This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by joe_cpfc
Ive just read the Athletic article and it seems PV sacked him. He didn't like the way he dealt with the players after the Everton smashing and apparently thats not the only time. The hairdryer treatment doesn't work anymore for modern players. I believe he wanted Sean as coach because he knew the players and club so well. Now that PV has been at the club a year himself he doesn't need him for that anymore? Perhaps can take a more active coaching role himself now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by joe_cpfc
Ive just read the Athletic article and it seems PV sacked him. He didn't like the way he dealt with the players after the Everton smashing and apparently thats not the only time. The hairdryer treatment doesn't work anymore for modern players. I believe he wanted Sean as coach because he knew the players and club so well. Now that PV has been at the club a year himself he doesn't need him for that anymore? Perhaps can take a more active coaching role himself now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by joe_cpfc
Ive just read the Athletic article and it seems PV sacked him. He didn't like the way he dealt with the players after the Everton smashing and apparently thats not the only time. So PV has the authority over the board to sack someone? Sounds dubious. More likely he had words with Derry and then they took it to the board and when the irreconcilable differences couldn't be sorted out Derry walked / had to go.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palacesince64
Clearly PV was unhappy to find him shouting at players after the Everton game 4 months ago. He must have spoken to him about it back then. The fact he’s gone now suggests he didn’t listen, can’t help himself, or disagreed with Vierra’s more measured style and told him so. I’m sure I read somewhere that PV for the first time in his managerial career tore into his players at Nice following a poor performance after which the lost 5 on the bounce and he got sacked. He’s the boss and his team need to follow his lead or move on. I cannot confirm or deny this, however what is FACT is that we won 2 successive games after the Everton debacle. Edited by Willo (04 Feb 2023 11.02am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Not really. The Ferguson approach worked for some players and not for others, but he was smart and powerful enough to build a squad of players who responded to his hair-dryer method. In contrast, Wenger did exactly the same thing and was successful with the opposite method - not "soft" but calm and measured. There isn't one, fixed "best" management style; different players are motivated by different bosses and good managers find the right players for their approach. Vieira, unsurprisingly given that his mentors are Wenger and Guardiola, is not a disciple of throwing things around the dressing room. That hardly makes him "soft". The caveman-only era is, thankfully, over. An awful lot of contradictions in that paragraph. The hard approach works but it doesn’t, different players react to different approaches. You are missing the whole point that Ferguson was so good because he used to know when to be hard nosed and when to put an arm around someone. Long live the cave man as you like to call it because some of these players who cause dressing room unrest need to be properly managed. Do you think Ronaldo would have been able to cause so much disruption in a Ferguson dressing room? Look at Dych. He’s gone straight into his new job and banned snoods and hats from training and tried to install some discipline and urgency to training sessions. I stick by my opinion that there are too many soft managers around who get easily influenced by senior players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
PV may be the manager but as soon as a better opportunity comes by he'll be off....Derry's paid his dues at the club through some of its hardest times. Team Derry on this one......The club owned him more sensitivity and respect on his departure than this. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Feb 2023 11.06am) If Viera didn't agree with Derry's approach to the players, then he had to go. PV is a black manager handling largely black players. He should be able to manage players the way he wants
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
PV may be the manager but as soon as a better opportunity comes by he'll be off....Derry's paid his dues at the club through some of its hardest times. Team Derry on this one......The club owned him more sensitivity and respect on his departure than this. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Feb 2023 11.06am) I agree PV will be gone in a year or two - people like Derry and McCarthy are the club.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
If Viera didn't agree with Derry's approach to the players, then he had to go. PV is a black manager handling largely black players. He should be able to manage players the way he wants What's that supposed to mean? White people can't comment? Most of us better stop posting. I'll post in a form of reggae or rap from now on.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
If Viera didn't agree with Derry's approach to the players, then he had to go. PV is a black manager handling largely black players. He should be able to manage players the way he wants What's the colour of the manager or player's skin got to do with anything!
|
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
If Viera didn't agree with Derry's approach to the players, then he had to go. PV is a black manager handling largely black players. He should be able to manage players the way he wants I'm not sure what being black has to do with it. I'm not saying that the manager doesn't get to make the decisions....it's their neck on the line and Derry wasn't his man. No, my point was on how the club handled the departure....or rather seemingly just ignored it when Derry is an important figure....and with respect much more important than some Arsenal fly by nighter.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
There's one boss and if Derry overstepped the mark having been told not to then that's on him. It would be damaging to the squad and a sign of weakness if Vieira didn't stamp down on this as you could end up with players also challenging his authority. If Everton was a one off then I'd support Derry, but if he didn't heed warnings (as has been suggested) then Big Pat made the right decision. Despite a bit more clarity we're still probably not getting the full story anyway. One thing I would say is that for all his coolness you wouldn't f*ck with Vieira as he's absolutely massive. I remember Keane admitting that if the fight was outside the stadium Vieira would demolish him. What'll be interesting now is who Vieira brings in as his replacement, whether it's another Palace man, a promotion from within or someone else. My understanding is that a replacement is not planned.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.