You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fishing Industry
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fishing Industry


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Nov 18 3.59pm

Originally posted by pefwin

too far apart you might as well claim that the Black Death was the main reason.

I have no time for the crutch of religon, but no we had periods of zealotry post the reformation. I would suggest the prime mover was the birth of capitalism and the drive for money via overseas trade.

None of it would have happened had we stayed under the control of Catholic Rome.
Look at Catholic countries now? How are they doing?
Spain stole all their money and Ireland was modernised by English influence. South America? Oh dear.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Nov 18 4.14pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Northern Ireland is more or less proportionally represented in the House of Commons - do you think the influence of the fishing industry on Brexit has been proportional to the size of the industry? I don’t, and so it’s interesting to consider why that is.

I was talking population but if you want to go with MPs.

Are they getting more influence than the less than 3% of MPs they represent? And nearly 40% of them don't even take their place in the house of commons.

Both are seeking what is in their best interests, which is not surprising. It's got nothing to do with being proportional.

 


Optimistic as ever

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Nov 18 4.39pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

None of it would have happened had we stayed under the control of Catholic Rome.
Look at Catholic countries now? How are they doing?
Spain stole all their money and Ireland was modernised by English influence. South America? Oh dear.

Blimey you don't half go off track following your anti everybody agendas.

As far as I am aware, to date being keen on the EU has not been classed as a religion. Which is a shame because there could then have been a way to use the law courts to attack this madness.

Control is an interesting word. To some extent we have to fall into line with the other 27 countries to be part of the bloc. But, here's the thing. To trade with the US we have to fall into line as well, I remember the amount of work Sarbanes Oxley forced everyone to do. It's a globalisation thing, not unique to being within the EU. And at least being within the EU brings additional benefits.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 16 Nov 18 4.41pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I was talking population but if you want to go with MPs.

Are they getting more influence than the less than 3% of MPs they represent? And nearly 40% of them don't even take their place in the house of commons.

Both are seeking what is in their best interests, which is not surprising. It's got nothing to do with being proportional.

They are influential now because of the nature of the coalition, but if you’re talking about their influence generally in the House of Commons, i’d say it’s roughly proportional, yes.

Of course everyone is seeking their best interests, but it’s about how much they are listened to.

The thread is about disproportionate influence of an industry, so to say it’s nothing to do with proportional is quite strange.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Nov 18 4.47pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I was talking population but if you want to go with MPs.

Are they getting more influence than the less than 3% of MPs they represent? And nearly 40% of them don't even take their place in the house of commons.

Both are seeking what is in their best interests, which is not surprising. It's got nothing to do with being proportional.

Maintaining a status quo regarding Northern Ireland is crucial, without it people will die again. This involves 1.875 million people in Northern Ireland and affects us all.

By contrast, commercial fishing employs fewer than 10,000 people.

Why they are even mentioned in the same breath is a question we should be asking, which is why I did. It simply plays to populism and totally ignores how the fishermen themselves have contributed to the reduction in their industry.


Edited by Mapletree (16 Nov 2018 4.47pm)

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 16 Nov 18 4.49pm

It's not only about jobs, but about sovereignty. The territorial sea is regarded as the sovereign territory of the state. But the majority of the modern-day left don't actually believe in a country's borders.

Edited by Penge Eagle (16 Nov 2018 4.51pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Nov 18 4.51pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Blimey you don't half go off track following your anti everybody agendas.

As far as I am aware, to date being keen on the EU has not been classed as a religion. Which is a shame because there could then have been a way to use the law courts to attack this madness.

Control is an interesting word. To some extent we have to fall into line with the other 27 countries to be part of the bloc. But, here's the thing. To trade with the US we have to fall into line as well, I remember the amount of work Sarbanes Oxley forced everyone to do. It's a globalisation thing, not unique to being within the EU. And at least being within the EU brings additional benefits.

When I voted Leave, trade was not a factor. Any short term issues we face with trade are a sacrifice worth making for me.

We were discussing historical cause and effect. I thought the Reformation was worth a mention since the same people who support Remain on here often seem to defend religious dogma. Nothing to do with fishing I agree, unless you are feeding the masses with only two fish of course.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Nov 18 4.59pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

When I voted Leave, trade was not a factor. Any short term issues we face with trade are a sacrifice worth making for me.

We were discussing historical cause and effect. I thought the Reformation was worth a mention since the same people who support Remain on here often seem to defend religious dogma. Nothing to do with fishing I agree, unless you are feeding the masses with only two fish of course.

I think you confuse defending religious dogma with defending people from accusations their religion makes them bad people.

In any case, was it not closely related to religion that the industrial revolution occurred? The Scottish Enlightenment, unlike the anti-religious enlightenments in other European countries, was closely linked to Presbyterianism.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Nov 18 5.00pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

They are influential now because of the nature of the coalition, but if you’re talking about their influence generally in the House of Commons, i’d say it’s roughly proportional, yes.

Of course everyone is seeking their best interests, but it’s about how much they are listened to.

The thread is about disproportionate influence of an industry, so to say it’s nothing to do with proportional is quite strange.

There isn't a coalition, but Northern Ireland would still be getting more influence over things even without the DUP issue. Because the EU have made a massive issue over it.

The thread is about the fishing industry, the person who started it made that assertion and I don't agree with it.

 


Optimistic as ever

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Nov 18 5.08pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Blimey you don't half go off track following your anti everybody agendas.

As far as I am aware, to date being keen on the EU has not been classed as a religion. Which is a shame because there could then have been a way to use the law courts to attack this madness.

Control is an interesting word. To some extent we have to fall into line with the other 27 countries to be part of the bloc. But, here's the thing. To trade with the US we have to fall into line as well, I remember the amount of work Sarbanes Oxley forced everyone to do. It's a globalisation thing, not unique to being within the EU. And at least being within the EU brings additional benefits.

Sox compliance is for US listed cos - not cos that trade

 

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Nov 18 5.10pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Maintaining a status quo regarding Northern Ireland is crucial, without it people will die again. This involves 1.875 million people in Northern Ireland and affects us all.

By contrast, commercial fishing employs fewer than 10,000 people.

Why they are even mentioned in the same breath is a question we should be asking, which is why I did. It simply plays to populism and totally ignores how the fishermen themselves have contributed to the reduction in their industry.

Edited by Mapletree (16 Nov 2018 4.47pm)

You just conveniently want to ignore something you don't think is an issue. I made a comparison that you could pick any group and say "Why listen to them?"

They haven't even had a big influence over things.

 


Optimistic as ever

npn Flag Crowborough 16 Nov 18 5.13pm

Sorry to take this On a tangent, but, asked from appearing to be some kind of playground level insults, can someone fill me in on the meaning of beaker and gammon (I am assuming it is not a container and a cut of ham)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Nov 18 5.17pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I think you confuse defending religious dogma with defending people from accusations their religion makes them bad people.

In any case, was it not closely related to religion that the industrial revolution occurred? The Scottish Enlightenment, unlike the anti-religious enlightenments in other European countries, was closely linked to Presbyterianism.

I don't think that was ever in question. In large part, the devout are victims of religion. Unfortunately, it is also the ambition of religion to convert or undermine other belief systems. It causes people to do bad things by the standards of more enlightened thinking. Defending the right to believe is not the same as justifying the results.

The Reformation was not anti-religious and in general, the level of religious pervasion into people's lives was more the issue for the common man during the period where we became more secular. Catholicism was too restrictive and dominating. The Church of England evolved to enable a looser association.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 Nov 18 7.42pm

I wouldn't like to pick a fight on a fisherman.

I'd love to punch a banker in the face.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Nov 18 11.24pm

Originally posted by chris123

Sox compliance is for US listed cos - not cos that trade

Right. So all the SOX work I did for British companies with some US activity was pointless then.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 17 Nov 18 12.40am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Right. So all the SOX work I did for British companies with some US activity was pointless then.

What were they doing reporting to the SEC if not listed in the US?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Nov 18 6.55am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I wouldn't like to pick a fight on a fisherman.

I'd love to punch a banker in the face.


We have other people on the forum with more knowledge of the financial services than I do but still I'd like to offer up these words.

I have some sympathy with you.....metaphorically of course....I don't think we should actually be hitting them!

I don't think perhaps you are referring to all bankers but instead to that small elite of bosses at the top.

We know from statistics that the wages of these guys from the seventies and earlier has rocketed.....it was always...as it should be for such a highly important job very well paid....but it became obscene a long time ago......This in my view hasn't been a good example of the meritocratic system because it hasn't always followed the same scale of success......It has the same issues that the wages of the top footballers have....there's an inbalance between how good someone is to what they are paid.

However, at the moment we have a financial sector which contributes....what is it...something like 25 percent of our tax.....We need to invest in other sectors rather than damage a productive one.

But the anger is justified all the same.....these people get to vote on each other's wages....it's like giving unions the right to set the wages of other union worker's wages...and most shareholders just don't care about ethics just as long as the bucks are flowing....complicity is obviously rife.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Nov 2018 9.43am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 17 Nov 18 9.37am

Originally posted by chris123

What were they doing reporting to the SEC if not listed in the US?

you need to comply with SOX and other US legislation for example the US terrorist list to trade over there (not listed).

It isn't reprical, for example, the issues with US' "safe harbour" legislation.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 17 Nov 18 10.38am

Originally posted by pefwin

you need to comply with SOX and other US legislation for example the US terrorist list to trade over there (not listed).

It isn't reprical, for example, the issues with US' "safe harbour" legislation.

Sanctions is different - sections 302 and 404 are for US listed companies - plenty of cos are listed in London and NY though. My point was you don't need to be sox compliant to trade.

 

jeeagles Flag 17 Nov 18 1.58pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


We have other people on the forum with more knowledge of the financial services than I do but still I'd like to offer up these words.

I have some sympathy with you.....metaphorically of course....I don't think we should actually be hitting them!

I don't think perhaps you are referring to all bankers but instead to that small elite of bosses at the top.

We know from statistics that the wages of these guys from the seventies and earlier has rocketed.....it was always...as it should be for such a highly important job very well paid....but it became obscene a long time ago......This in my view hasn't been a good example of the meritocratic system because it hasn't always followed the same scale of success......It has the same issues that the wages of the top footballers have....there's an inbalance between how good someone is to what they are paid.

However, at the moment we have a financial sector which contributes....what is it...something like 25 percent of our tax.....We need to invest in other sectors rather than damage a productive one.

But the anger is justified all the same.....these people get to vote on each other's wages....it's like giving unions the right to set the wages of other union worker's wages...and most shareholders just don't care about ethics just as long as the bucks are flowing....complicity is obviously rife.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Nov 2018 9.43am)

I was thinking of specific individuals. I used to spend a lot of time around both finance workers and fishermen.

Finance seems like good work if you can get it, but so mundain. It also appears to be full of people with massive egos.

Fishermen on the other hand are just bonkers.

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fishing Industry