You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Yo yo club.
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Yo yo club.


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 11.23am

I’d be over the moon if we had a couple of seasons in the top league (full houses, get to do the big away grounds) then get relegated (get to see loads more goals/wins, do a few of the championship away grounds). I know promotion isn’t guaranteed/easy , but if we could spend a few years in each league it would be ideal for me. Get the parachute payments, play millwall/charlton as well as maybe winning a league, play off finals.
More youngsters would get a chance , all the high earners would have clauses saying that would get reduced wages when relegated.
8 odd years in the top league and we haven’t improved Selhurst at all, I know the training ground is getting sorted.
The atmosphere would always be great, either fighting for promotion, or a first year in the premier league.
I’ve thought before that city/ Chelsea 50 odd year olds have had a right result, spent their 20s/ early 30s going to the ‘proper grounds’ coming away disappointed, understanding what it’s like to not be that good. Then reach their mid 30s/40s (when they are chilling out a bit and probably getting a few more quid) and they are winning leagues and going to the San Siro/ Nou camp.etc.
I know if we get relegated we might not come back up again for ages or ever. Watford, Norwich, West Brom seem to have it sussed.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 May 21 11.55am

We always were more or less a yo yo club. This last eight years has bucked the trend. I think we had the record for relegations and promotions until West Brom have now overtaken us? Or somewhere thereabouts.
It is a shame that the ground hasn't improved because it's getting shabbier by the season, although not quite falling apart - as it was before. At least we have an academy and better training facilities.
One day we'll be forced to do something to the ground, unless the National Trust stop us.

 


Red and Blue Army!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 15 May 21 12.31pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

We always were more or less a yo yo club. This last eight years has bucked the trend. I think we had the record for relegations and promotions until West Brom have now overtaken us? Or somewhere thereabouts.
It is a shame that the ground hasn't improved because it's getting shabbier by the season, although not quite falling apart - as it was before. At least we have an academy and better training facilities.
One day we'll be forced to do something to the ground, unless the National Trust stop us.


 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 May 21 3.48pm

the Prem is better football

but

the Championship is better entertainment.


Shaun Derry, Clint Hill, Michael Hughes, Clinton Morrison, Brede Hangeland, Yannick Bolasie .......

these are proper Eagles that i feel more connection to than many of our mercenary crop in the Prem.

the OP is correct. Many promotions & relegations is great entertainment. Even if it is sometimes heartbreaking.

Is there any better image than Kevin Phillips scoring that penalty at Wembley ? 120 million quid on a single shot....on target.

Imagine being like Everton....never in Europe, never in a terrifying relegation fight, never the ecstasy of a promotion....boring.

And increasingly Arsenal are headed to that graveyard of entertainment.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (16 May 2021 10.32am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

stujii Flag 15 May 21 4.07pm

Originally posted by Casual

I’d be over the moon if we had a couple of seasons in the top league (full houses, get to do the big away grounds) then get relegated (get to see loads more goals/wins, do a few of the championship away grounds). I know promotion isn’t guaranteed/easy , but if we could spend a few years in each league it would be ideal for me. Get the parachute payments, play millwall/charlton as well as maybe winning a league, play off finals.
More youngsters would get a chance , all the high earners would have clauses saying that would get reduced wages when relegated.
8 odd years in the top league and we haven’t improved Selhurst at all, I know the training ground is getting sorted.
The atmosphere would always be great, either fighting for promotion, or a first year in the premier league.
I’ve thought before that city/ Chelsea 50 odd year olds have had a right result, spent their 20s/ early 30s going to the ‘proper grounds’ coming away disappointed, understanding what it’s like to not be that good. Then reach their mid 30s/40s (when they are chilling out a bit and probably getting a few more quid) and they are winning leagues and going to the San Siro/ Nou camp.etc.
I know if we get relegated we might not come back up again for ages or ever. Watford, Norwich, West Brom seem to have it sussed.


Yes all fine and dandy but you’re forgetting a few things....We almost went out of existence twice. We were lucky not to get relegated to League 1 , We were loosing on average £4m a season, We also had to endure some really really toilet football in the Championship too...The grass isn’t always greener and in fact it can be downright dangerous

 

Dippo Flag Coulsdon 15 May 21 4.33pm

It wasn't so long ago that young lads and girls were wearing Arsenal and Chelsea shirts in the Croydon area.
Now they wear Palace shirts because we are Premier League.
We are still growing as a Premier club and we should be proud. We are a Premier club because of people like our Chairman and our Manager.
Instead of moaning we should be thanking Mr Parish and Mr Hodgson both Palace legends.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 7.17pm

Originally posted by stujii


Yes all fine and dandy but you’re forgetting a few things....We almost went out of existence twice. We were lucky not to get relegated to League 1 , We were loosing on average £4m a season, We also had to endure some really really toilet football in the Championship too...The grass isn’t always greener and in fact it can be downright dangerous

I’m not forgetting any of that.
Badly run football club, feel more sorry for the small local businesses
That got knocked, than the c*Nts that ran the club. The football was no worse than the last few years.
I’m talking about a world where we would get relegated for a couple of years then get promoted again.
The grass isn’t always greener? Have you been palace the last few years , the football is dire, the atmosphere is pony.
If we went up and down, would be great, probably unrealistic, but as a fan that will never challenge for the trophies , would be good for me.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 7.19pm

Originally posted by Dippo

It wasn't so long ago that young lads and girls were wearing Arsenal and Chelsea shirts in the Croydon area.
Now they wear Palace shirts because we are Premier League.
We are still growing as a Premier club and we should be proud. We are a Premier club because of people like our Chairman and our Manager.
Instead of moaning we should be thanking Mr Parish and Mr Hodgson both Palace legends.

Who’s moaning? Had a season ticket 30 years, don’t think the premier league is the holy grail.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 15 May 21 8.17pm

Originally posted by stujii


Yes all fine and dandy but you’re forgetting a few things....We almost went out of existence twice. We were lucky not to get relegated to League 1 , We were loosing on average £4m a season, We also had to endure some really really toilet football in the Championship too...The grass isn’t always greener and in fact it can be downright dangerous

All of this is true. All the time we are in the Premier league we should at least be able to feel that the continued existence of the club is assured, and that's probably the main thing.

One other point I think gets overlooked when people pine for a period in the championship is that all the good times we had in that league were before we found out how dull and dispiriting being an 'established' Premier league side actually is.

Competing in the championship when you don't actually want, or at least don't feel excited by, the greater implications of promotion would not only be very different to those good days we had in that league, it would also be a bizarre, probably unpleasant experience within itself.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 15 May 21 8.19pm

Originally posted by Casual

I’d be over the moon if we had a couple of seasons in the top league (full houses, get to do the big away grounds) then get relegated (get to see loads more goals/wins, do a few of the championship away grounds). I know promotion isn’t guaranteed/easy , but if we could spend a few years in each league it would be ideal for me. Get the parachute payments, play millwall/charlton as well as maybe winning a league, play off finals.
More youngsters would get a chance , all the high earners would have clauses saying that would get reduced wages when relegated.
8 odd years in the top league and we haven’t improved Selhurst at all, I know the training ground is getting sorted.
The atmosphere would always be great, either fighting for promotion, or a first year in the premier league.
I’ve thought before that city/ Chelsea 50 odd year olds have had a right result, spent their 20s/ early 30s going to the ‘proper grounds’ coming away disappointed, understanding what it’s like to not be that good. Then reach their mid 30s/40s (when they are chilling out a bit and probably getting a few more quid) and they are winning leagues and going to the San Siro/ Nou camp.etc.
I know if we get relegated we might not come back up again for ages or ever. Watford, Norwich, West Brom seem to have it sussed.

I agree with you and have said this for a long time.
In an ideal world, we come up and don't break the bank, just survive on a budget. Then, for the second season we use the money to invest in youth and to be the best team in the championship, whilst plying our trade in the prem. We stay up, 3rd year in the prem and introduce more youngsters to the squad, with an eye of having a good cup run, so we invest on experience.

So on paper, we have a strong championship, that looks solid with the future looking good, a stepping stone club, whilst playing in the prem with the mandate to get to 40 points in record time.
We go down, that's ok... we have a strong squad, we don't need to sell, we have money saved, no debt, youth... we have a fun season, get to play offs, miss out. That's ok, next year, we do it again and go up.. the joy.

Repeat.

That way, we never go bust, never break the bank, we invest and know who we are. We see wins, we have a fun season, we give it a go but know who we are.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 8.29pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

All of this is true. All the time we are in the Premier league we should at least be able to feel that the continued existence of the club is assured, and that's probably the main thing.

One other point I think gets overlooked when people pine for a period in the championship is that all the good times we had in that league were before we found out how dull and dispiriting being an 'established' Premier league side actually is.

Competing in the championship when you don't actually want, or at least don't feel excited by, the greater implications of promotion would not only be very different to those good days we had in that league, it would also be a bizarre, probably unpleasant experience within itself.

Your opinion mate. No problem with that.

Biggest /best Palace games in the last 30 years?
-4-3 Liverpool at villa Pk
-Blackburn play off game at home (Wright bright)
-zenith cup final
-fa cup final x 2
-Stockport away
-sheff we’d away
-5-0 Brighton at home
-Brighton playoff final away
-Watford play off final Wembley

You could argue 3-3 Liverpool at home. How many of the best/ biggest games have been in the premier league ?


 

uncleneal Flag Croydon 15 May 21 9.19pm

I know what you are saying but all the time we are up there, we have slim chance of winning the cup or qualifying for Europe.

Personally, I would die happy after that.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 May 21 9.42pm

Originally posted by uncleneal

I know what you are saying but all the time we are up there, we have slim chance of winning the cup or qualifying for Europe.

Personally, I would die happy after that.

Me too, I am not keen on planning for failure we will probably manage that without planning.

 


One more point

slubglurge Flag welling 15 May 21 10.02pm

Originally posted by Casual

Your opinion mate. No problem with that.

Biggest /best Palace games in the last 30 years?
-4-3 Liverpool at villa Pk
-Blackburn play off game at home (Wright bright)
-zenith cup final
-fa cup final x 2
-Stockport away

-sheff we’d away
-5-0 Brighton at home
-Brighton playoff final away
-Watford play off final Wembley

You could argue 3-3 Liverpool at home. How many of the best/ biggest games have been in the premier league ?


3-2 at the Etihad is right up there

 

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 15 May 21 10.11pm

The entertainment value of watching palace is zero but there’s no guarantee we would be the great entertainers of the championship we could easily become a Sheffield Wednesday or a Sunderland my biggest disappointment is the lack of progress on improving the ground it’s a dump at the moment

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 10.11pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

3-2 at the Etihad is right up there

Is it?
Compared to staying up, getting up, cup semi /finals, play off semi finals /finals.staying up( last game of the season) Games against our rivals.

An away game. Great result, not denying it , but it’s more about the opposition than Palace.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 10.14pm

Originally posted by uncleneal

I know what you are saying but all the time we are up there, we have slim chance of winning the cup or qualifying for Europe.

Personally, I would die happy after that.

I’d go to any European game , anywhere. Bosnia, galatasary, Serbia, Russia, Poland. wouldn’t care.
But do you honestly think our second team has a slim chance of winning the cup? No chance.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 15 May 21 10.45pm

Originally posted by Casual

Your opinion mate. No problem with that.

Biggest /best Palace games in the last 30 years?
-4-3 Liverpool at villa Pk
We were a top flight side at that time, having used the money and status to attract Thorn and Martyn, without whom we don't win that game.

-Blackburn play off game at home (Wright bright)
The great excitement of this was the chance of having a crack at the top flight, not the result itself.

-zenith cup final
I refer the honourable gentleman to my first answer.

-fa cup final x 2
See first answer.

-Stockport away
-sheff we’d away
Fair enough, but would it not be essentially the same if we had a last day escape like this in the Premier league?

-5-0 Brighton at home
Surely the league we were in isn't the point here? If we hammered them in the Premier league it'd be the same.

-Brighton playoff final away
-Watford play off final Wembley
See second answer.

You could argue 3-3 Liverpool at home. How many of the best/ biggest games have been in the premier league ?
Take your pick from the wins at Chelsea, United, City, Liverpool or Arsenal?

I totally get that premier league life isn't the fun we hoped it'd be, but hoping to go back down (even on a yo-yo basis) is like trying to recapture your youth. You can do the same stuff again that you used to, but it won't be the same because you've already found out where it all leads to. The mystery, novelty, and the dreamlike potential of the great unknown can't be recreated.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 May 2021 10.51pm)

 

eaglesdare Flag 15 May 21 10.56pm

Sorry but I never want to go back to loosing to scunthorpe 4-0 on a rainy Tuesday night!

Never never never never never!

 

Casual Flag Orpington 15 May 21 11.04pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I totally get that premier league life isn't the fun we hoped it'd be, but hoping to go back down (even on a yo-yo basis) is like trying to recapture your youth. You can do the same stuff again that you used to, but it won't be the same because you've already found out where it all leads to. The mystery, novelty, and the dreamlike potential of the great unknown can't be recreated.


I’m not anti premier league.
But I’d rather float around the 2 divisions, watching us win/score goals.
Stagnating at all in life isn’t what I want, my football club being the same.
Had 8 years in the top league. Would fancy millwall, charlton, Pompey, etc away. All proper 2nd tier teams in the football league, although not at the moment.
I’d have 2 years in the championship, getting up then 2 in the premier league , as a fan.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Yo yo club.