You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Catalonia


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
wordup Flag 03 Oct 17 12.22am

I have no dog in this fight either way, but images of hundreds of people getting a beating for trying to cast a vote, will very likely not damage the Catalonian cause for independence.

When you have to beat the opinion out of joe public, you may very well be in the wrong.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 03 Oct 17 7.57am

Originally posted by wordup

I have no dog in this fight either way, but images of hundreds of people getting a beating for trying to cast a vote, will very likely not damage the Catalonian cause for independence.

When you have to beat the opinion out of joe public, you may very well be in the wrong.

We should try this with Strictly Come Dancing and the X-Factor.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Oct 17 8.13am

Originally posted by hedgehog50

We should try this with Strictly Come Dancing and the X-Factor.

Television fascist and antifa style!

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mr Palaceman Flag 03 Oct 17 9.38am

Originally posted by Stuk

Until they get a right to vote from central government, and not just carry one out because they want to, it can't be deemed legal in any way.

Even the Catalan leader, I think it was, said he couldn't vote where he was supposed to as the police had closed it, so he voted somewhere else. That doesn't sound like an election that isn't prone to illegal voting or voting errors.

And then it's a matter for all of Spain to vote on, not just Catalonia.

Hmm, I'm not sure that it is. If they want to leave and the rest of Spain says no, that isn't self determination. It should be the same as when Scotland voted, it's down to them IF there was a proper referendum.

I feel for those Spaniards like Barcelona Eagle who are invested in the region.

I think both sides have gone about this in the wrong way. Can't end well.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Oct 17 10.08am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Hmm, I'm not sure that it is. If they want to leave and the rest of Spain says no, that isn't self determination. It should be the same as when Scotland voted, it's down to them IF there was a proper referendum.

I feel for those Spaniards like Barcelona Eagle who are invested in the region.

I think both sides have gone about this in the wrong way. Can't end well.

I think Stuk has a point in terms of the final resolution to this problem.

However, the Spanish government were definitely wrong to try and stop this vote via force. Once this region had decided to vote they should have been allowed to do it if the alternative was going to be force.

This is a matter of self determination between Spaniards.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 10.30am

Originally posted by rob1969

The vote may be illegal according to the Spanish constitution so any result will be purely a indication of people wishes and in no way binding or having any validity. Therefore why not let them go ahead and just ignore the outcome. Using force to try to prevent the vote seems totally pointless and just rings of Spain of 40 + years ago. Really unbelievable!

Because it will clearly display the desire for independence. Expect the future to involve an ETA like movement for Independence, if democratic means of pursuit of political change are unavailable, revolutionary ones will arise.

Also this will likely also see a return of ETA in Spain, as the two regions will see a potential 'joint cause' here.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 11.10am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Hmm, I'm not sure that it is. If they want to leave and the rest of Spain says no, that isn't self determination. It should be the same as when Scotland voted, it's down to them IF there was a proper referendum.

I feel for those Spaniards like Barcelona Eagle who are invested in the region.

I think both sides have gone about this in the wrong way. Can't end well.

So if I want to declare my house an independent country that's just up to me is it?

No. And that'd be with a 100% backing in a 100% voter turnout.

It wasn't down to Scotland when they voted, it was the UK government that gave them the right to have a referendum. Which is why Sturgeon can be totally ignored whenever she bangs on about having another one. They're a once in a generation thing, at best.

 


Optimistic as ever

npn Flag Crowborough 03 Oct 17 11.15am

It was madness by the Spanish government. Region demands independence referendum, government says no, region says "we're having one anyway".

Surely the sensible response would be "it won't be legitimate or recognised" and if they want to crack on and go through the motions, just let them and ignore the result completely. Charging in snatching polling boxes and handing out kickings is not going to help anyone.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 11.23am

Originally posted by npn

It was madness by the Spanish government. Region demands independence referendum, government says no, region says "we're having one anyway".

Surely the sensible response would be "it won't be legitimate or recognised" and if they want to crack on and go through the motions, just let them and ignore the result completely. Charging in snatching polling boxes and handing out kickings is not going to help anyone.

Correct. It probably wouldn't have stood up to independent scrutiny or recognition either.

 


Optimistic as ever

chris123 Flag hove actually 03 Oct 17 11.35am

Originally posted by Stuk

So if I want to declare my house an independent country that's just up to me is it?

No. And that'd be with a 100% backing in a 100% voter turnout.

It wasn't down to Scotland when they voted, it was the UK government that gave them the right to have a referendum. Which is why Sturgeon can be totally ignored whenever she bangs on about having another one. They're a once in a generation thing, at best.

Just as in Passport to Pimlico!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 12.16pm

Originally posted by Stuk

So if I want to declare my house an independent country that's just up to me is it?

No. And that'd be with a 100% backing in a 100% voter turnout.

It wasn't down to Scotland when they voted, it was the UK government that gave them the right to have a referendum. Which is why Sturgeon can be totally ignored whenever she bangs on about having another one. They're a once in a generation thing, at best.

It is technically possible, but very difficult if within a recognised, and ratified country as you need other countries to recognise you as an independent state.

However, if you were to do so, without breaking with continuity within the UK (ie paying taxes, adhering to laws etc) you could probably get away with doing things like issuing your own passports (for entry to the house), creating your own money for use in your country etc without any real problems. People would just think you weird.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 12.17pm

Originally posted by Stuk

So if I want to declare my house an independent country that's just up to me is it?

No. And that'd be with a 100% backing in a 100% voter turnout.

It wasn't down to Scotland when they voted, it was the UK government that gave them the right to have a referendum. Which is why Sturgeon can be totally ignored whenever she bangs on about having another one. They're a once in a generation thing, at best.

Are there no other people in your house (wife, girlfriend, children) or who have legal relationship (ex-wife, grown children / heirs etc). Also the bank if you have a mortgage would likely have a say.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 12.32pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It is technically possible, but very difficult if within a recognised, and ratified country as you need other countries to recognise you as an independent state.

However, if you were to do so, without breaking with continuity within the UK (ie paying taxes, adhering to laws etc) you could probably get away with doing things like issuing your own passports (for entry to the house), creating your own money for use in your country etc without any real problems. People would just think you weird.


It's nigh on impossible. Sealand is a good, and recent, example.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 12.36pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Are there no other people in your house (wife, girlfriend, children) or who have legal relationship (ex-wife, grown children / heirs etc). Also the bank if you have a mortgage would likely have a say.

My house. Anyone in it is on a temporary visa for this scenario.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 1.21pm

Originally posted by Stuk

My house. Anyone in it is on a temporary visa for this scenario.

Not if you declare independence, they're now citizens of Stukistania

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 1.25pm

Originally posted by Stuk

It's nigh on impossible. Sealand is a good, and recent, example.

I think it depends on what you want from independence. I think you could technically achieve it, if you remained within the laws of the UK, and declared independence in name only (Call your house and land Stukitania or Martinsland, and effectively play at being an autonomous state within the UK).

If you went further, like refusing to pay tax, I think you'd be f**ked (but you could argue that paying tax is your trade that you do with services outside of your country).

But yeah, becoming truly independent, almost impossible.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 2.28pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Not if you declare independence, they're now citizens of Stukistania

I'd do it while they were out.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Oct 17 2.28pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think it depends on what you want from independence. I think you could technically achieve it, if you remained within the laws of the UK, and declared independence in name only (Call your house and land Stukitania or Martinsland, and effectively play at being an autonomous state within the UK).

If you went further, like refusing to pay tax, I think you'd be f**ked (but you could argue that paying tax is your trade that you do with services outside of your country).

But yeah, becoming truly independent, almost impossible.

If it's not to refuse to pay tax, what's the point.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 2.30pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I'd do it while they were out.

Then they'd be refugees fleeing Stuistania to claim benefits in the UK

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Oct 17 2.33pm

Originally posted by Stuk

If it's not to refuse to pay tax, what's the point.

To stomp about on your balcony, issuing orders, wearing a white generals uniform, gold braiding shining in the sun, shaded by a sweet peaked military cap and aviator shades....

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia