You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How many players do we still need (realistic)
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How many players do we still need (realistic)


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Omph Flag Liverpool 30 Jul 21 10.52pm

Good point on the left footedness of Olise.

I'm also less sure than most on here about his absolute readiness for PL footie as a starter. He is not just younger than Eze but also a year behind him in experience and Eze himself took a while to really bed in.

Originally posted by Putitout

Some seem to to see Olise, as the answer for the RW, the kid can play virtually anywhere through mid field , and along either wing.
One problem ,is he is very left footed, when he is on the wide right he does what so many left footed players do ,which is turn inside instinctively so as to be on his left foot. It’s not that he can not go past a full back and get to the goal line but he doesn’t do it as often or as naturally as a more naturally right footed player might do. And when I have seen him do so he still tries to get on that left foot to find his last ball in. For this reason IMO, We should have an alternative type winger , for certain changes in tactic. And we definitely need more than Ayew, and Mateta, to back up Benteke, it’s a long season and If we want successful cup runs as well as a decent league performance , we need someone nearer to Benteke, in experience.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 31 Jul 21 12.15am

Originally posted by deetee

Three more minimum . right back, central defender, goal scorer.

Wait what? We’ve just signed two quality CB. And left back more important than right back. Ward and Clyne are proven PL performers (albeit limited ones), while left back we have zero proven ones. Mitchell has looked okay at best. Agree one more striker to compete with CB could be good.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 31 Jul 21 1.20am

I am very happy to see these new faces come in, but remember all we are doing is replacing experienced PL campaigners with largely untested newbies.

(Sakho, Cahill, Dann OUT - Guehi, Andersen IN)

(Townsend OUT - Olise IN)

(Eze OUT injured - Gallagher IN)

We have not necessarily improved a squad that finished 14th last season and with the loss of PVA one could say we may be weaker all around.

Yes, let's get excited about the new younger faces, but it is not automatic they will gel into a PL fighting force.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jul 21 7.49am

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I am very happy to see these new faces come in, but remember all we are doing is replacing experienced PL campaigners with largely untested newbies.

(Sakho, Cahill, Dann OUT - Guehi, Andersen IN)

(Townsend OUT - Olise IN)

(Eze OUT injured - Gallagher IN)

We have not necessarily improved a squad that finished 14th last season and with the loss of PVA one could say we may be weaker all around.

Yes, let's get excited about the new younger faces, but it is not automatic they will gel into a PL fighting force.


Sorry but I have to disagree re the defence and to an extent re the Eze/Gallagher inference.

1. As for CBs, Sakho was absent for virtually the whole season, Dann was found wanting when he covered for the injured Tomkins and Cahill was slow and injury prone. Andersen's performances for Fulham last season were well ahead of those 3 (and is hardly untested). Guehi is untested in the PL but IMO is unlikely to be worse than Dann, slower than Cahill or as injury prone as Sakho. IMO we have a stronger more reliable central defence than last year especially with Tomkins back (he only had 7 starts last year).

2. Gallagher is hardly untested and his performances for Baggies were similar to Eze's performances for us during Eze's first half of the season. Eze only blossomed when he was given a more central role in the second half of the season and he should be back by New Year.

3. Olise, I grant remains an unknown force in the PL and I'm not sure he will be ready to go straight into the team when he's recovered from his injury, but then Ayew will cover that position initially, and currently without any proven back-up so we are weaker in that position. The youngsters, Rak-Sakyi and Banks look like being the back-up unless we buy a wide player and we do still have a month in which to do that.

4. Finally, much will depend on the extent to which the squad can adapt to the style of play Vieira has clearly stated he's wanting us to play. The players brought in are believed to be comfortable on-the-ball players, so that's a start.

Where will we finish? Who Knows? Whilst I'm encouraged by what has been done so far, avoiding relegation remains the main thing and will be a challenge for us IMO.

Edited by doombear (31 Jul 2021 9.01am)

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 31 Jul 21 8.10am

Well said Doombear. I agree with your analysis, although I do think we should get a new RW to replace Townsend and see Rak-Sakyi develop for another 12 months with occasional appearances. I also wondered if Banks might be seen as a replacement/understudy for Gallagher. I still think we need another striker, as neither Ayew nor Mateta are offering much.

As for our defence it is unquestionably better than last season with the only departure not addressed being that of PVA and he was better up top than as a defender, so no great loss. I still believe we might need a RB, if we think there's any danger that we won't have Ferguson for the season.

So plenty still to do but for once there's time to do it and hopefully funds available.

 

Kant Flag exeter 31 Jul 21 8.32am

Originally posted by doombear


Sorry but I have to disagree re the defence and to an extent re the Eze/Gallagher inference….

That’s an excellent analysis. I particularly endorse the view that our fortunes are as likely to turn on PV’s abilities as a manager as they are on our activities in the transfer market.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 31 Jul 21 9.17am

I'm very much in the PV over transfer activity camp as to how well this goes down.

What interests me is that we are building the team from the back at least insofar as money spent goes.This will likely be Dougie of course but PV's reputation and record is actually of a manager who has a decent defence and dries goals up going forward!

I understand the optimism of having a new manager who is not committed to low block but passing the ball around doesn't always translate into more goals - just prettier football to watch.

Originally posted by Kant

That’s an excellent analysis. I particularly endorse the view that our fortunes are as likely to turn on PV’s abilities as a manager as they are on our activities in the transfer market.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 31 Jul 21 10.03am

Yes agree, excellent analysis db.

I do however share Sprites’ concern re Left Back and I haven’t seen enough from Mitchell yet to convince me he’s the answer to that position for us in the Premier League. He needed too much cover from other players last season and also got beaten by his man too often and too easily. Showing promise certainly and he may develop and improve but he’s not there yet IMHO and we need to strengthen LB more so than RB (Clyne, Ward & Ferguson).

Now we just need to unearth an Ian Wright or Jamie Vardy from Non-League and we’re on fire!

 

OneMax Flag Maidstone 31 Jul 21 11.57am

Unless Palace sell Zaha for big money I can not see any further significant signings. We hopefully will have Eze and Nathan Ferguson available later in the year.

 

IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 31 Jul 21 12.08pm

Originally posted by doombear


Sorry but I have to disagree re the defence and to an extent re the Eze/Gallagher inference.

1. As for CBs, Sakho was absent for virtually the whole season, Dann was found wanting when he covered for the injured Tomkins and Cahill was slow and injury prone. Andersen's performances for Fulham last season were well ahead of those 3 (and is hardly untested). Guehi is untested in the PL but IMO is unlikely to be worse than Dann, slower than Cahill or as injury prone as Sakho. IMO we have a stronger more reliable central defence than last year especially with Tomkins back (he only had 7 starts last year).

2. Gallagher is hardly untested and his performances for Baggies were similar to Eze's performances for us during Eze's first half of the season. Eze only blossomed when he was given a more central role in the second half of the season and he should be back by New Year.

3. Olise, I grant remains an unknown force in the PL and I'm not sure he will be ready to go straight into the team when he's recovered from his injury, but then Ayew will cover that position initially, and currently without any proven back-up so we are weaker in that position. The youngsters, Rak-Sakyi and Banks look like being the back-up unless we buy a wide player and we do still have a month in which to do that.

4. Finally, much will depend on the extent to which the squad can adapt to the style of play Vieira has clearly stated he's wanting us to play. The players brought in are believed to be comfortable on-the-ball players, so that's a start.

Where will we finish? Who Knows? Whilst I'm encouraged by what has been done so far, avoiding relegation remains the main thing and will be a challenge for us IMO.

Edited by doombear (31 Jul 2021 9.01am)

Your analysis appears to assume Tomkins will be available - a huge gamble. I will be delighted if Guehi proves to be anywhere near the quality of Scott Dann, who has in my opinion been the best centre half we have had at the club - albeit his last season was a bridge too far.

As for Gallagher and Andersen, whilst I hope they are a success, it can't have escaped your notice that ultimately both were relegated. Whilst the players they are replacing finished 14th.

So whilst you are correct they are not untested, the outcome was unavoidably relegation - in anybody's estimation that must be a failure.


Edited by IMMER PALACE (31 Jul 2021 12.09pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jul 21 12.50pm

Originally posted by IMMER PALACE

Your analysis appears to assume Tomkins will be available - a huge gamble. I will be delighted if Guehi proves to be anywhere near the quality of Scott Dann, who has in my opinion been the best centre half we have had at the club - albeit his last season was a bridge too far.

As for Gallagher and Andersen, whilst I hope they are a success, it can't have escaped your notice that ultimately both were relegated. Whilst the players they are replacing finished 14th.

So whilst you are correct they are not untested, the outcome was unavoidably relegation - in anybody's estimation that must be a failure.


Edited by IMMER PALACE (31 Jul 2021 12.09pm)


A failure for the team but does that make the individual a failure?

As has been stated in a thread on the Transfer board, the following players were relegated from the top division:
- Roy Keane (Notts F.)
- Harry Maguire (Hull C)
- Andy Robertson (Hull C)
- Gini Wijnaldum (Newcastle U)
Does that make them failures? Of course not. Likewise I suggest it's nonsense to suggest that Andersen and Gallagher are failures simply because they were relegated from the PL in poor teams.

Edited by doombear (31 Jul 2021 12.51pm)

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 31 Jul 21 1.07pm

I think Left back is a problem and we are also weak at right back. I agree centre forward is also a potential problem. PVA gave us an attacking option and had real pace. He was part of the reason so many of out attacks were down the left hand side. If we lack pace in both our full back's this is going to restrict us going forward. Even if Mitchell improves ( which he should given his age and a full pre season ) we don't have cover.
A pacey left back or and right back would be nice.
We have so many central midfielders though!!

 

IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 06 Aug 21 11.51pm

Originally posted by doombear


A failure for the team but does that make the individual a failure?

As has been stated in a thread on the Transfer board, the following players were relegated from the top division:
- Roy Keane (Notts F.)
- Harry Maguire (Hull C)
- Andy Robertson (Hull C)
- Gini Wijnaldum (Newcastle U)
Does that make them failures? Of course not. Likewise I suggest it's nonsense to suggest that Andersen and Gallagher are failures simply because they were relegated from the PL in poor teams.

Edited by doombear (31 Jul 2021 12.51pm)


Yes. When trudging off, after the final whistle, it is a failure both individually and collectively, but you know that. You can find good players in 30 plus years who've been relegated. If Connor and Andersen have the quality of the four you mentioned, I will be delighted. There wasn't too much evidence of that last season.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 07 Aug 21 6.38am

Originally posted by Omph

I'm very much in the PV over transfer activity camp as to how well this goes down.

What interests me is that we are building the team from the back at least insofar as money spent goes.This will likely be Dougie of course but PV's reputation and record is actually of a manager who has a decent defence and dries goals up going forward!

I understand the optimism of having a new manager who is not committed to low block but passing the ball around doesn't always translate into more goals - just prettier football to watch.

Indeed. Brighton spring to mind (although I have a feeling they will do very well this season &#128577

 

stayingup2017 Flag 07 Aug 21 11.15am

if we keep zaha and with tekers and 2 lively wingers I think we will always have goals in us. static is one thing we wont be

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 09 Aug 21 10.51am

So far the transfer window has been awesome. The "deadwood" shipped out and was replaced with young, quality players. If we can add one out of Lookman, Reis Nelson on loan from Arsenal, or Blackburn striker Armstrong (Southampton-bound it seems), it would almost be too good to be true.
Now let us hope the manager can put out a side that gives 100% in each game, we can never ask for more.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 09 Aug 21 12.50pm

Yep, one of Lookman or Reis Nelson would be great.

I know it will take some time for the injured to get back and the team to bed in, but we're assembling a really exciting set of players

 

BelfastEagle Flag 09 Aug 21 4.47pm

With the number of subs increased back up there is no way have enough players for a full bench. On my calculations we lost 9 in the summer with only 5 coming in one of whom is long term injured to add to the 2 long term injuries we already have. I think we need a min of 3 further players to bolster the squad otherwise it’s bare bones again.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Aug 21 5.02pm

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

With the number of subs increased back up there is no way have enough players for a full bench. On my calculations we lost 9 in the summer with only 5 coming in one of whom is long term injured to add to the 2 long term injuries we already have. I think we need a min of 3 further players to bolster the squad otherwise it’s bare bones again.

are you not taking into account Rak-Sakyi, Banks, Hamman, Boateng, Rich-Baghuelou, Wells-Morrison and Omilabu

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Aug 21 5.32pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

are you not taking into account Rak-Sakyi, Banks, Hamman, Boateng, Rich-Baghuelou, Wells-Morrison and Omilabu


Most if not all of those youngsters will not need to be included in the squad of 25 names submitted to the league after the window closes. They can be first team squad players, of course. What is looking very likely is that we won't have 25 names on that list, not that we need to if our youngsters are the ones who will be coming off the bench. There's no need to make up the numbers of 21yo and over to 25 if they aren't likely to feature in the matches or on the bench.

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How many players do we still need (realistic)