This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Labour could turn this around quite quickly with good policies, but the leader had none, and must go. The tories have not done all that well, they only have a by-election win in an untypical constituency with a dismal turnout, and despite the numbers, only won control of 11 councils. Big win for labour in Wales. SNP in Scotland and majority independence support. Khan about to be re-elected in London, Manchester and Liverpool labour. Starmer has been a disaster, strange he seemed such an experienced able politician, but he just doesn't get any of it, impervious to any reason or constructive criticism. Resign Sir Keir, and let the movement have a new leader and direction. 'Movement'
|
|
|
Keir Starmer - “I take full responsibility, but it’s her fault really ...” #KeirStarmer #LabourParty #LabourPartyCivilWar #AngelaRayner
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
'Movement' Nail on head
|
|
|
Would be interested to know what you would consider to be good policies. I would support nationalisation of rail and water for example, if we could guarantee not to return to the union driven chaos of the 70's when the train service was a joke. Water I believe requires investment at a level that allows little room for profit and should operate at break even. I would actively promote local bus services in the levelling in areas, there are virtually no bus services from surrounding towns to Hull for example, so people who need to attend hospital need to take a taxi which is ridiculous. Originally posted by steeleye20
Labour could turn this around quite quickly with good policies, but the leader had none, and must go. The tories have not done all that well, they only have a by-election win in an untypical constituency with a dismal turnout, and despite the numbers, only won control of 11 councils. Big win for labour in Wales. SNP in Scotland and majority independence support. Khan about to be re-elected in London, Manchester and Liverpool labour. Starmer has been a disaster, strange he seemed such an experienced able politician, but he just doesn't get any of it, impervious to any reason or constructive criticism. Resign Sir Keir, and let the movement have a new leader and direction.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Would be interested to know what you would consider to be good policies. I would support nationalisation of rail and water for example, if we could guarantee not to return to the union driven chaos of the 70's when the train service was a joke. Water I believe requires investment at a level that allows little room for profit and should operate at break even. I would actively promote local bus services in the levelling in areas, there are virtually no bus services from surrounding towns to Hull for example, so people who need to attend hospital need to take a taxi which is ridiculous. Yes they would be good, and some re-nationalisation is already starting. For me climate and green polices are my overriding concern anything else seems just inadequate. Crime, especially knife crime imo requires legislation to ban knives altogether and a return to the successful 'tough on crime etc.' policy. That means funding police intelligence on youths and bringing back youth centres. My real bete noir has been water privatisation, I find it quite disgusting in view of all the billions that have been poured in to private companies, that they discharge raw sewage into rivers and the sea. Grrrrr
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Yes they would be good, and some re-nationalisation is already starting. For me climate and green polices are my overriding concern anything else seems just inadequate. But what policies? What policies are going to encourage people who voted Leave to now vote for Labour as opposed to the Tories? What policies are going to be different?
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Would be interested to know what you would consider to be good policies. I would actively promote local bus services in the levelling in areas, there are virtually no bus services from surrounding towns to Hull for example, so people who need to attend hospital need to take a taxi which is ridiculous. The RMT have been bad enough with private companies. The reason they want nationalisation is to get more power. I'd say that the government should bid for rail and bus franchise against the private sector. The best tender wins. Issues with buses start as soon as you go outside of the M25. There are systems that could be easily introduced to help. Text my bus has been around for decades. Each bus stop has a number, you send it to a free to text number and it response with live data on when the next bus arrives could easily make an app that does the same. That would really help to get more people using buses, once customer numbers go up, more services can be provided.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
The RMT have been bad enough with private companies. The reason they want nationalisation is to get more power. I'd say that the government should bid for rail and bus franchise against the private sector. The best tender wins. Issues with buses start as soon as you go outside of the M25. There are systems that could be easily introduced to help. Text my bus has been around for decades. Each bus stop has a number, you send it to a free to text number and it response with live data on when the next bus arrives could easily make an app that does the same. That would really help to get more people using buses, once customer numbers go up, more services can be provided. If the governments of the world were serious about the 'green future' then public transport in whichever guise needs to be free for everyone.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
If the governments of the world were serious about the 'green future' then public transport in whichever guise needs to be free for everyone. Cost effective to the pocket? No. Cost effective for the planet? Yes. Personally I think it's all bo lax but I'm still allowed that opinion. Do you mean, free at the point of use, for everyone? Which isn't free. It's likely to be incredibly inefficient and those who can afford decent accountants won't have to pay anything whilst the rest of us get lumbered with the bill.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Do you mean, free at the point of use, for everyone? Which isn't free. It's likely to be incredibly inefficient and those who can afford decent accountants won't have to pay anything whilst the rest of us get lumbered with the bill. I mean 'free'. Hop on hop off, any domestic service any place anytime. We are going to get hammered, and I mean hammered very soon. Including the poor; they won't be immune from the bulls*** coming our way. So exactly where is that money going to go.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Labour could turn this around quite quickly with good policies, but the leader had none, and must go. The tories have not done all that well, they only have a by-election win in an untypical constituency with a dismal turnout, and despite the numbers, only won control of 11 councils. Big win for labour in Wales. SNP in Scotland and majority independence support. Khan about to be re-elected in London, Manchester and Liverpool labour. Starmer has been a disaster, strange he seemed such an experienced able politician, but he just doesn't get any of it, impervious to any reason or constructive criticism. Resign Sir Keir, and let the movement have a new leader and direction.
|
|
|
We are not a million miles apart, as ever, the devil is in the detail. Originally posted by steeleye20
Yes they would be good, and some re-nationalisation is already starting. For me climate and green polices are my overriding concern anything else seems just inadequate. Crime, especially knife crime imo requires legislation to ban knives altogether and a return to the successful 'tough on crime etc.' policy. That means funding police intelligence on youths and bringing back youth centres. My real bete noir has been water privatisation, I find it quite disgusting in view of all the billions that have been poured in to private companies, that they discharge raw sewage into rivers and the sea. Grrrrr
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Nail on head. Conservatives have taken the middle ground Labour needed to regain so hard to see any solution for them. As long as Labour promote pro EU stuff they will never get these seats back, they need to unequivocally make no rejoining the EU a policy foundation. Swallow the ideological pride and try a making Brexit work strategy. Project Fear has proved to be generally a load of crap, the vaccination success which would not have happened were we still in is tangible. Waste of time trying to argue otherwise. Annelise Dodds career is history, imagine being so crap you were shuffled to replace Angela Rayner. Originally posted by Matov
But what policies? What policies are going to encourage people who voted Leave to now vote for Labour as opposed to the Tories? What policies are going to be different?
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
As for Starmer the confusion from the last few days highlights his problem. He tried to sack Angela Rayner but as she is elected by the faithful she dug her heels in and demanded another job and he caved. I'm afraid the party will continue to re-arrange the deck chairs no great turnaround anytime soon and it maybe that Starmer is the one who gets fired.
I suspect that from Starmers POV, just surviving the weekend is a positive. And makes me wonder if all this Rayner stuff was a clever ruse? On Saturday, all the talk was about if Starmer survives. Then we get the announcement/briefings that Rayner is being sacked. All hell breaks lose. 24 hours later and Rayner is not being sacked. Instead promoted to an office that supposedly shadows Gove. And spun as a promotion. Here we are on Monday. Starmer still in place. And the left seemingly pacified. Could have been a master class in changing the narrative.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I suspect that from Starmers POV, just surviving the weekend is a positive. And makes me wonder if all this Rayner stuff was a clever ruse? On Saturday, all the talk was about if Starmer survives. Then we get the announcement/briefings that Rayner is being sacked. All hell breaks lose. 24 hours later and Rayner is not being sacked. Instead promoted to an office that supposedly shadows Gove. And spun as a promotion. Here we are on Monday. Starmer still in place. And the left seemingly pacified. Could have been a master class in changing the narrative. Perhaps or it could be that it is what it appears to be confirmation of weak leadership, having to placate people he doesn't want. I guess time will tell who is right. Matov you seem to have a good read on politics so I am loath to go against you but for now I will take the events at face value.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Matov you seem to have a good read on politics so I am loath to go against you but for now I will take the events at face value. LOL. Trust me, I love it when people disagree and there is a bloody good chance that face value is all there is to it. But humour me on this. I am nerd for this kind of s*** and will happily see all kinds of things in the tea-leaves when there is nothing at all.
Now Starmer faces two potential risks to his leadership if he has no intention of standing down. The first is a motion of no confidence from his own MP's, which requires (I think) 40 signatures. This then starts of a new leadership contest. Now there are 38 Labour MP's from the Corbynite Left who would happily sign this no matter what and two more could easily be rustled up but they need at least one heavy hitter to join the. The second is if the TU's rock up to his door and threaten to pull the financial funding that is under pinning the Labour Party which is in dire financial straits at the moment. With Angela Rayner closely linked to both groups. In terms of the MP's who would sign this motion of no confidence, she is considered to be their representative in the shadow cabinet and I believe she shared (might still) a flat in London with Rebbeca Long-Bailey who is/was Corbyn's chosen heir apparent. And Rayner is also closely linked to the TU's. Once again, she is seen as their closest friend inside the shadow cabinet. Also, Rayner is Deputy Leader. If Starmer goes/gets pushed, she is the one who automatically steps up. Now my understanding is that she was putting herself forward to do the round of Sunday morning political talk shows, apparently more than happy to be fed lines from Starmer's people. And I suspect they smelt a rat. Fearing she was intending to rock up on the Andrew Marr show and deliver the stab in the back. Part of a coordinated attack from both the Corybinite wing of the PLP and with the full backing of the Unions. So Starmer, advised I am 100% sure by the likes of Mandleson and Campbell, decided to go on the attack. Starts briefing about her sacking and all of a sudden the story changes hence we get the hysteria. Meaning that she does not get the chance to go on the television and signal the rebellion the following morning. For those crucial 24 hours she was not in the Shadow Cabinet and even if she still goes ahead with this possible attack on Starmer, it can be put down to just her spite coming to the fore. 24 hours later she is back in the Shadow Cabinet, the rebellion has been headed off for now and Starmer gets to start the week still in charge with no formal challenge to his leadership underway. Now, if this scenario is in anyway true, Starmer is still deep in the s*** but he gets to start the week still in situ. He has bought himself time. However, he could just be a f***ing moron. All possible!
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
LOL. Trust me, I love it when people disagree and there is a bloody good chance that face value is all there is to it. But humour me on this. I am nerd for this kind of s*** and will happily see all kinds of things in the tea-leaves when there is nothing at all.
Now Starmer faces two potential risks to his leadership if he has no intention of standing down. The first is a motion of no confidence from his own MP's, which requires (I think) 40 signatures. This then starts of a new leadership contest. Now there are 38 Labour MP's from the Corbynite Left who would happily sign this no matter what and two more could easily be rustled up but they need at least one heavy hitter to join the. The second is if the TU's rock up to his door and threaten to pull the financial funding that is under pinning the Labour Party which is in dire financial straits at the moment. With Angela Rayner closely linked to both groups. In terms of the MP's who would sign this motion of no confidence, she is considered to be their representative in the shadow cabinet and I believe she shared (might still) a flat in London with Rebbeca Long-Bailey who is/was Corbyn's chosen heir apparent. And Rayner is also closely linked to the TU's. Once again, she is seen as their closest friend inside the shadow cabinet. Also, Rayner is Deputy Leader. If Starmer goes/gets pushed, she is the one who automatically steps up. Now my understanding is that she was putting herself forward to do the round of Sunday morning political talk shows, apparently more than happy to be fed lines from Starmer's people. And I suspect they smelt a rat. Fearing she was intending to rock up on the Andrew Marr show and deliver the stab in the back. Part of a coordinated attack from both the Corybinite wing of the PLP and with the full backing of the Unions. So Starmer, advised I am 100% sure by the likes of Mandleson and Campbell, decided to go on the attack. Starts briefing about her sacking and all of a sudden the story changes hence we get the hysteria. Meaning that she does not get the chance to go on the television and signal the rebellion the following morning. For those crucial 24 hours she was not in the Shadow Cabinet and even if she still goes ahead with this possible attack on Starmer, it can be put down to just her spite coming to the fore. 24 hours later she is back in the Shadow Cabinet, the rebellion has been headed off for now and Starmer gets to start the week still in charge with no formal challenge to his leadership underway. Now, if this scenario is in anyway true, Starmer is still deep in the s*** but he gets to start the week still in situ. He has bought himself time. However, he could just be a f***ing moron. All possible! All that for the last line
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The Deputy Leader does not step up if the leader goes, there will have to be another leadership election. No but they get to take temporary charge (or so I believe) whilst the process takes place. And that is crucial because my understanding is that the big change Starmer is rumoured to want to bring about is fundamentally changing the entire leadership selection process. Primarily because this was what caused Corbyn to come to power in the first place. All the text message malarkey that swelled Labours ranks and then Corbyn, who was only ever meant to be the token Left challenger, goes on and wins. Not one but also twice by bloody big margins. Which is why I feel they feared, and still do, Rayner so much. I cannot imagine any other potential candidate at the moment who probably appeals as much to the membership and the PLP as well. She is the danger for Starmer. Nobody else.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.