You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dunkirk
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dunkirk


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 31 Jul 17 1.42pm

Has anyone seen it?
Would you recommend it if you have?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 31 Jul 17 1.46pm

Yes went Saturday night enjoyed it,very noisy.
Only criticism was that not enough time spent on the small boats.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 31 Jul 17 1.50pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Yes went Saturday night enjoyed it,very noisy.
Only criticism was that not enough time spent on the small boats.

I was hoping to see it with my others halves son, who's 13 and wants to see it. I've been looking at a few YouTube reviews on the film and they're all raving about it.. even the Yanks

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Part Time James Flag 31 Jul 17 1.54pm

I saw it a week ago. I really enjoyed it. I'm not a history buff so I'm sure there could've been historical inaccuracies but if a film is good then I couldn't really care less. I enjoyed Harry Potter but I have my doubts he could really do magic.

 




hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 31 Jul 17 1.55pm

It is a very good action movie or perhaps should say non-stop action movie. Not much character development but grips your attention throughout. Suitable for a thirteen-year-old, violence is not very graphic.

Edited by hedgehog50 (31 Jul 2017 1.56pm)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 31 Jul 17 2.53pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I saw it a week ago. I really enjoyed it. I'm not a history buff so I'm sure there could've been historical inaccuracies but if a film is good then I couldn't really care less. I enjoyed Harry Potter but I have my doubts he could really do magic.

Of course he can, you muggle. Expelliamus.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Jul 17 2.53pm

Don't spoil the ending, I haven't seen it yet.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 31 Jul 17 3.14pm

Originally posted by palace_in_frogland

Of course he can, you muggle. Expelliamus.

Is that upper middle class for 'you mug?'

 


COYP

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jul 17 3.22pm

Saw it yesterday. Dragged my teenage daughters along. I thought it was excellent and ("amaze-balls" - sorry) so did the girls.

Really well made. Great music and soundtrack. No blood, no gore (as it's a 12A) so a bit like war films of old, but much more sophisticated in conveying the horror.

Don't want to give too much away but the way the characters' stories were interwoven, while it was clever without being cliched, possibly removed some of the 'suspense'. I'll leave it at that.

Definitely go see.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

chris123 Flag hove actually 31 Jul 17 4.03pm

My great uncle Reg from Potter Heigham in Norfolk took his boat over and did three trips I think - years later the boat was used as a fishing deck on Hickling Broad. My dad and I went fishing with Reg in the early 70s and used his old hulk as our base - it was in poor condition but the stove in the galley still worked. But we did not know the history of the boat until years later when one of the lads from the village gave an eulogy at Reg's funeral - we had no idea what Reg had done 40 years earlier and he had never once mentioned the history of his old boat - I think the lad said that he was a school boy at the time and only went along as there needed to be a crew - just unbelievable.

Edited by chris123 (31 Jul 2017 7.13pm)

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jul 17 4.16pm

Originally posted by chris123

My great uncle Reg from Potter Heigham in Norfolk took his boat over and did three trips I think - years later the boat was used as a fishing deck on Hickling Broad. My dad and went fishing with Reg in the early 70s and used his old hulk as our base - it was in poor condition but the stove in the galley still worked. But we did not know the history of the boat until years later when one of the lads from the village gave an eulogy at Reg's funeral - we had no idea what Reg had done 40 years later and he had never once mentioned the history of his old boat - I think the lad said that he was a school boy at the time and only went along as there needed to be a crew - just unbelievable.

Well he was a bloody hero. There's echoes of what you've said in the movie, but I don't want to give it away. Let's just say one of my daughters said "how come they called xxx a hero; he didn't do a lot?" My answer was that they all were; (and I've got tears in my eyes as I type this).

Edited by YT (31 Jul 2017 4.17pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Part Time James Flag 31 Jul 17 4.41pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Is that upper middle class for 'you mug?'

I'll take it. I'm actually a mud-blood so no offence taken here.

 




steeleye20 Flag Croydon 31 Jul 17 4.41pm

Sounds like a blockbuster movie have often seen the 1958 version starring John Mills.

In all the years of WW2 history and new understanding I have only recently begin to wonder that surely the RAF should be protecting the soldiers on the beaches from the stukas.

And where is the rest of the luftwaffe? Stukas were pretty useless and discontinued after heavy losses.

Still lots we don't really know about WW2 that's why its still so interesting.

 

Part Time James Flag 31 Jul 17 4.44pm

One thing that confused me the first time it happened (doesn't take much) is that they flit backwards and forwards in a timeline so you'll suddenly see a scene from a different perspective quite some time after you saw it from the original perspective. It doesn't take a lot of brains to work out but if you go in forearmed with that info then you won't need to waste any time working that out!

 




baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 31 Jul 17 5.14pm

It was lucky hitler left the order 3 days to attack the bef or the world would have been a different place today

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jul 17 5.37pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

One thing that confused me the first time it happened (doesn't take much) is that they flit backwards and forwards in a timeline so you'll suddenly see a scene from a different perspective quite some time after you saw it from the original perspective. It doesn't take a lot of brains to work out but if you go in forearmed with that info then you won't need to waste any time working that out!

Er....that's the bit I didn't really want to give away in my first post.

If it's any consolation PTJ, Mrs YT came out of the cinema completely oblivious to the fact that she'd seen the same events a number of times over. I did kinda wonder which direction she'd been looking for an hour and three quarters. She's actually very intelligent (she married me, for example) but she does sometimes have problems with 'non-linear' stuff. Like, she would really enjoy Doctor Who if it wasn't for all those confusing time-travelling scenes!!

Edited by YT (31 Jul 2017 5.38pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

palace chick Flag South Croydon 31 Jul 17 5.44pm

Something that interested me during the film was the rearguard action allowing our soldiers to be evacuated. This could also make a great film in remembering those heroes including the French forces. Have a read [Link]

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Jul 17 5.45pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Yes went Saturday night enjoyed it,very noisy.
Only criticism was that not enough time spent on the small boats.

Although the historical role of the 'small boats' is somewhat overplayed, most of the evacuated troops were rescued by the navy. However at the time it was over emphasised as it presented a country coming together to overcome, rather than the set back of a retreat. That said the contribution of the small boat flotilla was incredible in its own right.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Jul 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Sounds like a blockbuster movie have often seen the 1958 version starring John Mills.

In all the years of WW2 history and new understanding I have only recently begin to wonder that surely the RAF should be protecting the soldiers on the beaches from the stukas.

And where is the rest of the luftwaffe? Stukas were pretty useless and discontinued after heavy losses.

Still lots we don't really know about WW2 that's why its still so interesting.

The range of fighter aircraft was limited at the time, with the operational range of most being about the French coastal area, from bases in the South of England. Add to that that the Blitzkrieg had resulted in the loss of a lot of fighter aircraft in France - the capacity of the Airforce to protect the Dunkirk beaches were limited due to numbers and being close to the maximum operational range of the British Aircraft that were available.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 31 Jul 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Although the historical role of the 'small boats' is somewhat overplayed, most of the evacuated troops were rescued by the navy. However at the time it was over emphasised as it presented a country coming together to overcome, rather than the set back of a retreat. That said the contribution of the small boat flotilla was incredible in its own right.

Isn't the purpose of the small boats to get people off the beach and into waiting naval vessels that could not get closer?

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dunkirk