This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Here we have the liberal left ‘justice’ system in action: Young offenders from black or ethnic minority backgrounds could be given lighter punishments under new sentencing guidelines.
|
|
|
Labor..???
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
A study in 2011 found that offenders from ethnic minorities are far more likely to be sentenced to prison for similar crimes than their white counterparts. For driving offences for example, black defendants were found 44% more likely to be jailed than white defendants. At one Magistrates court, for public disorder or weapons offences black defendants were 79% more likely to be jailed compared to white defendants. This was based off a study of over 500,000 cases.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
A study in 2011 found that offenders from ethnic minorities are far more likely to be sentenced to prison for similar crimes than their white counterparts. For driving offences for example, black defendants were found 44% more likely to be jailed than white defendants. At one Magistrates court, for public disorder or weapons offences black defendants were 79% more likely to be jailed compared to white defendants. This was based off a study of over 500,000 cases. All people want is equal treatment. Not discrimination, negative or positive. Perhaps if we had judges and magistrates who lived in the real world and not the 18th century or an upper middle class bubble, that might happen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
All people want is equal treatment. Not discrimination, negative or positive. Perhaps if we had judges and magistrates who lived in the real world and not the 18th century or an upper middle class bubble, that might happen. Agreed. But as Username has pointed out that wasn't what was happening under a system that was meant to ensure equal treatment. By asking judges to consider positive discrimination, maybe that will ensure equal treatment?
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show |
|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Regardless of how liberal left the governments of the last 40 odd years have been, I stand by my original point - "Ye shall know then by their fruits" [Matthew 7]
What you are describing is a post-war "Butskellism" who had their heart in the right place and probably would have described itself as progressive but to there was not a shred of liberalism in it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by OknotOK
Agreed. But as Username has pointed out that wasn't what was happening under a system that was meant to ensure equal treatment. By asking judges to consider positive discrimination, maybe that will ensure equal treatment? Clearly that is the intention, but it is a contradiction. You are either giving people lighter sentences relative to others or you are giving them parity. The guidelines as described suggest favorable treatment. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 Mar 2017 2.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Certainly I think the liberal left stifle free debate. And they go further in getting people sacked for the slightest criticism of their views. Furthermore, as with their react to Brexit, they label all opposition as stupid, racist, etc. It is telling that the response of liberal left champion, Legaleagle, to Liddle's words is to post a fatuous list of'14 defining characteristics of modern fascism' - although No.15 is missing, ie:'anyone who is not liberal left must be a fascist'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Clearly that is the intention, but it is a contradiction. You are either giving people lighter sentences relative to others or you are giving them parity. The guidelines as described suggest favorable treatment. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 Mar 2017 2.30pm) Agreed again and not really sure what the correct position should be - the status quo doesn't result in parity, but the adjustment to it is not parity in theory. Maybe judges should have league tables to show their past "performances"?
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
All people want is equal treatment. Not discrimination, negative or positive. Perhaps if we had judges and magistrates who lived in the real world and not the 18th century or an upper middle class bubble, that might happen. I completely agree. But for whatever reason, it doesn't seem to be happening does it? Bringing it back to football, I used to be massively against any type of 'positive discrimination' in terms of managerial vacancies. You look at the numbers though and have to wonder why there aren't more black managers. In NFL, the 'Rooney rule' might sound horrible on paper, but it ensures that more candidates get a chance. You don't have to hire a minority coach, you just have to ensure you interview one. I'm still not wild about the concept, but it's hard to deny that it does work. Before the Rooney rule (2003) there were only 7 minority coaches in the history of the NFL. Since then there have been 17. Still, that is sport and there is a vast leap from there to the criminal justice system. If it's tested in a trial and proven to work then ok I suppose.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Sedlescombe
Stifling free debate is only half of it. The liberal attitude proliferates among the gullible and young and pervades the politics of every walk of life. It is one thing to have a moral outlook, but another to use the pressure of public shaming based on the delusion of moral superiority for gain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by OknotOK
Agreed again and not really sure what the correct position should be - the status quo doesn't result in parity, but the adjustment to it is not parity in theory. Maybe judges should have league tables to show their past "performances"? There was a study featured in Matthew Syed's latest book where judges reviewing cases for potential for appeal (as an experiment, not for real appeals), where it was found that you had a much better chance of getting an appeal if you were reviewed after the judge had just eaten! The longer the sessions went on and the hungrier a judge got, the less likely he was to approve an 'appeal'. There's all sorts of sub conscious thought processes happening when people make decisions. I'm sure all of those judges were blissfully unaware of what was happening, just like I'm sure magistrates are unaware of the disparity between their decisions. Maybe if they were shown a table of previous cases it would have an impact on them. I don't think anyone is realistically accusing them all of being racist, but if there is someone way of neutralising an unknown bias then it's worth a try.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
I completely agree. But for whatever reason, it doesn't seem to be happening does it? Bringing it back to football, I used to be massively against any type of 'positive discrimination' in terms of managerial vacancies. You look at the numbers though and have to wonder why there aren't more black managers. In NFL, the 'Rooney rule' might sound horrible on paper, but it ensures that more candidates get a chance. You don't have to hire a minority coach, you just have to ensure you interview one. I'm still not wild about the concept, but it's hard to deny that it does work. Before the Rooney rule (2003) there were only 7 minority coaches in the history of the NFL. Since then there have been 17. Still, that is sport and there is a vast leap from there to the criminal justice system. If it's tested in a trial and proven to work then ok I suppose. Any policy that gives advantage based on ethnicity is just plain wrong. I doubt many sensible black football professionals want to be seen as being given a hand up either. You get a job because you deserve it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Stifling free debate is only half of it. The liberal attitude proliferates among the gullible and young and pervades the politics of every walk of life. It is one thing to have a moral outlook, but another to use the pressure of public shaming based on the delusion of moral superiority for gain. As opposed to the millions who believed that the NHS was going to get £350 million extra, or that Trump was really going to lock up Hillary Clinton? Public shaming? It wasn't the Guardian who printed the names of the judges involved in the Article 50 decision and declared them enemies of the people.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by OknotOK
Agreed again and not really sure what the correct position should be - the status quo doesn't result in parity, but the adjustment to it is not parity in theory. Maybe judges should have league tables to show their past "performances"? The whole judiciary needs sorting out. There shold be no need for any policy. Sentencing should be determined by the crime and the risk to society.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Rod Liddle summed this up well in a recent issue of the Spectator: "Try being a social worker who thinks gay adoptions are problematic. Or a doctor who disproves of abortion or gender transitioning. Or a student who quite likes Germaine Greer and wearing a sombrero. Or a teacher who thinks Trump is maybe OK. (The headmaster at a school in south London recently told pupils that if any child uttered the same sorts of words as Donald Trump about immigration, they'd be excluded.) Try being a judge who thinks an awful lot of hate crimes are imaginary or vexatious. In all cases you'd be drummed out. No job, You'd be finished. There would be tribunals - where you would be judged by other upholders of the liberal elite - and you'd be out. That is what we mean by the liberal elite." Liddle also addressed the notion mentioned here that we have had years of non left liberals in these positions: "I remember as a speechwriter for the Labour party in the early 1980s suggesting that we do something in support of the teachers, who were complaining about pay.'F**k them - they're all Tories' I was told. And so statistically they were at the time. And in the 1970s the BBC, the Church of England, the judiciary and the emergent quangos were small 'c' conservative. Elites last for about two generations. Our liberal elite has lasted since about 1985." Edited by hedgehog50 (06 Mar 2017 6.57pm) Of course a social worker who is against gay adoption has effectively taken a job which brings them into conflict with legal provision of adoption. Similarly a doctor who objects to abortion or transgendering, is placing their values ahead of their oath and job. Judges don't have discretion on what is and isn't a crime, that's established by government. Personal views don't really come into the judiciary. Having worked with a few, they tend to be vote conservative or liberal democrat and have interesting views about what they believe personally, and what they will endorse. They do tend to be quite authoritarian (which goes with the territory). Obviously, its a bit after my time as a student, but Germaine Greer tends to be quite high on a few reading lists. Plus my experience of university is that most students don't really give a s**t about politics either and don't fit the student stereotype at all (most being average dressed, ordinary kids rather than Student Gwants).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
As opposed to the millions who believed that the NHS was going to get £350 million extra, or that Trump was really going to lock up Hillary Clinton? Public shaming? It wasn't the Guardian who printed the names of the judges involved in the Article 50 decision and declared them enemies of the people. Whataboutery does not alter the reality and no one is suggesting that politicians and media of all types are not above hyperbole and playing to the mob.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Stifling free debate is only half of it. The liberal attitude proliferates among the gullible and young and pervades the politics of every walk of life. It is one thing to have a moral outlook, but another to use the pressure of public shaming based on the delusion of moral superiority for gain. I rather suspect that most of the people you are referring to - the sort of tossers that go through public school, into the professions and to the top of society - what generally gets called the "Establishment" are many things; but Liberals they aint.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Whataboutery does not alter the reality and no one is suggesting that politicians and media of all types are not above hyperbole and playing to the mob. So then why constantly throw slurs at people for being liberal because of things which are just as applicable to people with similar beliefs to yours?
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
So then why constantly throw slurs at people for being liberal because of things which are just as applicable to people with similar beliefs to yours? I actually don't have a problem with liberals. I believe they are broadly trying to do the right thing. My problem is that their idea of what the right thing is sometimes the wrong thing.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.