You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
PatrickA Flag London 20 Apr 22 8.28am

Ward’s role was to stop Alonso and he achieved this aim.
Vieira name checked him as having a good game.
The problem was that he didn’t contribute going forward (not his strength) so we looked pretty toothless down our right side.
Kouyate also did a good job at the back , but we missed both his energy and tenacity in midfield together with Gallagher’s industry.
In the absence of those two in midfield Schlupp played a more disciplined role, rarely breaking forward.
All of the above contributed to the lack of support and service for Mateta and Zaha.
The tactics largely worked defensively but at the same time curtailed our effectiveness going forward.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 8.49am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Ward’s role was to stop Alonso and he achieved this aim.
Vieira name checked him as having a good game.
The problem was that he didn’t contribute going forward (not his strength) so we looked pretty toothless down our right side.
Kouyate also did a good job at the back , but we missed both his energy and tenacity in midfield together with Gallagher’s industry.
In the absence of those two in midfield Schlupp played a more disciplined role, rarely breaking forward.
All of the above contributed to the lack of support and service for Mateta and Zaha.
The tactics largely worked defensively but at the same time curtailed our effectiveness going forward.

I concur with these comments.
My analysis of the game highlighted the points you have raised.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 20 Apr 22 9.24am

It seems obvious to me that next season we have to find a midfield general in the style of a Barry Bannon.

Against Chelsea PV set up a system that, apparently, we had practiced all week but we did not have the right players to make it effective against a far better and skilled team.

As others have said it was a 'Hodgson line-up' and was doomed to failure as we had few chances because we did not have a 'general' to provide. I was dismayed as soon as the line up was announced. Clyne should have played and the usefulness of Schlupp, Ayew and Ward is dubious. Mateta works hard but had no chances and it is a toss-up between him and Edouard who is the better. Bringing on Olise (belatedly) was good but Benteke ???

We will lose Gallagher and need a creator. We could do far worse than lure Eriksen to bring calmness and accurate passing.

If there is not a revival against Newcastle I fear we might sink lower and struggle to match Hodgson's points targets.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 9.30am

Originally posted by Uphill

It seems obvious to me that next season we have to find a midfield general in the style of a Barry Bannon.

Against Chelsea PV set up a system that, apparently, we had practiced all week but we did not have the right players to make it effective against a far better and skilled team.

As others have said it was a 'Hodgson line-up' and was doomed to failure as we had few chances because we did not have a 'general' to provide. I was dismayed as soon as the line up was announced. Clyne should have played and the usefulness of Schlupp, Ayew and Ward is dubious. Mateta works hard but had no chances and it is a toss-up between him and Edouard who is the better. Bringing on Olise (belatedly) was good but Benteke ???

We will lose Gallagher and need a creator. We could do far worse than lure Eriksen to bring calmness and accurate passing.

If there is not a revival against Newcastle I fear we might sink lower and struggle to match Hodgson's points targets.

Under Hodgson we attained 44,49,43 and 44 pts.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Apr 22 9.34am

Originally posted by Willo

Under Hodgson we attained 44,49,43 and 44 pts.

So 8 points in 7 games and we'll amass a points total bettering 3/4 of Hodgson's results, in PV's first season, with a squad comprising primarily of those just in and those on their way out. Not three bad I'd say, not even mentioning the style of football and a trip to Wembley (despite result).

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 9.42am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

So 8 points in 7 games and we'll amass a points total bettering 3/4 of Hodgson's results, in PV's first season, with a squad comprising primarily of those just in and those on their way out. Not three bad I'd say, not even mentioning the style of football and a trip to Wembley (despite result).

On Sunday I heard an alternative view from a gentleman of a certain vintage who is unlikely to be mistaken for a sunbeam.
Hs view was that we have only attained 8 PL victories and the quality of opposition we defeated on the way to Wembley was lacking.
My word,misery attached to him akin to fungus to a dying tree.

Edited by Willo (20 Apr 2022 9.43am)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 20 Apr 22 10.36am

Originally posted by Uphill

It seems obvious to me that next season we have to find a midfield general in the style of a Barry Bannon.

Against Chelsea PV set up a system that, apparently, we had practiced all week but we did not have the right players to make it effective against a far better and skilled team.

As others have said it was a 'Hodgson line-up' and was doomed to failure as we had few chances because we did not have a 'general' to provide. I was dismayed as soon as the line up was announced. Clyne should have played and the usefulness of Schlupp, Ayew and Ward is dubious. Mateta works hard but had no chances and it is a toss-up between him and Edouard who is the better. Bringing on Olise (belatedly) was good but Benteke ???

We will lose Gallagher and need a creator. We could do far worse than lure Eriksen to bring calmness and accurate passing.

If there is not a revival against Newcastle I fear we might sink lower and struggle to match Hodgson's points targets.

Im not so sure it was a 'Hodgson Line-up', Ayew and Benteke would have started if it was.
Also, I take umbrage with comments expecting Us to automatically get more points than Hodgson just because we are now playing 'better football'. It's the first season Since he departed FFS leaving a largely aging squad, and a lot of deadwood. A rebuilding job has been undertaken, and quite frankly think it's amazing that we're anywhere near his points success. I Was expecting being much closer to relegation at this point of the season. The difference is we now have the potential to get a lot more.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Apr 22 10.52am

I echo most in that we were too negative. I thought starting Ward and Butland sent out the wrong message. As far as I'm aware Guaita and Clyne currently hold the GK and RB shirts. Eze was a strange one as he's been so off the pace since returning from injury. Ayew has been great this season and would put in shift to replaced later by Olise to run at leggy defenders towards the end.

We held our own up until the goal but never really ventured forward.

I'm no master tactician but to replace Gallagher I would have been inclined to tell Schlupp to work like a dog for the first 45 mins and leave everything out there as your coming off at half time to replaced by someone else who will do the same (Reidewald perhaps?)

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 20 Apr 22 11.12am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I echo most in that we were too negative. I thought starting Ward and Butland sent out the wrong message. As far as I'm aware Guaita and Clyne currently hold the GK and RB shirts. Eze was a strange one as he's been so off the pace since returning from injury. Ayew has been great this season and would put in shift to replaced later by Olise to run at leggy defenders towards the end.

It doesn't seem more than a couple of weeks ago that there were several posts on here saying how good it was to see Eze back to his best! Not great on Sunday though.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 20 Apr 22 11.22am

Originally posted by JRW2

It doesn't seem more than a couple of weeks ago that there were several posts on here saying how good it was to see Eze back to his best! Not great on Sunday though.

Not sure who posted that, but he's not been close to his best form of last season.

On Sunday he was ok but no more than that.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 20 Apr 22 12.18pm

I think Clyne was very poor for one of the Leicester goals, that may be part of the reason he was dropped. Agree with the comments about the top six f*cking off to the super league so the rest of us can do real football again - they are a bore.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Apr 22 12.40pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I think Clyne was very poor for one of the Leicester goals, that may be part of the reason he was dropped. Agree with the comments about the top six f*cking off to the super league so the rest of us can do real football again - they are a bore.

You know what EH, the more I think about that the more I am inclined to agree.

It has gotten to a 'if you can't beat em', join 'em' stage.

There's your football clubs as they once were, of which we are undoubtedly one, and there are the money spinning corporate machines to a far greater extent then there was previously. I do enjoy watching their games but am becoming increasingly bored of watching games whereby the bench of one team in the Premier League can sometimes be worth multiples of the combined worth of an opposition starting XI.

Not to dismiss the corporate, disneyland-esque atmospheres at football grounds now, the very loose definition of what constitutes a 'fan' and the ridiculous costs associated with going to see your team play or God forbid wearing a replica shirt.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 20 Apr 22 12.48pm

We were undone by one mistake.
When we tried to press, we were killed off by the second goal.

It's no shame to lose to one of the best teams in the world.

What puzzles me is why we changed a successful back four.
How is Ward, who been average all season, suddenly better than Clyne who has done well in recent weeks? You don't drop someone for one poor game, especially for an FA Cup semi final.

Why did we introduce Benteke, who hasn't played for weeks and has been useless, when we had Edouard on the bench?
Is Benteke not good enough for the league, but suddenly good enough for the most important game of the season?
Unfathomable.

Why was Olise not risked for at leat a half in the biggest game this season when we are virtually safe in the league?
We were much better as soon as he came on, which was no surprise at all. Instead, we got Ayew again.

How does that make sense?

What was a fairy predictable result became an absolute certainty.

 

waterfordpal Flag 20 Apr 22 3.35pm

The plan was working up to halftime BUT imagine if we had come out for the second half with Wilf back on the left, Eze in the middle behind Mateta, Olive on the right and reverted to our usual 4 3 3 and really gone for it !
Then if we had got beaten it would be easier to take.
One last thought re Wembley who stole all the toilets that they boasted about when it was rebuilt ? The place is a disgrace.
Also why were fans herded together on the way out in a bottleneck when all they had to do was open the side streets to disperse the crowd ? Someone near me mentioned Hillsborough and the clown who organised the crowd flow should be sacked.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 20 Apr 22 7.10pm

Originally posted by waterfordpal

The plan was working up to halftime BUT imagine if we had come out for the second half with Wilf back on the left, Eze in the middle behind Mateta, Olive on the right and reverted to our usual 4 3 3 and really gone for it !
Then if we had got beaten it would be easier to take.
One last thought re Wembley who stole all the toilets that they boasted about when it was rebuilt ? The place is a disgrace.
Also why were fans herded together on the way out in a bottleneck when all they had to do was open the side streets to disperse the crowd ? Someone near me mentioned Hillsborough and the clown who organised the crowd flow should be sacked.

Seconded. A farce and a brilliant idea to keep the fans together. WAnd wat in heavens name was the point of the people who were just in the way outside the stadium

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Apr 22 12.12pm

the games can be good to watch, I used to like watching champions league when it was on terrestrial not only cos the quality of the football was so good but there was some jeopardy - this eternal top six is just tedious, their success is too secure, that's what makes it dull. If there is another Arsenal v Chelsea final they should abandon the FA Cup.

 

danny choo choo Flag Hayes 22 Apr 22 2.40pm

I did a VLOG for the semi-final.
Enjoy.

[Link]

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Post Match Analysis Semi - Thoughts? What next?