You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Has Roy lost it?
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Has Roy lost it?


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 May 21 6.46am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Does sh@t form now get classed as personal issues?

No but losing your Grandma does ( as in PVAs case)

 

EddieMac Flag 17 May 21 6.56am

I think some of our fans have lost it. Maybe bring back Max Meyer and Roy can keep his job.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 May 21 7.03am

a lot of the time...i really worry at the state of our fanbase.

how some of you leave the house with your shoelaces tied correctly is a mystery!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 17 May 21 9.35am

Such haters! Is it really so negative, odd, disloyal or stupid to question why we had two keepers on the bench?

 


Spirit of 1974

Putitout Flag Oxford 17 May 21 9.40am

There is little doubt it’s the fans that have lost it. But it’s nothing new in football. It has always happened to clubs like ours. Platforms such as this make it much easier to relay feelings of unrest, but the feelings expressed by many are not new to the situation Palace, are in.
The fact is clubs like ours, and there are quiet a few, always want the big time, the problem being the big time for such clubs is invariably a struggle year on year which will disappoint a section of the crowd no matter what ,because we will be lucky to win more than we lose in the company we keep. The game is littered with clubs that have been where we are, with patience finally breaking with appearing to merely survive.. Even back in Bert Heads time just being able to see the mega stars of that period batter us was not enough for many. It would have taken mega money to reverse that and batter them, and nothing has changed , the game at this level is mostly all about money. Many people bring up the Charlton, disaster. I would point to Stoke , like us ,several years of stable underwhelming performance, under Pulis, thrown away out of boredom .
At this moment 17 points clear of a relegation , and pissed off It really is a case of careful what you wish. Probably a forlorn request as fans across all clubs have never not got restless and not accepted it when it becomes clear their clubs have reached their maximum level within their means.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 May 21 9.48am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Such haters! Is it really so negative, odd, disloyal or stupid to question why we had two keepers on the bench?

It was a question as I had not seen it before, apologies. As for hate, I don’t think so, you don’t start hating a club you have supported for 60 years

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 May 21 9.56am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Such haters! Is it really so negative, odd, disloyal or stupid to question why we had two keepers on the bench?

Why do fans have to show loyalty and their opinions are only valid if they are deemed loyal?

There is no loyalty in football players and coaches go where they think it is best for them. I am fine with that so I have never got you must be loyal to your club argument.

As for negativity its perfectly human to react when you watch a load of dross are people disloyal when they slag off a boring movie?

Yesterday was a breath of fresh air if we produce football like that more often than the other stuff I am happy.

Edited by Badger11 (17 May 2021 9.57am)

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 May 21 10.01am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Such haters! Is it really so negative, odd, disloyal or stupid to question why we had two keepers on the bench?

Natural to question something like this.

But totally disrespectful and not a little ignorant to jump to conclusions and just bash the manager.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Putitout Flag Oxford 17 May 21 10.07am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Such haters! Is it really so negative, odd, disloyal or stupid to question why we had two keepers on the bench?


No it’s not. It’s disrespectful to ask if he has lost his mind. That takes it beyond strictly football matters.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 17 May 21 10.33am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

a lot of the time...i really worry at the state of our fanbase.

how some of you leave the house with your shoelaces tied correctly is a mystery!

While plenty of those calling for Roy's head are long of tooth and have been fans for donkeys years, we all knew when we came up that a few years in the top flight would attract many new fans. Most of them are sensible and very welcome; but some really don't understand that we are a third tier club just managing to tread water in the top flight and that we are vulnerable to relegation every season.

Newcastle, Southampton, Everton and Arsenal fans I can understand their pain (and laugh a bit) as their resources should be producing more and better. However, we have been punching above our weight for years and are riding our luck. This obvious fact never seems to appear in the Roy out posts.

Chris Sutton on R5 last night claimed that Roy's shoes will be very difficult ones to fill as he has done a superb job with what he has. I don't always agree with him but that fact is so blindingly obvious it is painful that so many fans can't see it.

 

French eagle Flag 17 May 21 11.05am

From my own point of view, the management plays to our strenghths to get the 40 points we need every year, and have done so for the last 4 years. Give Roy Raheem Sterling, Kanté, Van Dyke then he would adapt and play differently. We havent got the calibre of those players. Just give Roy better younger players and no management change is needed. Spend it on new players instead.Yes Roy cant go on forever, sadly, but just because there are two managers with promise available now it doesn't mean it's the last chance saloon. There will always be managers coming and going so other candidates will present themselves.
___

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 May 21 11.19am

Originally posted by French eagle

From my own point of view, the management plays to our strenghths to get the 40 points we need every year, and have done so for the last 4 years. Give Roy Raheem Sterling, Kanté, Van Dyke then he would adapt and play differently. We havent got the calibre of those players. Just give Roy better younger players and no management change is needed. Spend it on new players instead.Yes Roy cant go on forever, sadly, but just because there are two managers with promise available now it doesn't mean it's the last chance saloon. There will always be managers coming and going so other candidates will present themselves.
___

The irony this season being that our strengths (supposedly) this season have failed us, we have conceded 61 goals! Meanwhile we have attacking options as evidenced against Villa that haven't been utilised fully, I can think of numerous games where our shots on target ratio has been extremely poor, mainly due to the over emphasis on defence. For example, Roy is on record saying he prefers Benteke because of his defensive work! If Roy isn't here next season I hope the new manager can find that elusive balance.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (17 May 2021 11.26am)

 

French eagle Flag 17 May 21 1.18pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

The irony this season being that our strengths (supposedly) this season have failed us, we have conceded 61 goals! Meanwhile we have attacking options as evidenced against Villa that haven't been utilised fully, I can think of numerous games where our shots on target ratio has been extremely poor, mainly due to the over emphasis on defence. For example, Roy is on record saying he prefers Benteke because of his defensive work! If Roy isn't here next season I hope the new manager can find that elusive balance.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (17 May 2021 11.26am)

True we have conceded a lot this year. But is it any surprise when you look at the injuries suffered by Tomkins, Cahill , Dann plus their age. A solid back four that plays together week in week out is the only way to reduce goals conceded. Guaita Ward Tomkins Cahill Mitchell for 38 games, but it will never happen now because 3 of them aren't fit enough. We need younger quality players, not a change of manager.

Edited by French eagle (17 May 2021 1.21pm)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 17 May 21 1.54pm

Originally posted by French eagle

From my own point of view, the management plays to our strenghths to get the 40 points we need every year, and have done so for the last 4 years. Give Roy Raheem Sterling, Kanté, Van Dyke then he would adapt and play differently. We havent got the calibre of those players. Just give Roy better younger players and no management change is needed. Spend it on new players instead.Yes Roy cant go on forever, sadly, but just because there are two managers with promise available now it doesn't mean it's the last chance saloon. There will always be managers coming and going so other candidates will present themselves.
___

Now you see, I don't think that he would (or at least not massively differently). I think he uses the same methods regardless. That's why he had had a hard time getting Liverpool and England to shine - his methods are better suited to smaller clubs and nations.

My point about Roy has always been twofold:

1. I'm not necessarily pro-Roy, just anti the worst of the anti-Roy nonsense. That ends up leading me to challenge a lot of what is said about him, and perhaps to defend him more than I can remember defending any other Palace manager.

2. The way Roy naturally operates has been, is, and will likely remain, the best fit for a club our size. If we have suddenly got access to a far better squad than we have had in recent years then fine, get a different manager in - I reckon Howe or Lampard actually would play better football than Roy if all three were given the same top ten squad - but until we have a top ten squad we need the right man for the job, which we probably already have.

 

Den1923 Flag 17 May 21 2.02pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Totally without respect.

Whatever your thoughts on his abilities, that comment is just without class and uncalled for.

I consider Roy, whatever else he isn't, to be a true gentleman.

You could learn a lesson there.

Could not agree more, I'm truly grateful to Roy for keeping in this league and earning a huge income for the club with a fairly limited squad of players. This just shows what a quality manager and coach he is!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 May 21 2.21pm

Roy hasn't Lost it. far from it.

Still think that this squad isn't one that is best placed to be handed over to a different Man for a major overhaul.. They rarely work, especially when the new manager is part of that overhaul.

What is required is one more decent Summer, (it's a short one, remember, thanks to the Euros - that means a shorter pre-season) a couple of shrewd signings(like last summer) and RH for another year to get the squad into a state whereby it can be taken on without the need for an overhaul seems to be the best course of actions from where I'm sitting.


If that means more negative tactics, then so be it. Although, that's not necessarily what is going to happen. At some points this season RH tried to be more expansive/attacking, only for it to backfire horribly(probably as we have aging and injured defenders). This summers job: Sort out the reason for that backfire.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Den1923 Flag 17 May 21 4.08pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Roy hasn't Lost it. far from it.

Still think that this squad isn't one that is best placed to be handed over to a different Man for a major overhaul.. They rarely work, especially when the new manager is part of that overhaul.

What is required is one more decent Summer, (it's a short one, remember, thanks to the Euros - that means a shorter pre-season) a couple of shrewd signings(like last summer) and RH for another year to get the squad into a state whereby it can be taken on without the need for an overhaul seems to be the best course of actions from where I'm sitting.


If that means more negative tactics, then so be it. Although, that's not necessarily what is going to happen. At some points this season RH tried to be more expansive/attacking, only for it to backfire horribly(probably as we have aging and injured defenders). This summers job: Sort out the reason for that backfire.

I agree with all of this,an excellent post and well said!

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 17 May 21 5.00pm

It was stated on back of the nest that Roy only had 19 available and asked Hen as he has been training well if he wanted to be part of the squad for the match. The youngsters are busy/ just played and who knows what the procedure is on bubbles etc within the club.
Loyal respectful and a nice touch. That’s all it was I think.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 17 May 21 5.25pm

Originally posted by French eagle

True we have conceded a lot this year. But is it any surprise when you look at the injuries suffered by Tomkins, Cahill , Dann plus their age. A solid back four that plays together week in week out is the only way to reduce goals conceded. Guaita Ward Tomkins Cahill Mitchell for 38 games, but it will never happen now because 3 of them aren't fit enough. We need younger quality players, not a change of manager.

Edited by French eagle (17 May 2021 1.21pm)

Our defending has been poor this year, and we do look vulnerable. Whilst injuries have definitely had an impact and Roy must take some of the blame, you can't blame the manager for everything - Villa's 2nd goal was a complete joke. When the ball was headed up into the air (mistake 1) Cahill then was so worried about Watkins he didn't even jump (mistake 2) and for some bizarre reason Ward decided to leave his man and try and help Cahill out (mistake 3).
So a standing Watkins managed to head it backwards across goal to an unmarked colleague 6 yards out to finish with ease.

Joke defending due to 3 individual errors

 

French eagle Flag 17 May 21 5.39pm

Originally posted by palace99

Our defending has been poor this year, and we do look vulnerable. Whilst injuries have definitely had an impact and Roy must take some of the blame, you can't blame the manager for everything - Villa's 2nd goal was a complete joke. When the ball was headed up into the air (mistake 1) Cahill then was so worried about Watkins he didn't even jump (mistake 2) and for some bizarre reason Ward decided to leave his man and try and help Cahill out (mistake 3).
So a standing Watkins managed to head it backwards across goal to an unmarked colleague 6 yards out to finish with ease.

Joke defending due to 3 individual errors

Defences operate as a unit, knowing what your fellow defenders are going to do. But Every week there are 1 or 2 changes. Even the goalkeeper this week ! Unless you have continuity you will always get the kind of mistakes you describe. Will we have the same defence v the Arse ? I'd bet my balls the answer is no.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Has Roy lost it?