This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
i wouldnt sell him he is still young loan deal would be best to get him game time. i really hope we are not going for ayew We’re not really in the luxury position of loaning out £7 mil players. Do we now have 1 too many in 1 position when we’d ideally need a forward player instead and for similar money? That’s the kind of juggling that’s possibly going on.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
For that matter the train calls at Bristol Temple Meads and at Cardiff Central. On that route, it's usually Bristol Parkway, but yes, the permutations are almost endless.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I suspect the truth is that Palace don't rate Ayew highly enough to pay for him. It is a squad game not 11 players, Reidewald has been patient and just what you most want, someone who you can put on and is comfortable at the top level. If Palace really want Ayew then they can still loan or buy from Swansea can't they? I suspect they don't want the risk and don't rate him that highly. IMO I think you’re kind of on the right track in they don’t want to (can’t because of rules) pay the value of Riedewald plus £2 mil for a forward player, especially when they have just signed 2 midfielders on high wages in the Cabaye bracket and Puncheon is returning as well. They’re also trying to stop bulges and an unbalanced squad, especially if moving forward there’s going to be more strategy and longer term thinking. I know the arguments in keeping Riedewald but we’re not in the position where keeping a £7 mil player (or more if the Riedewald plus £2 mil cash says he’s worth more than £7 mil) go out on loan. Nice if we could, but that’s probably a big % of our budget at the moment and we do need more attacking options. None of these signings look like they were us accepting any dross left at the bottom of the barrel and them being this week and 2 of them very low key is a further clue. Edited by Rudi Hedman (02 Aug 2018 11.33am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I suspect the truth is that Palace don't rate Ayew highly enough to pay for him. It is a squad game not 11 players, Reidewald has been patient and just what you most want, someone who you can put on and is comfortable at the top level. If Palace really want Ayew then they can still loan or buy from Swansea can't they? I suspect they don't want the risk and don't rate him that highly. It comes under the headlines of balancing the books. Reidewald obviously hasn’t come enough to impress Roy, no point in keeping him any longer. People keeps moaning about players like Mutch and Lee, he comes under that category, so move him on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rogers Don
Did you actually watch the Reading game? His best performance in a Palace shirt in thec1st half. Replaced by a very rusty Luca. He's good cover for him and still only 21. Reading. The team whose fans think they’ll struggle to stay in... the championship. He’s some way down the pecking order and getting any money in/using as a swap for players not used is the situation we’re in. Roy didn’t and doesn’t intend on using him much or Riedewald moving up the pecking order. A bit of a harsh reality. Would be nice to loan him out but we’re not that financially fortunate to do it. Edited by Rudi Hedman (02 Aug 2018 1.32pm)
COYP |
|
|
Deal off by the sounds of it! Hooray! It's the wrong Ayew brother and Jairo has too much potential to let Wales have him...
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Reidewald's not getting a look ahead of Luka, Macca, Kouyaté, Schlupp. And Punch and Williams are still around. Also there's still a chance one of the other rumoured mids get signed, which would definitely push Reidewald off the bench and into the U23. I think that point may well be made to him that he can choose between playing regularly for a Championship club or playing for the Development Squad as he won't be in the main squad of 25
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Against Reading, Reidewald twice made dumb challenges just outside the box that gave Reading free kicks in great positions. Bright, who was commenting, mentioned that those kind of tackles would be costly in the Prem and just shouldn't happen. Other than that he was solid, but I'm sure Roy took note. They were the kind of tackle that Punch kept doing that got him pushed to the bench. I'm not a huge Ayew fan, but he was still in the top 40 in goals scored and would be great cover. Better Ayew than 10 minutes of Reidewald for a few games a season. Reidewald's not getting a look ahead of Luka, Macca, Kouyaté, Schlupp. And Punch and Williams are still around. Also there's still a chance one of the other rumoured mids get signed, which would definitely push Reidewald off the bench and into the U23.
Definite not, Jairo is a top player played for his country and such potential, only 22. Anyway Palace can buy Ayew it doesn't depend on anyone leaving, or loan. Don't dispose of good players, why?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Definite not, Jairo is a top player played for his country and such potential, only 22. Anyway Palace can buy Ayew it doesn't depend on anyone leaving, or loan. Don't dispose of good players, why? Because we only have 2 players able to play wide if needed and a handful of midfielders and a limited amount of money and wriggle room. You know this.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Definite not, Jairo is a top player played for his country and such potential, only 22. Anyway Palace can buy Ayew it doesn't depend on anyone leaving, or loan. Don't dispose of good players, why? I like the idea of Jaïro more than the player. A classy Dutch kid from the Ajax academy that can play in a number of positions. In reality he hasn’t ever really shown that he has enough to make the grade and doesn’t seem to excel in any area in particular. I’d love for him to step up, but truth be told, I can’t see it happening. Ayew is a proven performer at this level who gives us cover in a number of positions we are short on. It’s a shame this deal collapsed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Because we only have 2 players able to play wide if needed and a handful of midfielders and a limited amount of money and wriggle room. You know this. No I don't think so. But we cannot know, we are not party to SP, RH how things are done at Palace. From past experience Jedi Murray Mariappa etc. I would shackle SP to a chair to prevent anyone leaving !!
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No I don't think so. But we cannot know, we are not party to SP, RH how things are done at Palace. From past experience Jedi Murray Mariappa etc. I would shackle SP to a chair to prevent anyone leaving !! Just bl00dy stubborn in short. We have a limited budget and Riedewald bought for £8 mil is down the pecking order with priorities elsewhere. You keep telling yourself we can afford anything if you like. Or would you prefer us struggle out wide at times with more midfielders scratching their bollox? And why the big gap between your post and quote thing. A big press on the return key or something? Edited by Rudi Hedman (02 Aug 2018 5.32pm)
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.