You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 4 of 91 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 20 Jul 19 5.26pm

Originally posted by Bangell

This post has been merged from a topic called '“drink it in”' by Midlands Eagle

If you're satisfied with Benteke and Wickham as our options up front then we've got very different points of view.

who can we buy who we can afford who is better? just look at how much ajose perez went to leicester for, bonkers. look at how much bournmouth want for callum wilson, bonkers.

the market has gone absolutely bonkers, if we could get that guy from rangers for less than £10m that seems like a sound addition considering he is 23, were just lucky we dont play aberdeen. haha

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


deetee Flag 20 Jul 19 6.27pm

Three friendlies 3 defeats no goals - doesn't take a genius to realise we need a goal scorer ASAP.

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Jul 19 7.17am

Some on here have taken the view that the AWB deal is a good deal because it would enable enable the club to reinvest the £45 million plus and strengthen the attack.
Will they have the same view if Jenkinson,McCarthy and Ayew are the players invested in?
Yes I know there’s three weeks until the window shuts but it doesn’t look like we’ll be buying e.g a £20m attacking midfielder and £25m striker.
Hodgson said at the end of the last season when asked about plans on strengthening the squad that the key aim of the club was to retain the existing squad.
Which begs the question why have we sold AWB who was on a long term deal, why are we contemplating selling Zaha, and why are we letting Luka enter into the final year without signing him up?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 19 7.49am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Some on here have taken the view that the AWB deal is a good deal because it would enable enable the club to reinvest the £45 million plus and strengthen the attack.
Will they have the same view if Jenkinson,McCarthy and Ayew are the players invested in?

I think that you are manipulating what has been said to suit your agenda. Most people have said that selling AWB was a good deal at that price but only if the money was re-invested wisely and that is where many of us have had reservations

Originally posted by PatrickA

why are we contemplating selling Zaha, and why are we letting Luka enter into the final year without signing him up?

Both questions have been discussed at length in their relevant threads so we have no need to repeat ourselves here

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Jul 19 8.19am

I don’t have an agenda.
The central point I was making is that the club’s key aim at the end of the season was to ensure that the existing squad was retained for this season.
The actions of the club in recent weeks appear to run contrary to that aim and it’s a valid question to ask why this has happened.
If the proceeds are wisely invested I will be first to hold my hand up and admit I was wrong and as a fan I hope that this will be the case.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 21 Jul 19 9.31am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I don’t have an agenda.
The central point I was making is that the club’s key aim at the end of the season was to ensure that the existing squad was retained for this season.
The actions of the club in recent weeks appear to run contrary to that aim and it’s a valid question to ask why this has happened.
If the proceeds are wisely invested I will be first to hold my hand up and admit I was wrong and as a fan I hope that this will be the case.


No need to justify yourself, it was a valid post.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 19 9.37am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The central point I was making is that the club’s key aim at the end of the season was to ensure that the existing squad was retained for this season.
The actions of the club in recent weeks appear to run contrary to that aim and it’s a valid question to ask why this has happened.

I'm sure that the club had no intention of selling AWB until Manchester United offered a lot of money (something that this club seems short of) turning the player's head in the process.

If you were a 20 year old footballer playing for perpetual strugglers in a crumbling stadium and one of the largest and most famous clubs in the world came looking for you and offering eight times your existing wages in the process - wouldn't you clamour to leave?

No club can really hang on to players that wants to go

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 9.54am

Yep, as far as we’re aware, unless the US shareholders have sold half our team without us knowing to explain the losses this pre season then we’ve only sold one player. A right back that we are in the process of filling.

The Luka situation is not as simple as ‘letting it happen/drift.’ Luka will know his value and what is out there vs what’s happening at Palace due to wages, finances, ownership and uncertainty over Zaha and us relying on him till who knows when and how would we adapt when we do inevitably sell him.

Luka May be waiting for certain things to happen before signing an extension. Otherwise we should be selling him now or January, only because our scouting is so p1ss poor usually we’ll have to keep him to then lose him for nothing because once again we probably won’t survive if we sell him.

Further, we don’t know Luka’s wage expectations. What if it’s £100-£120k per week? We cannot afford that and will not be carrying on with that unless it’s for goal scorers. Maybe he wants what cabaye was on. What, £80k+. I don’t know but there’s a growing concern of a wage budget that is already far too high.

If you were Luka would you sign an extension before the close of the transfer window? I know I wouldn’t. You’re unlikely to get injured and the quality of our squad next season is far from clear.

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jul 19 10.32am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yep, as far as we’re aware, unless the US shareholders have sold half our team without us knowing to explain the losses this pre season then we’ve only sold one player. A right back that we are in the process of filling.

The Luka situation is not as simple as ‘letting it happen/drift.’ Luka will know his value and what is out there vs what’s happening at Palace due to wages, finances, ownership and uncertainty over Zaha and us relying on him till who knows when and how would we adapt when we do inevitably sell him.

Luka May be waiting for certain things to happen before signing an extension. Otherwise we should be selling him now or January, only because our scouting is so p1ss poor usually we’ll have to keep him to then lose him for nothing because once again we probably won’t survive if we sell him.

Further, we don’t know Luka’s wage expectations. What if it’s £100-£120k per week? We cannot afford that and will not be carrying on with that unless it’s for goal scorers. Maybe he wants what cabaye was on. What, £80k+. I don’t know but there’s a growing concern of a wage budget that is already far too high.

If you were Luka would you sign an extension before the close of the transfer window? I know I wouldn’t. You’re unlikely to get injured and the quality of our squad next season is far from clear.

You make it sound like no-one wants to play for Palace. We are a mid table PL side positioned in London in the finest league in the world. There are an awful lot of players out there that would jump at the opportunity to join us, its just a shame our scouts are so poor that we only appear capable of unearthing gems like Jach and Sorloth. If Luka thinks he is worth £100k a week then lets see if someone will pay it on top of a transfer fee. He is good, he is our captain, but he is replaceable.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jul 19 10.34am

Haha, maybe we should come up with a new transfer policy where we just throw an open invitation to join Palace into the market place at £50k a week and so who applies. It can't be any worse than our current policy.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jul 19 10.34am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Haha, maybe we should come up with a new transfer policy where we just throw an open invitation to join Palace into the market place at £50k a week and so who applies. It can't be any worse than our current policy.

so = see

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 21 Jul 19 10.44am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You make it sound like no-one wants to play for Palace. We are a mid table PL side positioned in London in the finest league in the world. There are an awful lot of players out there that would jump at the opportunity to join us, its just a shame our scouts are so poor that we only appear capable of unearthing gems like Jach and Sorloth. If Luka thinks he is worth £100k a week then lets see if someone will pay it on top of a transfer fee. He is good, he is our captain, but he is replaceable.

we already have his replacement in koyuate, who is more
than capable of playing that role.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jul 19 10.51am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

we already have his replacement in koyuate, who is more
than capable of playing that role.

Based on his performances in the Afcon I think Kouyate's best position could well be centre half. If that is the case we could offload Sakho's massive wages and try and get Reidewald to step up a level in Luka's place. According to the coaches that is his natural position, but if he is not good enough then he needs to go too and then we will need a replacement.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Jul 19 11.03am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Based on his performances in the Afcon I think Kouyate's best position could well be centre half. If that is the case we could offload Sakho's massive wages and try and get Reidewald to step up a level in Luka's place. According to the coaches that is his natural position, but if he is not good enough then he needs to go too and then we will need a replacement.

Now you're thinking like the CPFC management

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 21 Jul 19 11.05am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Based on his performances in the Afcon I think Kouyate's best position could well be centre half. If that is the case we could offload Sakho's massive wages and try and get Reidewald to step up a level in Luka's place. According to the coaches that is his natural position, but if he is not good enough then he needs to go too and then we will need a replacement.

personally i would not sell sakho as he is by far our best central defender...its nice to know kouyate could play there if needed though, would mean if we sold scotty dann we wouldnt need to replace him.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 11.19am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You make it sound like no-one wants to play for Palace. We are a mid table PL side positioned in London in the finest league in the world. There are an awful lot of players out there that would jump at the opportunity to join us, its just a shame our scouts are so poor that we only appear capable of unearthing gems like Jach and Sorloth. If Luka thinks he is worth £100k a week then lets see if someone will pay it on top of a transfer fee. He is good, he is our captain, but he is replaceable.

Wow, what a naive post. We’re not a mid table team. We spend 33 games in the bottom 4-6. We pick up more points vs teams in flip flops at end of the season.

How many players have jumped to join us in recent summers then? Or have we all imagined West Ham and whoever else nicking our targets, hence why we keep a close shop.

You’re leaving the possibility of Luka leaving for nothing, after you sad lyrical about how players are falling over themselves to join us. Not only is it illogical but if we were that well run we would get and have everything in order to encourage him to stay. It’s also bad business.

Finally you don’t seem to understand that free agents can negotiate higher wages because they’re, erm, free, with no transfer fee cost.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 11.25am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

personally i would not sell sakho as he is by far our best central defender...its nice to know kouyate could play there if needed though, would mean if we sold scotty dann we wouldnt need to replace him.

Sakho is the player that when he’s unavailable, our start of play is often pretty awful. He can also Marshall the halfway line and play balls through the lines from the halfway line. We need to find a cheaper replacement but currently he’s miles above the others and it’s noticeable without him playing the way we do, which was our aim to have possession about 4 years ago and more isn’t it?

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 21 Jul 19 11.40am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sakho is the player that when he’s unavailable, our start of play is often pretty awful. He can also Marshall the halfway line and play balls through the lines from the halfway line. We need to find a cheaper replacement but currently he’s miles above the others and it’s noticeable without him playing the way we do, which was our aim to have possession about 4 years ago and more isn’t it?

so im a bit confused, in one breath your saying we miss him a lot when unavailable, and in the next we need to replace him with a cheaper alternative. im not trying to be funny just trying to gauge your view on him.

for me, and maybe i am being biased but i think he is the best CB outside the top 6 and his wages represent that fact. i think we would miss him a lot more than we will miss AWB. i dont think we could purchase a cheaper alternative who is better than him, we could replace him with kurt zouma but he will probably end up at everton, and funnily enough has just handed in a transfer request.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


davehuggins Flag 21 Jul 19 11.52am

I am a SP supporter but the facts are it costs a fortune to run a PL club these days and he just doesn't have the funds to take Palace further. We need investment sooner rather than later IMO

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 11.52am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

so im a bit confused, in one breath your saying we miss him a lot when unavailable, and in the next we need to replace him with a cheaper alternative. im not trying to be funny just trying to gauge your view on him.

for me, and maybe i am being biased but i think he is the best CB outside the top 6 and his wages represent that fact. i think we would miss him a lot more than we will miss AWB. i dont think we could purchase a cheaper alternative who is better than him, we could replace him with kurt zouma but he will probably end up at everton, and funnily enough has just handed in a transfer request.

I hope this is clearer... We miss Sakho because the others are noticeably inferior. We could do with a cheaper alternative who isn’t any of our current CB’s. I can’t believe I’ve had to clarify that.

I agree we’d miss Sakho more than AWB, and that we’d struggle to buy a better alternative, but an alternative we’d have to find who is nearly as good, or a partnership that is as or more productive than Sakho plus any of the other 3.

We also have the wage bill issues and Sakho is on £100k. We should’ve been looking at alternatives anyway because even if you or anyone CPFC doesn’t like it, there’s rumours Sakho wants to return to France. Hopefully we have some idea how we’ll deal with that when it happens. He won’t be signing an extension I’d have thought with intentions to return to France so this must be dealt with. Here’s hoping.

 


COYP

Page 4 of 91 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread