This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
dreamwaverider London 11 Mar 18 10.31am |
|
|
According to the articles below Benteke is off to China in the summer. Great news he has totally lost his way with us. I blame the money.
|
chateauferret 11 Mar 18 10.35am |
|
Originally posted by The_Dumps
Did you even WATCH the game? He hit the post, scroed a legitimate goal and made the the goal we did score!? Jeez, there is so much negativity on this board.. this lad is a breath of fresh air.
I think maybe people are not used to seeing a player, at least an attacking player, use physical force rather than guile (Wilf), speed (Bolasie) or technique (Benteke) to hurt the opposition. I suppose Wickham used physicality to a degree, but we don't have anyone else who can really go up against big agricultural types like the sort Huddersfield use and beat them at their own game. I think they'll have trouble with a striker they can't knock over.
============ The Ferret ============
|
rawpalace05 Saltdean 11 Mar 18 10.35am |
|
|
Sorloth was poor. If benteke had his confidence we’d be fine. If sorloth had benteke’s nouse likewise. We’ve got two half standard players at the mo, just hoping that something drops for one of them. Seems sorloth doesn’t chase the ball down much in central areas either, guess he’s still learning and getting up to speed. So in answer, Wickham if fit!
1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.
palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
curlyeagle crowborough 11 Mar 18 10.37am |
|
|
I thought both looked poor in the first half! Benteke has the experience but sadly just lacks desire and lacks a football brain. Movement, anticipation and positional sense is shocking.
Sørloth is young and is still adapting to playing in a very different league. I do wish he would close the opposition defence down quicker though. He seems to jog around and his effort to close down looks like a token gesture to me.
Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days
|
Dangermouse Hastings 11 Mar 18 10.39am |
|
|
Really believe that Benteke actually damaged himself when he took the penalty from Luka. It was a foolish act he has been unable to mentally recover from IMO. He has won many flick ons which have not been read by teammates and played to instructions, contrary to many people's opinions, but the sparkle has gone. He's flat and reactive rather than bubbling and proactive. Also after Bournemouth the abuse he would have received must have an effect on your mindset, hence the fingers in ears celebration. No amount of money makes you immune, before someone comes up with that pathetic line. Sorloth has not done too well holding up the ball or winning headers and if Benteke had hit the post from 4 yards no one would be defending him. Difference is he's only played against the big boys so far and for all we know he might be a small club bully. God, I hope so. Personally both we're piss poor in the first half and either one could have gone off. Whoever stayed on was gonna improve because Zaha changes games. He affected the mindset of both clubs and Sorloth benefitted from his presence. Also I believe Roy's gameplan was wrong in the first half. Sorry, but it has to be said.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
chateauferret 11 Mar 18 10.42am |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Really believe that Benteke actually damaged himself when he took the penalty from Luka. It was a foolish act he has been unable to mentally recover from IMO. He has won many flick ons which have not been read by teammates and played to instructions, contrary to many people's opinions, but the sparkle has gone. He's flat and reactive rather than bubbling and proactive. Also after Bournemouth the abuse he would have received must have an effect on your mindset, hence the fingers in ears celebration. No amount of money makes you immune, before someone comes up with that pathetic line. Sorloth has not done too well holding up the ball or winning headers and if Benteke had hit the post from 4 yards no one would be defending him. Difference is he's only played against the big boys so far and for all we know he might be a small club bully. God, I hope so. Personally both we're piss poor in the first half and either one could have gone off. Whoever stayed on was gonna improve because Zaha changes games. He affected the mindset of both clubs and Sorloth benefitted from his presence. Also I believe Roy's gameplan was wrong in the first half. Sorry, but it has to be said.
The problem is it's hard to come up with a decent gameplan for us without using the letters W and Z.
============ The Ferret ============
|
Dangermouse Hastings 11 Mar 18 10.51am |
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
The problem is it's hard to come up with a decent gameplan for us without using the letters W and Z.
Replace the word hard with impossible and you've got a point. Thing is we had to be more proactive cos we were two down and who knows if Benteke had stayed on we might have won 2-3. No one has a crystal ball.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 11 Mar 18 11.00am |
|
|
Been a long time since I was as excited about a transfer as I was when we signed Benteke, thought he'd be superb for us. Was decent in patches last year but, in my opinion, he has been abject this year.
The blame isn't entirely his, our injury nightmare and lack of transfers reinforcements means that he has rarely had competition and often poor service, however there have also been a lot of matches where his effort and commitment have been lacking.
I say put him on the bench for a couple of games now and give Sorloth a crack with Wilf and Townsend back on the wings. If nothing else, it might give Benteke a kick up the arse.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
bifffabazz Highworth, Wiltshire 11 Mar 18 11.02am |
|
Originally posted by The_Dumps
Did you even WATCH the game? He hit the post, scroed a legitimate goal and made the the goal we did score!? Jeez, there is so much negativity on this board.. this lad is a breath of fresh air.
Quite right. The lad did great creating something from nothing on the right in the lead up to the goal. Can anyone tell me that Benteke could have done that?
Spirit of 1974
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 11 Mar 18 11.31am |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Really believe that Benteke actually damaged himself when he took the penalty from Luka. It was a foolish act he has been unable to mentally recover from IMO. He has won many flick ons which have not been read by teammates and played to instructions, contrary to many people's opinions, but the sparkle has gone. He's flat and reactive rather than bubbling and proactive. Also after Bournemouth the abuse he would have received must have an effect on your mindset, hence the fingers in ears celebration. No amount of money makes you immune, before someone comes up with that pathetic line. Sorloth has not done too well holding up the ball or winning headers and if Benteke had hit the post from 4 yards no one would be defending him. Difference is he's only played against the big boys so far and for all we know he might be a small club bully. God, I hope so. Personally both we're piss poor in the first half and either one could have gone off. Whoever stayed on was gonna improve because Zaha changes games. He affected the mindset of both clubs and Sorloth benefitted from his presence. Also I believe Roy's gameplan was wrong in the first half. Sorry, but it has to be said.
Please don't use the Bournemouth penalty debacle as a further excuse, Benteke had been awful up to that miserable point and excluding the Leicester match hasn't improved. This 'lack of confidence' thing is laughable, this guy is pulling £120k a week and giving sweet FA to the cause of which, by his performances he couldn't give a flying toss about! I sincerely hope he goes to China or indeed anywhere in the Summer.
Bring back Brolin
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 11 Mar 18 11.49am |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Replace the word hard with impossible and you've got a point. Thing is we had to be more proactive cos we were two down and who knows if Benteke had stayed on we might have won 2-3. No one has a crystal ball.
Absolutely, so if we just go on the facts to date it would have been highly unlikely he would have contributed with any goals. Roy obviously felt the same. I find the Teflon positivity for Benteke for the season he has had very odd. It’s almost a battle for some against those who are critical of him.
|
Charles Forest Hill 11 Mar 18 11.54am |
|
|
Why's it an 'either or'? Benteke's looked much better since Sorloth arrived and was at his best for us in the few games Wickham was alongside him. He's not the most brilliant fit with Wilf to date; maybe that will improve and it's probably not a concern for next season.
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 11 Mar 18 11.57am |
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Absolutely, so if we just go on the facts to date it would have been highly unlikely he would have contributed with any goals. Roy obviously felt the same. I find the Teflon positivity for Benteke for the season he has had very odd. It’s almost a battle for some against those who are critical of him.
Confusing, are you saying that you find it odd those who are critical of Benteke, If so what do you find odd?
Bring back Brolin
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 11 Mar 18 12.06pm |
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
Confusing, are you saying that you find it odd those who are critical of Benteke, If so what do you find odd?
Not sure where the confusion is.. I believe the criticism of Benteke is fully justified. The irrational and continual belief in Benteke is what I find odd.
|
AERO 11 Mar 18 12.25pm |
|
|
I will drive him to China tomorrow
|
Dangermouse Hastings 11 Mar 18 12.32pm |
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Absolutely, so if we just go on the facts to date it would have been highly unlikely he would have contributed with any goals. Roy obviously felt the same. I find the Teflon positivity for Benteke for the season he has had very odd. It’s almost a battle for some against those who are critical of him.
Didn't say he would. Said no one had a crystal ball. Sorloth was as bad if not worse first half, so why would I expect him to change the game either?
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Dangermouse Hastings 11 Mar 18 12.37pm |
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
Please don't use the Bournemouth penalty debacle as a further excuse, Benteke had been awful up to that miserable point and excluding the Leicester match hasn't improved. This 'lack of confidence' thing is laughable, this guy is pulling £120k a week and giving sweet FA to the cause of which, by his performances he couldn't give a flying toss about! I sincerely hope he goes to China or indeed anywhere in the Summer.
In just trying to find out why a proven Premier league scorer has totally died up and looks lost. No real pre season for the team, FdB debacle, knee injury all things that may contribute. His performance against Bournemouth had been his best of the season till the penalty thing, so it could be a factor. I suppose just abusing him works just as well though. Plus the tired old wages line, give me a break. Take your time travelling to China we won't miss you either.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Happiness Stan Itchycoo Park 11 Mar 18 1.00pm |
|
|
I'd carry him there on a sedan chair, but need a partner to do so. Up for it?
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"
|
A1969Eagle Redhill 11 Mar 18 1.04pm |
|
|
Its rarely worked all season with Benteke as main man so we have to make changes, at least Sorloth as young player who needs time in Premier league to leanr outsmart defenders but when gets the ball, he wants to score.. what does Benteke want... his confidence is shot. He (Benteke) is bossing Sorloth in the match rather than let Sorloth make his own decisions but him and Zaha worked much better. Yes keep the same 2nd half Zaha & Sorloth for the next match with benteke his replacement late in 2nd half with something to prove!!.
Sadly I dont think we shall see Wickham as premier leauge player again. Mr Sick Note always had a leg problem before the bad one, he took the penalty at Chelsea and wow did he wince, he came off soon after. His goals at WBA, he winced when he shot hard then next game out injured.
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 11 Mar 18 2.17pm |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Didn't say he would. Said no one had a crystal ball. Sorloth was as bad if not worse first half, so why would I expect him to change the game either?
Well unfair to judge Sorloth on 3 games. You could get a better guesstimate from Bentekes 24. Didn’t mean you directly anyway.
|