You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Niasse Dive


Page 4 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
chateauferret Flag 21 Nov 17 11.37am

I can't see how three experts could look at that and say he didn't dive. Are they allowed to take his remarks into account? The attitude they betray is surely deserving of a ban.

Pity they don't have the powers to make an example of him.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Den1923 Flag 21 Nov 17 11.39am

Originally posted by Bullhorn76

Good !! Cheating little get has been done , so really now the penalty should be stricken from the record hence us being awarded all three points ....... of course it won’t happen but it bloody well should !

yes I agree, its all well and good that he has been charged and will get a ban if proven, but the fact is we have been robbed of two points, there should be some mechanism that allows the goal to be be cancelled or match to be replayed!

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 21 Nov 17 11.47am

Sue the cheat,& the FA; forcing the authorities to be liable to a financial penalty when the ref makes a really wrong decision will bring about video assistance for ref's far sooner than anything else. Palace don't get anything out of his being charged, should award us the match 2-1.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Nov 17 11.52am

How long before calls for goals to be chalked off in these specific instances?

3 points please FA!! NOW

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

lefty27 Flag ipswich 21 Nov 17 12.02pm

Whilst I am happy he has been charged I cannot see how it benefits us. We still dropped 2 points due to the penalty and his ban will be served against teams that we are close to...West Ham and Southampton, not really compensation for us.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 21 Nov 17 12.22pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Whilst I am happy he has been charged I cannot see how it benefits us. We still dropped 2 points due to the penalty and his ban will be served against teams that we are close to...West Ham and Southampton, not really compensation for us.

Apart from he won't be on the pitch to win penalties and score goals? Everton are as close to us as they arw.

Edited by Southampton_Eagle (21 Nov 2017 12.23pm)

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 21 Nov 17 12.24pm

Originally posted by Den1923

yes I agree, its all well and good that he has been charged and will get a ban if proven, but the fact is we have been robbed of two points, there should be some mechanism that allows the goal to be be cancelled or match to be replayed!

How would you feel if we lost the replayed game?

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Nov 17 12.29pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

How would you feel if we lost the replayed game?

Money makes little difference to these people and suspending someone for a couple of games only makes a difference to clubs with less squad depth, i.e. less money. Guess who benefits from that arrangement.

My own view is that a cheat should forfeit the game, i.e. the result is declared 3 - 0 against the cheating side (unless they actually lost by more than that), as if they hadn't turned up.

That would put a stop to it pretty damn fast.

Won't happen of course because nobody really wants results being open to question after the final whistle has gone. Anyway it would have affected the game in progress: if we all thought Niasse was going to forfeit the match for a dive he committed in the sixth minute, why would either side bother to play football for the remaining eighty-four minutes? So the only practicable answer is to make sure these decisions are given correctly on the field at the time and that means VAR with bells on.

As for the existing arrangements, if they find him guilty (as they should) he will be suspended from matches against Wet Spam and Southampton, which is actually further to our detriment. Ridiculous.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Nov 2017 12.38pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 21 Nov 17 1.05pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Money makes little difference to these people and suspending someone for a couple of games only makes a difference to clubs with less squad depth, i.e. less money. Guess who benefits from that arrangement.

My own view is that a cheat should forfeit the game, i.e. the result is declared 3 - 0 against the cheating side (unless they actually lost by more than that), as if they hadn't turned up.

That would put a stop to it pretty damn fast.

Won't happen of course because nobody really wants results being open to question after the final whistle has gone. Anyway it would have affected the game in progress: if we all thought Niasse was going to forfeit the match for a dive he committed in the sixth minute, why would either side bother to play football for the remaining eighty-four minutes? So the only practicable answer is to make sure these decisions are given correctly on the field at the time and that means VAR with bells on.

As for the existing arrangements, if they find him guilty (as they should) he will be suspended from matches against Wet Spam and Southampton, which is actually further to our detriment. Ridiculous.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Nov 2017 12.38pm)

And therein lies the problem with the new rule. I think it was , like many others, intended to stop players diving as there were now consequences to their actions (unlike perviously). The issue is the potential punishment seems insufficient and, as you say, potentially to the detriment of the side on the receiving end.

It needs to be more punitive & fines don't seem to work (the bigger clubs would barely notice & the players seem unbothered) so maybe a points deduction would be better. I reckon if there was a a single point deduction from the offending team it would make a difference at both ends of the table & if that point was then awarded to the other team it would be a double whammy. Then again, would the FA have the bottle to even try it....

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

PA Flag Bedfordshire 21 Nov 17 1.18pm

The only ones to benefit from him being charged will be West Ham and Southampton as Everton will be weakened against them if he gets a ban.

Kind of a double penalty for Palace really!!

We suffer the consequences of the crime and our rivals benefit from the punishment given out.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Nov 17 1.22pm

So when do Everton get a point deducted and we get the other two we should've had? and get the +2 on our goal difference.

 


Optimistic as ever

Aolcpfc Flag Finchley, London 21 Nov 17 1.27pm

Would it work better if he were banned from his next two Premier League games against us? Obviously that wouldn't work if he were sold before his next two games against us, but it could work better for us than his being banned for his next two prem. games, especially if W Ham were to beat Everton in Niasse's absence

Would a two game ban be a ban from premiership games only, or does it include FA Cup and League Cup games?

If it's the latter types of game (i.e. not prem. games), then a two game ban could be of minimal impact to Everton's (top six?) aspirations.

 

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 21 Nov 17 1.29pm

All about money with the F.A. Everton and or their player will get fined, or both. More money in the F.A,s coffers for the Christmas pi$$ up. But, Palace we get naff all. What is the point in having this " diving ban" or whatever they want to call it when the club suffering from the consiquenses of said offences get ziltch. There's justice for ya, pi$$ take.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

Noz Flag North Hampshire 21 Nov 17 1.32pm

Another point to note: if the dive was spotted by the ref in the first place he would have got a yellow for simulation, then would have been sent off for the second yellow he received... did he get that before or after he scored?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Nov 17 1.35pm

Originally posted by Noz

Another point to note: if the dive was spotted by the ref in the first place he would have got a yellow for simulation, then would have been sent off for the second yellow he received... did he get that before or after he scored?

10 mins before.

 


Optimistic as ever

chateauferret Flag 21 Nov 17 1.36pm

Originally posted by Stuk

10 mins before.

And that's only counting the yellow card he got, not the ones he deserved.

 


============
The Ferret
============

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 21 Nov 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by Aolcpfc

Would it work better if he were banned from his next two Premier League games against us? Obviously that wouldn't work if he were sold before his next two games against us, but it could work better for us than his being banned for his next two prem. games, especially if W Ham were to beat Everton in Niasse's absence

Would a two game ban be a ban from premiership games only, or does it include FA Cup and League Cup games?

If it's the latter types of game (i.e. not prem. games), then a two game ban could be of minimal impact to Everton's (top six?) aspirations.

probably not. - we only play 2 games vs each team per season, I see no benefit if the offender has to miss a game next season.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

YT Flag Oxford 21 Nov 17 1.54pm

Maybe the Sunday Times will be forced to rescind the ‘Man of the Match’ rating they gave him.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 21 Nov 17 2.06pm

Originally posted by Noz

Another point to note: if the dive was spotted by the ref in the first place he would have got a yellow for simulation, then would have been sent off for the second yellow he received... did he get that before or after he scored?

That ref was never going to issue an Everton player with two cards. After all, for most of the game he seemed to get his hand stuck in his pocket even when just one card was called for.

 

Den1923 Flag 21 Nov 17 2.08pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

How would you feel if we lost the replayed game?

Of course I would not be happy, as I am with any game we lose, but at least we would be given another chance in this instance the results stands come what may. It is really about time that video ref were introduced to football, like Rugby, especially so at the top levels as the financial loss is potentially catastrophic if we are relegated because of the two points we have lost in this game!

 

Page 4 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Niasse Dive