Very suprised to see some say he was better on the wing. I don't think he was and wouldn't suit our current setup on the wing.

It's not his playing style to take players on down the byline, often wanting to cut back in, slow the pace and play a simple pass or cross from deep. Lacks pace to beat a fullback for pace and lacks the dribbling skill to trick his way past. He is sometimes successful with driving runs and his effort to get stuck in. These traits actually made him a better central player then a wide player in my opinion and up to the FA Cup Final he did very well in the center of our midfield.

From then on it spiraled downhill for him and actually the enforced break may well have done him the world of good. Only time will tell but has the fresh start and potential ability to still do a good job for us.

I always felt he was too slow in possession, he often thought he had more time on the ball than he actually did. So frequently, losing possession.

Unless he can speed up his game, then he is a liability.

Not at all, no.

Punch was good for us about 3 seasons ago, he had good technical ability, scored some great free kicks, and was a good passer of the ball.

Then he turned into Owen Garvan, but slower, and started waving his arms around like a helicopter all game.

He does have one thing in common with Gazza though as they both did themselves major injuries by trying to foul other players.

Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

it's a no from me. His last decent run out was the Cup Final. And even before then he blew hot and cold. Since then he's done nothing in the Red n Blue to merit a return.

Is he still the club captain? That should change

Final few minutes winding the clock down is about his limit theseadays

Agree. I think he’s always been 2 bob , apart from 5/6 game purple patch under Pullis. Worked next to his house though and judging by that, I’m sure his bank balance isn’t 2 bob.
Would struggle to make the bench , if we get a couple in.

Edited by Casual (26 Jul 2018 9.55pm)