You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Awful
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Awful


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
CPO4OFC Flag Redhill 15 Jan 23 6.11pm

Back from Chelsea and had to post

What has happened to our squad? Zaha looks frustrated playing right wing… schlupp is just absolute dog s**t too scared to make a forward pass… this playing out from
the back is becoming painful to watch week in week out half the time the ball ends up with the opposition before we’ve even made it to the halfway line!

Ok we had a couple of decent chances today but I can’t for the life of me understand why we insist on playing like Man City by trying to pass the ball into the oppositions box… we really need somebody who’s not scared to take a shot like Decoures today!

 

Charlie B Flag 15 Jan 23 6.14pm

From an outside view, Palace have no fight, no grit, no determination. The end is in sight.

 

Jacey Flag 15 Jan 23 6.17pm

SP,in his infinite wisdom,seems to think we need a couple of loan signing and everything will come up smelling of roses,when we are now,given our forthcoming fixtures,in serious trouble and probably,favourites together with Bournemouth,to go down.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 15 Jan 23 6.25pm

You get what you deserve in this league - & it is just not possible to keep on trying to compete on the cheap - even a horrible little club like Bournemouth attracted outside new investment recently.
We have had 10 years in this league now - are we any bigger or established at this level now in that time ?? Methinks not.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 15 Jan 23 6.25pm

I know we have limitations, so there is no perfect fix within the squad.

But I think Hughes deserves to play instead of Schlupp. If we had 2 Doucourés we would have a chance of finding some authority in midfield. Hughes seems to he the nearest fit in that regard.

I also think we need to persevere with either Eduoard or Mateta as a focal point. I don't get what they've done so horrendously wrong compared to everyone else. I know they have underwhelmed, but my God, so have the alternatives. Today I was wondering whether Edouard was actually signed to replace Wilf, given his preference for the inside left position.

I thought we were okay today. But let's be honest, when that goal went in, did a single Palace fan genuinely believe we could equalise? I used to be so confident that we had it in us to give a bloody nose to the elites, but now I have so little expectation.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 15 Jan 23 6.41pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I know we have limitations, so there is no perfect fix within the squad.

But I think Hughes deserves to play instead of Schlupp. If we had 2 Doucourés we would have a chance of finding some authority in midfield. Hughes seems to he the nearest fit in that regard.

I also think we need to persevere with either Eduoard or Mateta as a focal point. I don't get what they've done so horrendously wrong compared to everyone else. I know they have underwhelmed, but my God, so have the alternatives. Today I was wondering whether Edouard was actually signed to replace Wilf, given his preference for the inside left position.

I thought we were okay today. But let's be honest, when that goal went in, did a single Palace fan genuinely believe we could equalise? I used to be so confident that we had it in us to give a bloody nose to the elites, but now I have so little expectation.

Those two changes are exactly what most people must be thinking. I don't think it'll improve us drastically but it might at least provide us with some bite and protection in midfield and the threat of someone running in behind the opposition's defence. It's frustrating to watch. Last season seems like we over performed obviously with the help of Gallagher and now we're really struggling in the second year of transition from Roy's old boys. We're coming unstuck after not continuing to invest in the new squad.

 

benchharp Flag 15 Jan 23 6.42pm

I'm really frustrated by Eze. He seems to get the fans highest rated player on BBC Sport for some unknown reason. He just contributes so little.

So many creative players but no interest in moving the ball forward with any type of urgency.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 15 Jan 23 6.43pm

I don't understand why we are in the middle of a transfer window but nothing appears to be happening to improve the squad? What does it take to get a reaction from our owners? Is it make do and drop down to the Championship while the mythical new stand takes up all the available cash?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

pax3908 Flag 15 Jan 23 6.43pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I know we have limitations, so there is no perfect fix within the squad.

But I think Hughes deserves to play instead of Schlupp. If we had 2 Doucourés we would have a chance of finding some authority in midfield. Hughes seems to he the nearest fit in that regard.

I also think we need to persevere with either Eduoard or Mateta as a focal point. I don't get what they've done so horrendously wrong compared to everyone else. I know they have underwhelmed, but my God, so have the alternatives. Today I was wondering whether Edouard was actually signed to replace Wilf, given his preference for the inside left position.

I thought we were okay today. But let's be honest, when that goal went in, did a single Palace fan genuinely believe we could equalise? I used to be so confident that we had it in us to give a bloody nose to the elites, but now I have so little expectation.

I am becoming reconciled to relegation as much as l don't wish it on us,l think the manager has lost his way completly,why we set up as we do with no centre forward just signals to the opposition we are running scared every match,this continual prattling around in our own half thinking we are man city is not working,we can't hit a barn door,Ayew might be lively but doesn't matter how much running and chasing you do it don't equal goals,we need some battlers in midfield,not Milo or schlupp they are both clapped out,if we don't get a grip pdq we are gone and that will be a disaster! It is so very disappointing after all the hard work that has gone before!!!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Jan 23 6.50pm

Originally posted by CPO4OFC

Back from Chelsea and had to post

What has happened to our squad? Zaha looks frustrated playing right wing… schlupp is just absolute dog s**t too scared to make a forward pass… this playing out from
the back is becoming painful to watch week in week out half the time the ball ends up with the opposition before we’ve even made it to the halfway line!

Ok we had a couple of decent chances today but I can’t for the life of me understand why we insist on playing like Man City by trying to pass the ball into the oppositions box… we really need somebody who’s not scared to take a shot like Decoures today!

It wasn't that bad. Eze really didn't do much though and neither did Schlupp. Hughes was better. Edouard pretty useless when he came on and it is weird how Mateta jumps so late that he always misses headers. But we had some good chances against a relatively weak Chelsea side and overall it was close.

If Gallagher had been on our side we would have won that, quite convincingly.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 15 Jan 23 7.10pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

If Gallagher had been on our side we would have won that, quite convincingly.

Not sure how you came to that conclusion.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 23 7.15pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I don't understand why we are in the middle of a transfer window but nothing appears to be happening to improve the squad? What does it take to get a reaction from our owners? Is it make do and drop down to the Championship while the mythical new stand takes up all the available cash?

Even 'Mr C.Bait' has gone very quiet.

 

auk Flag 15 Jan 23 7.36pm

I don’t think recent performances have been as bad as some are suggesting.

However, I would deploy Zaha (or Olise) differently.

Wilf is very effective at wriggling into space on the edge of the box, but by then the angle is too narrow for him to fire home.

I would give him a central Messi-type role with instructions to shoot on sight.

Back four and keeper looked solid today, and , in midfield, Hughes plays with more purpose than Eze imo.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Jan 23 7.36pm

Bizarre team selections, players not showing heart, aggression, intent plus running less than everyone in the league. Obvious holes in first team and lack of depth in squad. Manager seemingly making same mistakes over and over and with a previous track record of failing second season. Not scoring goals. Very tough run in of games and a forthright statement of no intent to sign anybody this window.

All seems very bleak on the face of things and on the pitch yes, awful. Probably not what anybody wants to hear but there are a few alternative points of thinking:

~ Some other teams and arguably all those below us are in far more disarray.
~ We are still twelfth with game in hand on most
~ Every team suffers a 'slump' and this may well be ours now. Might as well tie in with our toughest run of games
~ We do have some real quality in there, certainly more than some others
~ The likelihood of us going down is actually still low, would take a real turn of events including both us staying in this poor form and other teams miraculously resurrecting.

As things stand, for all my good will, I cannot see us signing anybody to really help the team out or getting anything more than two points until March, I'd actually be grateful just for that but fact is you really just don't know. I fail to believe Parish and co. would stand absolutely still if this dismal run continues and things start to look genuinely perilous. I'd rather PV stay and we do well of course but if not I can see him going and we may revert to type.

Things seem to have taken a dismal turn since the hope and optimism of last year but that may just be the crash back to reality. I will remain a non-fan of the sceptics unless they start putting some money in and we get players off the back of that. My fear is that the financial plan for us was perhaps overestimated and now the powers that be are quietly backtracking on it. My only hope therefore is that we stay in the league, which I have faith (nothing more) we will, and see where we go from there.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Jan 23 8.02pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91


All seems very bleak on the face of things and on the pitch yes, awful. Probably not what anybody wants to hear but there are a few alternative points of thinking:

~ Some other teams and arguably all those below us are in far more disarray.
~ We are still twelfth with game in hand on most
~ Every team suffers a 'slump' and this may well be ours now. Might as well tie in with our toughest run of games
~ We do have some real quality in there, certainly more than some others
~ The likelihood of us going down is actually still low, would take a real turn of events including both us staying in this poor form and other teams miraculously resurrecting.


Ah, the "there are 3 worse teams than us" old chestnut that is uttered whenever we hit a bad patch. It's held good thus far

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 15 Jan 23 8.09pm

Originally posted by benchharp

I'm really frustrated by Eze. He seems to get the fans highest rated player on BBC Sport for some unknown reason. He just contributes so little.

So many creative players but no interest in moving the ball forward with any type of urgency.

I have chuckled a couple of times when I keep hearing about how much talent we have going forward, presumably referencing Zaha, Eze, Olise. I think they're just pundits who don't watch Palace and have seen Eze's goal against Sheffield United a couple of years ago. I honestly don't think I've ever known a Palace player who disappears like he does. I've seen games where he's picked up the ball after half an hour and it will be the first time I realised he was even playing.

OK, so here's my contradictory counter-argument to stick up for these chaps, because I honestly think they're great when at their best. I worry that if they're no good for us, then they'll leave and be good for someone else. Sometimes we are too slow to get the ball 'in there'. Primarily because there's no focal point, and evidently no definitive action plan for what they're actually trying to do. Because there's no obvious target, there's a tendency to pass to someone else when there's no benefit in doing so. Or in Wilf's case, take that extra touch that slows the play and allows the opposition to close the gap that was there for a split second. It's not like we have energetic players marauding forward to join the attack. In these moments we just don't have time for players to think about what they're trying to do.

Olise at his best makes things look so simple. He looks up and plays the simple pass. Wilf, at his age, looked incredible when he beat the same full back 3 times. Olise on form instantly gets the ball and seeks a shot or a cross at the earliest opportunity. Even today, there was a point when Wilf takes an extra touch when you just want him to play it into the box with the first touch. I'm not asking for hoof ball, or the days when plan A was 'Give It To Wilf', I just want the sense that there's a clear attacking strategy that everyone can implement.

We have flair in this team, but very little steel and virtually no energy in the engine room. What happened to the high press? Where has this energy gone? Are our tactics too exhausting (I very much doubt it) or is our fitness substandard? I think I'm right in saying we have used the fewest players this season. If that is the case, and evidently we are not investing, then those players need to be super fit. Is the fact that we basically have a squad of 16 players across 38 games the reason they're not running? Given the World Cup break, I don't believe they're tired. I'm worried the coaching is just a bit s***. We can't be better, we can't be more talented, but we can be fitter and more combative. Yet we just aren't.

The flair cannot flourish without a backbone. I suspect Eze would benefit with 2 industrious central midfielders either behind or alongside. He's never going to be the one to stick the boot in, and be a bit of an annoying s***, like Gallagher was in moments today. We need that. Desperately.

Doucouré - Another Doucouré

Eze

Olise ------------------------------------- Zaha

Édouard

I mean, if we can get our running stats up, move the ball a bit quicker, get some full backs who enjoy getting involed.... that's not the worst attack in the world. Surely? Or am I just naive and biased?


Here's a little reminder of a time when we had dynamism and hope... [Link] I feel sorry for Doucouré, who has never met this version of ourselves.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Jan 23 8.24pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Not sure how you came to that conclusion.

By being there and watching the game. Gallagher was directing much of Chelsea's play in the way that Schlupp wasn't. And he also looked dangerous himself.

He can compensate to some extent for the fact we don't have a striker worth the title.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Jan 2023 8.25pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Jan 23 8.31pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Ah, the "there are 3 worse teams than us" old chestnut that is uttered whenever we hit a bad patch. It's held good thus far

I actually started a thread once with that title SNH!

All that talk of top half and Europe had me going for a while but I think we’re back there now!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 15 Jan 23 8.37pm

When looking at team selection Pulis had one simple crtiteria ‘what does he bring to the team?’
It’s why he was able to get the best out of limited but wholehearted players like Jerome by using his pace and strength to stretch defences and allow Bolassie and Puncheon to flourish.
He was less trusting of flaky players who may not turn up.
It’s why McArthur has subsequently proved so invaluable by turning in at least 7 out of 10 performances when featuring.
Which brings me to our current team.
Guehi, Anderson, possibly Doucoure and arguably Zaha are our only consistent performers.
We have some very talented players who may look world beaters in training, but if they don’t turn up on match days on a regular basis they are no use to the team and would fail that Pulis test.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 23 8.45pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

When looking at team selection Pulis had one simple crtiteria ‘what does he bring to the team?’
It’s why he was able to get the best out of limited but wholehearted players like Jerome by using his pace and strength to stretch defences and allow Bolassie and Puncheon to flourish.
He was less trusting of flaky players who may not turn up.
It’s why McArthur has subsequently proved so invaluable by turning in at least 7 out of 10 performances when featuring.
Which brings me to our current team.
Guehi, Anderson, possibly Doucoure and arguably Zaha are our only consistent performers.
We have some very talented players who may look world beaters in training, but if they don’t turn up on match days on a regular basis they are no use to the team and would fail that Pulis test.

In terms of Eze, it was said about 5 years ago when he was at QPR that he needed to add discipline and work rate to his game.Probably a couple of years later it was stated that when he is "On it" he is unplayable but the problem was that he is not always "On it".
He has the quality,can get past players with ease and score with either foot but at present he is just a 'Luxury player' drifting out of games and not contributing to the team.


Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2023 8.46pm)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Awful