You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why its Very Important To Complain NOW !! (LOCKED)


Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Aug 17 8.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We are ranked 14th on lots of things in this division. We're expecting logical decisions, strategies and direction, and maybe not being embarrassed by the play off winners 3-0 at home. Not that entitled.

I don't think many would have predicted that we would have spent just £8 Mill and signed 2 'Loan' players with limited first team experience by the start of the season.

 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 16 Aug 17 8.11pm

I'm taking a break from Hol.. this is utterly stupid.

I think we're all getting rather spoiled.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Aug 17 8.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

I don't think many would have predicted that we would have spent just £8 Mill and signed 2 'Loan' players with limited first team experience by the start of the season.

Oh I did. So did Bexleydave and a few others but are viewed as too negative and nobody wants to hear the truth. But this is not the only issue.

Frank is new in the country, League and club, yet has ploughed on with this 3-4-3 with some mind boggling preparation and changes league day 1. Unnecessary unless you're trying make your point to the football world asap and risk it going t1ts up. He's here long term. What's the rush with 3-4-3? Slow down, play to our strengths a bit more, get some points on the board, keep yourself in the job and is in the league.

Only one match gone but I wouldn't experiment regardless for long if I was him.

 


COYP

Kodg Flag LDN 16 Aug 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by Willo

Rather declamatory and emotive rhetoric with hatred foaming like 'Fairy Liquid'. !

A snarling Rottweiller with dripping fangs !!!!

Edited by Willo (16 Aug 2017 7.37pm)

I'm happy to live up to that description. Although dial down back on those explanation marks, son!

But I have no hatred foaming like Fairy Liquid. a rabid dog, or a Poundland lavender bubble bath for that matter.

I simply despise and pity those who believe they are entitled to anything. They are not. No one is. On top of that the dictionary definition of supporter is: a person who is actively interested in and wishes success for a particular sports team. How the f*** does that sit with entitlement?.

And while I'm on the subject. what's with 'loan', willo they not real players or something? They don't count?

Grow the f*** up!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Aug 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Oh I did. So did Bexleydave and a few others but are viewed as too negative and nobody wants to hear the truth. But this is not the only issue.

Frank is new in the country, League and club, yet has ploughed on with this 3-4-3 with some mind boggling preparation and changes league day 1. Unnecessary unless you're trying make your point to the football world asap and risk it going t1ts up. He's here long term. What's the rush with 3-4-3? Slow down, play to our strengths a bit more, get some points on the board, keep yourself in the job and is in the league.

Only one match gone but I wouldn't experiment regardless for long if I was him.

Perhaps not to the exact detail !

But I can appreciate what you were thinking when others were seduced with stories of us being linked with established overseas players who would have cost a tidy sum in transfer fees and wages.

Still the 'Transfer Window' is still open for a while !

 

Kodg Flag LDN 16 Aug 17 8.29pm

Originally posted by GlaziertoEagle

I'm taking a break from Hol.. this is utterly stupid.

I think we're all getting rather spoiled.

Totally agree. Reading this s*** is embarrassing. I thought we were better than this. But obviously not

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 16 Aug 17 8.32pm

BFS "retired " and put us in a position where we needed a new manager. The board decided that they wanted a change in direction. They wanted to play a more possession game and selected FdB to achieve it. The board are the holders of the purse strings and decide if they are going to release funds in order to purchase the players the manager requires. If we fail to convert to possession football and do not collect ant points there is only one body responsible and that is the booard. They selected the manager and provided the funds to bring in players. If neither were up to it then the fault always rests at the top as a result of poor decision making.
On the other hand as it is very early in the piece we may well find over the next couple of weeks players come in the fortunes of the team turns and we start picking up points and we will all be happy again.
If not the poor decisions of the board will be where the fault lays or if it succeeds where the praise should be directed.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Aug 17 8.32pm

Originally posted by Kodg

I'm happy to live up to that description. Although dial down back on those explanation marks, son!

But I have no hatred foaming like Fairy Liquid. a rabid dog, or a Poundland lavender bubble bath for that matter.

I simply despise and pity those who believe they are entitled to anything. They are not. No one is. On top of that the dictionary definition of supporter is: a person who is actively interested in and wishes success for a particular sports team. How the f*** does that sit with entitlement?.

And while I'm on the subject. what's with 'loan', willo they not real players or something? They don't count?

Grow the f*** up!

My comments were made with a liberal sprinkling of jest and NOT designed to be critical or offensive in any way.

Maybe I should have said they were passionate remarks !

Edited by Willo (16 Aug 2017 8.41pm)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 16 Aug 17 8.34pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Oh I did. So did Bexleydave and a few others but are viewed as too negative and nobody wants to hear the truth. But this is not the only issue.

Frank is new in the country, League and club, yet has ploughed on with this 3-4-3 with some mind boggling preparation and changes league day 1. Unnecessary unless you're trying make your point to the football world asap and risk it going t1ts up. He's here long term. What's the rush with 3-4-3? Slow down, play to our strengths a bit more, get some points on the board, keep yourself in the job and is in the league.

Only one match gone but I wouldn't experiment regardless for long if I was him.

Judging by some on here, he should already be gone, lol.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

bodge Flag 16 Aug 17 8.45pm

SA took time to turn it around without Sakho he would have failed he left because he knows how hard this job is. SA fans who make excuses for the crap games we played under him and there were plenty should give FDB time to get it right.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Aug 17 8.49pm

Originally posted by bodge

SA took time to turn it around without Sakho he would have failed he left because he knows how hard this job is. SA fans who make excuses for the crap games we played under him and there were plenty should give FDB time to get it right.

How many so called "SA Fans" must have thought that if he was on charge on Saturday we wouldn't have suffered an abject 3-0 defeat.

 

rattus2002 Flag 16 Aug 17 11.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Oh I did. So did Bexleydave and a few others but are viewed as too negative and nobody wants to hear the truth. But this is not the only issue.

Frank is new in the country, League and club, yet has ploughed on with this 3-4-3 with some mind boggling preparation and changes league day 1. Unnecessary unless you're trying make your point to the football world asap and risk it going t1ts up. He's here long term. What's the rush with 3-4-3? Slow down, play to our strengths a bit more, get some points on the board, keep yourself in the job and is in the league.

Only one match gone but I wouldn't experiment regardless for long if I was him.

Rudi, we get it. You don't agree with FDB deciding that he wants to play the 3-4-3 formation. You are repeating the same message in pretty much every post.

You continuously stress about us playing to our strengths. What are these? Being defensively solid by playing 4-4-2? We haven't been that for 18 months and we don't have the one player who provided some defensive strength for about 6 games last season.

Getting the ball into the box earlier instead of passing the ball around? Listen to the quotes from De Boer, he isn't asking us to be Barca...he just wants us to stop thumping aimless 60 yard balls from back to front and conceding so much possession. If our players cannot make the correct decisions as to when to pass and when to be more direct then they are not good enough regardless of any formation that we employ.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Aug 17 11.29pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

BFS "retired " and put us in a position where we needed a new manager. The board decided that they wanted a change in direction. They wanted to play a more possession game and selected FdB to achieve it. The board are the holders of the purse strings and decide if they are going to release funds in order to purchase the players the manager requires. If we fail to convert to possession football and do not collect ant points there is only one body responsible and that is the booard. They selected the manager and provided the funds to bring in players. If neither were up to it then the fault always rests at the top as a result of poor decision making.
On the other hand as it is very early in the piece we may well find over the next couple of weeks players come in the fortunes of the team turns and we start picking up points and we will all be happy again.
If not the poor decisions of the board will be where the fault lays or if it succeeds where the praise should be directed.

Sorry but someone else ignoring the mistake of the big change to 3-4-3.

We didn't and don't need to. More possession football can be played with 4 at the back, and we have the players to play 4 at the back. But let's suddenly ignore that.

Frank has broadcast to the world it's full steam ahead with 3-4-3. Huddersfield analysed what to do and did it successfully, providing the blue print for others to do likewise.

Play 4 at the back, or at a push, 3-5-2, start evolving the play and then maybe change to 3-4-3. We don't currently have the players, the funds, the regular possession to play it. But everyone ignores that and believes we've suddenly got loads more than another £22 mil to spend after £8 mil on Riederwald. Frank knew the finances, but has ploughed on regardless.

 


COYP

homes Flag New Eltham 17 Aug 17 7.25am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sorry but someone else ignoring the mistake of the big change to 3-4-3.

We didn't and don't need to. More possession football can be played with 4 at the back, and we have the players to play 4 at the back. But let's suddenly ignore that.

Frank has broadcast to the world it's full steam ahead with 3-4-3. Huddersfield analysed what to do and did it successfully, providing the blue print for others to do likewise.

Play 4 at the back, or at a push, 3-5-2, start evolving the play and then maybe change to 3-4-3. We don't currently have the players, the funds, the regular possession to play it. But everyone ignores that and believes we've suddenly got loads more than another £22 mil to spend after £8 mil on Riederwald. Frank knew the finances, but has ploughed on regardless.

Spot on, I don't understand the rush to 3-4-3. Gradually over time yes, he signed a 3 year deal. Steady the ship understand the league and what you're up against and implement the 3-4-3 slowly.

We have a system that works for us use it. Personally I couldn't be bothered if the system is not pretty I just want effective.

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Aug 17 9.45am

Originally posted by rattus2002

Rudi, we get it. You don't agree with FDB deciding that he wants to play the 3-4-3 formation. You are repeating the same message in pretty much every post.

You continuously stress about us playing to our strengths. What are these? Being defensively solid by playing 4-4-2? We haven't been that for 18 months and we don't have the one player who provided some defensive strength for about 6 games last season.

Getting the ball into the box earlier instead of passing the ball around? Listen to the quotes from De Boer, he isn't asking us to be Barca...he just wants us to stop thumping aimless 60 yard balls from back to front and conceding so much possession. If our players cannot make the correct decisions as to when to pass and when to be more direct then they are not good enough regardless of any formation that we employ.

Sorry you don't get it.

Read posts about 'gradual change.' There's one above. Read posts about Frank's drastic change. Read continuous posts inferring Frank's possession football requires 3-4-3. It does not. We didn't have the players when he came in even though he said we did. We didn't have the players vs Huddersfield even though he ploughed on anyway with players who hadn't played there all summer and we need at least 3 just to possibly keep up with Huddersfield at home.

And I'm sorry but it wasn't just Sakho but Luka too who made the difference, but now he's not just a shield but more because we only have 2 central players because we've got 3 players standing high up the pitch. A lot of our problems would've been addressed with a number 10, Luka and Cabaye together and just quality players all over the pitch with no weak links. But no, let's all lie that 3-4-3 is so imperative to the point it could see us in serious trouble.

Oh and it was just Delaney who thumped 60 yard balls. Where we struggled was only threatening from wide, hence why I talk about a number 10 rather than just 2 midfielders and still no attacking midfielder. Jeez

Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Aug 2017 9.51am)

 


COYP

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 17 Aug 17 10.06am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sorry but someone else ignoring the mistake of the big change to 3-4-3.

We didn't and don't need to. More possession football can be played with 4 at the back, and we have the players to play 4 at the back. But let's suddenly ignore that.

Frank has broadcast to the world it's full steam ahead with 3-4-3. Huddersfield analysed what to do and did it successfully, providing the blue print for others to do likewise.

Play 4 at the back, or at a push, 3-5-2, start evolving the play and then maybe change to 3-4-3. We don't currently have the players, the funds, the regular possession to play it. But everyone ignores that and believes we've suddenly got loads more than another £22 mil to spend after £8 mil on Riederwald. Frank knew the finances, but has ploughed on regardless.

I did not mention a system I just stated he was selected by the owners to play more possession football and if he fails responsibility will not only lay with the manager but also the owners who selected him.
COYP

 

rattus2002 Flag 17 Aug 17 10.26am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sorry you don't get it.

Read posts about 'gradual change.' There's one above. Read posts about Frank's drastic change. Read continuous posts inferring Frank's possession football requires 3-4-3. It does not. We didn't have the players when he came in even though he said we did. We didn't have the players vs Huddersfield even though he ploughed on anyway with players who hadn't played there all summer and we need at least 3 just to possibly keep up with Huddersfield at home.

And I'm sorry but it wasn't just Sakho but Luka too who made the difference, but now he's not just a shield but more because we only have 2 central players because we've got 3 players standing high up the pitch. A lot of our problems would've been addressed with a number 10, Luka and Cabaye together and just quality players all over the pitch with no weak links. But no, let's all lie that 3-4-3 is so imperative to the point it could see us in serious trouble.

Oh and it was just Delaney who thumped 60 yard balls. Where we struggled was only threatening from wide, hence why I talk about a number 10 rather than just 2 midfielders and still no attacking midfielder. Jeez

Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Aug 2017 9.51am)

You have posted the same content time after time and yet don't answer the points anyone raises. You make out that we were a successful team playing 4-3-3 as per last year. We were not...the season points tally indicates that alone. FDB is not coming in and changing a formation or style of play that has has provided us with success over the last 50 odd league games. What is the point of a gradual change? To keep getting the results we were getting in the last 5 games of last year?

Luka was great, no question but Sakho was the difference. Without him marshalling at the back we would have been doomed, even with Luka.

Regardless of the formation we lack quality players wth the ability of keeping the ball. It was not only Delaney who gave away posesssion regularly and cheaply, Hennessy, Ward and Kelly all have traits of it too.

I don't agree with some of FDB decisions granted...not enough preseason games and playing players on sat who hadn't figured in preseason but you are over playing the formation change. We just aren't great...and haven't been for a long time.



 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Aug 17 10.30am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I did not mention a system I just stated he was selected by the owners to play more possession football and if he fails responsibility will not only lay with the manager but also the owners who selected him.
COYP

You mention "Owners" but in reality it was Steve Parish who selected him.

If this doesn't work out and the axe falls sooner rather than later, one suspects that Steve will come in for a great deal of vituperation and will have to don a tin helmet and tighten the straps.

FDB might also be seen as 'Damaged goods' following his exit from Inter Milan.

Edited by Willo (17 Aug 2017 10.31am)

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 17 Aug 17 10.39am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Oh I did. So did Bexleydave and a few others but are viewed as too negative and nobody wants to hear the truth. But this is not the only issue.

Frank is new in the country, League and club, yet has ploughed on with this 3-4-3 with some mind boggling preparation and changes league day 1. Unnecessary unless you're trying make your point to the football world asap and risk it going t1ts up. He's here long term. What's the rush with 3-4-3? Slow down, play to our strengths a bit more, get some points on the board, keep yourself in the job and is in the league.

Only one match gone but I wouldn't experiment regardless for long if I was him.

Yepp, I did too. Just because a few of us are perceived as negative it doesn't mean we are not correct.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 17 Aug 17 10.41am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

BFS "retired " and put us in a position where we needed a new manager. The board decided that they wanted a change in direction. They wanted to play a more possession game and selected FdB to achieve it. The board are the holders of the purse strings and decide if they are going to release funds in order to purchase the players the manager requires. If we fail to convert to possession football and do not collect ant points there is only one body responsible and that is the booard. They selected the manager and provided the funds to bring in players. If neither were up to it then the fault always rests at the top as a result of poor decision making.
On the other hand as it is very early in the piece we may well find over the next couple of weeks players come in the fortunes of the team turns and we start picking up points and we will all be happy again.
If not the poor decisions of the board will be where the fault lays or if it succeeds where the praise should be directed.

Kind of makes you wonder if it was Pardew or Parish who wanted the more expansive type of football we tried last season.

Sam knew what was coming and knew he couldn't do it again on the small budget he was given, knowing how many players were leaving and needed replacing.

 

Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic