This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Without the vax I have a 99.9 percent chance of survival from covid. Without the vax I have a 100 percent chance of no side effects. People who are vaccinated still carry and spread covid just as much as someone who is unvaccinated. = Science This is correct, but as usual on here reductive and overly simplistic Being vaccinated can help clear the virus from the system faster, therefore reducing the time spent being infectious. = social benefit Declaring oneself unvaccinated and encouraging others to do the same assuming everyone will have the same experience as you, ie. light illness, no hospitalisation, no long covid etc. = selfish and shortsighted It's not all about you, essentially. Just because the survival rate is so high now that doesn't eliminate the very real chances of being severely impacted by it in a multitude of other ways. Edited by SW19 CPFC (09 Jan 2023 1.58pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This is correct, but as usual on here reductive and overly simplistic Being vaccinated can help clear the virus from the system faster, therefore reducing the time spent being infectious. = social benefit Declaring oneself unvaccinated and encouraging others to do the same assuming everyone will have the same experience as you, ie. light illness, no hospitalisation, no long covid etc. = selfish and shortsighted It's not all about you, essentially. Just because the survival rate is so high now that doesn't eliminate the very real chances of being severely impacted by it in a multitude of other ways. Edited by SW19 CPFC (09 Jan 2023 1.58pm)
The difference in survival chances between the vaccinated and unvaccinated is also so close that to criticise someone for not being vaccinated seems moot. If someone is old and/or immune weak I can see the sense of it, but it's always going to be a risk/benefit analysis for the individual. In my view it was always ethically dodgey to tell people to vaccinate for others. It should have been left purely to their own decision without pressure.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This is correct, but as usual on here reductive and overly simplistic Being vaccinated can help clear the virus from the system faster, therefore reducing the time spent being infectious. = social benefit Declaring oneself unvaccinated and encouraging others to do the same assuming everyone will have the same experience as you, ie. light illness, no hospitalisation, no long covid etc. = selfish and shortsighted It's not all about you, essentially. Just because the survival rate is so high now that doesn't eliminate the very real chances of being severely impacted by it in a multitude of other ways. Edited by SW19 CPFC (09 Jan 2023 1.58pm) That's the exact same as telling someone / forcing someone to be vaccinated! Not everyone will have the same experience being vaccinated! Some people have terrible side effects! Some people die from it and some people don't recover for a long time! Pretty selfish telling someone to get an experimental drug who don't need nor want it in my opinion. The best course of action is to respect each and everyone's decision if they want to or not to get it! Regardless a person decision does not affect you!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The difference in survival chances between the vaccinated and unvaccinated is also so close that to criticise someone for not being vaccinated seems moot. If someone is old and/or immune weak I can see the sense of it, but it's always going to be a risk/benefit analysis for the individual. In my view it was always ethically dodgey to tell people to vaccinate for others. It should have been left purely to their own decision without pressure. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jan 2023 2.39pm) Completely agree and it should be left at this! :-)
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
That's the exact same as telling someone / forcing someone to be vaccinated! Not everyone will have the same experience being vaccinated! Some people have terrible side effects! Some people die from it and some people don't recover for a long time! Pretty selfish telling someone to get an experimental drug who don't need nor want it in my opinion. The best course of action is to respect each and everyone's decision if they want to or not to get it! Regardless a person decision does not affect you! As usual the point is completely missed I have no personal issue with people deciding not to take the vaccine, nor any desire to force them to do so. To a rational human what I said is obviously not the 'exact same' (American?) as telling someone to get it. I do however have an issue with people who don't take it encouraging others not to do so, and even more so if it's based on pocket fluff and whimsey. The number of people logged with notable vaccine side effects vs. the number of people who have suffered from infection is night and day. Therefore making out like they're equivalent is misguided. I'd suggest the vaccines (plural, as there are many) are no longer 'experimental'. The sample size and time elapsed alone move us well away from that and will continue to do so. I also take issue in people continually oversimplifying complex issues – as stated the current research indicates that vaccination can reduce the chance of infection due to reducing how long you might be infectious for (social benefit), along with reducing how much viral load the person you are infecting might get (social benefit). It's that simple. ALSO PERHAPS GO EASY ON THE EXCLAMATION! MARKS! IT! TENDS! TO! REDUCE! THEIR! IMPACT! WHEN! OVERUSED! Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Jan 2023 5.23pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Completely agree and it should be left at this! :-) yeah lets not debate anything that warrants debate and go with 'as it's my own decision therefore cancel all other viewpoints'
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
yeah lets not debate anything that warrants debate and go with 'as it's my own decision therefore cancel all other viewpoints' Current debates are exactly like this 'my body my choice' abortion - fine. 'I can be whatever gender I feel like' Trans, LGBTQ etc, fine. Yet, COVID vaccine - 'choice?' take it or you're far right, if you don't agree with vaccination you're an anti-vaxer. Even recognizing that LOADS of people had bad reactions to the vaccine without labelling them conspiracy theorists would be nice.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The difference in survival chances between the vaccinated and unvaccinated is also so close that to criticise someone for not being vaccinated seems moot. If someone is old and/or immune weak I can see the sense of it, but it's always going to be a risk/benefit analysis for the individual. In my view it was always ethically dodgey to tell people to vaccinate for others. It should have been left purely to their own decision without pressure.
Ah but it is more nuanced than that. It's certainly not Moot. For some reason I am always reminding people that viral load is one of the most important factors with COVID, in fact, with any virus really, not whether you get infected or not. So as per research – vaccination increases the speed at which your body can rid itself of the virus, which has the added benefit of reducing how long you're infectious for, which means you're likely to infect less people with less viral load. It's not as simple as 'well everybody's had it so it's all fine now' or 'everybody will get infected anyway'. It's whether you're more succsptible than others and the amount you get infected with that are the most important factors. In my view there's nothing wrong with advising people to take a vaccine to provide a wider social benefit. What is wrong is forcing people to take it if they don't want it. What is also wrong is making the decision not to get it and then encouraging others not to do so based on spurious dross that Brian drinking down the 'ol Lion got third hand from his lobotomised Auntie. Also, final point, even if the government had not pushed vaccination so much (not sure what alternate universe that would happen in, but I'm humouring the suggestion) most people would have taken it and peer pressure would have filled that particular void anyway.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Current debates are exactly like this 'my body my choice' abortion - fine. 'I can be whatever gender I feel like' Trans, LGBTQ etc, fine. Yet, COVID vaccine - 'choice?' take it or you're far right, if you don't agree with vaccination you're an anti-vaxer. Even recognizing that LOADS of people had bad reactions to the vaccine without labelling them conspiracy theorists would be nice. Pretty sure I've not labelled anyone a conspiracy theorist here... It's public fact that a significant number of people, globally, suffered reactions to the vaccines. What people, yet again, fail to be able to remember or comprehend is that relative to the total number of vaccinated this number is within expectations of pretty much every other vaccine on the market. LOADS of people suffer reactions to vaccines on a daily basis. These vaccines are no different. For reference, the Shingles vaccine has a far worse side effect rate than any of the mainstream COVID vaccines. The flu vaccine fares slightly better. Therefore if we all had to take the shingles vaccine tomorrow the numbers would be worse. But the difference is, we don't all take the shingles vaccine at the same time now, do we? And in the context you just put it, the very definition of being opposed to or against something is to be anti it... Besides, for me it's the constant wonky and poorly constructed reasoning behind why a lot of people are anti-vax than being anti-vax in and of itself. Again, entirely up to you, your decision. But if you start spouting utter dross as the reason then I'm going to go for you because it's absolutely intolerable.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ah but it is more nuanced than that. It's certainly not Moot. For some reason I am always reminding people that viral load is one of the most important factors with COVID, in fact, with any virus really, not whether you get infected or not. So as per research – vaccination increases the speed at which your body can rid itself of the virus, which has the added benefit of reducing how long you're infectious for, which means you're likely to infect less people with less viral load. It's not as simple as 'well everybody's had it so it's all fine now' or 'everybody will get infected anyway'. It's whether you're more succsptible than others and the amount you get infected with that are the most important factors. In my view there's nothing wrong with advising people to take a vaccine to provide a wider social benefit. What is wrong is forcing people to take it if they don't want it. What is also wrong is making the decision not to get it and then encouraging others not to do so based on spurious dross that Brian drinking down the 'ol Lion got third hand from his lobotomised Auntie. Also, final point, even if the government had not pushed vaccination so much (not sure what alternate universe that would happen in, but I'm humouring the suggestion) most people would have taken it and peer pressure would have filled that particular void anyway. We would agree on viral load, however due to the reality that vaccinated or not you are going to get infected again I have to say I regard it as moot. The difference between anti bodies from previous infections and vaccines....which are only effective for three or four months and require boosters (who most wouldn't have kept up) means that again I regard it as moot. The harsh horrible reality of covid, as with all infections, is that those who were going to die of that initial infection did. We are seeing significant excess death now long after vaccines were introduced and that's also due to weakened systems for whatever reasons. Considering most adults vaccinated the reality is that for the young and healthy this is of very doubtful benefit in terms of covid. We have agree to disagree on the ethics regarding taking injections for a wider social benefit. I have no issues with people doing that if that's what they think they are doing however I do disagree with you on the ethics of this. Vaccines used to be age appropriate, ie the flu vaccine wasn't offered to all ages and obviously the flu is an infectious pathogen. In my view that's going to be the system going forward and we will see if that's what the system is going to revert to.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
At the end of the day it should be up to someone if they accept or do not accept the risks of getting a vaccine. The information is there now for anyone who was vaccine hesitant or decided to hold off getting it because of lack of info. I like many others made an informed decision about my body that I did not need the vaccine. If anyone made the same informed decision to get the vaccine then no problem. I never told anyone to get or not to get it. Anyways. Back to normal life anyway! I see the amount of people deciding against the booster is high! Also..... !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :-) Again, I never said it shouldn’t be… what’s being discussed is generalising and oversimplification of a complex issue, which was the point of my first reply that has been ignored. As for informed it does of course depend on the quality of the sources of information as to how informed someone actually is. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Jan 2023 7.31pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
We would agree on viral load, however due to the reality that vaccinated or not you are going to get infected again I have to say I regard it as moot. The difference between anti bodies from previous infections and vaccines....which are only effective for three or four months and require boosters (who most wouldn't have kept up) means that again I regard it as moot. The harsh horrible reality of covid, as with all infections, is that those who were going to die of that initial infection did. We are seeing significant excess death now long after vaccines were introduced and that's also due to weakened systems for whatever reasons. Considering most adults vaccinated the reality is that for the young and healthy this is of very doubtful benefit in terms of covid. We have agree to disagree on the ethics regarding taking injections for a wider social benefit. I have no issues with people doing that if that's what they think they are doing however I do disagree with you on the ethics of this. Vaccines used to be age appropriate, ie the flu vaccine wasn't offered to all ages and obviously the flu is an infectious pathogen. In my view that's going to be the system going forward and we will see if that's what the system is going to revert to.
I don’t see how you can regard the benefits of reducing the potential size of infection as a moot point and therefore irrelevant. It’s also a bit simplistic to say that because antibodies are the same for infection and vaccination then it’s irrelevant… timing matters here - pre-emptive vaccination at a time of peak case load would mean if you did get it you’d have it for less time and with potentially less impact on those around you. No vaccination means you’d be likely to have it for longer and it would be worse. As previous. Everyone isn’t getting infected and vaccinated at the same time. As for ethics - surely that’s only an issue if people are being forced to take vaccines. Otherwise as you (and I have said) it’s up to the individual. It is a fact that protecting a population against pathogens has significant social benefits. If more people took the flu vaccine it would have a big positive impact. I also reckon that a good few people who ‘were going to die of that initial infection’ actually didn’t due to the vaccine. Again, flu. I’d wager many many older or more vulnerable people avoid death because of it every year. Also I’m pretty sure the flu vaccine is offered to all age groups. Kids have it as a nasal rather than a needle. Reason? Because since it came in eons ago research indicates that kids are super spreaders when it comes to pathogens. Therefore this approach reduces the impact on the health system. Ultimately the fact people don’t bother slightly counters the benefits but better to have it than not. So not particularly surprising that the viability for younger age groups is being explored. It’s needed for flu, but it might not be needed for COVID. Research.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Again, I never said it shouldn’t be… what’s being discussed is generalising and oversimplification of a complex issue, which was the point of my first reply that has been ignored. As for informed it does of course depend on the quality of the sources of information as to how informed someone actually is. Yes a lot of people who took the vaccine were misinformed of the side effects and adverse reactions and as to why they should take it. But now alot of them have done research and are informed and have chosen not to take the booster shot.
|
|
|
Yes, research is never a bad thing. [Tweet Link]
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Yes a lot of people who took the vaccine were misinformed of the side effects and adverse reactions and as to why they should take it. But now alot of them have done research and are informed and have chosen not to take the booster shot. Pretty sure it's only the vulnerable etc. or older age groups (just like flu, again) that have been invited to take the booster. So on that basis deciding against it as a vulnerable person, on balance, would actually be against the science and research and certainly higher risk than not taking it at all. For what it's worth I see no reason for me to pay to get another shot until the science suggests it's actually necessary. I do tend to get the flu jab annually but like most people I often forget or don't bother, but I know the risk vs benefit means I should really get it. Which brings me back to your original post. I’m not sure how I missed this but you can’t write something as reductive (and untrue) as ‘People who are vaccinated still carry and spread covid just as much as someone who is unvaccinated' then sign off with ‘science’ and expect to not get slammed. Based on the available information your point of view is in fact more emotive and ideological than scientific and logical. And to be clear there’s nothing wrong with that, just don't try to claim your viewpoint and statement is in any way scientifically aligned, because it's currently not. If you actually followed the science you'd always go with the least risky option.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This is not new to me. I bought and read Ben Goldacres book years ago (I think I've recommended this to you before, Bad Pharma). I'm more than aware of how these companies work and the depths they go to. Just look up the Sacklers and Oxycontin if you really want to see how bad it can get. However it would be overly simplistic and not particularly scientific to say Pharma bad therefore all medicine bad. One just has to be rational rather than ideological about these things. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Jan 2023 8.22pm) Well, certainly. I think Russell Brand has done a lot of good work in this area. Anybody sensible knows that medicine is extremely important and very needed....that's part of the problem and why the human need for this most noble of professions is under exploitation by some of the least noble.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, certainly. I think Russell Brand has done a lot of good work in this area. Anybody sensible knows that medicine is extremely important and very needed....that's part of the problem and why the human need for this most noble of professions is under exploitation by some of the least noble. Agreed. The other issue is that the exploitation goes both ways... Big Pharma on one side and people making money out of misinformation on the other. Both exist because of the other and feed off each other. Not much that can be done about that, ultimately you will only get to the best possible conclusion on things if you (again) take a scientific and objective view rather than ideological or pre-determined one.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.