This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by A89M
He regrets Wilf not playing for England, Wilf was in great form when Southgate was interim manager, so much so that he was the first player he went to see when he was made permanent, so why did he not pick him?! Very odd! "I didn't really appreciate there was this disappearing egg timer on him going to the Ivory Coast. He was the first player I went to see when I got the job permanently but he'd already made his mind up." too little too late i'd say
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan |
|
|
Originally posted by paperhat
"I didn't really appreciate there was this disappearing egg timer on him going to the Ivory Coast. He was the first player I went to see when I got the job permanently but he'd already made his mind up." too little too late i'd say I used to have a lot of time for Southgate, I knew him when he just broke into the Palace team and you couldn't have met a nicer or more humble bloke but this has hacked me right off. Basically Wilf scores an incredible goal and he realises that there is a danger that his decision to not push hard enough for him to play for England is going to be questioned so he comes out with stuff that in my opinion paints Wilf in a negative light, questioning his commitment. I think its totally unnecessary diversion tactic away from the fact that they know he would have been a very useful weapon for an extremely average England side, maybe not as a starter but certainly off the bench. Even if its true and Wilf wasn't committed to England, why feel the need to go to the press about it, he could easily have given a more diplomatic answer.
|
|
|
To be fair to Southgate, the Wilf & England ship had sailed before he got the gig.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
sheesh, you guys are harsh. I must admit that I read Southgate's comments this morning and thought that they had the ring of truth about them Danny Mills also commented that Zaha had "taken the easier option and thought 'I might get a few more caps and might get to play in a few more tournaments because my chances with England are probably going to be limited' which also has the ring of truth about it
|
|
| bubble wrap |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
I used to have a lot of time for Southgate, I knew him when he just broke into the Palace team and you couldn't have met a nicer or more humble bloke but this has hacked me right off. Basically Wilf scores an incredible goal and he realises that there is a danger that his decision to not push hard enough for him to play for England is going to be questioned so he comes out with stuff that in my opinion paints Wilf in a negative light, questioning his commitment. I think its totally unnecessary diversion tactic away from the fact that they know he would have been a very useful weapon for an extremely average England side, maybe not as a starter but certainly off the bench. Even if its true and Wilf wasn't committed to England, why feel the need to go to the press about it, he could easily have given a more diplomatic answer. You have got it wrong. Southgate was responding to critism by Steve Parish. He had to come back with what went on and the way i read it i make Southgate right. Wilf was not 100% committed to England and Southgate could not put him in his squad for that reason. That is what i want to hear from the England manager. Too many players have been capped that dont really show the passion for their country that they put on for their clubs and its part of the reason we dont do very well in tournaments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bubble wrap
You have got it wrong. Southgate was responding to critism by Steve Parish. He had to come back with what went on and the way i read it i make Southgate right. Wilf was not 100% committed to England and Southgate could not put him in his squad for that reason. That is what i want to hear from the England manager. Too many players have been capped that dont really show the passion for their country that they put on for their clubs and its part of the reason we dont do very well in tournaments. You're right about the SP part but you don't think Wilf would have been 100% committed to England had he been selected? Do you really believe that? As for England not doing well in tournaments because they don't show passion, I can't agree with that - they've just not been good enough.
|
|
|
"And for my next trick, I shall make this egg-timer disappear... ...up Gareth Southgates' A55.."
|
|
|
Originally posted by A89M
you don't think Wilf would have been 100% committed to England had he been selected? Do you really believe that? Personally I'm not sure what Wilf is committed to. He could have said to Ivory Coast that he would play for them but after the AFCON as he didn't want to leave Palace at a time when they were in the brown stuff but he appeared to be more committed to playing in AFCON than helping Palace avoid the relegation spots
|
|
|
Originally posted by bubble wrap
You have got it wrong. Southgate was responding to critism by Steve Parish. He had to come back with what went on and the way i read it i make Southgate right. Wilf was not 100% committed to England and Southgate could not put him in his squad for that reason. That is what i want to hear from the England manager. Too many players have been capped that dont really show the passion for their country that they put on for their clubs and its part of the reason we dont do very well in tournaments. Sorry mate, I have to disagree, I think all Parish said was that Zaha should be scoring those goals in an England shirt (could be wrong but that's all I saw). Southgate has taken offence to that because its true - to make his defence what seems to be a personal attack on Wilf is wrong. He could have easily just said that Parish is entitled to his own opinion etc He did not have to question his commitment to England. It's fairly well known that Southgate and Wilf don't get on, I've no doubt that Wilf's exclusion is as much down to that as anything else. Do you think he has sat down every player that he has selected so far and grilled them on their commitment to the cause?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
Sorry mate, I have to disagree, I think all Parish said was that Zaha should be scoring those goals in an England shirt (could be wrong but that's all I saw). Southgate has taken offence to that because its true - to make his defence what seems to be a personal attack on Wilf is wrong. He could have easily just said that Parish is entitled to his own opinion etc He did not have to question his commitment to England. It's fairly well known that Southgate and Wilf don't get on, I've no doubt that Wilf's exclusion is as much down to that as anything else. Do you think he has sat down every player that he has selected so far and grilled them on their commitment to the cause? And Henderson
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
Do you think he has sat down every player that he has selected so far and grilled them on their commitment to the cause? Perhaps it hasn't been necessary in other cases as others don't drop hints that they will switch their allegiance to another country if they aren't picked
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Perhaps it hasn't been necessary in other cases as others don't drop hints that they will switch their allegiance to another country if they aren't picked Do we know he actually said that though,or is it just Southgate covering his arse.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Wilf said at a very very young age that he hadn't decided which country he wanted to represent. If I emigrated and my kid was good enough to play international sport, I'd want them to represent England, not their new home, and would try to keep them connected to England. I'd speculate that, coming from a fairly poor country, the Zaha family might feel honor bound for him to represent that country. Talk of switching allegiance is the wrong place to start the conversation. He wasn't decided. Then he was. Yeah spot on. I can vouch for this. My son was born in Sydney (to English parents)but no way will he be playing for Australia. He's going to captain Palace and England instead.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
Sorry mate, I have to disagree, I think all Parish said was that Zaha should be scoring those goals in an England shirt (could be wrong but that's all I saw). Southgate has taken offence to that because its true - to make his defence what seems to be a personal attack on Wilf is wrong. He could have easily just said that Parish is entitled to his own opinion etc He did not have to question his commitment to England. It's fairly well known that Southgate and Wilf don't get on, I've no doubt that Wilf's exclusion is as much down to that as anything else. Do you think he has sat down every player that he has selected so far and grilled them on their commitment to the cause? I'm with you. Southgate's statement is inflammatory and, by some measures, racist. Hope it inspires Wilf to go on a tear up through the rest of the season and shove those words down Southgate's throat.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.