You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy on January
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy on January


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
gerry theagle Flag newbury 30 Dec 18 6.34pm

Just a comment about the smalamount of added time Craig Pawson allowed, 4 minutes. There were 5 substitutions, quite a lengthy injury to Giraud and a lot of time wasting by their keeper, who should have been yellow carded as was Guiata at The Etihad last week. Probably made no difference as we didn't have a clue today but you never know.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 30 Dec 18 6.37pm

Oops should have been in match thread. Mods can you move, sorry

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Dec 18 7.43pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Oops should have been in match thread. Mods can you move, sorry

Sorry but we can't move posts

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 Dec 18 10.39am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Which part of "this is something that will be addressed in January with hopefully the addition of one or two players" is confusinig you?

No confusion,I’ve just learnt unlike yourself obviously to take everything that’s said about transfers approaching and during a transfer window with a pinch of salt and see what we end up with by the end of it all, especially since poor old Roy’s been at the helm.


 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 Dec 18 10.44am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

as it's pantomime season I think that I can safely say "Oh yes we will"

Oh no we won’t

I bet SP has said to Roy, benteke and wickham will be like new signings

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 31 Dec 18 12.19pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Should be Roy driving the recruitment and by this I mean giving his targets to SP and DF, not DF telling Roy who is available. I just wonder how much input he has into transfers given SP’s programmer notes. Somehow don’t think much at all. Not a manager more Head Coach.


For RH to do this, he'd have to be our Scouting department!

RH needs to identify the type of player he wants. DF, with the help of the Scouts, should source and find a player that fits his requirements.
Managers cannot be expected to keep an eye on every team in every league. that's not their job. and certainly not at 71.

The trick is having that understanding between manager and DoF regarding the player(s) they are after.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 18 12.55pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger


For RH to do this, he'd have to be our Scouting department!

RH needs to identify the type of player he wants. DF, with the help of the Scouts, should source and find a player that fits his requirements.
Managers cannot be expected to keep an eye on every team in every league. that's not their job. and certainly not at 71.

The trick is having that understanding between manager and DoF regarding the player(s) they are after.

Long gone are the days when a manager used to traverse miles in all climes to watch a player before driving several miles back home in the dark after an evening match.

Scouting has been transformed in this modern era with technology at the forefront providing data led analysis and information.Clubs deal in global markets with some clubs concentrating on major leagues with software analytics company StatDNA being used to drive moneyball principles.Wyscout,Scout7 etc etc are used to identify a plethora of players, indeed Southampton have identified 20 players for each position before whittling this down to 3 or 4.

The manager will liaise with his recruitment team who will scour the software to match his requirements and carry out further analysis if necessary to identify possible targets.He might of course have certain targets in mind.Then of course the ardous task is to get these 'Over the line' and I am led to believe this whole process can be extremely protracted, frustrating and in the end disappointing if the target is not acquired.Financial constraints of course play their part and unrealistic targets are not pursued.

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2018 1.02pm)

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 31 Dec 18 1.00pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

as it's pantomime season I think that I can safely say "Oh yes we will"


"Oh no we wont"

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Dec 18 1.03pm

Originally posted by Willo

Long gone are the days when a manager used to traverse miles in all climes to watch a player before driving several miles back home in the dark after an evening match.

Scouting has been transformed in this modern era with technology at the forefront providing data led analysis and information.Clubs deal in global markets with some clubs concentrating on major leagues with software such as StatDNA being used to drive moneyball principles.Wyscout,Scout7 etc etc are used to identify a plethora of players,

The manager will liaise with his recruitment team who will scour the software to match his requirements and carry out further analysis if necessary to identify possible targets.He might of course have certain targets in mind.Then of course the ardous task is to get these 'Over the line' and I am led to believe this whole process can be extremely protracted, frustrating and in the end disappointing if the target is not acquired.Financial constraints of course play their part and unrealistic targets are not pursued.

And with all this technology we end up with Sorloth, Jach and Rakip

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 31 Dec 18 1.04pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Whoever we sign (if) will be a player that another club wants to offload. More concerning is how this/these players would be used and in what sort of tactical system. Hodgson is fixated on 4-4-2, so what is it to be?

4-4-2 ??, did you watch the Chelsea game, only Zaha up front on his own untill the last 20 mins

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Dec 18 1.04pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And with all this technology we end up with Sorloth, Jach and Rakip

Badda boom tish!

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 31 Dec 18 1.10pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And with all this technology we end up with Sorloth, Jach and Rakip


Wish i had said that.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Dec 18 1.38pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

4-4-2 ??, did you watch the Chelsea game, only Zaha up front on his own untill the last 20 mins

Yes you are right, it was 4-5-1. Just as clueless, isolating our best player from the midfield. Just as clueless as 4-4-2 with two wingers up front. Personally I think we need something like a 4-3-3. If Solanke does join and is unfortunate enough to be the lone striker he'll be crowded out like Wilf.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 18 1.50pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes you are right, it was 4-5-1. Just as clueless, isolating our best player from the midfield. Just as clueless as 4-4-2 with two wingers up front. Personally I think we need something like a 4-3-3. If Solanke does join and is unfortunate enough to be the lone striker he'll be crowded out like Wilf.

Teams play with a lone central striker but if their movement is decent and the movement of the team in general is good they can be effective.Wolves whom we play on Wednesday will probably have Jimenez as their central striker.Brighton play Murray up front although he alternates with Andone.Locadia can play as lone striker but he has been deployed wider recently.Cardiff play with one up front,recently using Callum Paterson who was bought as a right-back.At a different level, Man C only play with one striker, either Aguero or Jesus.

 

AERO Flag 31 Dec 18 1.57pm

Maybe stating the obvious but if the lone striker is experienced enough and decent first touch then his major roll is holding ball up and bringing others into play .Benteke and wickham should be more than capable of that plus adding a couple of goals.We are looking for something that we have already got .Who is going to guarantee us that on our budget ?

 

chateauferret Flag 31 Dec 18 2.09pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

I'd say it's the "hopefully" that makes the "addressing" somewhat equivocal.

Well someone's had a medical and the window hasn't even opened yet so I'd take "hopefully" at face value and not cynically interpret it at some sort of premature excuse.

He's made a positive statement and one which shows awareness of the problem and possible solution. You've picked on one word of it and tried to use that to undermine everything else he's said depsite there seemingly being concrete action well underway.

The right time to appraise the transfer window is, as always, after it has closed.

Edited by chateauferret (31 Dec 2018 2.15pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 31 Dec 18 2.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

Long gone are the days when a manager used to traverse miles in all climes to watch a player before driving several miles back home in the dark after an evening match.

Scouting has been transformed in this modern era with technology at the forefront providing data led analysis and information.

Is this the same technology as is used to forensically examine the performance of referees?

 


============
The Ferret
============

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 31 Dec 18 2.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

Long gone are the days when a manager used to traverse miles in all climes to watch a player before driving several miles back home in the dark after an evening match.

Scouting has been transformed in this modern era with technology at the forefront providing data led analysis and information.Clubs deal in global markets with some clubs concentrating on major leagues with software analytics company StatDNA being used to drive moneyball principles.Wyscout,Scout7 etc etc are used to identify a plethora of players, indeed Southampton have identified 20 players for each position before whittling this down to 3 or 4.

The manager will liaise with his recruitment team who will scour the software to match his requirements and carry out further analysis if necessary to identify possible targets.He might of course have certain targets in mind.Then of course the ardous task is to get these 'Over the line' and I am led to believe this whole process can be extremely protracted, frustrating and in the end disappointing if the target is not acquired.Financial constraints of course play their part and unrealistic targets are not pursued.

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2018 1.02pm)

Are you sure about that? Of course Clearly they will use data to help them and point them in the right direction but they will certainly watch them over a period. I play golf with an Everton scout and he is part of a team who constantly watch players across the age groups and they watch the players before signing them. Are you suggesting Palace do not do that because I would be very surprised if that were the case?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 18 2.41pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

Are you sure about that? Of course Clearly they will use data to help them and point them in the right direction but they will certainly watch them over a period. I play golf with an Everton scout and he is part of a team who constantly watch players across the age groups and they watch the players before signing them. Are you suggesting Palace do not do that because I would be very surprised if that were the case?

For avoidance of doubt I am not suggesting this at all.

I was just trying to highlight the role that technology now plays in the recruitment process which is a far cry from the old days.Teams still of course have a network of scouts and I believe that Everton have some 200 in the north-west alone covering a range of ages.Everton appointed a new Director of Football, Marcel Brands who took over in June from Steve Walsh who was at Leicester.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 31 Dec 18 2.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

For avoidance of doubt I am not suggesting this at all.

I was just trying to highlight the role that technology now plays in the recruitment process which is a far cry from the old days.Teams still of course have a network of scouts and I believe that Everton have some 200 in the north-west alone covering a range of ages.Everton appointed a new Director of Football, Marcel Brands who took over in June from Steve Walsh who was at Leicester.

Thats fine thanks for the clarification.

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy on January