyed me so much was the inconsistency (once again) was his issuing of cards. How Benteke was booked for an absolute limp arm on the defenders shoulder in the corner of the pitch, only for Kaboul to escape any caution for two blatant attack stopping fouls on Zaha is beyond me.

This is not just a Mr C thing, it happened last week when Kante blantantly held back MacArthur, in a typical 'take a booking for the team and stop a counter' style. He knew he'd get booked, but the ref waited until his 7th foul to brandish the yellow. That's a joke.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Dec 16 4.52am

Originally posted by Inapickle

Willo is very entertaining actually.

Neither you or Willo are entertaining.....Blinkered, wind up merchants maybe but entertaining.....NO!!

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Dec 16 4.55am

Originally posted by Inapickle

Thank you Dad.

Now more accurate!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Dec 16 7.28am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Of course he can. You're just embarrassing now. He took out Benteke at the knee. He is lucky it wasn't a career ending injury.

Is the correct answer. You can be going for the ball elbows first or studs showing..that is dangerous play

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 7.42am

Originally posted by Inapickle

If he was going for the ball and was just beaten to it he cannot be accused of dangerous play.

You are completely wrong. It can still be dangerous play and it was.

Sort of undermines your credibility in assessing Clattenburg if you don't understand the rules.

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 28 Dec 16 7.47am

Clearly goalkeepers are protected by the 18 yard box because I reckon if he makes the challenge outside the box he's off , didn't that happen a couple of years back when mcgregor made a challenge on one of ours versus hull I'm sure it was near the touchline when he made contact and he got a straight red I think

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 28 Dec 16 7.52am

And I have never seen a more furious keeper on any pitch neither before nor since..

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 28 Dec 16 10.40am

Aberdeen v Hamilton on Boxing Day same Fifa rules same situation , first thing ref did was blow for a penalty followed swiftly by a yellow card without hesitation proving that golden boy screwed up!

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 16 10.43am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Aberdeen v Hamilton on Boxing Day same Fifa rules same situation , first thing ref did was blow for a penalty followed swiftly by a yellow card without hesitation proving that golden boy screwed up!

I've not seen this incident but it might have totally differed from the one against Watford in terms of the keepers challenge.One has to accept that perhaps no two challenges are identical in every shape or form.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 10.57am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Not discussed on match of the day and hardly here on the holmesdale.
Last man and not even a yellow! Anywhere else on the pitch it's a card and if it's a card in that position it has to be a red.

I think there is an argument that it was a yellow card, but never a red, and it shouldn't be a red either if a penalty is given.

But I can see why in the moment the referee saw it as a collusion, not a deliberate kick and didn't give a yellow.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 16 11.04am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think there is an argument that it was a yellow card, but never a red, and it shouldn't be a red either if a penalty is given.

But I can see why in the moment the referee saw it as a collusion, not a deliberate kick and didn't give a yellow.

My view as well.
No 'Yellow' in my book and I would say the same even if there was a different referee.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.05am

Originally posted by Bullhorn76

Clearly goalkeepers are protected by the 18 yard box because I reckon if he makes the challenge outside the box he's off , didn't that happen a couple of years back when mcgregor made a challenge on one of ours versus hull I'm sure it was near the touchline when he made contact and he got a straight red I think

The difference between a free kick (20%) chance at best of scoring, or a penalty (90%) chance of scoring. The problem with the Red Card and Penalty is that it effectively ends most games. Of course if the team misses the penalty they lose out.

Also Beneteke if he goes past the keeper, also isn't in a clear goal scoring opportunity either. Its a very tight angle, and there is no support.

Yellow card in opinion, with the benefit of hindsight of seeing the replay. Never a red.

Also I don't think Clattenburg saw the kick, just the collision, otherwise he'd have got the yellow out.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.07am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Aberdeen v Hamilton on Boxing Day same Fifa rules same situation , first thing ref did was blow for a penalty followed swiftly by a yellow card without hesitation proving that golden boy screwed up!

Yeah I think he got it wrong, it should have been a yellow. But when the keeper brought down Beneteke, before I saw any replays, I didn't think it was by kicking out at the player, I thought it was just a late clumsy keeper charge.

So I can forgive the referee that decision. The booking of Zaha, was harsh, as it probably wasn't either a foul or a dive.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gomez challenge on benteke