You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings:
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player ratings:


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
priestinator Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 6.57pm

My ratings for today:

Hennessey: 4- Not really at fault for the goals but looked shaky at corners and is terrible with his feet.
Fosu-Mensah: 6- Made one phenomenal tackle to deny a 1-on-1 and looked reasonable although distribution was poor.
Dann: 4- Didn't look comfortable in possession, not suited to 3 at the back at all.
Riedewald: 5- Not great defensively, especially at corners but showed glimmers of quality, hopefully will get better.
Ward: 3- Dreadful. Not pacey enough to play RWB. Didn't seem to get forward or back in time, stuck around the halfway line as Huddersfield got in behind again and again.
Milivojevic: 5- Uncharacteristically quiet performance, struggled to get 'stuck in' like he usually does but was perhaps unfairly subbed at HT.
Puncheon: 3- Ineffective and slow. Difficult to see what he actually adds to the team beyond the captaincy. Set-pieces especially woeful.
Van Aanholt: 5- Looks far more capable of playing wing back than Ward and did manage to get forward a few times, but wasn't particularly threatening. Set pieces also poor.
Loftus-Cheek: 7 (MOTM)- Best player in Red and Blue by far, looks more composed in possession than the rest, especially in the second half when playing CM.
Benteke: 4- Isolated for most of the game and failed to really make an impact. Nearly scored a header but for a brilliant save, but was ultimately wasteful witht the few opportunities he got.
Zaha: 6- Offered some creativity and had a few good moments, although was marked heavily and missed a great opportunity when through on goal. Whole team now starting to rely on him to make things happen.

Subs:

Townsend (on for Milivojevic): 6- looked lively and desperate to make an impact, but struggled to find space.
Tomkins (on for Fosu-Mensah): 4- Came on and was immediately at fault for the third goal, didn't make much of an impression otherwise.

 

Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 12 Aug 17 7.01pm

Originally posted by priestinator

My ratings for today:

Hennessey: 4- Not really at fault for the goals but looked shaky at corners and is terrible with his feet.
Fosu-Mensah: 6- Made one phenomenal tackle to deny a 1-on-1 and looked reasonable although distribution was poor.
Dann: 4- Didn't look comfortable in possession, not suited to 3 at the back at all.
Riedewald: 5- Not great defensively, especially at corners but showed glimmers of quality, hopefully will get better.
Ward: 3- Dreadful. Not pacey enough to play RWB. Didn't seem to get forward or back in time, stuck around the halfway line as Huddersfield got in behind again and again.
Milivojevic: 5- Uncharacteristically quiet performance, struggled to get 'stuck in' like he usually does but was perhaps unfairly subbed at HT.
Puncheon: 3- Ineffective and slow. Difficult to see what he actually adds to the team beyond the captaincy. Set-pieces especially woeful.
Van Aanholt: 5- Looks far more capable of playing wing back than Ward and did manage to get forward a few times, but wasn't particularly threatening. Set pieces also poor.
Loftus-Cheek: 7 (MOTM)- Best player in Red and Blue by far, looks more composed in possession than the rest, especially in the second half when playing CM.
Benteke: 4- Isolated for most of the game and failed to really make an impact. Nearly scored a header but for a brilliant save, but was ultimately wasteful witht the few opportunities he got.
Zaha: 6- Offered some creativity and had a few good moments, although was marked heavily and missed a great opportunity when through on goal. Whole team now starting to rely on him to make things happen.

Subs:

Townsend (on for Milivojevic): 6- looked lively and desperate to make an impact, but struggled to find space.
Tomkins (on for Fosu-Mensah): 4- Came on and was immediately at fault for the third goal, didn't make much of an impression otherwise.

3 for Puncheon is generous.

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.04pm

I agree with some of these. I can also now give my opinion given that someone has helped me recognise which of the new players I thought was dogsh*t!

Going:

Hennessey 4
Fosu Mensah 6
Dann 4
Riedewald 3
Ward 4 - didn't he also prevent a certain goal? Did a lot of crap stuff too though and apparently the first goal was his OG!
Milovojevic 5
Puncheon 4
Van Aanholt 4 (marking him down for those corners)
Loftus-Cheek 6
Benteke 4
Zaha 4 (although largely due to the marking on him, but he looked flimsy)

Townsend 6 - he did as some spark to an almost spent bonfire
Tomkins - I couldn't tell you. I didn't really see him do anything except run onto the pitch. I thought it was a pitch invader.

 




priestinator Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 7.06pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Tomkins - I couldn't tell you. I didn't really see him do anything except run onto the pitch. I thought it was a pitch invader.

I must say he doesn't look much like a footballer...

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.09pm

Originally posted by Jules111

3 for Puncheon is generous.

I gave him 4.

To be honest, I've seen him play worse and because the whole team was poo he didn't stand out as much this time.

 




Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 12 Aug 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by Jules111

3 for Puncheon is generous.

It's been said and said until everyone is red and blue in the face. JP has had his season in the sun, he is now no longer good enough for our team, amazingly.

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.11pm

Originally posted by priestinator

I must say he doesn't look much like a footballer...

He looks like he could win a "beautiful glossy hair" award but a player needs more to their game than shiny hair.

I'm being unfair, he's had some decent games in the past. I'm pretty sure he was better than Riedewald today as well. I'd take an uneventful performance over that Subbuteo game Riedewald was playing with Hennessey.

Edited by Part Time James (12 Aug 2017 7.12pm)

 




teedee Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 7.12pm

Our best 2 players were the 2 loanees - says it all really

Dann isn't good enough in a 3 - pay the money and get Sakho ASAP

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.12pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

It's been said and said until everyone is red and blue in the face. JP has had his season in the sun, he is now no longer good enough for our team, amazingly.

He'd be a fantastic second choice for his position. That's my analysis.

 




Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by teedee

Our best 2 players were the 2 loanees - says it all really

Dann isn't good enough in a 3 - pay the money and get Sakho ASAP

I'd not just get Sakho but ditch the idea of 3-4-3 until we have better options than Ward and Puncheon for their positions. Ward is out of position, Puncheon is out of his depth.

 




Hudsoneagle Flag 12 Aug 17 7.15pm

I also thought it was Ward that made the best tackle of the 1st half at least. Stopped a one on one situation it was a fantastic tackle.

Very disappointed today with the performance as much as the result. Wilf was marked out of the game first half, there was no obvious plan B.

Huddersfield just wanted the points so much more than us and that is hard to take.

 

teedee Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 7.15pm

The fans won't accept another performance like that against Swansea. Things will get ugly - F**k style give us results.

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.18pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

I also thought it was Ward that made the best tackle of the 1st half at least. Stopped a one on one situation it was a fantastic tackle.

Very disappointed today with the performance as much as the result. Wilf was marked out of the game first half, there was no obvious plan B.

Huddersfield just wanted the points so much more than us and that is hard to take.

I mentioned that in my ratings, it was him that came from nowhere to dive over the ball for Hennessey to pick the ball out from under. He actually played better as a right wing back than last time I saw him try (that was Sunderland before anyone wonders how that's possible). I like the guy, I like him as a defender more though.

 




Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 12 Aug 17 7.19pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I'd not just get Sakho but ditch the idea of 3-4-3 until we have better options than Ward and Puncheon for their positions. Ward is out of position, Puncheon is out of his depth.

JP looked good a couple of seasons or three ago in a team that barely played any kind of passing football. Only one who looked like he could control the ball, take his time to find a constructive pass.

Now when he gets the ball in the 18 yard box he skys it's like he's never scored a goal in his life.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Aug 17 7.23pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

JP looked good a couple of seasons or three ago in a team that barely played any kind of passing football. Only one who looked like he could control the ball, take his time to find a constructive pass.

Now when he gets the ball in the 18 yard box he skys it's like he's never scored a goal in his life.

He used to play well as an attacking midfielder. Since AP had the brainwave of making him a defensive midfielder he's been s**t. Can't believe frank sees him not only as a DM but captain. ...

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.24pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

JP looked good a couple of seasons or three ago in a team that barely played any kind of passing football. Only one who looked like he could control the ball, take his time to find a constructive pass.

Now when he gets the ball in the 18 yard box he skys it's like he's never scored a goal in his life.

Oh for sure. There was a time when I lauded him as one of my favourite players on the pitch. Don't get me wrong, I'd love for him to find that form again.....how long can we wait though?

 




priestinator Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 7.24pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

JP looked good a couple of seasons or three ago in a team that barely played any kind of passing football. Only one who looked like he could control the ball, take his time to find a constructive pass.

Now when he gets the ball in the 18 yard box he skys it's like he's never scored a goal in his life.

And to think he's joint with Benteke as our top premier league scorer in our squad! That FA cup final just seems to have kicked it out of him...

 

Username Flag Horsham 12 Aug 17 7.26pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I gave him 4.

To be honest, I've seen him play worse and because the whole team was poo he didn't stand out as much this time.

Problem with that is, Puncheone's absence contributed to so many other problems that affected other people.

Dann in particular looked so shaky on the ball, but every time he looked up for someone to pass to, Puncheon was nowhere to be seen.

We badly missed Cabaye today.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 12 Aug 17 7.28pm

Punch was better than:
1. henesey
2.dann
3. Luka
2. Ward
4. Riedewald
arguably better than
5. benteke
6. PVA

he got involved far more than these and his contribution was overall better.


 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.31pm

Originally posted by Username

Problem with that is, Puncheone's absence contributed to so many other problems that affected other people.

Dann in particular looked so shaky on the ball, but every time he looked up for someone to pass to, Puncheon was nowhere to be seen.

We badly missed Cabaye today.

Yes I agree. Did Luka go off injured? That seemed like an odd sub otherwise

 




Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings: