You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and subs


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
leejaneagles Flag 26 Aug 18 5.29pm

I remember when Roy took over I was a bit concerned about his willingness to change a game, remembering his Euros disaster as England Manager.

However, within a month he was facing an injury crisis and we only had about 11 fit players. He had no options so it went largely unnoticed how little he made subs and when he did just how late they were.

However, this season it just doesn't make sense. It's one of the strongest benches we've ever had as a Palace team.

Meyer is clearly going to be a starter but in games like today where possibly he's not quite up to speed, he's perfect for when Schlupp's having an unspectacular game in the 55th minute.

Ayew hasn't had a minute yet and correct me if I'm wrong he can't play against Swansea so it's baffling he didn't get any time.


That game was an easy Palace win if you drag Tekkers off at half time and give Meyer at least 30 minutes.

At 72 I don't see Roy changing his ways. Is this going to be a problem? I hope not, he seems excellent in every other way but we really don't need something silly like a stubbornness to change things hindering us in a season that could potentially be our best.

 

bashy2 Flag London 26 Aug 18 5.36pm

he left the subs to late again he should of brought the subs on earlier personally think he should of done about the 60minute mark than we go 2-0 down and still didn't do anything until the 75 minute his substitute of beneteke for sorloth was totally wrong I would.of bought on ayew instead of sorloth but what do I know

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Aug 18 6.03pm

It was the case all last season and was very conspicuous today given that we were terrible in the second half.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 26 Aug 18 6.15pm

Totally agree. Roy is always leaving it too late to make substitutions.

Also he's showing too much patience with Benteke, and I don't think Sorloth is the answer either. Ayew is probably asking himself whether he's done the right thing if Roy has him behind those two.

 

Dan Theolmesdaleroad Flag Up north 26 Aug 18 6.23pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

I remember when Roy took over I was a bit concerned about his willingness to change a game, remembering his Euros disaster as England Manager.

However, within a month he was facing an injury crisis and we only had about 11 fit players. He had no options so it went largely unnoticed how little he made subs and when he did just how late they were.

However, this season it just doesn't make sense. It's one of the strongest benches we've ever had as a Palace team.

Meyer is clearly going to be a starter but in games like today where possibly he's not quite up to speed, he's perfect for when Schlupp's having an unspectacular game in the 55th minute.

Ayew hasn't had a minute yet and correct me if I'm wrong he can't play against Swansea so it's baffling he didn't get any time.


That game was an easy Palace win if you drag Tekkers off at half time and give Meyer at least 30 minutes.

At 72 I don't see Roy changing his ways. Is this going to be a problem? I hope not, he seems excellent in every other way but we really don't need something silly like a stubbornness to change things hindering us in a season that could potentially be our best.

Totally agree. It's a squad game, and we had some good options at our disposal today. It's so frustrating when they're either not used or not given enough time to have any impact.

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Aug 18 6.26pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Totally agree. Roy is always leaving it too late to make substitutions.

Also he's showing too much patience with Benteke, and I don't think Sorloth is the answer either. Ayew is probably asking himself whether he's done the right thing if Roy has him behind those two.

I do think that if we start Soerloth or Benteke and it isn't working for them then swapping the one for the other isn't going to solve the problem. Changing the game means changing the system, not just the personnel.

 


============
The Ferret
============

est1905 Flag 26 Aug 18 6.32pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

I remember when Roy took over I was a bit concerned about his willingness to change a game, remembering his Euros disaster as England Manager.

However, within a month he was facing an injury crisis and we only had about 11 fit players. He had no options so it went largely unnoticed how little he made subs and when he did just how late they were.

However, this season it just doesn't make sense. It's one of the strongest benches we've ever had as a Palace team.

Meyer is clearly going to be a starter but in games like today where possibly he's not quite up to speed, he's perfect for when Schlupp's having an unspectacular game in the 55th minute.

Ayew hasn't had a minute yet and correct me if I'm wrong he can't play against Swansea so it's baffling he didn't get any time.


That game was an easy Palace win if you drag Tekkers off at half time and give Meyer at least 30 minutes.

At 72 I don't see Roy changing his ways. Is this going to be a problem? I hope not, he seems excellent in every other way but we really don't need something silly like a stubbornness to change things hindering us in a season that could potentially be our best.

He only recently turned 71.
We dont have the benefit of working with players on the training ground all week, only for 90 mins on a match day and only those picked to play so I'd have to bow to Roy's vastly superior knowledge, experience, football knowledge and opinion of the individual.
We all do. Nobody deserves unconditional, unending praise or is immune from criticism indefinitely but I think after the miracle he pulled off last season he deserves at least the benefit of the doubt that he knows a bit more than any of us what he's doing wouldn't you say?

 

leejaneagles Flag 26 Aug 18 6.35pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I do think that if we start Soerloth or Benteke and it isn't working for them then swapping the one for the other isn't going to solve the problem. Changing the game means changing the system, not just the personnel.

Completely agree it's a case of horses for courses. Having said that, it does look like a big target man is part of Roy's plan A and I find it hard to argue against when you think we look good in most games despite Benteke.

We often win with what is effectively 10 players or we win by 1 goal but Benteke misses direct chances like the header today or he doesn't anticipate and move to the right part of the box when we put a cross in.

Sometimes the tactics are definitely wrong, I think that was highlighted when Wilf moved to the left and scored immediately but imagine if Sorloth can do what Benteke can't and stick the chances away, we'd be unstoppable as we are.

I actually wish Peter Crouch was 5 years younger as absurd as it sounds. I feel like asking a 30 year old Crouch to do exactly as Benteke does in our system he'd end up with 20 goals a season.

Either way if Benteke or Sorloth can't do it we need to buy a big man that can if that's what Roy wants. Surely you don't need 30 million every time either.

 

leejaneagles Flag 26 Aug 18 6.43pm

Originally posted by est1905

He only recently turned 71.
We dont have the benefit of working with players on the training ground all week, only for 90 mins on a match day and only those picked to play so I'd have to bow to Roy's vastly superior knowledge, experience, football knowledge and opinion of the individual.
We all do. Nobody deserves unconditional, unending praise or is immune from criticism indefinitely but I think after the miracle he pulled off last season he deserves at least the benefit of the doubt that he knows a bit more than any of us what he's doing wouldn't you say?

To be fair I think I reference this when I mentioned Meyer is clearly a starter but I assume from Roy's experience and understanding of football that Schlupp is the better option at this stage of the season.

I'm a massive critic of Benteke, I hate the player to be totally honest but again, I do bow down to Roy's superior knowledge and it's hard to argue after our Fulham and Liverpool performance that starting with the same team was the wrong thing to do.

Like you say though, no one should be immune to criticism just because they are football professionals and it is my unprofessional opinion judging by how Meyer changed the game that he should have been given at least 35 minutes, unfit or not.

I also think Roy is wrong to leave it unchanged despite how well we played in previous games, hell even in the previous half of the same game, when we are playing as terribly as we did that 2nd half.

Zaha was having a terrible game but history tells us he's capable of still popping up with something when needed. He scored a goal when largely anonymous. History tells us Benteke won't put the ball in the net if you give him 5 hours of playing time so why give him until the 85th?

I like many others don't believe Sorloth is the answer but there is no history to say one way or the other and 5 minutes when 2-1 down won't help anyone figure out the answer.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 26 Aug 18 7.25pm

Just to clear it up guys, Ayew is not match fit cuz he's a sulky t*** and bunked off pre-season with Swansea - that's why he's not being fielded at the moment.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 26 Aug 18 8.20pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Just to clear it up guys, Ayew is not match fit cuz he's a sulky t*** and bunked off pre-season with Swansea - that's why he's not being fielded at the moment.

In theory Meyer should be less match fit than Ayew as he was without a club whereas Ayew had pre-season.

Weight isn't an issue really (within reason) especially if we're talking coming on for the last 20 minutes instead of Sorloth.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 26 Aug 18 8.21pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Just to clear it up guys, Ayew is not match fit cuz he's a sulky t*** and bunked off pre-season with Swansea - that's why he's not being fielded at the moment.


You can only get match fit by playing matches so how will he ever be fit when he is never being used in the matches.

Roy doesn't have a proper plan b.

I am critical of Benteke but a quality striker doesn't just become rubbish and one of the reasons has to be due to Roy style.

After listening to his post match interview I expect him to put out the same team next game how he can think he only had a small spell of being bad is shocking.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Aug 18 9.13pm

so it seems like weve got people already starting threads questioning Roys decisions & tactics.

what unappreciative philistines we have as fans.

some or you guys dont even know your born when it comes to supporting palace.

people seem to think they have the right so sceond guess sebody with 30 years management experience from their keyboards

Edited by Midlands Eagle (27 Aug 2018 6.45am)

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


bashy2 Flag London 26 Aug 18 9.20pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

so it seems like weve got people already starting threads questioning woys decisions & tactics.

what unappreciative philistines we have as fans.

some or you guys dont even know your born when it comes to supporting palace.

people seem to think they have the right so sceond guess sebody with 30 years management experience from their keyboards

should of bought the subs on earlier when we went 1-0 down and not wait until 10 minutes after we went 2-0 down when it.was far to late and should of started Meyer and bought on ayew instead of sorloth

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 27 Aug 18 12.47am

Only three points after three games, Two away games one at home against some people's runners up elect,
Get rid and appoint some Dutch guy who knows how to start a season properly.

 

george1212 Flag london 27 Aug 18 12.56am

People are going to hate this, but I honestly think we did well last season in spite of Roy, not because of him.

Games like this are won and lost on making effective changes early.

Roy either forgets or doesn't believe the subs will make a difference, it's just not good enough from a top manager. We need a manager who can make some bold decisions a bit earlier on.

We should have got at least a draw today.

Bentecke should be off. Why play him when Ayew scored 10 goals last season?

There is no rationale. Giving Bentecke can come on from the bench to score. He doesn't have a right to start games anymore, it's f***ing shocking that he starts.

 

CT Charlie Flag 27 Aug 18 1.08am

One wonders how often Benteke scores in training. At this point, I think Roy probably believes CB's value lies in drawing attention from the opponents' best defenders, leaving our other players open for chances. On the final corner, Ward was as well marked as I was.

Edited by CT Charlie (27 Aug 2018 1.09am)

 

01CPFC Flag central coast NSW (The Mariners Mi... 27 Aug 18 2.38am

Originally posted by bashy2

he left the subs to late again he should of brought the subs on earlier personally think he should of done about the 60minute mark than we go 2-0 down and still didn't do anything until the 75 minute his substitute of beneteke for sorloth was totally wrong I would.of bought on ayew instead of sorloth but what do I know

Exactly,u know nothing
Obviously u have no qualifications or experience so stop criticising our manager,
in the future WATCH and LEARN Sonny!!!
COYP

 


Where is the Joker shown, I haven't used it ?

01CPFC Flag central coast NSW (The Mariners Mi... 27 Aug 18 2.44am

Originally posted by bashy2

should of bought the subs on earlier when we went 1-0 down and not wait until 10 minutes after we went 2-0 down when it.was far to late and should of started Meyer and bought on ayew instead of sorloth

What would be your tactics be for the Swansea game,
looking forward to your recommendations for Roy,

COYP

 


Where is the Joker shown, I haven't used it ?

michaelpearce Flag grays 27 Aug 18 6.20am

Originally posted by 01CPFC

Exactly,u know nothing
Obviously u have no qualifications or experience so stop criticising our manager,
in the future WATCH and LEARN Sonny!!!
COYP

why are you belittling a comment nobody said sack Roy,
he is poor when making subs timing is his worst trait,lot of the time he wont change the team he picked to start with,every manager has faults and that is Roys,
when the first 11 are doing well nobody notices when it starts going wrong people start to notice,we all made excuses last year due to injurys why he didnt bring players on until last min dot com or not at all ,its the best bench we have had for awhile, he just needs to use it earlier,minor details not total change

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs