This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
This is the problem that referees suffer from. Fouls are not subjective. The ball was either won or it wasn't. The players was either impeded or he wasn't. It is either a foul or it isn't. There is no subjectivity. yes there is subjectivity. I'm afraid it's human nature. Read Mark Clattenburgs book, to read about how influenced referees can be.
I guess we'll have to live with the smaller stuff, but if we can eliminate the 'big calls', that's a step in the right direction
Edited by Forest Hillbilly (25 Feb 2019 2.55pm)
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
yes there is subjectivity. I'm afraid it's human nature. Read Mark Clattenburgs book, to read about how influenced referees can be.
I guess we'll have to live with the smaller stuff, but if we can eliminate the 'big calls', that's a step in the right direction
Edited by Forest Hillbilly (25 Feb 2019 2.55pm) There isn't room for subjectivity when the rules are applied as they should be. Mark Battenburg is prime example of everything that is wrong with refereeing. This culture of "game management", letting things go to suit, or carding players to avoid blame as he put it (about the battle of the bridge). It is corruption based on vanity. Just because they've completely lost sight of their role in the game, doesn't make 17 simple rules any less concrete then they actually are.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
There isn't room for subjectivity when the rules are applied as they should be. Mark Battenburg is prime example of everything that is wrong with refereeing. This culture of "game management", letting things go to suit, or carding players to avoid blame as he put it (about the battle of the bridge). It is corruption based on vanity. Just because they've completely lost sight of their role in the game, doesn't make 17 simple rules any less concrete then they actually are. How many times have you watched match of the day and the 'pundits' can't agree wether or not it's a penalty. ....so I'm afraid even with VAR there will be subjectivity..
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
How many times have you watched match of the day and the 'pundits' can't agree wether or not it's a penalty. ....so I'm afraid even with VAR there will be subjectivity.. Again, just because a couple of incompetent pundits give their opinion ("for me, that wasn't a penalty": well, the rule book states that it is) it doesn't alter the fact that it's 17 rules which should be enforced objectively.
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
How many times have you watched match of the day and the 'pundits' can't agree wether or not it's a penalty. ....so I'm afraid even with VAR there will be subjectivity.. You have highlighted subjectivity in terms of penalty incidents but there will also be subjectivity in terms of whether a player in an offside position is deemed to have interfered with the keeper's line of sight as the ball flies past him and goes into the goal. And I suspect there will be debate and interpretation as to a "Clear and obvious error".Perhaps the debate will move away from the onfield referee and focus on the VAR system !
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Again, just because a couple of incompetent pundits give their opinion ("for me, that wasn't a penalty": well, the rule book states that it is) it doesn't alter the fact that it's 17 rules which should be enforced objectively. If only it was that black and white. You haven't got a clue.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
If only it was that black and white. You haven't got a clue. It is that black and white. Subjectivity regarding offside FFS. They're either offside or they're not. It boils down to competency: can the referee enforce to law, or do they allow subjectivity to influence them. The culture encourages the latter, so VAR will never work. Edited by ChrisGC (25 Feb 2019 6.22pm)
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Accidental second post deleted. Edited by ChrisGC (25 Feb 2019 6.22pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
It is that black and white. Subjectivity regarding offside FFS. They're either offside or they're not. It boils down to competency: can the referee enforce to law, or do they allow subjectivity to influence them. The culture encourages the latter, so VAR will never work. Edited by ChrisGC (25 Feb 2019 6.22pm) Offside is just one aspect for VAR. This is black and white and VAR is perfect for it. With regard all the other decisions its subjective by all that look at the screen. I think that with more looks at the screen and in slow mo, mire correct decisions will be made. I am fully for VAR.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bifffabazz
Agreed. The VAR ‘team’ must be have been smoking something (paid for by Madrid). Absolutely shocking. UEFA need to step in (unless they’re taking bungs too!) I thought it was a perfectly good decision.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
I thought it was a perfectly good decision. Would you care to elaborate as that statement needs some explaining. The Levante defender swung his boot at thin air and made no contact with the RMA player who wasn’t impeded but then threw himself on the floor (dived).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
At this moment in time I’m inclined to agree. 1) Ultimately I still see there being a number of ridiculous and incorrect decisions being given even after the introduction of VAR. 2) The Euphoria of scoring a goal and seeing the referee point to the centre circle and going mental will be gone, as we will all be waiting for the review and for it to be chalked off because of some innocuous infringement in the build up 2 minutes earlier. 3) I see VAR creeping in to more and more decisions and the time it will take to review them all and go through the process will further kill the game and the atmosphere. 4) I can see the game becoming a game of penalties. The slow motion review process seems to award a penalty where there is ANY contact on the attacking player. Those of us who have played the game know this doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s a foul, far from it. VAR is a good idea in principle but the way it is currently being implemented, the detrimental effect it is having on the flow of the game and the atmosphere and the fact that it hasn’t eliminated the ridiculous and incorrect decisions we are still witnessing regularly tells me that it isn’t fit for purpose in its current form and I for one much prefer games without it (even taking into account the injustice Wilf suffers week in week out).
Incredulity is going to increase as the inconsistency ramps up. One incident getting VAR attention in one match will not get VAR in the next. It is imho, going to be carnage and by far the best way to keep on top of the game we love is (as one earlier poster put it) increase the retro banning system. Salah, Hernandez, Snodgrass, Hazard, Capoue etc would all have to start behaving then! My concern is more cynical however in that I think VAR is being introduced to make things more exciting for the armchairers...at the cost of those in the stadium.
Spirit of 1974 |
|
|
Originally posted by bifffabazz
Why? The so called armchairers already have the benefit of seeing the incident over again and in slow motion too so it wouldn't make any difference to their enjoyment.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
At this moment in time I’m inclined to agree. 1) Ultimately I still see there being a number of ridiculous and incorrect decisions being given even after the introduction of VAR. 4) I can see the game becoming a game of penalties. The slow motion review process seems to award a penalty where there is ANY contact on the attacking player. Those of us who have played the game know this doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s a foul, far from it. VAR is a good idea in principle but the way it is currently being implemented, the detrimental effect it is having on the flow of the game and the atmosphere and the fact that it hasn’t eliminated the ridiculous and incorrect decisions we are still witnessing regularly tells me that it isn’t fit for purpose in its current form and I for one much prefer games without it (even taking into account the injustice Wilf suffers week in week out). This is my main concern. A goal is scored and the crowd go mental......then the ref has to check VAR and the moment is lost. Will really effect the atmosphere at a game. Edited by spartakev2 (26 Feb 2019 9.16am)
|
|
|
God, footballs crap isn't it?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.