You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > James O'Brien
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James O'Brien


Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 29 Jun 18 1.04pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

why do you vehemently defend the wealthy? Do you subscribe to the trickle down theory? do you think the wealth gap is too narrow?

Edited by Pussay Patrol (28 Jun 2018 10.28pm)

People like Bill Gates should be celebrated and the world would be a worse place without him, from enabling poor people to own a computer, to providing jobs, helping business, to using his wealth for philanthropy. He could never even exist in a socialist utopia.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Jun 18 6.23pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

No worries Cryrst, I do defend the wealthy.

They are a sign of a meritocratic society that works and as long as they are responsible and support the society that enabled that wealth I celebrate them.

I totally agree with you that you don't kill the goose which lays the golden egg....instead you feather the nest.

Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Jun 2018 8.35am)


I'm as jealous as the next man about rich people.
I work in environments where money is no object literally no object.
I was tipped £50 yesterday for 2 hours work which I got paid the hours for through my firm anyway.
That's where I would like to be.
I wish I was them without the aggro that comes with being rich.
That being picked on as the route of the problems.
They put in the bare minimum money which is still a hell of a lot more than most.
And the ones you won't defend Stirling are the ones who don't even put in the minimum and they are out there.
Like I said fairness has to be both ways.
Your statement seems loaded by the way and being a teacher allows you to think like that

 

.TUX. Flag 29 Jun 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Stirling I don't defend the wealthy.
There is nothing to defend them about.
They need people to see that fairness has to be the normal.
The wealthy are actually a group of people which is getting bigger
Not through actually getting richer but by the gap between rich and poor closing. So it is very narrow at present and will get even more so.
If you have a house worth a million you are now deemed as rich and in that bracket.
But you only got that because you bought it ages ago.
That's not down to an individual being an entrepreneur and stuffing people on the way up. It doesnt mean you are rich as you need to live somewhere.
It does seem like no one actually gives a monkey's about what the rich pay. Unless they can "surely" pay more.
Be careful not to kill the goose which lays the golden egg.

Complete and utter bollocks. You are bloody clueless.

That is all.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Jun 18 6.34pm

Originally posted by cryrst


I'm as jealous as the next man about rich people.
I work in environments where money is no object literally no object.
I was tipped £50 yesterday for 2 hours work which I got paid the hours for through my firm anyway.
That's where I would like to be.
I wish I was them without the aggro that comes with being rich.
That being picked on as the route of the problems.
They put in the bare minimum money which is still a hell of a lot more than most.
And the ones you won't defend Stirling are the ones who don't even put in the minimum and they are out there.
Like I said fairness has to be both ways.
Your statement seems loaded by the way and being a teacher allows you to think like that

I wasn't always a teacher and I don't teach much anymore......It's a burn out job if you do it properly....one of a few in the public services.

When I helped run my old man's pub in Bermondsey back in the nineties we had a few city guys who liked the old Swan & Sugarloaf.

I learnt enough to know it's a completely different world.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Jun 18 8.58pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Complete and utter bollocks. You are bloody clueless.

That is all.

Very nice TUX
To what exactly
When I got repossessed in the eighties I didn't blame the rich
When I lived in a council flat on shrublands for 12 years I didn't blame the rich
When I visited the council 3 days in a row with statements , aferdavids from family and all the proof to prove I was potless with a Mrs a kid and a mortgage with no job I didn't blame the rich.
And you think I'm clueless.
Ha ha when did you go there TUX.
When did you get a £20 crisis loan after all that to feed your family on beans on toast for a week.
And some piss head in the cubicle next to me gets his £200 giro for him and his mates tenants super.
I didn't blame the rich.
I played the loan back 11 years later with £15 interest and I didn't blame the rich.
I might be naive, I might come across as a bit stupid, I might sit on the fence.
BUT do not call me clueless cos I been there matey.
HAVE YOU ??????

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 30 Jun 18 10.20am

I don't think it's a case of blaming wealthy people, that's what governments want you to do, blame other sections of society like Immigrants so they can mug you off and continue to force austerity on you.

But the fact is the wealth gap is too wide in this country. For example London has more millionaires than any other city in the world yet homelessness has increased significantly. Public transport is too expensive, renationalise and subsidise so it is affordable comparable to the rest of europe. I'd also increase the minimum wage. Plus I don't want to live in a society where executive pay and bonuses are a plenty yet Nurses only get 1% pay increases on already menial wages. Again i'm not blaming the rich just highlighting the imbalances

Edited by Pussay Patrol (30 Jun 2018 10.26am)

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Jun 18 3.13pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

I don't think it's a case of blaming wealthy people, that's what governments want you to do, blame other sections of society like Immigrants so they can mug you off and continue to force austerity on you.

But the fact is the wealth gap is too wide in this country. For example London has more millionaires than any other city in the world yet homelessness has increased significantly. Public transport is too expensive, renationalise and subsidise so it is affordable comparable to the rest of europe. I'd also increase the minimum wage. Plus I don't want to live in a society where executive pay and bonuses are a plenty yet Nurses only get 1% pay increases on already menial wages. Again i'm not blaming the rich just highlighting the imbalances

Edited by Pussay Patrol (30 Jun 2018 10.26am)

I don't think you can use a national boundary to compare the wealth gap
London is always going to have more of everything finance wise.

 

.TUX. Flag 30 Jun 18 6.27pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Very nice TUX

To what exactly
When I got repossessed in the eighties I didn't blame the rich
When I lived in a council flat on shrublands for 12 years I didn't blame the rich
When I visited the council 3 days in a row with statements , aferdavids from family and all the proof to prove I was potless with a Mrs a kid and a mortgage with no job I didn't blame the rich.
And you think I'm clueless.
Ha ha when did you go there TUX.
When did you get a £20 crisis loan after all that to feed your family on beans on toast for a week.
And some piss head in the cubicle next to me gets his £200 giro for him and his mates tenants super.
I didn't blame the rich.
I played the loan back 11 years later with £15 interest and I didn't blame the rich.
I might be naive, I might come across as a bit stupid, I might sit on the fence.
BUT do not call me clueless cos I been there matey.
HAVE YOU ??????

You are ''clueless'' in thinking that the rich are the goose laying the Golden Egg when the truth is the complete bloody opposite! You're happy with financing their wealth, i'm not.

PS A bit strong of a response, soz, but you have to change your bloody mindset bud. Rich people take more than a fair share of money from those who can least afford it. That's you that is


[Link]


 


Buy Litecoin.

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 30 Jun 18 6.56pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

You are ''clueless'' in thinking that the rich are the goose laying the Golden Egg when the truth is the complete bloody opposite! You're happy with financing their wealth, i'm not.

PS A bit strong of a response, soz, but you have to change your bloody mindset bud. Rich people take more than a fair share of money from those who can least afford it. That's you that is


[Link]


So if trickle down doesn't work, what's the solution?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Jun 18 7.30pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

You are ''clueless'' in thinking that the rich are the goose laying the Golden Egg when the truth is the complete bloody opposite! You're happy with financing their wealth, i'm not.

PS A bit strong of a response, soz, but you have to change your bloody mindset bud. Rich people take more than a fair share of money from those who can least afford it. That's you that is


[Link]


Go on then
How do they "take" it.
This started by me saying they pay a lot more on tax than you and me, and that it is a bit strong keep wanting more. Then I stated a fixed amount annually would be fair in my eyes.
So there is no golden egg then.
If you look at figures the top 10% pay at least half of the tax take to the government.
Is that not a golden section of society.
What you want is everyone to be equal.
So let's be equally f####d when they leave.
My response was of someone living in the real world not blaming other people for their bad luck or misfortune or even self implosion.
And who are those who can least afford it.
That's down to who gives it out and policy of government. Maybe some people don't know how to manage what they have and go on the warpath of people who can manage it and have got it when they screw up.

 

.TUX. Flag 30 Jun 18 8.05pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

So if trickle down doesn't work, what's the solution?

Any good economy is driven by it's largest participants, the middle/working classes. The 'rich' add little in comparison to this group (despite the rants of the blinkered).
Stop raping the economic drivers. Simple.

 


Buy Litecoin.

.TUX. Flag 30 Jun 18 8.06pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Go on then
How do they "take" it.
This started by me saying they pay a lot more on tax than you and me, and that it is a bit strong keep wanting more. Then I stated a fixed amount annually would be fair in my eyes.
So there is no golden egg then.
If you look at figures the top 10% pay at least half of the tax take to the government.
Is that not a golden section of society.
What you want is everyone to be equal.
So let's be equally f####d when they leave.
My response was of someone living in the real world not blaming other people for their bad luck or misfortune or even self implosion.
And who are those who can least afford it.
That's down to who gives it out and policy of government. Maybe some people don't know how to manage what they have and go on the warpath of people who can manage it and have got it when they screw up.

Not at all.
Stop being dumb.

 


Buy Litecoin.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Jun 18 9.44pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Not at all.
Stop being dumb.

I can cherry pick any line from a statement.
Isolate it
And criticise it.
Is it because I said 'you' or just the equal term.
C'mon TUX there is no mileage IMO in keep on blaming rich people for the woes of the bottom bit of society.
Life deals a hand
Some are impossible to play I will agree.
A lot are playable and it's just effort and time to get a better one.
Is the equation on tax take to rich people correct IYO. You have to try to protect this income surely.
And my equal bit by the way is what socialism deep down is all about.
Take from the rich.
Give to the poor
Bingo everyone the same
Got nuffink

That's metaphorical.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 30 Jun 18 10.08pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Any good economy is driven by it's largest participants, the middle/working classes. The 'rich' add little in comparison to this group (despite the rants of the blinkered).
Stop raping the economic drivers. Simple.

OK, who are the rich you referring to? A salary of £70,000 in the UK puts you in the top 5 per cent of earners.

The top 1% pay over a quarter of all the income tax the government gets. If these people did not exist then everyone else has to match that amount – or the govt income reduces significantly. The top 1% already pay more than their fair share.

Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich!

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 30 Jun 18 10.40pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

OK, who are the rich you referring to? A salary of £70,000 in the UK puts you in the top 5 per cent of earners.

The top 1% pay over a quarter of all the income tax the government gets. If these people did not exist then everyone else has to match that amount – or the govt income reduces significantly. The top 1% already pay more than their fair share.

Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich!

Technically true- but this is for Income tax only, which makes up just a quarter of the total tax revenue. It should be noted that the top 1% have benefited disproportionately from, for example, the cuts in corporation tax, property taxes etc.

Oh, and the old "Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich" line? Lazy. Here's another equally broad and lazy line- 'capitalism privatises profits and socialises losses'.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Jun 18 10.58pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Technically true- but this is for Income tax only, which makes up just a quarter of the total tax revenue. It should be noted that the top 1% have benefited disproportionately from, for example, the cuts in corporation tax, property taxes etc.

Oh, and the old "Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich" line? Lazy. Here's another equally broad and lazy line- 'capitalism privatises profits and socialises losses'.

Yes they have benefited from corp tax cuts etc but that's not the point really.
They have only benefited because they're in a position to.
Is that a reason to want more and more
the point of this bit of the thread is about what they pay, not what they get back or don't pay.
They still pay a massive amount pro rata than most of us. Greed causes issues and resentment and in isolation is a bad trait. Rich people don't want to be a pound less rich tomorrow I get that but as said they pay loads.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 30 Jun 18 11.39pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Technically true- but this is for Income tax only, which makes up just a quarter of the total tax revenue. It should be noted that the top 1% have benefited disproportionately from, for example, the cuts in corporation tax, property taxes etc.

Oh, and the old "Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich" line? Lazy. Here's another equally broad and lazy line- 'capitalism privatises profits and socialises losses'.

And NI accounts for about 20% of total tax revenue, which combined with income tax is 45%.

What happens when corporation tax goes down? Companies invest the savings into the business by employing more staff, buying more product and investing into more innovation, plus wages go up.

It's a waste of time explaining economics to a socialist. To cut to the chase, just show me some countries that are thriving economically under socialism. It does not work otherwise everyone would be doing it.

Edited by Penge Eagle (30 Jun 2018 11.43pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jun 18 11.58pm

The only countries that remain socialist are dictatorships.

The proof is in the eating.....the only democratic countries that elect socialist governments are ones that haven't had them for decades.....enough time for youth, who have never experienced a socialist government to get to voting age.

They are easily fooled and believe the promises socialists put out. Enough of them are ignorant of history so they actually believe it.

There is actually hope for socialism in the future once automation has radically changed the workforce enough for the capitalist system to have to consider a change.

But it will have to be a part of the new system....not the actual system itself.......both traditional capitalism and socialism will be outmoded solutions in of themselves.

But for now....it's the last thing any sane country votes for.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Jul 2018 2.16am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

YT Flag Oxford 01 Jul 18 6.55am

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Technically true- but this is for Income tax only, which makes up just a quarter of the total tax revenue. It should be noted that the top 1% have benefited disproportionately from, for example, the cuts in corporation tax, property taxes etc.

Oh, and the old "Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich" line? Lazy. Here's another equally broad and lazy line- 'capitalism privatises profits and socialises losses'.

Please name some UK property taxes and explain which ones have been cut. Genuine request, as I don’t know the answer.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

.TUX. Flag 01 Jul 18 7.46am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

OK, who are the rich you referring to? A salary of £70,000 in the UK puts you in the top 5 per cent of earners.

The top 1% pay over a quarter of all the income tax the government gets. If these people did not exist then everyone else has to match that amount – or the govt income reduces significantly. The top 1% already pay more than their fair share.

Socialists would rather everyone be poor than some people be rich!

As a percentage of your(my) income, you(i) pay far far more in tax than 'the rich' ever will........yet you talk about ''fairness''?
It baffles me why many continually ignore this fact.

As for Socialism (zzzzzz), you live in that world whether you choose to accept it or not. Bank bail-outs/ins, Working Tax Credits etc etc are all paid for by YOU for the benefit of those wealthier than YOU.
Who tells you that you need rich people? Rich people.
Along with many you've been indoctrinated. You just can't see it.

"It's easier to fool people than to convince them that they have been fooled".


 


Buy Litecoin.

Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > James O'Brien