You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What Went On Behind The Scenes?
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What Went On Behind The Scenes?


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Sep 17 7.24am

Originally posted by chateauferret

It looked like de Boer had pardewed Milivojevic before a ball was even kicked and was well on his way to pardewing Ward and Kelly. He then proceeded to start Lee on Sunday when both Milivojevic (presumably) and van Aanholt were available, and has thrown players under the 'bus after each game. We can then add to that the fact that he was playing the wrong style in contradiction to discussions he had with the Board, which even if it had worked would still have been a breach of trust.

I subscribe to the view that as well as getting nulle points in four games he has also upset the apple cart by behaving like a t**t.

Which is obviously the real reason why he is out on his arse.

Edited by chateauferret (12 Sep 2017 7.17am)

Spot on.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 12 Sep 17 7.29am

Noone comes out of this at all well. De Boer may have been given false promises of funds for new players, but to be pig-headed and to steam-roller on his new formation with clearly the wrong players was selfish in the extreme.

He should have seen that from the start, and if so walked before a ball was even kicked. At least we would be on 0 points with 38 games left.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 12 Sep 17 7.48am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

FDB turned out to be a bit of a c*nt. SP couldn't have really accounted for that. Simple really.

Pretty much

 

The Dolphin Flag 12 Sep 17 7.56am

I have calmed down - just.
I think it is a shame that FDB has gone but as this thread headlines and what none of us know is the real reason behind his sacking.
Laddo's post is very good and is probably pretty accurate.
At the end of the day SP appears to have made a mistake or been duped when appointing FDB and the ship was very unsteady.
He didn't sit back and watch it sink - he acted/reacted and as I trust him implicitly to do the best for the Club I can only presume that there is far more to it than we will ever know.
Do I agree with Hodgson being appointed - not a jot I'm afraid as it is short term and here we go again!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Sep 17 8.03am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Delaney appears to be a bit of a trouble maker as he has made known in the past that he didn't like certain players including Glen Murray and it wouldn't surprise me if he was the team's shop steward.

Kelly apparently didn't like being told that he wasn't good enough but that's something that most HOLers have been saying for ages and reading between the lines de Boer would have unloaded him in the transfer window but Parish interfered and wouldn't sell him.

Ward allegedly didn't like being told to sit out a training session so that he could watch from the sidelines how a wingback should play. The only word that springs to mind is "diddums"

de Boer was supposed to be a football club manager not a nursemaid to highly paid prima donnas so Parish needs to make sure that the job specification for the new manager includes the fact that the person needs to be an experienced mummy


I'm normally in broad agreement with your posts, but this one demonstrates that you know little, if anything at all, about people-management. It's particularly important to be good at keeping a team onside when you're attempting to initiate major changes and alienating individuals, notwithstanding your views on their abilities, will not work. To be a success as a manager requires that you have the respect of the people you're managing and that they have confidence in you. The attitude you've demonstrated in your post is most likely the very same one that got de Boer the sack. Sorry, but you don't get a group of people to give you their best and support you to the hilt by bullying them.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Sep 17 8.26am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have calmed down - just.
I think it is a shame that FDB has gone but as this thread headlines and what none of us know is the real reason behind his sacking.
Laddo's post is very good and is probably pretty accurate.
At the end of the day SP appears to have made a mistake or been duped when appointing FDB and the ship was very unsteady.
He didn't sit back and watch it sink - he acted/reacted and as I trust him implicitly to do the best for the Club I can only presume that there is far more to it than we will ever know.
Do I agree with Hodgson being appointed - not a jot I'm afraid as it is short term and here we go again!

There is so much speculation on this matter and I will not make any comment.

All I will say is that you don't sack your manager after his first 4 games in charge based on results alone.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Sep 17 8.31am

Originally posted by Willo

There is so much speculation on this matter and I will not make any comment.

All I will say is that you don't sack your manager after his first 4 games in charge based on results alone.


I agree and especially when the last outing, whilst unsuccessful, did show some evidence of steps in the right direction.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Sep 17 8.38am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

FDB turned out to be a bit of a c*nt. SP couldn't have really accounted for that. Simple really.

Of all the countless posts of unsubstantiated rumors, this says it all in a nutshell.
SP should be given credit for removing him, before it got worse.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Sep 17 8.39am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I agree and especially when the last outing, whilst unsuccessful, did show some evidence of steps in the right direction.

I heard someone ask the question yesterday that had we won at Burnley on the back of that performance would FDB have still been removed of his duties ?

He went on to speculate that if Parish and the 'Board' had made their decision before the game why didn't they sack FDB beforehand and put Lee in charge on an 'Interim' basis as a win at Burnley followed by a sacking would have seemed totally ludicrous to supporters and the outside world.

I overheard this and never got involved in the discussion !

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Sep 17 8.43am

Originally posted by Willo

I heard someone ask the question yesterday that had we won at Burnley on the back of that performance would FDB have still been removed of his duties ?

He went on to speculate that if Parish and the 'Board' had made their decision before the game why didn't they sack FDB beforehand and put Lee in charge on an 'Interim' basis as a win at Burnley followed by a sacking would have seemed totally ludicrous to supporters and the outside world.

I overheard this and never got involved in the discussion !

Just giving him more rope to hang himself, that's all.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Sep 17 8.44am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I'm normally in broad agreement with your posts, but this one demonstrates that you know little, if anything at all, about people-management. It's particularly important to be good at keeping a team onside when you're attempting to initiate major changes and alienating individuals, notwithstanding your views on their abilities, will not work. To be a success as a manager requires that you have the respect of the people you're managing and that they have confidence in you. The attitude you've demonstrated in your post is most likely the very same one that got de Boer the sack. Sorry, but you don't get a group of people to give you their best and support you to the hilt by bullying them.

Haha. No s***!

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

michaelpearce Flag grays 12 Sep 17 8.53am

This topic as been a very good read for a change no told you so,fans have thought about what was going on not just gut reaction myself I feel we wont hear the full story for sometime, sacking wrong maybe, appointment of woy thats not going forward, but he may show case what a good squad we have and a better younger manager may want tobe part of that hopefully

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Sep 17 8.54am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

If some of the players don't like it because the manager shows off a few skills and was better than them they need to get a grip. Pathetic.

De Boer did look a proper tool when he was doing the press ups on twitter mind.

This I agree with, I remember reading years ago that Steve Coppell loved a kick around in the 5 a sides and he still had a bit of magic. These players need to get a grip and understand that while tv money has sent wages flying, most of them can't actually play decent football.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Sep 17 9.02am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

This topic as been a very good read for a change no told you so,fans have thought about what was going on not just gut reaction myself I feel we wont hear the full story for sometime, sacking wrong maybe, appointment of woy thats not going forward, but he may show case what a good squad we have and a better younger manager may want tobe part of that hopefully

We have to not look too far ahead into the future in terms of progression etc etc.

At the present time, even after 4 games we are in a relegation battle especially when one considers the games coming up against Man C,Man Utd and Chelsea.We need someone who can extricate us from the position we are in and ensure our PL survival.That is all that matters now.

 

Fred Bassett Flag rotherfield 12 Sep 17 9.16am

Nobody comes out of this very well. It's been a car crash from the summer and from what I've been told, combined with reading between the lines it went like this.

1. In May Parish met Big Sam to discuss transfers only to be left stunned at Sam wanting to leave.

2. Immediately the board made contact with Marco Silva who was making noises to force Watford's hand. We were keen but Watford had made strides in securing silva. It was never an option.

3. Pellegrino was then our number 1 choice. He had a great interview, was a good fit and worked with Sammy Lee before. The board wanted to appoint him but he was waiting on Southampton offer.

4. Dyche agent was keen for talks but palace had their man in Pellegrino. Meanwhile, FDB's agent made his move.

5. Parish set up interview and was impressed with the Dutchman who claimed he'd alter our playing style over time. Despite being impressed Pellegrino was first choice.

6. Pellegrino went to Southampton. Time was ticking and a decision had to be made.

7. FDB appointed.
----------------------

this post by Laddo seems to be spot on .

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Sep 17 9.50am

Originally posted by Fred Bassett

Nobody comes out of this very well. It's been a car crash from the summer and from what I've been told, combined with reading between the lines it went like this.

1. In May Parish met Big Sam to discuss transfers only to be left stunned at Sam wanting to leave.

2. Immediately the board made contact with Marco Silva who was making noises to force Watford's hand. We were keen but Watford had made strides in securing silva. It was never an option.

3. Pellegrino was then our number 1 choice. He had a great interview, was a good fit and worked with Sammy Lee before. The board wanted to appoint him but he was waiting on Southampton offer.

4. Dyche agent was keen for talks but palace had their man in Pellegrino. Meanwhile, FDB's agent made his move.

5. Parish set up interview and was impressed with the Dutchman who claimed he'd alter our playing style over time. Despite being impressed Pellegrino was first choice.

6. Pellegrino went to Southampton. Time was ticking and a decision had to be made.

7. FDB appointed.
----------------------

this post by Laddo seems to be spot on .

As it turns out the Southampton fans seem ready to get rid of Pellegrino already as well! I remember some people suggesting these two managers went to the wrong clubs and that de Boer was more suited to Southampton and Pellegrino to Palace. Maybe we can do a swap now and find out?

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Sep 17 9.54am

It appears that there are a number of facets at play here, which ultimately contributed in FdB getting the boot and the ensuing confusion as to what actually happened.

1) FdB's attitutde towards players
2) Player Power
3) SP's inability to keep off of social media when he needs to

Whilst I'm all for a Manager to stamp his own authority on a club and with the squad, to upset the apple cart quite so quickly (if what's been reported is to be believed) is something of a triumph.

It appears that FdB was/is intent to live off of his playing reputation to force his ideals (however merited) on to a team to get them playing his way.

This is twice now that he has upset a squad within a short period and twice now that he has been shown the door.

I hope for his sake that he drops his ego and learns from this mistake as it's ok to act this way in a club that molded you with that mentality, subsequently allowing you to work with players in that style (as in Ajax); but another entirely to try and force that on other clubs in other countries.

Managing is as much about building relationships with players as it is coaching them and developing their skill sets.

As for Player Power...I'm a little concerned that SP is too close to a number of players, who seem to have running to him when they get upset.

To be fair to FdB, telling Ward and Damo that they weren't good enough is pretty much what us on the boards have been saying for 12months...the truth is hard to take, but again its not what you say its the way you say it.

However, for players to then go to the Chairman in order to oust the Manager and for Parish to then (seemingly) act on their behest shows he is too close to the squad. We've already seen that he has a fair amount of sentiment (we saw that we Jonniesta getting yet another contract) and I accept that he, like us is a fan first and foremost. But he needs to distance himself now from the day to day squad issues, concentrating on the Club's infrastructure and plans for progression. Perhaps that's why DF is now in as DoF?

Finally SP and Social Media; he needs to know when to go on it and when to simply turn the phone off.

Part of what makes SP special and someone to be treasured is that he DOES interact with us, but in the last few days his tweets have caused confusion around the situation when mentioning we need to stick together before then sacking FdB within 12hrs.

This confusion has led to further unnecessary interaction with Trolls etc. who are all over the situation due to the lack of clear thought and direction..just what the fans and club needs at a time like this from its Chairman.

All in all its been a pretty unedifying 36hrs for the club and it'd be wrong to blame any one individual...it appears that there were a number of contributors that have led to the current situation but now is the time to move on, as always and support the eleven that take the pitch.

I just hope that the experiences of the last few days have given SP food for thought and that lessons are learned preventing this from happening again.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Sep 17 10.01am

They've released a video of Frank's interview process in which his "qualities" were assessed

[Link]

 

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Sep 17 10.02am

He simply had no clue of man management. If its true that after Kellys shocking performance against Swansea he told him he was rubbish and sent to train with the U23 then thats not on. Drop him yes but send him into exile no. The players must have really annoyed at the treatment of their mate. De Boer sounds like a right arrogant piece of wotk

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 12 Sep 17 10.02am

Part of me feels very sorry for FDB however I think it is the right descision. At his original press conference there was talk of evolution to a more attacking way. There clearly was something wrong behind the scenes so the rumours do not suprise me. Some will disagree but in my mind both Joel Ward and Martin Kelly are both solid EPL players. They have weaknesses but are good squad players at worst. Both will give 100% every game. Ward is not a wingback and had clearly never played there before Huddersfield.

Luka was one of the successes of last season and was not the same player under FDB

Delaney was always going to be a bit player this season but was still the "captain" in the dressing room.

Virtually No players came in, we can speculate why. One of them has to be FDB changed his mind about targets. In retrospect the fact Tete chose to go elsewhere and Jairo Riedewald took ages may say something.

Andros Townsend was poor until allardyce and Lee sorted him out. FDB appears to have Pardewed him.

Clearly the board must take some responsibility as they knew that these changes were going to cause tensions. This is why they wanted evolution not revolution and I think FDB broke that understanding and he had to go

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What Went On Behind The Scenes?