You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Franca’s Opportunity??
November 14 2026 5.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Franca’s Opportunity??


Page 4 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 09 Feb 24 6.06pm

Originally posted by est1905

You are pinning all our hopes on him wrong footing Walker? Once? For all you know he might have not even meant that!

If the alternative is to watch Jeff do nothing, then yeah I guess we'll take our chances!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Feb 24 6.11pm

Originally posted by est1905

You are pinning all our hopes on him wrong footing Walker? Once? For all you know he might have not even meant that!


Were you at the Etihad. I was and Franca's introduction helped keep Citeh on the back foot after Mateta's goal. As well as losing the ball on a couple of occasions, he had several successful dribbles and his direct running had the Citeh defence worried.

Like any new player, he needs to start games and not simply be brought on when all seems lost. On the one occasion he did start (FA Cup v Everton) the rest of the team seemed to ignore him in the first 25 minutes even though he was in acres of space on several occasions.

Given our current situation with attacking options, we could do worse than give him a few starts.

 

est1905 Flag 11 Feb 24 12.28pm

Originally posted by doombear


Were you at the Etihad. I was and Franca's introduction helped keep Citeh on the back foot after Mateta's goal. As well as losing the ball on a couple of occasions, he had several successful dribbles and his direct running had the Citeh defence worried.

Like any new player, he needs to start games and not simply be brought on when all seems lost. On the one occasion he did start (FA Cup v Everton) the rest of the team seemed to ignore him in the first 25 minutes even though he was in acres of space on several occasions.

Given our current situation with attacking options, we could do worse than give him a few starts.

Well if he starts Monday we'll see whether all this faith in him is well founded or just wishful thinking. I love nothing more than to see him have a decent game and show signs of why the club paid so much money for him. However, unlike some on here that laughably talk like they are so insightful and that they know more than the coaching staff I have my doubts whether he is yet ready. There is a reason why he hasn't been given more minutes up to now (even with the injuries). I'm starting to wonder if some people would really rather just accuse Roy (a veteran of 47 years in coaching) of not knowing what he is doing and refuse to accept there could actually be a reason we're not using him just so they have another stick to beat him with. I do wonder if a well loved manager was in charge that we all thought walked on water, if he was doing the same thing, if these same people would just accept his decision.
Mourinho many times benched players that the fans thought should be playing. Particularly at United and Spurs. After he left said players were used much more often and those same fans that were moaning started to acknowledge that he was right all along.

 

est1905 Flag 11 Feb 24 12.31pm

Originally posted by doombear


Were you at the Etihad. I was and Franca's introduction helped keep Citeh on the back foot after Mateta's goal. As well as losing the ball on a couple of occasions, he had several successful dribbles and his direct running had the Citeh defence worried.

Like any new player, he needs to start games and not simply be brought on when all seems lost. On the one occasion he did start (FA Cup v Everton) the rest of the team seemed to ignore him in the first 25 minutes even though he was in acres of space on several occasions.

Given our current situation with attacking options, we could do worse than give him a few starts.

This bit is just ridiculous and totally untrue. So now you're blaming his team mates for his average/below par performances?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Feb 24 12.36pm

Originally posted by est1905

Well if he starts Monday we'll see whether all this faith in him is well founded or just wishful thinking. I love nothing more than to see him have a decent game and show signs of why the club paid so much money for him. However, unlike some on here that laughably talk like they are so insightful and that they know more than the coaching staff I have my doubts whether he is yet ready. There is a reason why he hasn't been given more minutes up to now (even with the injuries). I'm starting to wonder if some people would really rather just accuse Roy (a veteran of 47 years in coaching) of not knowing what he is doing and refuse to accept there could actually be a reason we're not using him just so they have another stick to beat him with. I do wonder if a well loved manager was in charge that we all thought walked on water, if he was doing the same thing, if these same people would just accept his decision.
Mourinho many times benched players that the fans thought should be playing. Particularly at United and Spurs. After he left said players were used much more often and those same fans that were moaning started to acknowledge that he was right all along.


Unlike you, many of us don't have blind faith in Hodgson who, clearly in your book, can do no wrong.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Feb 24 12.37pm

Originally posted by est1905

This bit is just ridiculous and totally untrue. So now you're blaming his team mates for his average/below par performances?

If they don't pass to him then yes. I concur with Doombear. You really don't like people who have an honest opinion that doesn't rhyme with yours. Or, do you like being an obnoxious poster? Asking for a friend.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 11 Feb 24 12.38pm

Originally posted by est1905

Well if he starts Monday we'll see whether all this faith in him is well founded or just wishful thinking. I love nothing more than to see him have a decent game and show signs of why the club paid so much money for him. However, unlike some on here that laughably talk like they are so insightful and that they know more than the coaching staff I have my doubts whether he is yet ready. There is a reason why he hasn't been given more minutes up to now (even with the injuries). I'm starting to wonder if some people would really rather just accuse Roy (a veteran of 47 years in coaching) of not knowing what he is doing and refuse to accept there could actually be a reason we're not using him just so they have another stick to beat him with. I do wonder if a well loved manager was in charge that we all thought walked on water, if he was doing the same thing, if these same people would just accept his decision.
Mourinho many times benched players that the fans thought should be playing. Particularly at United and Spurs. After he left said players were used much more often and those same fans that were moaning started to acknowledge that he was right all along.

I understand the point you are making and you are right about mourinho as an example but then there are the other sides of the coin where Vieira wouldn’t play Eze and look how he has been since Vieira left. So yes the truth is none of us know until we see the evidence on the pitch.
What I really want are some threats to occupy the minds of the opposition defense so it’s not an attack v defence training session again. Playing for a 0-0 only builds confidence for the opposition and look what can happen if we concede early

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Feb 24 12.42pm

Originally posted by est1905

This bit is just ridiculous and totally untrue. So now you're blaming his team mates for his average/below par performances?


I have not said that at all. I referred to the one start Franca made when for the first 25 minutes it was if his team mates were ignoring him. I made a point of watching him and his movement in that first half as I was interested to see how he did, as I did with Ozoh at the Etihad. When new players are given a serious outing, I like to focus on them to see how they perform. So my statement of perception (not necessarily fact) is neither ridiculous nor totally untrue.

I suggest you start showing a little respect for other posters on this site as your arrogance seems to know no bounds.

 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Feb 24 1.12pm

This struck me too.
Franca was in acres of space, but wasn't passed to in that first half.
I assumed it was a tactic and the ball would eventually be switched to him,but it didn't happen.


Originally posted by doombear


I have not said that at all. I referred to the one start Franca made when for the first 25 minutes it was if his team mates were ignoring him. I made a point of watching him and his movement in that first half as I was interested to see how he did, as I did with Ozoh at the Etihad. When new players are given a serious outing, I like to focus on them to see how they perform. So my statement of perception (not necessarily fact) is neither ridiculous nor totally untrue.

I suggest you start showing a little respect for other posters on this site as your arrogance seems to know no bounds.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 11 Feb 24 1.29pm

Originally posted by doombear


Were you at the Etihad. I was and Franca's introduction helped keep Citeh on the back foot after Mateta's goal. As well as losing the ball on a couple of occasions, he had several successful dribbles and his direct running had the Citeh defence worried.

Like any new player, he needs to start games and not simply be brought on when all seems lost. On the one occasion he did start (FA Cup v Everton) the rest of the team seemed to ignore him in the first 25 minutes even though he was in acres of space on several occasions.

Given our current situation with attacking options, we could do worse than give him a few starts.

I was at the Everton game few rows back in main stand so agree, the first 25 mins we saw a lot of him close up but not with the ball

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

est1905 Flag 11 Feb 24 1.30pm

Originally posted by doombear


Unlike you, many of us don't have blind faith in Hodgson who, clearly in your book, can do no wrong.

Thats where you let yourself down and talk like a spoilt child. I never said I had unlimited or blind faith in Roy at all. You say this to me because I dont fall in line with your opinion. Its a little pathetic.
Not that I owe you or anyone else an explanation of my opinion but I did not want Roy Hodgson to be extended in the summer. I felt it displayed a lack of ambition as well as a lazy approach from the board but...as a SUPPORTER (clue is in the name) I believe in getting behind the team. Roy is at the head of that team. Do I think Roy is above criticism? No. Do I think he can do no wrong? Of course not. Do I think he is vastly more experienced that any of us by a country mile. Yes. I also think he'll do anything to get the points in games. Including play a young Brazilian the club has paid too much money for if he thinks he'll make a difference. This is why I am presuming that the coaching staff dont think he is ready. Personally, I would accept that and bow to their superior knowledge. You on the other hand seem to think you know better and would prefer to make out the coaching staff are wrong and you are right.
Good luck with that outlook. Not knowing your limits will only obstruct any progress in your life.

 

est1905 Flag 11 Feb 24 1.34pm

Originally posted by doombear


I have not said that at all. I referred to the one start Franca made when for the first 25 minutes it was if his team mates were ignoring him. I made a point of watching him and his movement in that first half as I was interested to see how he did, as I did with Ozoh at the Etihad. When new players are given a serious outing, I like to focus on them to see how they perform. So my statement of perception (not necessarily fact) is neither ridiculous nor totally untrue.

I suggest you start showing a little respect for other posters on this site as your arrogance seems to know no bounds.



Respect is earned. I dont think much will be coming your way lol.
You said his team mates ignored him for the first 25 minutes. I stand by my previous comment on that. Tripe

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 11 Feb 24 2.04pm

Originally posted by est1905



Respect is earned. I dont think much will be coming your way lol.
You said his team mates ignored him for the first 25 minutes. I stand by my previous comment on that. Tripe

It happened. You deny it because like all Hodgson apologists you have to bend the truth to argue the case for a failing manager

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Feb 24 2.14pm

Originally posted by est1905



Respect is earned. I dont think much will be coming your way lol.
You said his team mates ignored him for the first 25 minutes. I stand by my previous comment on that. Tripe

Respect is earned, yes, trouble is you have none & therefore neither do we towards you. Still, generally, keyboard warriors like you, lead an insular life, never mind, eh.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 11 Feb 24 2.19pm

I say give him a start and decent chance to shine against Chelsea. Pass the ball to him and let him run at them with Mateta and Edouard both getting forward for his crosses.

Let’s be positive.

Edited by XKudu (11 Feb 2024 2.20pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Feb 24 2.36pm

Originally posted by est1905

Respect is earned. I dont think much will be coming your way lol.
You said his team mates ignored him for the first 25 minutes. I stand by my previous comment on that. Tripe

Unfortunately it's true as I watched that game and it seemed that his team mates preferred a difficult pass across the pitch rather than give him the ball

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 11 Feb 24 4.30pm

We’ve had 19 days to practice our preferred line up against Chelsea in the absens of Eze and Olise. Safe to assume Richards will slot in for Guehi and Lerma will be one of the DMs. Ozoh has earned his place as the other DM and Mateta will play up front. That being the case Ayew, Wharton and Franca would surely be preferable to Hughes and Sclupp. Edouard on the bench either as a replacement for Mateta or wide left with Ayew moving to the right to replace Franca later on ( not 85 mins please Roy). Ahamada would be an alternative on the bench.

We have options but our weakness is that none of them have had much game time because the same 11 started so often even when they’ve not been playing well. Roy can either be adventurous for a change or stick with Hughes and Schlupp and hope to nick a 0-0.

 

RichardJP Flag Epsom 11 Feb 24 6.18pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

This struck me too.
Franca was in acres of space, but wasn't passed to in that first half.
I assumed it was a tactic and the ball would eventually be switched to him,but it didn't happen.


They did switch after half time and Anderson singled him out a couple of times, once from a free kick just in front of our goal and Fanca was out on his own. When he had the ball he looked dangerous, but then Woy took him off after 60 minutes

Every time he gets an 8 minutes at the end of a game, when all is already lost, he has a punt at goal. He was tearing up the Man City defence, he had a shot on goal against Chelsea, he won the free kick for Eze to waste against Everton, but he isn't getting the time. He just needs to be on the pitch for longer and who knows what will happen.

Edited by RichardJP (11 Feb 2024 7.17pm)

 


Glasner’s Glaziers

RichardJP Flag Epsom 11 Feb 24 6.24pm

It definitely felt like nobody was passing to Richards at the Brighton match though.

The rest of the team obviously think he's the weak link too.


Edited by RichardJP (11 Feb 2024 6.25pm)

 


Glasner’s Glaziers

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Feb 24 8.17pm

Originally posted by palace99

Are are aware that Eze and Olise are injured so we have zero creativity in the team. If those two are fit 100% agree, but things have changed.
As has been said playing Schlupp on the left offers nothing going forward and he's not even bothering to track back - see the 2nd Brighton goal on Sat.
I think it's a gamble worth taking

Maybe. I wouldn't be against it. Schluppy does pose somewhat of a goal threat though...pops up with a few precious goals here and there. Reckon he might do the same against Chelsea!

 

Page 4 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Franca’s Opportunity??