You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Dann start now fit?
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Dann start now fit?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
leejaneagles Flag 27 Feb 17 8.30am

Before Saturday I'd of definitely said yes but Tomkins had a great performance.

Him and Sakho looked so assured on the ball and I don't recall seeing too many pointless diagonals from the back.

Only trouble is Dann is much more likely to score and Tomkins will miss sitters but I think our Captain is going to have to fight to get his place back.

Still, nice to have options again!

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Feb 17 8.34am

Play the same team again Sam.
Mind you we did that against Sunderland.!!

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Flightsequence Flag 27 Feb 17 8.42am

I think we will go back to 3 centre backs against WBA so Dann will play.

 

Face in Wetherspoons Flag 27 Feb 17 9.21am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Before Saturday I'd of definitely said yes but Tomkins had a great performance.

Him and Sakho looked so assured on the ball and I don't recall seeing too many pointless diagonals from the back.

Only trouble is Dann is much more likely to score and Tomkins will miss sitters but I think our Captain is going to have to fight to get his place back.

Still, nice to have options again!

Dann is still a massive player for us although his performances have dipped a bit following injuries. He will benefit from having Luka in front of him and it should restore him to full confidence. I think that he would benefit from giving up the captaincy and Luka already looks a sound bet to take over. Yes, Tomkins
did look assured against Boro and it would be interesting to see a fully fit Dann and Tomkins as the CB pairing. How nice it is to have Sako and Damo in the mix and the options that we have available to us.

 

Mad4palace Flag 27 Feb 17 9.22am

If he's fully fit then start him, personally I think Tomkins is our worst defender. Middlesbrough didn't test us a great deal and I think Sakho did the work of 2 men back there, Tomkins was as hesitant and scared of shots as he usually is.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 Feb 17 9.29am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

If he's fully fit then start him, personally I think Tomkins is our worst defender. Middlesbrough didn't test us a great deal and I think Sakho did the work of 2 men back there, Tomkins was as hesitant and scared of shots as he usually is.

I agree. Tomkins has never looked quite up to standard. maybe that will come.

however, Dann alongside Sakho with Luka playing in front of them seems like a pretty solid Triangle to build a side around.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Bangell Flag Oxford 27 Feb 17 9.36am

Originally posted by Flightsequence

I think we will go back to 3 centre backs against WBA so Dann will play.

I seriously doubt we'll ever play 3 at the back again this season.

In the long run, I prefer Dann to Tomkins, but I wouldn't change a defence that kept a clean sheet, and we've rushed Dann back from injury too many times before.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Feb 17 9.38am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

If he's fully fit then start him, personally I think Tomkins is our worst defender. Middlesbrough didn't test us a great deal and I think Sakho did the work of 2 men back there, Tomkins was as hesitant and scared of shots as he usually is.

You obviously dislike Tomkins.
He was fine Saturday.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

chateauferret Flag 27 Feb 17 10.00am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

You obviously dislike Tomkins.
He was fine Saturday.

He was certainly better than Ward ànd plys right back s well so I'd say Tomkins Dann Sakho van Aanholt.

 


============
The Ferret
============

pete58 Flag Northampton 27 Feb 17 10.08am

No to Dann. He's not the same player as a year ago. Don't know if it's being captain of the side. Definitely needs a bit of time out.

 

Username Flag Horsham 27 Feb 17 10.11am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I agree. Tomkins has never looked quite up to standard. maybe that will come.

however, Dann alongside Sakho with Luka playing in front of them seems like a pretty solid Triangle to build a side around.

Hard to settle in a side when you're playing with a different partner/full back each week.

Think Tomkins was decent on Saturday and he needs to have a bit longer before he's written off.

Given Dann's injury issues I would have no problem with the same team starting the next game.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

bicycle repair man 27 Feb 17 10.13am

Like a lot of the squad Dann is suffering a lack of confidence at the moment, and it would be madness to tamper with the defence that played against Middlesbrough.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 27 Feb 17 10.16am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Like a lot of the squad Dann is suffering a lack of confidence at the moment, and it would be madness to tamper with the defence that played against Middlesbrough.

It's the difference between having 2 center backs that are playing without confidence - when you have a partner next to you that's confident and relaxed, that filters into you - Sakho was excellent and that brought Tomkins level up. We've not seen the best from him yet I'm sure and agree it would be crazy to change it unless he is planning on a different system.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Feb 17 10.52am

Well as I said earlier keep the winning team together.
Which we did after Bournemouth.
West Brom will be more daunting than Boro.
So its over to Sam.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Pierre Flag Purley 27 Feb 17 12.20pm

I think SA will want to play with more height at the back against WBA. He may well go for 3 CB's and include Dann to try and nullify their prowess in the air(as flightsequence has already pointed out)

This also gives us an attacking advantage as well! This could be an afternoon of crosses and aerial dueling!

 

Part Time James Flag 27 Feb 17 12.25pm

Three CBs is fine if

a) It makes your defence stronger than having two
b) The wing backs get forward and create something.

Taking van Aanholt out of what I am about to say, as I think he's been decent since he joined...I have one word:

SUNDERLAND.

 




Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Feb 17 12.35pm

I agree with Ferret. Although playing Tomkins at right back would probably restrict our attacking options on that side, I think it would add more solidity at the back as JW has been struggling this season. So for me it would be
TOMKINS - DANN - SAKHO - PVA
LUKA
ZAHA - MAC - CABAYE - SCHLUPP
BENTEKE
Im not a great lover of Townsend but I did think his performance has been better the last couple of games so happy to see him start instead of Schlupp.

 

Mad4palace Flag 27 Feb 17 12.55pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I agree with Ferret. Although playing Tomkins at right back would probably restrict our attacking options on that side, I think it would add more solidity at the back as JW has been struggling this season. So for me it would be
TOMKINS - DANN - SAKHO - PVA
LUKA
ZAHA - MAC - CABAYE - SCHLUPP
BENTEKE
Im not a great lover of Townsend but I did think his performance has been better the last couple of games so happy to see him start instead of Schlupp.


Going against West Brom we'll have to deal with their physical approach and threat from set pieces. I think this is closer to the team we'll play, Dann probably has to play, whether it be in a back 4 or 3. I slightly suspect we'll go with 3 at the back. Benteke will get no joy out of WBA's defenders so we may need to go with 2 up front too.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 27 Feb 17 1.10pm

He is probably a better defender than Tomkins but he is worse on the ball. The reason we looked so good on the weekend was the passing out from the back. No more Dann and Damo shanks up field.

Keep the back four the same

 

Mad4palace Flag 27 Feb 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

He is probably a better defender than Tomkins but he is worse on the ball. The reason we looked so good on the weekend was the passing out from the back. No more Dann and Damo shanks up field.

Keep the back four the same

Really? I think Tomkins has been poor in possession, he was better on Saturday than usual (I think Milivojevic was an influencing factor) but generally Dann is superior on the ball. Dann has a great first touch and cross-field pass, his lofted passes upfield aren't as good possibly. Both Tomkins and Ward seem to have their passing angles cut off because they take too long passing it. I think Dann might come back better than he has been of late if he just lets Sakho do most of the leading.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Dann start now fit?