You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Corbyn to be deselected.
November 21 2026 9.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Corbyn to be deselected.


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Matov Flag 13 Feb 22 10.59am

The Sunday Times is carrying a story about Labour deselecting Corbyn and standing a new candidate in his safe Islington seat.

Ouch.

A man who led Labour to polling over 40% in 2017 is now considered no longer fit for purpose by the party he once led.

Be interesting to see how the Left react. And the Trade Unions. Labour has a funding crisis as it is so they really are playing with fire now.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 13 Feb 22 11.09am

Originally posted by Matov

The Sunday Times is carrying a story about Labour deselecting Corbyn and standing a new candidate in his safe Islington seat.

Ouch.

A man who led Labour to polling over 40% in 2017 is now considered no longer fit for purpose by the party he once led.

Be interesting to see how the Left react. And the Trade Unions. Labour has a funding crisis as it is so they really are playing with fire now.

Yep I read that too Matov. Pity they can't do something about his brother. Just as bad a character, if not worse. They seem a crazy pair.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Feb 22 11.47am

Jeez. Perhaps we should check to make sure Steeley is ok

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 Feb 22 11.53am

Labour could have just said Corbyn was retiring and let him shuffle off into the sunset.
The media will probably want to exploit any falling-out with the Labour leadership. The problem with Corbyn and now with Starmer, is that they are not media-savvy enough.
Look at the 5hlt BJ gets away with and he's still in No.10. Corbyn makes a joke about bacon-dodgers, and all of a sudden Labour's celebrating the holocaust.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Feb 22 11.56am

Rumours he may stand as an independent in which case he would split the Labour vote in Islington. Not saying the Tories would win but if they and the other parties had a little pact maybe the Greens or Lib Dems might get in.

 


One more point

Matov Flag 13 Feb 22 12.02pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Rumours he may stand as an independent in which case he would split the Labour vote in Islington. Not saying the Tories would win but if they and the other parties had a little pact maybe the Greens or Lib Dems might get in.


Or stands as part of a wider Left-wing movement? Because this move is not just about Corbyn. Its about putting his supporters still within Labour in a real predicament.

If they swallow this then they are essentially finished. Toeing the line. Or else they can bugger off and form their own party/movement.

There has been some chatter in Left-Wing circles about forming a new party, with Laura Piddock being touted as the leading light given that she has already left the Labour party.

I do wonder if this current move, if it materialises, is about trying to force the issue, one way or the other?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Feb 22 12.30pm

I feel somewhat differently about it.

Anyone on the right has serious issues with Corbyn, however he represents a serious chunk of Labour's grass roots and they deserve a voice like anyone else.

If this is done then Starmer is kicking sand in the face of his base and that's a fundamental disconnection between the grass roots and it's leadership. That would be copying how the Tory party is run.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 Feb 22 1.06pm

Great points by Matov and stirling. However, my view is that a socialist Labour is very unlikely to get into Parliament. sure, it would get a significant chunk of the vote, but nowhere near enough to get into Government - just my view.

I think that's why Blair was so successful, because he was media-savvy, and kept the hardliners at the back of the room. Slow implementation of Labour policies, so they didn't have an immediate impact on the tory voters. Giving them time to warm to policies.

The problem any (Labour) leader taking over from BJ will have, is the massive debt, which will restrict public spending.

I understand many socialist Labourites loved Corbyn, and if you listened to him, he was very sensible and articulate and measured. But he was never going to get Labour into Government. And that is what is holding Labour back, is that a lot of its supporters still think Socialism is an election-winner. And it ain't

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (13 Feb 2022 1.07pm)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 13 Feb 22 1.38pm

i love Corbyn. I love it when the enemy are led by a clown.


even hip-hop Boris (7x3) looks sane compared to Corbyn.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (13 Feb 2022 1.39pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 Feb 22 1.39pm

If true, it looks both brave and essential if Labour are ever going to hold power again.

There is not, and my opinion never will be, sufficient appetite for hard left socialism in this country for any Party which even tolerates it within it's ranks to gain sufficient votes to do so. It might be as part of a coalition but as that would mean them having to dump any hard left policies what's the point?

The only way back is for them to re-occupy the centre ground and become even newer Labour. A genuinely modern party with democratic socialism at its heart. They would not lose as much funding as might be imagined as some Unions are perfectly able to see the common sense of this.

It could as easily fail as succeed, but as it's their only chance they have of surviving, let alone holding power, they have got to rid themselves of all the hard left. Given that they control most of the local committees, dumping Corbyn would only be the opening salvo in a long war of attrition.

Meanwhile, we don't have an effective opposition to a populist government led by an increasingly unpopular PM. Just when we really need some statesmanship in public life.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Feb 22 1.46pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Great points by Matov and stirling. However, my view is that a socialist Labour is very unlikely to get into Parliament. sure, it would get a significant chunk of the vote, but nowhere near enough to get into Government - just my view.

I think that's why Blair was so successful, because he was media-savvy, and kept the hardliners at the back of the room. Slow implementation of Labour policies, so they didn't have an immediate impact on the tory voters. Giving them time to warm to policies.

The problem any (Labour) leader taking over from BJ will have, is the massive debt, which will restrict public spending.

I understand many socialist Labourites loved Corbyn, and if you listened to him, he was very sensible and articulate and measured. But he was never going to get Labour into Government. And that is what is holding Labour back, is that a lot of its supporters still think Socialism is an election-winner. And it ain't

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (13 Feb 2022 1.07pm)

It's your view and I think an intelligent one.

Labour seem to want to move away from Corbyn's politics and move towards some soft focus media spin version that doesn't frighten the media and funding elites.

Well, we have seen corporate Labour before and it's an inversion of what the left was....well, excepting Corbyn, that's been the last twenty five years hasn't it?

It would be more honest if they just came out and said it. Say to the Corbyn supporters...we want to be the Blair party again and we don't want your money, go make your own party.

The Tories should do the same....I'm not a critic of coalition building but there are limits. The Tory party is deaf to its grass roots to such a degree that it looks like a party within a party and I don't think that's healthy.

Before Brexit that resulted in Ukip where you saw what the Tory grass roots actually was....those more interested in the principles over being a mish mash.

I'd just be happier if the parties actually reflected their bases more than what their big donators wanted.....because in truth that is what we have.

More parties would be more honest.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Feb 2022 1.48pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 Feb 22 2.20pm

you're probably right, stirling. The Parties (policies) follow the money. With Labour, it's the unions, with the Tories, it's business and private donors.
I don't think the Unions are such a militant force they used to be, except where transport is concerned. Their membership is falling (i think), so their influence lessens, and so Labour has to find new funding.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Feb 22 3.00pm

In the case of Labour they don't have to ditch the policies they just need to ditch the man (Corbyn). He is now toxic to the voters so they need to get rid. I expect the replacement candidate will probably be just as left wing as he is.

In a way it's what John Smith and Tony Blair did, they kicked out the most high profile hard left that the voters disliked but soft peddled the same policies. So change the faces not the policies.

The hard left openly talked about massive spending scaring the voters. Gordon Brown always used words like "prudent" in his budget speech and gave the impression he was the canny Scots banker counting the pennies but in reality he was an old tax and spend Chancellor.

The hard left believe in open borders again scaring the voters Blair didn't even bother to talk about it he just did it.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Feb 22 3.05pm

Originally posted by Badger11

In the case of Labour they don't have to ditch the policies they just need to ditch the man (Corbyn). He is now toxic to the voters so they need to get rid. I expect the replacement candidate will probably be just as left wing as he is.

In a way it's what John Smith and Tony Blair did, they kicked out the most high profile hard left that the voters disliked but soft peddled the same policies. So change the faces not the policies.

The hard left openly talked about massive spending scaring the voters. Gordon Brown always used words like "prudent" in his budget speech and gave the impression he was the canny Scots banker counting the pennies but in reality he was an old tax and spend Chancellor.

The hard left believe in open borders again scaring the voters Blair didn't even bother to talk about it he just did it.

Very true.

Lying to the masses.....the manipulation and distortion of language...very soviet.....in the old days you could rely on the fourth estate to call out BS.....but today the fourth estate has been increasingly bought out by the corporates....especially social.....and the rest of it comes from the universities, who have been fully indoctrinated since the seventies.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 13 Feb 22 5.36pm

I must confess that I struggle with the logic of it. No matter what people might think of Corbyn and the people who support him, the reality is that when it comes to grind of electioneering, they are far more likely to be out on the streets doing all the knocking on doors and handing out leaflets and so on.

Plus the funds from the unions and the monthly membership subscriptions that would leave, especially given Labours perilous financial situation as things stand.

No. This stinks.

I wonder, and this is pure speculation, if this is the opening move in the creation of a 'Progressive Alliance'? That by effectively disowning Corbyn fully, and driving out his supporters, then it leaves a core-Labour, fully centrist,movement that could effectively join up with the Lib-Dems and perhaps elements of the Greens? With Blair giving it his blessing and able to bring a s*** load of funding to the party via his contacts?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 Feb 22 6.29pm

Originally posted by Badger11

In the case of Labour they don't have to ditch the policies they just need to ditch the man (Corbyn). He is now toxic to the voters so they need to get rid. I expect the replacement candidate will probably be just as left wing as he is.

In a way it's what John Smith and Tony Blair did, they kicked out the most high profile hard left that the voters disliked but soft peddled the same policies. So change the faces not the policies.

The hard left openly talked about massive spending scaring the voters. Gordon Brown always used words like "prudent" in his budget speech and gave the impression he was the canny Scots banker counting the pennies but in reality he was an old tax and spend Chancellor.

The hard left believe in open borders again scaring the voters Blair didn't even bother to talk about it he just did it.

This view from the right, that the centre is still to the left, is ultimately what will lead people to abandon their flirtation with them. Smith, Blair and now Starmer all had, and still have, a much better appreciation of the need to run a balanced budget than even some Tories do. That they also want social justice is to their credit as decent people. Most of us are decent people, and we want decent people to represent us.

No-one at all, not even the hardest of the left, believes in open borders, and never did. Controlled, targeted immigration has always been the intention, although sometimes events overtook the good intentions.

It's this kind of slur that drove the lemmings over the Brexit cliff. Those that survive the experience won't make that mistake again. Many of these people are not blue rinse home county Tory
"grass root" voters who would, and did, vote for a clown so long as they wore a Tory label. They are either traditional Labour voters, or swing voters, neither right, nor left. They aren't truly xenophobic. They were just seduced by the thrill of change in a grey world. It's them who hold the balance, and it's them who need to be courted.

If the Tories decide not to, and Labour gets it right, more change is on the horizon.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 Feb 22 6.36pm

Originally posted by Matov

I must confess that I struggle with the logic of it. No matter what people might think of Corbyn and the people who support him, the reality is that when it comes to grind of electioneering, they are far more likely to be out on the streets doing all the knocking on doors and handing out leaflets and so on.

Plus the funds from the unions and the monthly membership subscriptions that would leave, especially given Labours perilous financial situation as things stand.

No. This stinks.

I wonder, and this is pure speculation, if this is the opening move in the creation of a 'Progressive Alliance'? That by effectively disowning Corbyn fully, and driving out his supporters, then it leaves a core-Labour, fully centrist,movement that could effectively join up with the Lib-Dems and perhaps elements of the Greens? With Blair giving it his blessing and able to bring a s*** load of funding to the party via his contacts?

That's new thinking and makes excellent sense. Thanks for the ideas.

Even if they couldn't form a government on their own, a grand coalition with the Tories could be possible, with the condition that they dump the hard right and only include the progressives, of which there are many. If our economy falters as badly as it appears it is going to, then a government of national unity could be on the cards.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Feb 22 6.44pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This view from the right, that the centre is still to the left, is ultimately what will lead people to abandon their flirtation with them. Smith, Blair and now Starmer all had, and still have, a much better appreciation of the need to run a balanced budget than even some Tories do. That they also want social justice is to their credit as decent people. Most of us are decent people, and we want decent people to represent us.

No-one at all, not even the hardest of the left, believes in open borders, and never did. Controlled, targeted immigration has always been the intention, although sometimes events overtook the good intentions.

It's this kind of slur that drove the lemmings over the Brexit cliff. Those that survive the experience won't make that mistake again. Many of these people are not blue rinse home county Tory
"grass root" voters who would, and did, vote for a clown so long as they wore a Tory label. They are either traditional Labour voters, or swing voters, neither right, nor left. They aren't truly xenophobic. They were just seduced by the thrill of change in a grey world. It's them who hold the balance, and it's them who need to be courted.

If the Tories decide not to, and Labour gets it right, more change is on the horizon.

Whats your definition of Social justice ?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Feb 22 7.05pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This view from the right, that the centre is still to the left, is ultimately what will lead people to abandon their flirtation with them. Smith, Blair and now Starmer all had, and still have, a much better appreciation of the need to run a balanced budget than even some Tories do. That they also want social justice is to their credit as decent people. Most of us are decent people, and we want decent people to represent us.

No-one at all, not even the hardest of the left, believes in open borders, and never did. Controlled, targeted immigration has always been the intention, although sometimes events overtook the good intentions.

It's this kind of slur that drove the lemmings over the Brexit cliff. Those that survive the experience won't make that mistake again. Many of these people are not blue rinse home county Tory
"grass root" voters who would, and did, vote for a clown so long as they wore a Tory label. They are either traditional Labour voters, or swing voters, neither right, nor left. They aren't truly xenophobic. They were just seduced by the thrill of change in a grey world. It's them who hold the balance, and it's them who need to be courted.

If the Tories decide not to, and Labour gets it right, more change is on the horizon.

I don't think so Blair and brown left the country with no money.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 Feb 22 8.05pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Whats your definition of Social justice ?

To give a full and considered answer would take more time than I have at the moment. Essentially ensuring opportunities and fairness for all.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Corbyn to be deselected.