This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Hennessey Should cut the wage bill a bit. I agree. Would like to keep Cahill, to assist in helping any young/ new CB we may wish give a try
|
|
|
Originally posted by Knightstar
I do find it quite amusing the way some of the commentators on TV say we face a major problem with so many players being out of contract. I don't think it needs to be a problem at all, as there are only a handful of these guys we should be keeping. We should definitely lose Hennessey, Wickham, Sakho, Dann, PVA, Clyne, Batshuyai and probably Kelly and McCarthy, only reconsidering one or two if any of the top 5 turn us down. This would mean that we still retain the core of the first team squad and can supplement it with some new young signings and a few promotions from the Academy/Development team. Thank goodness that you aren't the manager then You are happy to trim our squad of 25 down to 16 so would you mind telling us which of Development Squad or under 18s you feel would warrant a place in a Premier League squad and which young players from outside you feel are good enough and cheap enough to buy to fill up the rest of the squad places?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Thank goodness that you aren't the manager then You are happy to trim our squad of 25 down to 16 so would you mind telling us which of Development Squad or under 18s you feel would warrant a place in a Premier League squad and which young players from outside you feel are good enough and cheap enough to buy to fill up the rest of the squad places? Before you dismiss that out of hand, a 17yo & an 18yo both made their debuts & scored for their respective clubs in the EPL, our very own Mitchell also scored his 1st EPL goal for us, & he was playing for the U23's last season. We have an exciting crop of youngsters in the U23's & the U18's, dont get me wrong, as a few others who watch their games have noted, they dont think they are ready for 1st team duties(yet), BUT, if you dont give them a go, how will anybody know?
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Thank goodness that you aren't the manager then You are happy to trim our squad of 25 down to 16 so would you mind telling us which of Development Squad or under 18s you feel would warrant a place in a Premier League squad and which young players from outside you feel are good enough and cheap enough to buy to fill up the rest of the squad places? Quite. I would LIKE to live in a much bigger house, send my kids off to an expensive boarding school, have 3 luxury foreign holidays a year... you get the picture? The upgrades you mention require 1 availability 2 willingness to come to us 3 compatibility and 4 very deep pockets if you are talking prem-ready players. The latter is a must in a team like ours as we do not have the depth of squad to allow expensive marquee signings to find their feet Perhaps there are a few youngsters ready to come through and the closed season will give an idea which. But not to fill that may gaps at one go.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
According to Transfermkt we have 16, yes SIXTEEN players whose contracts end on 30th June 21. Fortunately they're wrong. Surprisingly, really obviously wrong. This shows that none of McArthur, Schlupp, Kelly or Henderson are out of contract as they signed extensions this season. By necessity, they were contracted for this season, so the extension at a minimum covers next season. The following appear to be out of contract, with 3 not having played at all: Benteke, Wickham, Batshuayi (End of Loan), Townsend, McCarthy, Van Aanholt, Clyne, Ward, Cahill, Sakho, Dann, Hennessey
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
I forgot Schlupp, so make that 20!
|
|
|
I would now keep Benteke plus Cahill, Clyne and Townsend.
|
|
|
If Schlupp is out then sign him immediately!
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Fortunately they're wrong. Surprisingly, really obviously wrong. This shows that none of McArthur, Schlupp, Kelly or Henderson are out of contract as they signed extensions this season. By necessity, they were contracted for this season, so the extension at a minimum covers next season. The following appear to be out of contract, with 3 not having played at all: Benteke, Wickham, Batshuayi (End of Loan), Townsend, McCarthy, Van Aanholt, Clyne, Ward, Cahill, Sakho, Dann, Hennessey
I think Henderson is out of contract as his was a 1 year extension. We need 3 goalkeepers in first team squad and They will be Guita and Butland plus possibly one of u23 goalkeepers Right back Both Ward and Clyne may be kept as Ferguson has not returned from injury. Left Back Mitchell and Let PVA go Central Defender Are any of U23 ready? Sakho we can not afford so he will go. Dann may go to but he could be kept as a fairly cheap backup. Cahill will wait until he sees who manager is Midfield is where age is showing McCarthy may stay if we decide to sell Luka which I think is possible. The U23 have a few promising midfielders but are they ready to be regulars. Attacking Midfielders - Townsend is still EPL quality on his day and we need some backup. Strikers - The fact is that none of our strikers have impressed but is this because our service is so poor. Wickham and Bats to go. Benteke to stay and get another striker who challenges for his place to push him
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
I think Henderson is out of contract as his was a 1 year extension. We need 3 goalkeepers in first team squad and They will be Guita and Butland plus possibly one of u23 goalkeepers Right back Both Ward and Clyne may be kept as Ferguson has not returned from injury. Left Back Mitchell and Let PVA go Central Defender Are any of U23 ready? Sakho we can not afford so he will go. Dann may go to but he could be kept as a fairly cheap backup. Cahill will wait until he sees who manager is Midfield is where age is showing McCarthy may stay if we decide to sell Luka which I think is possible. The U23 have a few promising midfielders but are they ready to be regulars. Attacking Midfielders - Townsend is still EPL quality on his day and we need some backup. Strikers - The fact is that none of our strikers have impressed but is this because our service is so poor. Wickham and Bats to go. Benteke to stay and get another striker who challenges for his place to push him There's Mateta remember.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
I think Henderson is out of contract as his was a 1 year extension. We need 3 goalkeepers in first team squad and They will be Guita and Butland plus possibly one of u23 goalkeepers Right back Both Ward and Clyne may be kept as Ferguson has not returned from injury. Left Back Mitchell and Let PVA go Central Defender Are any of U23 ready? Sakho we can not afford so he will go. Dann may go to but he could be kept as a fairly cheap backup. Cahill will wait until he sees who manager is Midfield is where age is showing McCarthy may stay if we decide to sell Luka which I think is possible. The U23 have a few promising midfielders but are they ready to be regulars. Attacking Midfielders - Townsend is still EPL quality on his day and we need some backup. Strikers - The fact is that none of our strikers have impressed but is this because our service is so poor. Wickham and Bats to go. Benteke to stay and get another striker who challenges for his place to push him
We NEED at least 1, preferably 2 younger CBs otherwise we won't be able to press higher up the pitch next season. Midfield needs strengthening. As for strikers, if we keep Mateta on loan and get Benteke to stay on lower wages, then with Ayew in the wings we can survive without having to fork out for another striker.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
We NEED at least 1, preferably 2 younger CBs otherwise we won't be able to press higher up the pitch next season. Midfield needs strengthening. As for strikers, if we keep Mateta on loan and get Benteke to stay on lower wages, then with Ayew in the wings we can survive without having to fork out for another striker. You've made good points about the use of loans. I'd rather we buy the CBs and properly sort that area out - everything seems to indicate that defence is where the clear out will happen. We're in a position to set a partnership for the next few years with Tomkins/Cahill on hand to help it bed in and I'd rather we just do that well. The Gallacher chat isn't going away and he sounds a good purchase in a position of need at a good price. We can use Zaha up top if needed, which is where I'd rather we use loans on the attacking players - the RLCs, Minamino, Nelson, Nketiah types of the world where buying an impact player is big £££ (and where their impact will be zero if we can't sort out the defence and play higher).
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by Knightstar
I forgot Schlupp, so make that 20! He is not out of contract!
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Before you dismiss that out of hand, a 17yo & an 18yo both made their debuts & scored for their respective clubs in the EPL, our very own Mitchell also scored his 1st EPL goal for us, & he was playing for the U23's last season. We have an exciting crop of youngsters in the U23's & the U18's, dont get me wrong, as a few others who watch their games have noted, they dont think they are ready for 1st team duties(yet), BUT, if you dont give them a go, how will anybody know? I hear what you say but whilst it might be a simple matter to give one or perhaps even two youngsters a try out we can't rely on a whole squad of them to keep us in the top division. You of all people might have a reasonable idea of which youngsters might make it in the first team next season and I'm happy to listen to your opinion
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I hear what you say but whilst it might be a simple matter to give one or perhaps even two youngsters a try out we can't rely on a whole squad of them to keep us in the top division. You of all people might have a reasonable idea of which youngsters might make it in the first team next season and I'm happy to listen to your opinion I do think we could simply replace the outgoing Wickham with say Omilabu in the squad. Plus he seems a different style of player to Bentenke, Ayew and Mateta. Rak-Sakyi currently has the most noise around him, so it'll be interesting to see how he gets on in pre-season if he plays. Both AWB and Mitchell got their opportunities after performing well in pre-season. The standard at U18 and U23 level is so far off the PL that I imagine it is really hard to know how players will get on until they play. If you listen to coaches and former players, a lot seems to be about temperament and personality as to whether players succeed, however talented they may be. The future certainly seems exciting anyway with the current crop of youngsters. I'd love to see us take on the German model and blood youngsters early and in doing so be able to attract the best young talent in the country. Whether that is actually feasible or not is a whole other matter!
|
|
|
Originally posted by StrangerThing
According to the Athletic PVA is on his way, Sakho, McCarthy, Hennessey and Wickham are on their way too. Bats is heading back. Cahill will get a new one year deal, Ward and Dann are discussing reduced terms. That is pretty much how I would have liked it. BTW the bile spewed at Ward and Dann is unfair. Neither expected to play much this season but have stepped up to the best of their ability. To spend a great deal to replace perfectly good second XI players is simply daft. And before you attack their ability, I would also like to see back-up players warming our bench who are of top half quality. But then we don't all have the financial backing of Man City do we? Even Liverpool struggled with their support players when their first choices got crock.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I do think we could simply replace the outgoing Wickham with say Omilabu in the squad. Plus he seems a different style of player to Bentenke, Ayew and Mateta. Rak-Sakyi currently has the most noise around him, so it'll be interesting to see how he gets on in pre-season if he plays. Both AWB and Mitchell got their opportunities after performing well in pre-season. The standard at U18 and U23 level is so far off the PL that I imagine it is really hard to know how players will get on until they play. If you listen to coaches and former players, a lot seems to be about temperament and personality as to whether players succeed, however talented they may be. The future certainly seems exciting anyway with the current crop of youngsters. I'd love to see us take on the German model and blood youngsters early and in doing so be able to attract the best young talent in the country. Whether that is actually feasible or not is a whole other matter! I agree with much of the post, but I seem to recall that AWB was given the nod (v manure ironically) as he was the last RB standing.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.