You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each
November 16 2026 7.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 04 Mar 18 1.38pm

Originally posted by Uphill

add Bamford, Mariappa, Jerome and Alex McCarthy to the list of players who have begun to show their ability after they left us.

There must be a reason - lack of opportunity, the wrong formations, managerial impatience, lack of encouragement?

There is a problem somewhere and I am beginning to show sympathy for Benteke. While we wait for the return of Zaha it is time that Townsend stepped up to the plate and gave him some support

Bamford's a bit of an enigma. He seems a perfect fit at Middlesbrough. He's done well for them, but in between his two spells there, he's been pretty much a waste of space.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

The Dolphin Flag 04 Mar 18 2.07pm

Murray scores - yet again!

 

Jacey Flag 04 Mar 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Murray scores - yet again!

Yes,his 13th goal in all competitions this season.
Gayle has scored 5.
Neither considered good enough for us,however.

 

stujii Flag 04 Mar 18 2.24pm

And all the know it alls said he couldn't cut it in the Prem...surly now they will do the decent thing and admit they in fact know nothing...you know who you are..

We should never have sold Muzza !

 

peterg Flag Anerley 04 Mar 18 2.33pm

Disastrous decision. Pardew had ideas above his station. So we spent £32mil on a crap replacement. If we had stuck with Murray and/or Gayle, we could have spent that money on the midfielders we so badly needed.

 


The right place at the right time

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 04 Mar 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by peterg

Disastrous decision. Pardew had ideas above his station. So we spent £32mil on a crap replacement. If we had stuck with Murray and/or Gayle, we could have spent that money on the midfielders we so badly needed.

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 04 Mar 18 3.04pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.

The past is past. This season the evidence is right before you.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 04 Mar 18 3.14pm

I love Muzza but he has scored some lucky goals this season. Apart from the pens they have come off all parts of his body plus todays one Cech should have easily saved it. Benteke would love luck like that

 

cardiff eagle Flag 04 Mar 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I love Muzza but he has scored some lucky goals this season. Apart from the pens they have come off all parts of his body plus todays one Cech should have easily saved it. Benteke would love luck like that

Yeah really lucky to score 13 goals. I'd rather have a lucky player than an unlucky (s***) one in Benteke.

Should've kept Murray as a squad player anyway and he would have stayed. Parish f***ed up with this one and has been negligent in not replacing him ever since.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 04 Mar 18 3.30pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.

It is the ‘Premier League’ the Premiership only exists in Scotland.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 04 Mar 18 3.36pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I love Muzza but he has scored some lucky goals this season. Apart from the pens they have come off all parts of his body plus todays one Cech should have easily saved it. Benteke would love luck like that

Yeah but Benteke wouldnt have been in a position to score Murrays 'lucky' goals would he?? Benteke only cares about his 120k a week, he'll be off whether we go down or not! As to Benteke needing some luck...you tend to make your own luck in football by working hard/getting in the right places/getting in the CBs faces....Benteke does none of those things..he just doesnt care!

Edited by the silurian (04 Mar 2018 3.53pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Mar 18 3.41pm

Murray has scored 6 goals in his last 6 games but at the end of the day whilst he of course has played his part by his reading of situations and his movement, he is of course reliant on the service he receives.

Murray has never been the quickest but has always been a clever player and is of course good in the air.

 

Sthlondonuk Flag STH NORWOOD 04 Mar 18 3.49pm

Older strikers like Murray and Kevin Phillips when he played for just have a natural talent of where to be in and around the box without running around too much and both knew where the target is. Defoe is another example but I’ve never really seen it with Benteke in fact he is too often in the wrong place and for a younger striker that’s poor. Some might say he’s been unlucky but his run of goal scoring form has been dire for a while now and will have been a major factor if we do get relegated

 

slubglurge Flag welling 04 Mar 18 3.58pm

Muzza is having a purple patch where everything he touches goes in whereas Benteke is having the exact opposite. Overall Benteke is the better player but the biggest asset that Muzza has over him is that he will put his body on the line to score whereas there is no chance of CB doing that

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 18 4.02pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Yeah really lucky to score 13 goals. I'd rather have a lucky player than an unlucky (s***) one in Benteke.

Should've kept Murray as a squad player anyway and he would have stayed. Parish f***ed up with this one and has been negligent in not replacing him ever since.

Trouble is that's not true. Murray wanted to play but when playepat Bournemouth he couldn't adapt to what they wanted.

 


COYP

pax3908 Flag 04 Mar 18 4.03pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.

Benteke absolute overated waste of money, Liverpool New what they where doing getting rid, and so should we, peoples impatience got rid of Murray and Gayle, and now we are paying the price, anyone with half a decent football brain could see played up front together they would have worked well, one of the management's biggest mistakes among many. How we have stayed in the Premier so long has been on a wing and a prayer!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 18 4.05pm

Originally posted by Sthlondonuk

Older strikers like Murray and Kevin Phillips when he played for just have a natural talent of where to be in and around the box without running around too much and both knew where the target is. Defoe is another example but I’ve never really seen it with Benteke in fact he is too often in the wrong place and for a younger striker that’s poor. Some might say he’s been unlucky but his run of goal scoring form has been dire for a while now and will have been a major factor if we do get relegated

Whenever the crosser is far away enough Benteke is at the back post and whenever the crosser is close Benteke is central towards the 6 yard line. Rarely strays from these 2 positions, safe from getting hurt, and there's a World Cup in a few months so why get hurt?

 


COYP

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 4.07pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.


Buddy, you need to get your facts straight.

1. Benteke scored 13 goals last year from open play, not 15. The fact that his teammates let him take 2 penalties doesn't mean he's better than if he had not taken them. But ok, let's go with the number 15 as he also accounted for 2 assists last season. His 13 goals from open play and 2 asists came in 3200 minutes, less than 1 every 200 minutes. If you count out the penalties he scored while at Villa and Liverpool, he pretty much has a similar ratio.

2. Gayle scored 23 and assisted 2 in 2300 minutes in all competitions last year, with no penalties taken. If his teammates had let Gayle take 2 penalties like Benteke, he could have had 2 more goals. But disregard the Championship goals. Gayle in the PL had scored for Palace 20 goals (18 from open play) and provided 1 assist in 2700 minutes. That's 1 every 140 minutes. This season he has 5 goals and 2 assists in 1300 minutes for Newcastle, somewhat keeping his tally (leading the line, not as second striker).

3. Glenn Murray had 19 goals from open play in the Championship, but 6 assists too in 3400 minutes. In the Premier League he had scored 8 from open play and assisted 3 in 1500 minutes for Crystal Palace and Bournemouth. This season (counting out the penalties) he has 6 goals and no assists in 1500 minutes.

Bottom line: if one striker takes penalties, his goals appear to be much more than what they truly are and perception makes him seem like a better player than he truly is.

 

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 04 Mar 18 4.14pm

Murray is willing to do the dirty work and is far more intelligent as a player than benteke he's a far better finisher and penelty taker benteke is a very very average football player and possibly the worst value that any prem club has payed big money for with the exception of Torres

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Buddy, you need to get your facts straight.

1. Benteke scored 13 goals last year from open play, not 15. The fact that his teammates let him take 2 penalties doesn't mean he's better than if he had not taken them. But ok, let's go with the number 15 as he also accounted for 2 assists last season. His 13 goals from open play and 2 asists came in 3200 minutes, less than 1 every 200 minutes. If you count out the penalties he scored while at Villa and Liverpool, he pretty much has a similar ratio.

2. Gayle scored 23 and assisted 2 in 2300 minutes in all competitions last year, with no penalties taken. If his teammates had let Gayle take 2 penalties like Benteke, he could have had 2 more goals. But disregard the Championship goals. Gayle in the PL had scored for Palace 20 goals (18 from open play) and provided 1 assist in 2700 minutes. That's 1 every 140 minutes. This season he has 5 goals and 2 assists in 1300 minutes for Newcastle, somewhat keeping his tally (leading the line, not as second striker).

3. Glenn Murray had 19 goals from open play in the Championship, but 6 assists too in 3400 minutes. In the Premier League he had scored 8 from open play and assisted 3 in 1500 minutes for Crystal Palace and Bournemouth. This season (counting out the penalties) he has 6 goals and no assists in 1500 minutes.

Bottom line: if one striker takes penalties, his goals appear to be much more than what they truly are and perception makes him seem like a better player than he truly is.

Problem was and is is that Gayle is anonymous in first halves. He cannot occupy defenders or find space whatsoever. All his success for us was in 2nd halves when its end to end stuff.

Seeing Murray score a good few goals this season is sickening but tbf a lot are bouncing off him or he's unchallenged etc. But then he's in there making it happen whereas Benteke isn't and seems to adopt a space that is safe from injury or criticism if he messes it up.

It should be remembered that Murray and Gayle are playing in a side promoted together with momentum and with them both scoring. That's a bit different to Gayle trying to develop a talent in first halves whilst having little of it and being 2nd fiddle at best and Murray wanting to be playing all the time and not going to be after signing Benteke who we all thought would score 10 every season, absolute minimum.

I've been critical of Palace or Parish but it's not as simple as we should have them both. We could've been relegated with both. How rubbish was Murray at Bournemouth?

 


COYP

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each