You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Overseas Aid budget question
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Overseas Aid budget question


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 26 Nov 20 1.11am

This is an emotive subject and rightly so. The Ethiopian Spice Girls scandal or what ever etc etc.

Does anybody here know and where the actual use of the aid money is shown/listed.

I would like to have a look, my instinct ( and happy to be proved wrong ) is that a lot goes to what would be considered vanity projects for those responsible for giving it away, a significant amount on " admin costs " and corruption.

If the use of the funds is not in the public domain in some detail that is a scandal in itself.

Simply to say the money is used to help the less fortunate overseas is not good enough.

Anyway, I have tried to search and not found anything that casts any light.

Edited by HKOwen (26 Nov 2020 1.12am)

Edited by HKOwen (26 Nov 2020 1.14am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Teddy Eagle Flag 26 Nov 20 1.26am

Originally posted by HKOwen

This is an emotive subject and rightly so. The Ethiopian Spice Girls scandal or what ever etc etc.

Does anybody here know and where the actual use of the aid money is shown/listed.

I would like to have a look, my instinct ( and happy to be proved wrong ) is that a lot goes to what would be considered vanity projects for those responsible for giving it away, a significant amount on " admin costs " and corruption.

If the use of the funds is not in the public domain in some detail that is a scandal in itself.

Simply to say the money is used to help the less fortunate overseas is not good enough.

Anyway, I have tried to search and not found anything that casts any light.

Edited by HKOwen (26 Nov 2020 1.12am)

Edited by HKOwen (26 Nov 2020 1.14am)


Quite a bit of information here

[Link]

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 26 Nov 20 4.09am

Thanks, had a speed read and can't see anything that specifically refers to individual projects and what they do.

Do not see anything that would lead me to continue with this " cashpoint in the sky " in it's current forms.

I would have no objection to giving aid in the form of for example Covid vaccines but cannot support pouring cash into these projects with tangible means of monitoring results and value for money.

The high level scandals of money wasted do nothing to give any integrity to the expenditure.

Edited by HKOwen (26 Nov 2020 4.15am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

dannyboy1978 Flag 26 Nov 20 6.17am

In a nut shell it's influencing money.
"We will pay you this but expect this now or later"

 

Matov Flag 26 Nov 20 6.37am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

In a nut shell it's influencing money.
"We will pay you this but expect this now or later"


Yes. It is how we pay a lot of bribes. A smoke screen in effect.

Bongo-Bongo land are in the market for say 50 tanks they do not need. Us Brits step in to sell them but the Minister who signs it off wants a nice little sweetner. Of course we would never stoop so low as to just bung him an envelope but if he has a family friend with a worthy cause to support and no questions asked about how the funds are spent?

Of course it is a little more nuanced than that but essentially that is the nuts and bolts of it all.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Nov 20 6.46am

Originally posted by Matov


Yes. It is how we pay a lot of bribes. A smoke screen in effect.

Bongo-Bongo land are in the market for say 50 tanks they do not need. Us Brits step in to sell them but the Minister who signs it off wants a nice little sweetner. Of course we would never stoop so low as to just bung him an envelope but if he has a family friend with a worthy cause to support and no questions asked about how the funds are spent?

Of course it is a little more nuanced than that but essentially that is the nuts and bolts of it all.

My brother used to work for Overseas Development Department, you would be surprised where the money is spent in certain places, not all.
Much of it is used as influence money but you would be unable to trace it as such obviously
Visa Officers are occasionally “asked” to issue a visa to a relative of someone who may be of assistance, even if that relative dies not qualify. Happened to me. Some of our own MPs alsohave a similar habit.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Nov 20 8.17am

Originally posted by Matov


Yes. It is how we pay a lot of bribes. A smoke screen in effect.

Bongo-Bongo land are in the market for say 50 tanks they do not need. Us Brits step in to sell them but the Minister who signs it off wants a nice little sweetner. Of course we would never stoop so low as to just bung him an envelope but if he has a family friend with a worthy cause to support and no questions asked about how the funds are spent?

Of course it is a little more nuanced than that but essentially that is the nuts and bolts of it all.

Nicely put.

Emergency aid for disasters, no issue. If you really care about the poor in these countries the best way to help them is to sign free trade deals that will help these people trade their way out of poverty.

Many of these countries have agricultural produce they would love to sell us but EU rules have so far stopped. I am disappointed that the FO has not been quicker to sign these deals especially in Africa.

We have a real opportunity here to help people without a cash hand out which goes in some politicians back pocket.

Get on with it Boris.

 


One more point

Matov Flag 26 Nov 20 8.41am

Originally posted by Badger11

Many of these countries have agricultural produce they would love to sell us but EU rules have so far stopped.

Its even worse than that. Not the most interesting of subjects but how the EU, and Germany in particular, stitch up poor countries around coffee is quite incredible.

Wont bore you with the details but you need to ask yourself how a country like Germany, with weather similar to ours, is one of the largest EXPORTERS of coffee in the world. Understand that and you wonder about why all the smug, self-righteous virtue signalling types can be so keen on the European Union.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Nov 20 8.54am

Originally posted by Matov

Its even worse than that. Not the most interesting of subjects but how the EU, and Germany in particular, stitch up poor countries around coffee is quite incredible.

Wont bore you with the details but you need to ask yourself how a country like Germany, with weather similar to ours, is one of the largest EXPORTERS of coffee in the world. Understand that and you wonder about why all the smug, self-righteous virtue signalling types can be so keen on the European Union.

Agreed. The EU is the largest Protectionist block in the world. The people who love the EU also love foreign aid but don't connect the dots, if the EU was more open you wouldn't need the aid.

If throwing money at the third world worked I would happily support it but Africa has had billions thrown at it over 60 years and they are still no better off, time to try something new.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Nov 20 9.19am

Previous PMs Tory and Labour, are weighing in against this, and they ought to know what they are taking about.

The UK shooting itself in the foot for no benefit is a sign of the times.

 

DanH Flag SW2 26 Nov 20 9.19am

Originally posted by Matov

Its even worse than that. Not the most interesting of subjects but how the EU, and Germany in particular, stitch up poor countries around coffee is quite incredible.

Wont bore you with the details but you need to ask yourself how a country like Germany, with weather similar to ours, is one of the largest EXPORTERS of coffee in the world. Understand that and you wonder about why all the smug, self-righteous virtue signalling types can be so keen on the European Union.

Interesting, but how do you explain Switzerland being third, above Germany?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Nov 20 9.33am

When UK Foreign Aid goes to China and India and to prop-up some corrupt regimes around the world is it any wonder that nearly 70% of Britons want the budget cut.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 26 Nov 20 9.39am

Originally posted by DanH

Interesting, but how do you explain Switzerland being third, above Germany?

Doesn’t explain Switzerland but Italy, France and Belgium are also in the top 10 exporters.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Nov 20 9.48am

Originally posted by Willo

When UK Foreign Aid goes to China and India and to prop-up some corrupt regimes around the world is it any wonder that nearly 70% of Britons want the budget cut.

I think this is the biggest issue. Haven’t India actually said they don’t want it? Both countries mentioned have their own space programmes but abject amount of poverty. Priorities not high on their agendas

 

davenotamonkey Flag 26 Nov 20 9.49am

Originally posted by DanH

Interesting, but how do you explain Switzerland being third, above Germany?

Nestle is Swiss. Nestle produces Nespresso. Import of low volumes of coffee, very high markup.

I don't know what data you're referring to, but I imagine it refers to $$ export, not volume. Germany *imports* around 4x that of Switzerland in raw coffee by volume, but in $$ export value, Switzerland recieves about 75% more than Germany.

The Swiss take a little of a material, produce a highly desirable product with a high market cost and successfully exports it. That's pretty much the MO of Switzerland generally. It also doesn't rely on dirt-poor countries devaluing it's currency to aid with exports.

Nice that the Swiss also keep their factories in-house rather than exploiting the... ahem... "level playing field" of dirt-cheap EU labour in Eastern Europe.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 26 Nov 20 9.58am

For context:

All the so-called "Conservatives" losing their s*** about dropping our foreign aid budget by £4b.

We just quetly handed the EU 25% of that amount for the crime of beating our economic growth records last year. Were it not for the utter spinelessness of our government, Boris should have presented them a choice:

Hand over that money to the EU and cut the budget. By that amount twice to recover the cost.

Keep the budget, tell the EU to f*** off and use it for rebuilding OUR country, instead of the EU's wannabe superstate.

Point being: we hand money over to the likes of India, to the tune of £1b, in the hope they will favour us when it comes to big procurements. Bribery essentially. The Indians then snub us for France, as per (among other examples) Dassault Rafale vs. BAE Systems.

Waste of money - we have plenty of corrupt causes in the UK we can funnel this cash into (anyone remember "Kids Company"?). Who knows, some, just *some* of it might even trickle through to benefit the UK taxpayer.


 

DanH Flag SW2 26 Nov 20 10.02am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Nestle is Swiss. Nestle produces Nespresso. Import of low volumes of coffee, very high markup.

I don't know what data you're referring to, but I imagine it refers to $$ export, not volume. Germany *imports* around 4x that of Switzerland in raw coffee by volume, but in $$ export value, Switzerland recieves about 75% more than Germany.

The Swiss take a little of a material, produce a highly desirable product with a high market cost and successfully exports it. That's pretty much the MO of Switzerland generally. It also doesn't rely on dirt-poor countries devaluing it's currency to aid with exports.

Nice that the Swiss also keep their factories in-house rather than exploiting the... ahem... "level playing field" of dirt-cheap EU labour in Eastern Europe.

Ah, Nestlé makes sense.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Nov 20 10.13am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

For context:

All the so-called "Conservatives" losing their s*** about dropping our foreign aid budget by £4b.

We just quetly handed the EU 25% of that amount for the crime of beating our economic growth records last year. Were it not for the utter spinelessness of our government, Boris should have presented them a choice:

Hand over that money to the EU and cut the budget. By that amount twice to recover the cost.

Keep the budget, tell the EU to f*** off and use it for rebuilding OUR country, instead of the EU's wannabe superstate.

Point being: we hand money over to the likes of India, to the tune of £1b, in the hope they will favour us when it comes to big procurements. Bribery essentially. The Indians then snub us for France, as per (among other examples) Dassault Rafale vs. BAE Systems.

Waste of money - we have plenty of corrupt causes in the UK we can funnel this cash into (anyone remember "Kids Company"?). Who knows, some, just *some* of it might even trickle through to benefit the UK taxpayer.


They are legion and cause celebres that are corrupt as hell but mostly untouched due to ideology.

I recall Erin Pizzey talking about how lies were used to overly increase funding and are used to maintain funding into women's groups....which she thinks is now an income industry instead of a legitimate reaction to domestic abuse.

The same is true for the diversity industry and so on.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Nov 2020 10.15am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Nov 20 10.28am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Previous PMs Tory and Labour, are weighing in against this, and they ought to know what they are taking about.

The UK shooting itself in the foot for no benefit is a sign of the times.

Is the right answer. Not that will stop the criticism of course. I heard one of the past ministers suggest last night that this could cost the lives of 100,000 children due to poverty. Emotional overstatement perhaps but this has consequences.

When the actual saving is so cosmetically small the damage done to our reputation just when we need to be building it is mind-blowingly inept.

This is simply pandering to the new Tory voters in the north. The description I also heard yesterday of it being "Trump-lite" in approach seems justified. Daft to go the Trump route just when the Biden one is available.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Nov 20 10.39am

Sir Humphrey said that the government gives aid money so the taxpayers can feel good about themselves. A cynical statement but probably has a grain of truth.

The foreign aid budget is beloved of the virtue signallers who are no doubt out in force today (cue Gary unless the BBC has muzzled him).

As I said previously it doesn't work, if it did I would be happy to support it.

 


One more point

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Overseas Aid budget question