This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It is a lie to say that immigrants are blamed for everything. It's a disfigurement of the argument made. Agreed. It's immigrants AND the EU that are to blame for everything. Especially in the case of the latter the mismanagement of the housing, health and education sectors. Luckily, we get full control over those areas again soon.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
Agreed. It's immigrants AND the EU that are to blame for everything. Especially in the case of the latter the mismanagement of the housing, health and education sectors. Luckily, we get full control over those areas again soon. Sure the EU situation encompasses apart of the immigration issue and much else besides. However, they are but a significant actor in the play of problems that beset this nation of nations.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
Agreed. It's immigrants AND the EU that are to blame for everything. Especially in the case of the latter the mismanagement of the housing, health and education sectors. Luckily, we get full control over those areas again soon. ... and left wing agitators of course.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yep. I do not want to be too critical of what people choose to do with their own money but offshoring isn't good. Never claimed it was - so make it illegal, or tax the cash on repatriation. The idea that people would not follow a financial expert's advice (on something they don't really understand) because it's the "right thing to do" is just silly. I do a tax return every year, I am honest and above board on it, and it tells me what I owe or what they owe me, then I pay it (or occasionally they pay me). If a bank says to me "invest in this product, it's called an ISA, and it's tax free", an IFA says "pump more money into your pension, you'll save loads of tax", or Delboy Trotter's Offshore investments says "this product returns x% and is completely legal and tax free" are all largely the same to me - I'm being advised by subject matter experts on what is best for me financially. In the same way that I never receive a tax demand and say "no, I think you've done excellent work spending my taxes, and I'm feeling a bit flush, so don't take £1,000, have £2,000" I'm not going to second guess experts on tax liability. If it's offensive to people, then change the rules to make it no longer a legal option, it's that simple. Incidentally, I don't have any offshore investments except whatever may be in my pension pot and/or ISA plans, so I'm not directly affected, just to declare my position, but I find it harsh to vilify people as immoral for doing something totally legal that they almost certainly don't fully understand on the advice of a paid expert employed to advise them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PaddyMcPaddy
Why should it benefit the less well off? In theory yes they should be given help. Unfortunately most don't help themselves to get off the system of support or play the system just enough to keep hand outs and so on. I've plenty of family that do it so I know. What we shouldn't do is then over tax the high earners, where is the equality of that? If you do well we will tax you more. Thanks for that. You will end up with a mediocre society. You can say that they won't miss much lifestyle but why should they miss any? I am all for supporting under privileged people that true want to better themselves. Unfortunately we don't have a society to do that. Anyone that goes to school and tries hard, works to achieve can make and earn good money in this country. It really is a simple as that. Most!!! Just because someone does not earn as much as someone else doesn't mean they don't work hard and if your family do what you say, you should take responsibility and have a word. Edited by Mr Palaceman (07 Nov 2017 10.20am)
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
Agreed. It's immigrants AND the EU that are to blame for everything. Especially in the case of the latter the mismanagement of the housing, health and education sectors. Luckily, we get full control over those areas again soon.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'll try. It's going to be impossible though. Humour mindset is firmly based on sarcasm. Red Robbo is dead. Red Kermit to follow. Ah, well...
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
What HMRC should do is pretty simple. Stop prioritising people with degrees - recruit trained and experienced accountants. The flow of experienced staff at the moment is gamekeepers turning poacher. I applied for a job with HMRC - rejected as I didn't fit the spec and I quote "insufficient experience/higher education" That's poor management on their behalf. Never saw the point of a degree if you have professional qualifications. Thing is always going to be, the people who take advantage and police the loopholes, are also the people who run and influence the country. A lot of MPs seem to take advantage of the situation, and that's a real problem - because they're also not likely to be wanting to change that situation. HMRC funding means they go after 'the easy cases' rather than the big boys who can afford to fight back.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Our old bin men, because we lived near a traffic light, wouldn't collect the bin if the lights were green. Its odd that I'm excited about the fact our bin men collect our rubbish, on a weekly basis, and are helpful. That's how far the 'outsourcing' of the bin services have got us. Used to be a hard work, that paid well (as I used to know a few 'tougher kids' who worked on the bins when I left school. Now it seems its not so much work, for f**k all money.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by npn
Never claimed it was - so make it illegal, or tax the cash on repatriation. The idea that people would not follow a financial expert's advice (on something they don't really understand) because it's the "right thing to do" is just silly. I do a tax return every year, I am honest and above board on it, and it tells me what I owe or what they owe me, then I pay it (or occasionally they pay me). If a bank says to me "invest in this product, it's called an ISA, and it's tax free", an IFA says "pump more money into your pension, you'll save loads of tax", or Delboy Trotter's Offshore investments says "this product returns x% and is completely legal and tax free" are all largely the same to me - I'm being advised by subject matter experts on what is best for me financially. In the same way that I never receive a tax demand and say "no, I think you've done excellent work spending my taxes, and I'm feeling a bit flush, so don't take £1,000, have £2,000" I'm not going to second guess experts on tax liability. If it's offensive to people, then change the rules to make it no longer a legal option, it's that simple. Incidentally, I don't have any offshore investments except whatever may be in my pension pot and/or ISA plans, so I'm not directly affected, just to declare my position, but I find it harsh to vilify people as immoral for doing something totally legal that they almost certainly don't fully understand on the advice of a paid expert employed to advise them. ...and again I think npn has hit the nail on the head. The real issue here is that ALL this stuff is LEGAL...so it doesnt matter what tangents we all go off on during this thread the real question that needs answering is wtf is the WORLD going to do about it to bring all the corporations (forget about individuals for the time being) to book and pay tax when and where its due. Start there and then look at individuals...the whole BBC panorama programme last night was simply celeb bashing, solacious and tabloidesque
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
...and again I think npn has hit the nail on the head. The real issue here is that ALL this stuff is LEGAL...so it doesnt matter what tangents we all go off on during this thread the real question that needs answering is wtf is the WORLD going to do about it to bring all the corporations (forget about individuals for the time being) to book and pay tax when and where its due. Start there and then look at individuals...the whole BBC panorama programme last night was simply celeb bashing, solacious and tabloidesque Indeed, the celebrities are being used as a dead cat look at them argument so people don't look at corporations or people in power.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
the real question that needs answering is wtf is the WORLD going to do about it to bring all the corporations (forget about individuals for the time being) to book and pay tax when and where its due. How about whacking on import duty on products brought in from companies registered in tax havens. There are plenty of things that could be done if the Governments of the day have the will
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
That's poor management on their behalf. Never saw the point of a degree if you have professional qualifications. Thing is always going to be, the people who take advantage and police the loopholes, are also the people who run and influence the country. A lot of MPs seem to take advantage of the situation, and that's a real problem - because they're also not likely to be wanting to change that situation. HMRC funding means they go after 'the easy cases' rather than the big boys who can afford to fight back. It's one of the only areas I can see very real benefits, regardless of your political hue, to funding heavily - so long as your extra funds return more in tax revenue that the expense in retrieving it, it ought to be a no brainer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Indeed, the celebrities are being used as a dead cat look at them argument so people don't look at corporations or people in power. The argument for the big corporates is that they bring employment etc to the country, but, as far as I can see, if they pay 40% tax rather than 2% (or whatever stupid figures many are getting away with) it's down to them whether they want to make 60% profits on a very large market, or walk away with nothing. In the case of coffee shops etc, if they walk away it would really be no great loss (more independent coffee shops on the high street would be great). Amazon would be harder to replace (simply due to buying power keeping prices down) but it can't be beyond the wit of man. The fact that some of the big boys have attempted to score brownie points through voluntary tax contributions is laughable - how the hell is tax voluntary for anyone?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I disagree.......Perhaps in a system where there were enough jobs about that could provide a reasonable lifestyle for everyone this point would be arguable....though you run into problems with having enough money to provide for the weak, such as the elderly, disabled and the simple....what was it that Boris Johnson said? 16 percent 'of our species' have an IQ below 85 and only 2 percent have an IQ of 130 or more. I disagree with any tax idea that would, in effect, result in us going back to Victorian states of poverty. There simply doesn't exist a system where people born in council estates can work themselves into the middle classes in rates anymore than a trickle. Any number of practical blocks exist to stop that. The vast majority of people end their lives in the same social status they started in. This has very little to do with talent or ability and much more to do with life chances. Automation is and will adversely affect those who are poorer....though it is also coming for the white collar jobs as well. Tax systems that would widen inequality are only going to increase support for the pseudo communists we already have leading the left.....And essentially they will pursue polices that will result in the wealthy moving their money out and worsen life for the majority far more. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Nov 2017 4.45pm) Small government, for me is a principle, from where we are now it would take years of reform in all areas of government but you start with the principle as your foundation and work towards that principle over a sustained period of time until you achieve your goals. At the same time you work hard to protect what is already benefiting society. That should be what all governments do, imo. My personal view is that everyone is ultimately responsible for their own happiness and government or government type has little or nothing to do with this. Not to say that sh!t doesn't happen and governments can't mess you up but I personally try to minimise the level of influence that government has in my life and the lives of my family. It's fair to say that I have little regard for our current political class of any hue. I have little time for those who profess to work for others and yet serve no-one but themselves first. Those people are easily spotted and I don't give them a mandate by voting for them. I pay my tax by consent because I think it's a worthy thing to do and some taxation for the benefit of all is a good thing and although I pay in, I try not to take out but am grateful for institutions like the NHS being there when I need them. I also would never want a return to Victorian poverty, who would.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Amazon Apple etc. whoever, if you don't pay the tax due we confiscate your assets with no compensation. Leaving? Here let us open the door for you. We will just take over everything you had with no compensation and employ just as many people who will be treated properly as in our modern car industry. Go back to your Trump coal fires.
That's just the problem - the tax is not dues, but it damned-well should be! They have dedicated HMRC staff with whom they negotiate what they are willing to pay (if I understand correctly) - ludicrous. If you can find it online (not on iplayer currently) there was a great BBC documentary about it called "The Town That Took on the Taxman" where they took an entire high street in Wales full of independent shops and attempted to set up the same tax dodges that the big boys use (largely based around intellectual property rights IIRC - offshore company owned the name "fair tax town", all the shops were owners of the offshore firm, and all paid the offshore firm for the right to use the name, so profits in the UK were minimal and all profits were basically siphoned off to overseas havens with much lower tax liabilities. Really showed how the big boys do it and why the smaller shops just can't compete on an even playing field
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
How about whacking on import duty on products brought in from companies registered in tax havens. There are plenty of things that could be done if the Governments of the day have the will This is why it needs a concerted effort. they all know its an issue but no one wants to be brave enough to make a stand as the companies will simply bugger off elsewhere. The OECD needs to drive this through, followed by major nations implying economic/trade 'sanctions' on those that refuse.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.