You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedi


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
palace-metros Flag Redhill 06 Jan 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

I totally disagree with you...I could not disagree with you more!

Murray - He is good enough to play for a prem team but he doesn't want to be a bench player. He is an honest bloke who wants to play a key role for a club and so he would rather play for Brighton regularly...but that doesnt mean he isn't good enough.

Jedinak - exactly the same thing...he wants first team football and Pardew said he couldn't ask him to sit on the bench for us week in week out (but Ledley and Mutch are ok for bench roles). It says a lot about his ability that he was more sought after than either Ledley or Mutch don't you think?

To say Gayle isn't good enough for the prem just shows what a plonka you are...top scorer for us 3 years running or something like that??? After barely starting a game? On fire in the Champ??? He is prem quality all day long but he didn't suit our system...in some respects we were not good enough for him because we couldn't play with a front two.

Murray doesn't want to be a bench player in the EPL - I agree but if good enough, he wouldn't be on the bench. Having said that, I think of the three he would have been the most effective had we kept him and I say this despite thinking it was a good bit of business at the time.

Jedi, as much as I love his commitment and leadership, has to play regular 90 mins to be seen at his best (as does Murray)and I would debate that his leadership qualities make up for his technical deficiencies in the way that Terry's did at Chelski.

Gayle - best natural finisher at the club when he was here. However, that didn't make him EPL quality. Couldn't be played up top on his own so you would have to adjust the whole team to suit one player. Scoring goals for fun at Championship level as we all knew he would. Playing in the best team at that level and getting plenty of chances. Good luck to him and I would have kept him over Townsend but it was the right move for him.

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 06 Jan 17 7.19pm

Originally posted by Painter

Jedinak, Gayle and Murray are all playing in the Championship for a reason, we all know they aren't good enough for the Premier. There wasn't any interest from other Premier managers for them.
Why do you all think our old players are better once they leave, when they failed to perform whilst here.

Because Alan Pardew/SP sold them.
I would rather have those two up front for us rather than Bene/Wickham.(if that was the plan)

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 06 Jan 17 7.36pm

Greate news, if possible get him back he will boost the whole team with his attitude like nowone else in this club seemes able to do.
He4 should never have been sold at the first time, just another of Alan Pardew`s stupid moves.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 06 Jan 17 8.04pm

Originally posted by Asian Eagle

Greate news, if possible get him back he will boost the whole team with his attitude like nowone else in this club seemes able to do.
He4 should never have been sold at the first time, just another of Alan Pardew`s stupid moves.

Is there no limit to the bollocks you talk?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 06 Jan 17 9.23pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Is there no limit to the bollocks you talk?

I think, if you reach deep down inside your subconscious, you already know the answer to your question.

Edited by NickinOX (06 Jan 2017 9.24pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Jan 17 11.09pm

I've been called deluded on here. But some of the calls for has-been players is beyond reason. Murray, past it. I loved (man-love) his goals in our promotion season. But he is not "Palace", like everyone says. He came from the weed, he went back to the weed.

Gayle was bought as back-up to said FFS Murray by Holloway from Peterborourgh. He never did fit into our team. Whoever managed. And that includes the "saviour" Pulis. He was given plenty of chances, but never cut it.

I can't remember how many threads were started about how poor Jedi was at passing or giving away fouls/penalties. Yet now, the cry is for him to return, even though he is clearly older than when he left, and therefore not as good (bad).

I must go see my shrink.......

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Jan 17 11.16pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

I totally disagree with you...I could not disagree with you more!

Murray - He is good enough to play for a prem team but he doesn't want to be a bench player. He is an honest bloke who wants to play a key role for a club and so he would rather play for Brighton regularly...but that doesnt mean he isn't good enough.

Jedinak - exactly the same thing...he wants first team football and Pardew said he couldn't ask him to sit on the bench for us week in week out (but Ledley and Mutch are ok for bench roles). It says a lot about his ability that he was more sought after than either Ledley or Mutch don't you think?

To say Gayle isn't good enough for the prem just shows what a plonka you are...top scorer for us 3 years running or something like that??? After barely starting a game? On fire in the Champ??? He is prem quality all day long but he didn't suit our system...in some respects we were not good enough for him because we couldn't play with a front two.



You disagree, then agree Jedinak and Murray would only be bench warmers in the Premier. They knew they could play for a Championship team, fair play to them, they wanted to play.
On Gayle, I liked him, but is not good enough in the role he was asked to play, basically he not strong enough.
I stand by my comment, that no Premier clubs were interested in them.


Edited by Painter (06 Jan 2017 11.18pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Jan 17 8.25am

Originally posted by Johnny Byrne

It's been a case of "be careful what you wish for" as far as the board and former manager felt at the start of this season.

Back to the heart of CPFC, guts, fight, togetherness, as one with the fans. Been lost this past 2 years. Time to regain this is now.

Absolutely spot on!

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Jan 17 8.30am

I think some people miss the point about Jedinak.
I would not expect him to play every game or even a full 90 minutes.
It is the effect a player like that can have by being around.
Strength of character, being there for the other players, a positive influence in the dressing room etc.
Frank Lampard - if he were with us - would not be capable of playing all the time now but what an effect he would have.
If reports are to be believed the whole squad was unhappy with the way Jedinak was treated by Pardew and so I feel that unlikely as it is that a return to CPFC would only help us.
Jedinak or Mutch - you decide!

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 07 Jan 17 11.57am

Jedi: somewhat similar on-pitch representative of BFS as Kevin Nolan, who normally follows BFS around. We need an enforcer of this type, and I'd rather have Jedi than Nolan. The ideal solution would be a younger version of either of the above, although I have no idea who might fit that bill...

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 07 Jan 17 10.12pm

Originally posted by Painter



You disagree, then agree Jedinak and Murray would only be bench warmers in the Premier. They knew they could play for a Championship team, fair play to them, they wanted to play.
On Gayle, I liked him, but is not good enough in the role he was asked to play, basically he not strong enough.
I stand by my comment, that no Premier clubs were interested in them.


Edited by Painter (06 Jan 2017 11.18pm)

I said I think they can all do a job in the prem...that they could be prem players. I never said they were 1st team prem players week in week out. I disagreed that all they were capable of was champ football.

The notion that players playing well in the champ wouldn't be of any use at all to teams like ours is daft. I wish clubs had had that opinion before they took Moses and Clyne away from us...that would have been sweet.

Edited by Hudsoneagle (07 Jan 2017 10.13pm)

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 07 Jan 17 10.20pm

can we please bring back routledge/benny watson & lewis grabban aswell please? nowt like pining for the past to look forward

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 07 Jan 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I think some people miss the point about Jedinak.
I would not expect him to play every game or even a full 90 minutes.
It is the effect a player like that can have by being around.
Strength of character, being there for the other players, a positive influence in the dressing room etc.
Frank Lampard - if he were with us - would not be capable of playing all the time now but what an effect he would have.
If reports are to be believed the whole squad was unhappy with the way Jedinak was treated by Pardew and so I feel that unlikely as it is that a return to CPFC would only help us.
Jedinak or Mutch - you decide!

Got any links to back up the "reports"?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Hansy Flag 07 Jan 17 10.49pm

I'd be more than happy to pay double the amount they paid for him. We just need him at this moment in time.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Jan 17 11.32pm

Originally posted by Hansy

I'd be more than happy to pay double the amount they paid for him. We just need him at this moment in time.

You don't make those decisions, luckily.

The price you're quoting is £8mil for someone who isn't going to be worth that.

It's not that Pardew sold Jedi, it's that he didn't replace him properly, although you could make a case for too many of that guard being sold, but then again the replacements come into question.

In fact all of Pardew's recruits should be questioned. Acquiescence top of the character requirements. Woodman and Salako, tick. Millen, you a yes man or afraid your job's in danger if you challenge super al? Check, you're safe as well. What a joke. Club run for Alan's job security. Utter farce. Glad it's all over. Start being professional again.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Jan 17 7.29am

Originally posted by Hansy

I'd be more than happy to pay double the amount they paid for him.

I'm sure that Steve Parish would be glad to hear of your kind offer

 

The Dolphin Flag 08 Jan 17 9.01am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3106226]

Got any links to back up the "reports"?


[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Unfortunately I am unable to find the article written the day after Pardew lost his job - more of a commentary on his tenure actually - where it was felt that his general treatment of Jedinak didn't play well with the squad of players at all.
I honestly can't remember whether it was internet or newspaper but it was a fair resume to be honest

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 08 Jan 17 10.36am

Love Jedi to death, but would not resign him. Mistake was not bringing in a dedicated holder as replacement. Punch, Cabaye, Macca, Ledley and Flamini, have all been tried there, but none cut it as it's just not their natural games. The fall of Jedi came about as AP coped very well without him when he went to that Asia cup thing and when he returned he stupidly got a four match ban for that elbow against West Ham and if I remember we coped well then too.
Both FFS and Jedi did not want to be bench warmers and that was what they would of been under AP, so fair play for not holding them back IMO. Gayle is an enigma. Praised by every manager since Ollie, yet none could find a way to fit him in. Now he looks great in the strongest squad in the championship playing games where they have the majority of possession and he gets chances galore. Maybe he'd even do it for a top 6 side in the prem, but not a struggling one like us IMO.
Benteke is already being abused by the patient ones on here, but I think he has 8 league goals so far, quite possibly the most by a Palace forward since we came up, sure someone will correct me. He's playing in a struggling side and he's new to the club. Yes he cost more than Gayle, but seriously there's no contest in the who I'd rather have stakes. As for the lazy jibes, total bollocks, he ran down Forster, Gomez and Fabianski to great effect in recent weeks and but for a bent ref who knows what could of happened at Swansea. Would take him off pens though.
Too many want the old players back because they had this "spirit" thing you go on about. So did Ramage, Moxey, KG, Garvan and Wilbraham, shall we resign them too?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 08 Jan 17 11.09am

As other have already stated it is the failure to adequately replace Jedi that is the issue. However that was never going to be easy due to his history, persona within the recent club's history which is huge. Leadership takes time, that's why you need other more experienced players within the club to step up. If you are looking to upgrade usually you would replace with a younger, sharper player, able to play every game not necessarily a leader. For instance you would not necessarily sign the likes of Mark Noble as a replacement, the same deficiencies would be seen.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Painter Flag Croydon 08 Jan 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

As other have already stated it is the failure to adequately replace Jedi that is the issue. However that was never going to be easy due to his history, persona within the recent club's history which is huge. Leadership takes time, that's why you need other more experienced players within the club to step up. If you are looking to upgrade usually you would replace with a younger, sharper player, able to play every game not necessarily a leader. For instance you would not necessarily sign the likes of Mark Noble as a replacement, the same deficiencies would be seen.

Replacing a fans favourite is never easy. I assume Flamini was brought in as replacement, not a carbon copy, but has vast experience at the top level, about the same age and has played about as much as Jedinak would have.


 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi