This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
While i agree the invasion of Ukraine was heinous and monstrous,.... i do not recall the same outcry from the Media for the invasions of Iraq or Afghanistan? And agreed, the human-rights of LGBT people were abused in the past and i would support their equality and respect before the law. And the suffering of peoples under slavery in the past was awful. Africans across the Atlantic, Celtic-Brits to Rome or Irish kids traded by Vikings to Byzantium. But lets project ourselves forward to 2030. What crusades, cavalcades and other flags will be filling up the time that should be otherwise used to discuss whether that Referee performed badly again ? Take one option : remove ALL the politics, or overload us with a bit more.... the brutalized peoples of East Timor, the border dispute in Nogorno-Karabac, Catalan Independence, Female Genital Mutilation, Human Rights in Saudi.....etc etc. Football, the clue is in the name ? Steady on Palazio old chap. A bit extreme, but I think I get your point. Of course there's more media attention to the Russian war on Ukraine than those to which you refer, because they're attacking a European ally and this country and others could easily be dragged in. Doesn't bear thinking about. I've read at least three articles in the paper this morning commenting that arguments about trivial issues such as, say, about the standard of refereeing, seem futile in the face of what's going on in Ukraine.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Good points Nuicholas91 and I agree that I do not need celebrities and corporates to lecture me on their concerns. Most global corporates have skeletons in their closet e.g. child labour, poor safety, lack of union recognition or workers rights etc. And yet they feel the need to moralise to the public. Yes another excellent point. I know I went on a massive rant earlier but I really do struggle to take the messages seriously, not within themselves but in the context of who is promoting them. I fail to believe it is in the interests of anyone's hearts more so or even close to their pockets and thus it is not the messages themselves that people take issue with (I would hope not in any case) it is the reasoning/motivation behind the never ending bombardment. Hence, they have hijacked something many people hold most valuable in their lives, football. Am I against all forms of war, racism, homophobia so on and so forth etc. Yes of course. Do I go to football on the weekend purely to watch my team, the sport I love, socialise, bond with others and enjoy myself? I most certainly do. However my passion for football is what is being abused and weaponized for ulterior motives.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The withdrawal of broadcasting sporting rights in Russia over Ukraine is a very specific action intended to try to separate the Putin regime from the Russian people. I disagree with it. But not because it is a political action. I think it's actually a missed opportunity. If the Russian people want to watch the PL, then let them. It's going to be one of the only things they now see which isn't Putin propaganda. Let them see the Uranian flags. Messages on shirts and around the ground. Let the questions be asked. Every journey starts with a single step. The PL could be taking it. I would combat that, as a suggestion WE not an informed and well evidenced opinion, by saying that perhaps the reduction of Russia to Pariah status, financially weakening them and the resultant affects on the population, would most likely be the motivation here and probably far more effective than whatever can be played off as 'Western Propaganda' or I'm guessing easily censored by the state.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I believe the HF has been a strong voice for morality and is a good example of how football and politics are linked by the concept that localities find their voices in a club environment. i will concede that the HF supporting the victims of the Croydon Tramlink accident is ok. But their opinions on, say, the Israel/Palestine conflict ? it is an anachronism.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
i will concede that the HF supporting the victims of the Croydon Tramlink accident is ok. But their opinions on, say, the Israel/Palestine conflict ? it is an anachronism. Football club ownership, the cost of tickets and supporting the local food bank come to mind.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yes another excellent point. I know I went on a massive rant earlier but I really do struggle to take the messages seriously, not within themselves but in the context of who is promoting them. I fail to believe it is in the interests of anyone's hearts more so or even close to their pockets and thus it is not the messages themselves that people take issue with (I would hope not in any case) it is the reasoning/motivation behind the never ending bombardment. Hence, they have hijacked something many people hold most valuable in their lives, football. Am I against all forms of war, racism, homophobia so on and so forth etc. Yes of course. Do I go to football on the weekend purely to watch my team, the sport I love, socialise, bond with others and enjoy myself? I most certainly do. However my passion for football is what is being abused and weaponized for ulterior motives. Agree entirely. All sport is doing is reflecting the most currently acceptable opinions of certain events and causes - any players with different views wouldn’t be encouraged, to say the least. Reducing cultural, societal or political events to slogans, or Tweets, doesn’t help inform anyone’s thought processes.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Politics has been allowed into sport because commercial interests have been allowed to control politics. It's not a coincidence Every opportunity is now used to enforce right think, which itself is designed to make someone more profit. I find myself in agreement with this. Even if certain causes are worth highlighting, I'd rather individuals or groups highlight it off their own backs. As soon as something becomes commercial, it's essentially a business decision and not often based on genuine support for a cause. These businesses would happily hold the exact opposite view in a different culture if that was the profitable move.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I find myself in agreement with this. Even if certain causes are worth highlighting, I'd rather individuals or groups highlight it off their own backs. As soon as something becomes commercial, it's essentially a business decision and not often based on genuine support for a cause. These businesses would happily hold the exact opposite view in a different culture if that was the profitable move. Far better articulated than my own fumbling attempts BlueJay & co. (though calm down it's not hard
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
I believe we should scrap the monarchy, therefore playing god save the queen at the start of the FA cup final is a political statement. Never called for it to be scrapped though, just let it happen. Its impossible to keep politics out of football because the definition of politics is nearly impossible to define. Is showing solidarity behind Ukraine politics? Or is it showing that the country almost universally showing how they feel about the whole thing? Probably both. I think you dont like it because you dont agree with the message. I don't know what the technical term for a right wing tankie is but before this war there were a lot of them lurking around here... Why can’t they just kick a ball for 90 minutes and then go home?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Far better articulated than my own fumbling attempts BlueJay & co. (though calm down it's not hard Cheers! Yes, well meaning consideration, and putting yourself in others shoes, is surely a positive especially when accompanied by something more than just a gesture (tho I appreciate that short of a slapping someone in the face repeatedly, EVERYTHING now including breathing is classified as 'virtue signalling' I guess in football Rashford is the prime example of someone who has publicly tried to push and help certain causes with a bit of passion attached, but he gets flack from some quarters and 'why don't you just play football', so I guess doing anything opens you up to criticism really. Just have do the what you feel is the right thing for the right reasons in life I suppose, and tune out the noise
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.