You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > God help Aston Villa
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

God help Aston Villa


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
tonymair Flag 27 Aug 19 10.49pm

Point to prove, lads...

 

Bekken Flag 27 Aug 19 11.42pm


Despite the United win, we are bang in trouble. Hodgson is on a tight rope and the players need to sort themselves out.

Deeply embarrassed by tonight’s result

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 19 11.56pm

They won’t be needing god. Just a decent defensive plan which will be the carbon copy doing the rounds. I hope I’m wrong and we go at them with some intensity and pace in moments when we can.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 28 Aug 19 8.07am

Originally posted by tonymair

Point to prove, lads...

We've had a point to prove at home for ages, but Roy isn't, on the evidence, likely to be able to do it.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Aug 19 8.23am

There were ten changes from Saturday’s win at United and three points against Villa are far more precious than progress in the Carabao Cup. I’d expect to see a far different performance.

I don’t know of any manager that would do better with the hand that Roy has been given. Our Premier League points tally since the turn of the year is impressive.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 19 8.35am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

There were ten changes from Saturday’s win at United and three points against Villa are far more precious than progress in the Carabao Cup. I’d expect to see a far different performance.

I don’t know of any manager that would do better with the hand that Roy has been given. Our Premier League points tally since the turn of the year is impressive.

You make good points, only there are tweaks and things possible during matches that are never done. Swapping Zaha and Townsend, earlier subs, not just like for like and sometimes more defensive.

You’re right that Roy has had to work with little money, but it’ll be frustrating again if it’s just accepted we don’t pick up a point or 3 in any of f our league games because plan A didn’t work that week and the next and next home game. That’s very different to when Roy came in and had it even worse if you count no striker (Benteke) at all being worse and Zaha and Townsend aiming to arrive in the box.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 28 Aug 19 8.37am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

There were ten changes from Saturday’s win at United and three points against Villa are far more precious than progress in the Carabao Cup. I’d expect to see a far different performance.

I don’t know of any manager that would do better with the hand that Roy has been given. Our Premier League points tally since the turn of the year is impressive.

P10 W3 D3 L4 (12 points out of 30), at home, "since the turn of the year", is poor by anyone's standard, any anyone who thinks it isn't is deluding themselves.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Aug 19 8.37am

Villa look very good on the break, so they will probably be happy to let us come onto them. If that happens I think we'll lose. Hopefully we go with 4-5-1/4-3-3 approach again. If we shut down the midfield we should get at least a draw. The depressing thing is the only way I see us winning is by playing a slightly negative game.

I wouldn't read too much into last night as we were sh*t in almost every Carabao Cup game last season, we just dragged our depressing performances out over a few games. The players tend to look incredibly unmotivated and unprepared in the CC which probably points to how much the management care about it. For Roy it was probably more like giving a pre-season to some of the new boys and a signal to the board that they should have signed some fullbacks.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Aug 19 8.52am

Originally posted by bexleydave

P10 W3 D3 L4 (12 points out of 30), at home, "since the turn of the year", is poor by anyone's standard, any anyone who thinks it isn't is deluding themselves.

Not great but more than a point a game and combined with decent away form enough to keep us in the league.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Aug 19 9.31am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

There were ten changes from Saturday’s win at United and three points against Villa are far more precious than progress in the Carabao Cup. I’d expect to see a far different performance.

I don’t know of any manager that would do better with the hand that Roy has been given. Our Premier League points tally since the turn of the year is impressive.

Palace struggling to score a single goal and playing without any real heart? You can expect that performance for most of the season.

Not sure what your optimism is based on?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Aug 19 9.44am

We can only hope that they're feeling confident and positive and will come to attack us. If they sit back, they'll be given the obligatory Selhurst Park away clean sheet.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Aug 19 10.08am

Listening to the post-match news conference Roy said Ward and Schlupp were carrying injuries. In the case of the former I hope it doesn't keep him out of Saturday given how well Kelly played alongside Cahill and our lack of other options. The highlights suggest Camarasa has the ability to create us chances (albeit this was against L2 opposition)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Aug 19 10.23am

We have to maintain the 4-5-1 (or 4-3-3) on Saturday.

Two up top has worked in the past but this season we appear to have even less ability to make 3 passes in midfield. With 5 in midfield even with bad passing at least you see players able to still get involved in the game - as opposed to just having 2 up top with the game just passing them by. I'd go with just one change from last week (as they all more than earned their place) in order to be slightly more creative given we'll likely have a bit more possession. Could exchange Kouyate and MacArthur tbh.

Guaita
Ward Kelly Cahill PVA
Wilf Luka Camarasa MacArthur Schlupp
Ayew

Meyer/ to replace Camarasa after 65
Townsend on for Schlupp 75
Benteke on for Ayew 80

 

Master Coin Flag 28 Aug 19 10.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You make good points, only there are tweaks and things possible during matches that are never done. Swapping Zaha and Townsend, earlier subs, not just like for like and sometimes more defensive.

You’re right that Roy has had to work with little money, but it’ll be frustrating again if it’s just accepted we don’t pick up a point or 3 in any of f our league games because plan A didn’t work that week and the next and next home game. That’s very different to when Roy came in and had it even worse if you count no striker (Benteke) at all being worse and Zaha and Townsend aiming to arrive in the box.

There are many things to knock Roy for (with subs and playing players out of position the most culpable) but this isn’t it. Townsend is definitely a worse player on the left wing rather than right and at this point Wilf is an inferior winger on the right wing too. Swapping wings serves nothing.

If the point of swapping wings is to pander to Benteke then that’s madness. Taking two players from good* to average to bring Benteke up from bad to average is a bad trade.

* Admittedly Andros hasn’t actually looked good this season so far but it’s early and he’ll come good based on prior evidence.

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 28 Aug 19 10.28am

It seemed that against Spurs that Villa were quite attacking and got the lead then they parked the bus and tried to see it out but Spurs with their attacking players were able to break them down so they may try that tactic with us knowing that we struggle in this area. Therefore it is vital that we get the first goal. I just hope Roy finally changes our game plan and lets us attack with freedom rather than this negative backwards and sideways tippy tappy stuff that never produces anything.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 19 11.10am

Originally posted by Master Coin

There are many things to knock Roy for (with subs and playing players out of position the most culpable) but this isn’t it. Townsend is definitely a worse player on the left wing rather than right and at this point Wilf is an inferior winger on the right wing too. Swapping wings serves nothing.

If the point of swapping wings is to pander to Benteke then that’s madness. Taking two players from good* to average to bring Benteke up from bad to average is a bad trade.

* Admittedly Andros hasn’t actually looked good this season so far but it’s early and he’ll come good based on prior evidence.

Yes you make a good point on Townsend, but Zaha isn’t that much inferior on the right than the left. So I’d have them swap at some points in the game because it asks different questions of full backs when we hav the usual stalemate. Obviously that’ll never happen (breaking a stalemate with anything intentional).

The aim is to score goals and if the supply works then the equation isn’t so relevant. It’s a big ‘if’ though.

Your logical post makes the Benteke extension even more ridiculous, which you probably agree with, unless we sign 2 direct crossing wingers and then a year or 2 later we need to feed a modern, smaller, faster footballer who can actually play football. I wouldn’t be surprised.

 


COYP

Deleted11 28 Aug 19 12.34pm

Can't really understand the negativity towards Hodgson. This is a team that at best can finish 12th. Roy, without spending any money, is doing a blinding job. I think we'll be fine. 4 points from 3 games ain't bad.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Aug 19 12.39pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Palace struggling to score a single goal and playing without any real heart? You can expect that performance for most of the season.

Not sure what your optimism is based on?

I saw plenty of heart against Everton and United.
What I really learnt last night is quite how poor some of our players are particularly Wickham, Benteke, Riedewald and Meyer.

 

Fatherken Flag 28 Aug 19 12.44pm

it will be a different team on Saturday . I think there will be 6 changes .

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 28 Aug 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Jway89

Can't really understand the negativity towards Hodgson. This is a team that at best can finish 12th. Roy, without spending any money, is doing a blinding job. I think we'll be fine. 4 points from 3 games ain't bad.

I think people are becoming frustrated with his stubbornness and a lack of a tactical plan to rectify our dreadful home form. If he can do that then everything is fine.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > God help Aston Villa