This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by sprites
I’m Eduoard and Benteke we have two stickers who would get 10-15 goals each. We’re just not playing this for some reason! I don’t think Benteke is up there anymore.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I don’t think Benteke is up there anymore. Not convinced Benteke ever fully overcame his knee injury. He always looks like he is protecting himself from any sort of physicality when he occasionally plays. Maybe mentally he finds it all too much. He’s still a great header of the ball but that is about it and it’s not enough.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Hey Lanzo and Sprites, why don't the two of you set up a WhatsApp group dedicated to Benteke Talk so you can argue the toss as much as you like without boring the rest of us? Read my statement
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Benteke has been a poor investment altogether, even accounting for the decent first season he had with us. At his worst he has been the very definition of a waste of money, occupying the very top end of the wage structure and the bottom end of not only the performance table, but also of the effort, commitment and physical courage tables too. Every supporters worst nightmare to see. At the same time, three things make him my first choice centre forward: 1. He seems finally to be in form. He got seven of his ten league goals from this point of last season, and looked good to carry that on this season. We invested so much in him that binning him when he might finally pay a bit of it back makes no sense. 2. Tactically, he offers something unique. With the possible exception of the Dutch striker Burnley just signed, nobody else comes close to Benteke as an areial threat from crosses - I know he misses as many as he scores, but to have a forward who is almost unplayable, albeit within a narrow dimension of the game, isn't something to discard lightly. When Vieiras possession game is working and opposing teams drop off and sit in a compact block to make life hard for Zaha, Olise, Eze etc, the option of just swinging a cross in for benteke becomes the perfect counterpoint. This is exactly what happened at home to Wolves and Newcastle this season. 3. We still haven't got anybody better. Ayew gives us workrate and greater mobility, but no greater number of goals than benteke. Edouard has individual skill but can't lead the line at all, and Mateta is simply second rate. Bentekes faults are plain to see, but the question is not what's wrong with benteke, but rather who do we have that is clearly better. For me, we don't have anyone better. Couldn't have put it better myself.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Read my statement That's a fair comment, doombear. I honestly try and ignore the ridiculous posts about Mateta being the saviour etc...I really do. But I just can't do it. Plus to be fair, this is a thread specifically titled 'centre forwards'. So it's sort of justified debate on this thread. Will try not to overtake other threads from now on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Benteke has been a poor investment altogether, even accounting for the decent first season he had with us. At his worst he has been the very definition of a waste of money, occupying the very top end of the wage structure and the bottom end of not only the performance table, but also of the effort, commitment and physical courage tables too. Every supporters worst nightmare to see. At the same time, three things make him my first choice centre forward: 1. He seems finally to be in form. He got seven of his ten league goals from this point of last season, and looked good to carry that on this season. We invested so much in him that binning him when he might finally pay a bit of it back makes no sense. 2. Tactically, he offers something unique. With the possible exception of the Dutch striker Burnley just signed, nobody else comes close to Benteke as an areial threat from crosses - I know he misses as many as he scores, but to have a forward who is almost unplayable, albeit within a narrow dimension of the game, isn't something to discard lightly. When Vieiras possession game is working and opposing teams drop off and sit in a compact block to make life hard for Zaha, Olise, Eze etc, the option of just swinging a cross in for benteke becomes the perfect counterpoint. This is exactly what happened at home to Wolves and Newcastle this season. 3. We still haven't got anybody better. Ayew gives us workrate and greater mobility, but no greater number of goals than benteke. Edouard has individual skill but can't lead the line at all, and Mateta is simply second rate. Bentekes faults are plain to see, but the question is not what's wrong with benteke, but rather who do we have that is clearly better. For me, we don't have anyone better. Is it April 1st already? The most ridiculous post from an otherwise sensible poster I have seen on these pages. Benteke's record speaks for itself, he's a lazy gravy train riding waste of space. PV has realised it by not selecting him, funny that...
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Is it April 1st already? The most ridiculous post from an otherwise sensible poster I have seen on these pages. Benteke's record speaks for itself, he's a lazy gravy train riding waste of space. PV has realised it by not selecting him, funny that... I have to say, I do agree with this. I probably gave more patience than many to Benteke but now it seems like he has completely moved into retirement and I doubt he'll get much more than a cameo in the remaining games as Vieira clearly wants his players to at least break a sweat. Mateta still looks like Bambi on ice but he has clearly taken on board this fact and now runs around and closes players down. I still don't understand why Edouard has had so little game time down the middle though? I know he hasn't exactly torn up trees but he is the only one of the three who seems to have a proper striker's instinct and I really hope he gets a run of games. Sorry to any Ayew fans but I just don't see him as a striker.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I have to say, I do agree with this. I probably gave more patience than many to Benteke but now it seems like he has completely moved into retirement and I doubt he'll get much more than a cameo in the remaining games as Vieira clearly wants his players to at least break a sweat. Mateta still looks like Bambi on ice but he has clearly taken on board this fact and now runs around and closes players down. I still don't understand why Edouard has had so little game time down the middle though? I know he hasn't exactly torn up trees but he is the only one of the three who seems to have a proper striker's instinct and I really hope he gets a run of games. Sorry to any Ayew fans but I just don't see him as a striker.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Is it April 1st already? The most ridiculous post from an otherwise sensible poster I have seen on these pages. Benteke's record speaks for itself, he's a lazy gravy train riding waste of space. PV has realised it by not selecting him, funny that... It was actually a well reasoned and insightful comment - even for the Benteke haters. Did you even read it in detail, or just clock that it went against the anti Benteke agenda and instantly dismiss it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
That's a fair comment, doombear. I honestly try and ignore the ridiculous posts about Mateta being the saviour etc...I really do. But I just can't do it. Plus to be fair, this is a thread specifically titled 'centre forwards'. So it's sort of justified debate on this thread. Will try not to overtake other threads from now on. I don't recall anyone saying he is the saviour he is just above average which goes to show how poor the others CFs are, Mateta is the best of a bad bunch, why would PV choose him above the others, unless you think PV is Clueless
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
It was actually a well reasoned and insightful comment - even for the Benteke haters. Did you even read it in detail, or just clock that it went against the anti Benteke agenda and instantly dismiss it. I read it. Curious how it started by saying Benteke's not that good, but.... then shifts to how he scored a few at the end of last season, to he offers something a bit different, to he is the best of what we have.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
It was actually a well reasoned and insightful comment - even for the Benteke haters. Did you even read it in detail, or just clock that it went against the anti Benteke agenda and instantly dismiss it. Happy to second your comment Sprites. Benteke is an asset in offering something others cannot. He's a very likeable character for me so I personally find it hard to hate him. Just needs to be crystal clear on what he can and cannot bring to a game (wordplay intended). Edouard is looking a bit lightweight since he arrived, that cameo at Spurs still looking to be his best performance. Might also argue he needs time to adjust to the league and team and vice versa. Thought he was a fantastic acquisition at the time. Mateta - Good movement, tall, seems technically capable, young but yet to be convinced of him as a 'finished article'. Very much see him as an Origi character, may have decent spells but struggle to see him developing to become 'prolific'. What do I know though eh? Ayew - Not Russia, apologies, meant 'not a striker'. My diagnosis would be that each of these players has the potential and opportunity to become 1st choice however none of them have grabbed that. Equally, I'd still be reluctant to write anybody off just yet though Benteke has had his time. Perhaps this is what Vieira is holding out for but should the time come, you'd like to think we'd still look for that 1st choice man and perhaps move on those that become deadwood and keep those who still have something to offer squad. Also, just a final point. It's something that gets said a lot, including probably by me, but I really do have a gripe with this notion of young players having 'potential' as if it is a given. F***ing Michael Owen peaked at 18 and just because you're half decent when young doesn't mean you will automatically get better and better down the years. Random rant of a cerebral challenged lunatic for today!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Happy to second your comment Sprites. Benteke is an asset in offering something others cannot. He's a very likeable character for me so I personally find it hard to hate him. Just needs to be crystal clear on what he can and cannot bring to a game (wordplay intended). Edouard is looking a bit lightweight since he arrived, that cameo at Spurs still looking to be his best performance. Might also argue he needs time to adjust to the league and team and vice versa. Thought he was a fantastic acquisition at the time. Mateta - Good movement, tall, seems technically capable, young but yet to be convinced of him as a 'finished article'. Very much see him as an Origi character, may have decent spells but struggle to see him developing to become 'prolific'. What do I know though eh? Ayew - Not Russia, apologies, meant 'not a striker'. My diagnosis would be that each of these players has the potential and opportunity to become 1st choice however none of them have grabbed that. Equally, I'd still be reluctant to write anybody off just yet though Benteke has had his time. Perhaps this is what Vieira is holding out for but should the time come, you'd like to think we'd still look for that 1st choice man and perhaps move on those that become deadwood and keep those who still have something to offer squad. Also, just a final point. It's something that gets said a lot, including probably by me, but I really do have a gripe with this notion of young players having 'potential' as if it is a given. F***ing Michael Owen peaked at 18 and just because you're half decent when young doesn't mean you will automatically get better and better down the years. Random rant of a cerebral challenged lunatic for today!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.