You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Things learnt from today's game
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Things learnt from today's game


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Master Coin Flag 19 Aug 17 4.53pm

1) We can play a defensively disciplined game in 3-4-3 and it just might take a few games to adapt but is doable
2) Benteke and Puncheon don't really have a home in this formation. Benteke looks slow and isolated and Puncheon isn't in our top 2 central mids. At the moment he's just making us play RLC or of position for no good reason
3) We are pretty toothless without Wilf

In summary I'm not as concerned with the defence as I was but we look awful as an attacking unit without Zaha. Gonna be a long month unless we sign a tasty winger

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 19 Aug 17 4.58pm

agree 100%, if not for Milo's mistake we would likely have gotten a point. Not blaming Milo, he ran his socks off and likely tiredness played a part.

Benteke seems only fit for a team that can continually cross the ball for him.
JP we have known about for a while.

WH put in a good shift though, have not understood his naysayers. I guess they will complain about the Liverpool goal today.

We need a more dynamic forward, not sure where you will get it though. I would have loved Chicharito.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Aug 17 5.01pm

We need 5 or 6 players at least, I doubt we'll sign more than 1 if that, will be a January panic job again if we are lucky

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

larscc Flag Nrond y 19 Aug 17 5.02pm

Liverpool has 13 shots on target, we had one! So we learnt that we have an outstanding keeper. And welearnt that a manager can destroy our defence and offence simultanously!

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 19 Aug 17 5.05pm

Couldn't hold on to the ball for love nor money. w***y 70th minute goal conceded, no surprises there really. Ok defensively, pretty similar to last season really.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 19 Aug 17 5.09pm

Originally posted by twist

agree 100%, if not for Milo's mistake we would likely have gotten a point. Not blaming Milo, he ran his socks off and likely tiredness played a part.

Benteke seems only fit for a team that can continually cross the ball for him.
JP we have known about for a while.

WH put in a good shift though, have not understood his naysayers. I guess they will complain about the Liverpool goal today.

We need a more dynamic forward, not sure where you will get it though. I would have loved Chicharito.


No it wasn't just down to that mistake Liverpool was all over us at the end changes needed to be made but came too late.

Milo was great today him and Cheek looked real quality shame Punch is not up to that standard he needs to be dropped.

WH did nothing special all those he saved you would expect him to do so but again he looked iffy at times he is another we need to buy replacement for.

Benteke can play only one way that is the problem with him which is why he did poor at Liverpool he can't adapt we really need another striker.

Wilf wouldn't of made much of a difference in that game i think the way Liverpool are they would of wound him up just look at the ref treatment of Benteke he was doing nothing wrong yet ref always sided with Liverpool player.

I agree should of gone for Chicharito his trnasfer fee was nothing really in this market and yes he wanted wages demands around 140 but again that is not that much wilf/benteke/cabaye are on that sort of money he is proven.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Aug 17 5.12pm

Originally posted by larscc

Liverpool has 13 shots on target, we had one! So we learnt that we have an outstanding keeper. And welearnt that a manager can destroy our defence and offence simultanously!

If you look at the stats from last season's win at Anfield we had only three shots on target and 28% possession. Not a lot different from today. The difference is that we didn't have Zaha to create chances for us today and Bentenke fluffed his lines. Don't be a drama queen.

An improved performance and signs that FdB will adapt our game according to who we're playing, etc. As the Liverpool goal came fairly late there was little chance to change tactically and throwing Dann up (given our lack of a back-up striker) was about the only option.

Some big positives today and good to see he gave Kai Kai a chance in a game that actually meant something.

Onwards!

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 19 Aug 17 5.17pm

Benteke is just a lump, sorry but i cant stand the bloke. He is lazy, can't control the ball, supposedly the best header in Europe (really) doesn't harry defenders as the 1st line of defence. At £32 million i would expect him to be all over the pitch and missing chances for fun. If he had been a £400k signing from Rochdale he would be banished to the reserves never to be seen again.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Aug 17 5.23pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

We need 5 or 6 players at least, I doubt we'll sign more than 1 if that, will be a January panic job again if we are lucky

-.-'

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Norway Flag Sandnes,Norway 19 Aug 17 5.23pm

Thought Kaikai was promising when he came on - nice shot though the whistle had gone

 


Norway

mixed nuts Flag 19 Aug 17 5.53pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


No it wasn't just down to that mistake Liverpool was all over us at the end changes needed to be made but came too late.

Milo was great today him and Cheek looked real quality shame Punch is not up to that standard he needs to be dropped.

WH did nothing special all those he saved you would expect him to do so but again he looked iffy at times he is another we need to buy replacement for.

Benteke can play only one way that is the problem with him which is why he did poor at Liverpool he can't adapt we really need another striker.

Wilf wouldn't of made much of a difference in that game i think the way Liverpool are they would of wound him up just look at the ref treatment of Benteke he was doing nothing wrong yet ref always sided with Liverpool player.

I agree should of gone for Chicharito his trnasfer fee was nothing really in this market and yes he wanted wages demands around 140 but again that is not that much wilf/benteke/cabaye are on that sort of money he is proven.

The blue is the reason for the red.

 

mixed nuts Flag 19 Aug 17 5.59pm

Originally posted by larscc

Liverpool has 13 shots on target, we had one! So we learnt that we have an outstanding keeper. And welearnt that a manager can destroy our defence and offence simultanously!

You cannot reflect fairly on these stats, a shot that just misses the goal could be a lot nearer to going in than one straight at the keeper!
Today's performance just showed how sacking Pardew was not a good idea.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 19 Aug 17 6.05pm

Originally posted by mixed nuts

You cannot reflect fairly on these stats, a shot that just misses the goal could be a lot nearer to going in than one straight at the keeper!
Today's performance just showed how sacking Pardew was not a good idea.

I'm more disappointed that big Sam went.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 19 Aug 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by kenners46

Benteke is just a lump, sorry but i cant stand the bloke. He is lazy, can't control the ball, supposedly the best header in Europe (really) doesn't harry defenders as the 1st line of defence. At £32 million i would expect him to be all over the pitch and missing chances for fun. If he had been a £400k signing from Rochdale he would be banished to the reserves never to be seen again.

Unfortunately I'm really starting to agree with this viewpoint.

He missed a number of sitters against Huddersfield and he is SO lazy.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 19 Aug 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by mixed nuts

You cannot reflect fairly on these stats, a shot that just misses the goal could be a lot nearer to going in than one straight at the keeper!
Today's performance just showed how sacking Pardew was not a good idea.

The fact that we WERE playing at Anfield today shows it was a good idea to sack Pardew!

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 19 Aug 17 6.09pm

What it did show was how far Liverpool have come in the last 4 seasons . After all it is their first win against us at Anfield in 4 seasons !

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Aug 17 6.14pm

We looked tired and leggy at the back at the end I thought.

Punch needs dropping fast. Ward needs replacing.

PVA is better than we're seeing.

I'd rather see 3 midfielders centrally.

 


COYP

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 19 Aug 17 6.16pm

Milo had been replaced by Jimmy Mac when Sane scored albeit from 2 deflections. The culprits for our demise were Puncheon and Benteke. Our captain who has no pace and we carry and a striker who can't hit a cows arse from 7 yards.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Aug 17 6.17pm

Originally posted by kenners46

Benteke is just a lump, sorry but i cant stand the bloke. He is lazy, can't control the ball, supposedly the best header in Europe (really) doesn't harry defenders as the 1st line of defence. At £32 million i would expect him to be all over the pitch and missing chances for fun. If he had been a £400k signing from Rochdale he would be banished to the reserves never to be seen again.

Yeah, our 15 goal striker from last year would be banished to the reserves for failing to score in 2 games.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 19 Aug 17 6.18pm

Our defense was pretty decent in the centre, but it's clear that Ward and Van Aanholt don't really understand the wig back positions.
Luckily McArthur doesn't seem to be totally out of favor.
We lack an incisive force, especially without Wilf, but even with him.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Things learnt from today's game