This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Excited for Puncheon coming back next season?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
mattteo 26 Jul 18 3.25pm |
|
|
Still 1 year contract to go, so I can't see anyone taking him just now, after he has recuperated from injury. He was wonderful in the Premier League as winger, especially on the right. His movement to the centre was a disaster, especially as a defensive player. But he did have the skills and technique to play inverted winger. Could he be an adequate substitute for Townsend? Townsend is a similar left footed inverted winger, but younger and a starter.
Chungy was a substitute as right wing last season, but mostly unused. Instead of buying a new substitute for 2-3 million, could Puncheon fill that?
|
Aray South London 26 Jul 18 3.31pm |
|
|
moving Puncheon infield was a disaster. So, so one footed. But he used to do a decent job on the wing.
|
Bangell Oxford 26 Jul 18 3.32pm |
|
|
No
|
cpj Kent 26 Jul 18 3.38pm |
|
|
The only PL games he started last season were 6 of the first 7 and we know what happened then! I hope we never see him again.
|
Woolsy Essex 26 Jul 18 3.40pm |
|
|
I think he's got something to prove, so maybe we will see a new improved player this season.
|
AERO 26 Jul 18 4.18pm |
|
|
Scoring would be a start and something different Lol
|
matthau South Croydon 26 Jul 18 4.31pm |
|
|
he got caught up in the club incident, he wasn't playing well before that happened, and age wise he shouldn't really be past it yet, PERHAPS something happened in his personal life that made him lose it a bit, someone close to him passed or the cup final loss was too much for him to take, I dunno, but its possible we may see a different puncheon this year, something closer to the one 4 years back, who knows.
whether he gets his chance is the bigger question.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 26 Jul 18 4.39pm |
|
Originally posted by matthau
he got caught up in the club incident, he wasn't playing well before that happened, and age wise he shouldn't really be past it yet, PERHAPS something happened in his personal life that made him lose it a bit, someone close to him passed or the cup final loss was too much for him to take, I dunno, but its possible we may see a different puncheon this year, something closer to the one 4 years back, who knows.
whether he gets his chance is the bigger question.
It could just be that not one manager even dropped him from the team apart from the cup final and then Roy drops him from not only the captaincy and team altogether but also the bench, every week. No doubt that got to him after being first on the teamsheet for quite a few seasons.
COYP
|
Mapletree Croydon 26 Jul 18 5.14pm |
|
|
We know he is capable of playing well
If - and it's a big one - he has recovered from his injury
and if - a smaller one - he is used in the right position by a manager who knows how to get the most out of him
and if - I have no idea how big this one is - he has his head right, he could be as good as he once was and maybe even better
Too early to write him off, in Roy we trust.
|
ex hibitionist Hastings 26 Jul 18 5.19pm |
|
|
no is the immediate response, he's lost some pace so I don't think he's a credible option on the wing anymore, he was never a central midfielder, second team player now, if he did find hid form again he could be an option as a number 10 but i'd say he's basically past his sell by date, players like him used to end up at Orient back in the day.
|
pssguy 26 Jul 18 5.26pm |
|
|
Be optimistic He's going to have a belter
|
Hrolf The Ganger 26 Jul 18 5.27pm |
|
|
NO!
He did not impress at all as captain or as a player. We need to do better.
|
Mwncisee Middlesbrough 26 Jul 18 6.05pm |
|
|
Very suprised to see some say he was better on the wing. I don't think he was and wouldn't suit our current setup on the wing.
It's not his playing style to take players on down the byline, often wanting to cut back in, slow the pace and play a simple pass or cross from deep. Lacks pace to beat a fullback for pace and lacks the dribbling skill to trick his way past. He is sometimes successful with driving runs and his effort to get stuck in. These traits actually made him a better central player then a wide player in my opinion and up to the FA Cup Final he did very well in the center of our midfield.
From then on it spiraled downhill for him and actually the enforced break may well have done him the world of good. Only time will tell but has the fresh start and potential ability to still do a good job for us.
|
grumpymort US/Thailand/UK 26 Jul 18 6.12pm |
|
|
He only did well under Pullis.
Why is this it is simple really Pullis played rigid system so punch spent most times defending on that side and then counter attack this was it so very easy to learn and do.
he doesn't have the brain to play in middle.
At the end of the day he is another one of those because he is from the area he is kept we need to stop this throughout the club there is deadwood who cares about ties to the club you want the best for the role/job
(VPN) - [Link] (Alt VPN) - [Link]
|
Crystal_Clear Belfast 26 Jul 18 6.20pm |
|
|
I always felt he was too slow in possession, he often thought he had more time on the ball than he actually did. So frequently, losing possession.
Unless he can speed up his game, then he is a liability.
|
AERO 26 Jul 18 6.35pm |
|
|
Do well to make bench in my opinion
|
Maine Eagle USA 26 Jul 18 6.59pm |
|
|
Not at all, no.
Punch was good for us about 3 seasons ago, he had good technical ability, scored some great free kicks, and was a good passer of the ball.
Then he turned into Owen Garvan, but slower, and started waving his arms around like a helicopter all game.
He does have one thing in common with Gazza though as they both did themselves major injuries by trying to foul other players.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 26 Jul 18 7.05pm |
|
|
Wheres he been playing during preseason ?
wing or central midfield?
|
EagleinSF San Fransisco 26 Jul 18 7.44pm |
|
|
it's a no from me. His last decent run out was the Cup Final. And even before then he blew hot and cold. Since then he's done nothing in the Red n Blue to merit a return.
|
kev64 Cambs 26 Jul 18 8.18pm |
|
|
I’ve certainly missed him picking up the ball spinning around and passing it backwards. Plus the pointing at random parts of the pitch was a sight to behold.
|