This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The man had the balls to do what the cowards running the Police don't. f*** these people. I agree. But they probably have the wrong police there. Need more Public Order or riot trained police in there. All they have are police who stop you in your car or call for backup to stop one or two people in the street. They’re outnumbered without anything to use. Only going to go one way.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
So did Jimmy Savile. Except what this Bristol man did was legal at the time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Except what this Bristol man did was legal at the time. That really is the point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Except what this Bristol man did was legal at the time. So slavery was OK because it was legal at the time? Sure you want to stick your neck out on that one?
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
So slavery was OK because it was legal at the time? Sure you want to stick your neck out on that one? I wouldn’t want to judge previous generations by today’s standards.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I wouldn’t want to judge previous generations by today’s standards. It’s not hiding it by not having a statue of a slave owner there any longer. History belongs in museums. Statues are supposed to commemorate good.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
It’s not hiding it by not having a statue of a slave owner there any longer. History belongs in museums. Statues are supposed to commemorate good. What are the rules on statues? I don’t know.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
It’s not hiding it by not having a statue of a slave owner there any longer. History belongs in museums. Statues are supposed to commemorate good. Where is the evidence that the people who have been requesting its removal asked for that to happen,just one piece of evidence. There is none I reckon. Not once would that have been middle ground. It's gone now and will cost £1000s to retrieve and repair the damage. Then as soon as its put in a museum it will be attacked again. Like it would have been if it was in a museum already.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
If you read up on it there have been attempts to have it removed by the proper channels for years. This isn’t trying to erase history. Statues are meant to be for those to be idolised. If you are comfortable with a statue for someone who made a fortune out of slavery then that should really make you worry. I already told you I couldn't care less about the statue I am not defending it or slavery I am defending law and order against anarchy. You say attempts have been made to remove it legally, so the local Labour council hasn't been listening to the people? And what if a group decide they don't like the statue of Nelson Mandela? it's okay to tear that down as well? No I didn't think so. I predict now that this is setting an example and other statues will be torn down if they happen to be favourites of the left they will be outraged.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
mmmmm I’m not sure this is as controversial as you’re making out Criminal act aside, no one seems to be saying ‘erase history’ - or that the simple act of removing a slave traders statue, seemingly a symbol of celebration of murder and tyranny, equals that? There are plenty of celebrated and also controversial and horrendous historical figures that don’t have statues and are heavily prominent in written and taught history. They don’t have statues. Does that mean they’re erased from history? Bit of a silly point. Not sure I get the argument As for Churchill - I’m not sure that statue will be pulled down anytime soon. He should be remembered and revered with a statue but he’s not as squeaky clean and good ol England as some might like to make out. Nor was Nelson Mandela, has his statue been defaced? I think I know the answer Edited by Spiderman (08 Jun 2020 8.35am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lucretius
Like, also, the idea that that it's wrong for the public to remove a piece of public property seems contradictory. It was in a public space. The public rose up and took it down. Awesome. Taking ownership of the city. What a bizarre last sentence
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Haha Alternative views are what make for great debate However whatever the view, it should at least be a worthy contribution rather than recycled rhetoric from whatever targeted social media certain individuals had been reading 5 minutes before hand. Even worse when it’s reposted constantly as a form of propaganda communication Do you think the same about DanH? Probably not
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Put it in a museum, where history is documented and for people to learn. A statue suggests they have done something good and should be commemorated. That is what a lot of people suggested. You'd have to find a Museum that's willing to take it due to its historical implications and security issues. You're right, a statue does suggest he did something good... and he did, although the reasons for doing it are debatable. We are talking about a time when the United Kingdon didn't exist. It was 100 years before the USA existed. Ireland was being conquered by Cromwell who committed atrocities theire in the name of religion, but he also brought a constitutional monarchy. You don't see people pulling down his statue, probably because outside Ireland people aren't properly educated about him (even in Ireland its distorted). He also developed a constitutional monarcy, the first nation in the world to have one, 100 years before anywhere else in Europe, and possible a precurser to the democracy we have today. I think it's more important to tell the whole story of how we got to where we are today, rather than just block out the bits we don't like. Pulling it down just reinforces the position that AntiFA are intollerant of anyone who objects to their narrative. I think all the looting and fighting police, what people are trying to achieve has been lost.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The man had the balls to do what the cowards running the Police don't. f*** these people. He probably got arrested for inciting
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
That is what a lot of people suggested. You'd have to find a Museum that's willing to take it due to its historical implications and security issues. You're right, a statue does suggest he did something good... and he did, although the reasons for doing it are debatable. We are talking about a time when the United Kingdon didn't exist. It was 100 years before the USA existed. Ireland was being conquered by Cromwell who committed atrocities theire in the name of religion, but he also brought a constitutional monarchy. You don't see people pulling down his statue, probably because outside Ireland people aren't properly educated about him (even in Ireland its distorted). He also developed a constitutional monarcy, the first nation in the world to have one, 100 years before anywhere else in Europe, and possible a precurser to the democracy we have today. I think it's more important to tell the whole story of how we got to where we are today, rather than just block out the bits we don't like. Pulling it down just reinforces the position that AntiFA are intollerant of anyone who objects to their narrative. I think all the looting and fighting police, what people are trying to achieve has been lost. Is very poignant. If they were at all serious about achieveing anything they cannot possibly think their current actions are going to reach the desired outcome. If anything, they've actually very probably further cemented any ill feeling in many peoples heads. My take away from everything yesterday is 'Black People b!tching and moaning about racism in the UK have decided to attack and `vandalise a statue dedicated to the man who Brits voted as Greatest Briton of all time'. What genius.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
So slavery was OK because it was legal at the time? Sure you want to stick your neck out on that one? No it wasn’t but it was accepted practice at the time. Don’t forget slaves were initially enslaved by black slave traders. Have you ever got on your high horse about young white kids being sent up chimneys or white women having endure workhouses? Not acceptable today but no protests. We cannot be held responsible for events that happened a century or more ago. Where does it stop
|
|
|
Wonder if DanH has any clothes made in Bangladesh? Edited by Spiderman (08 Jun 2020 9.05am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
It’s not hiding it by not having a statue of a slave owner there any longer. History belongs in museums. Statues are supposed to commemorate good. Many people want the statue many don't. Who gives them the right to choose that it comes down?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Is very poignant. If they were at all serious about achieveing anything they cannot possibly think their current actions are going to reach the desired outcome. If anything, they've actually very probably further cemented any ill feeling in many peoples heads. My take away from everything yesterday is 'Black People b!tching and moaning about racism in the UK have decided to attack and `vandalise a statue dedicated to the man who Brits voted as Greatest Briton of all time'. What genius. I didn’t think the London rioting was going to be a good image for young black people at the start and it still isn’t. Government no doubt knew this is likely. At some point the batons will have to come out so the ill feeling will mean the media can’t brainwash everyone the government or police are institutionally racist. Again, something I keep hearing is in Britain today because of a few incidents of racist words or actions from individual cops. The police are not institutionally racist today. Just like ‘oppression’ and ‘white privilege’, another false and exaggerated term for today.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
There is a rational reason to tear down the statue celebrating someone who benefited massively from slavery and death. They had been trying for a number of years to have it removed. I heard about this years ago. Actually I forgot about it and thought it had been removed. If you ask most people, they wouldn’t give a s*** about it. I e heard people from Bristol against the rioting but not concerned the statue has gone. If anything it holds the city back. Again, the suggestion was a museum of slavery. 300 years ago and real oppression, not the so called oppression I’m hearing daily today, was real torture was awful then and awful now. I’ve never watched any documentaries or historical dramas on slavery and just thought it was legitimate then so that’s that. Keeping that statue up is like a ‘fvck you it’s staying and you’re going to see it everyday’ to black people. The stance of maintaining it should stay goes beyond principles of law and all that and starts to show prejudice. It’s the sort of thing I’d expect in Mississippi in the ‘60s. Even if you had a dislike or whatever of black people it’s not a great position to take to stand firm and say they must put up with the statue whatever and lump it. In general there’s going to have to be some compromises and meeting in the middle and standing firm on a slave trader’s statue isn’t the best start. That said the batons should’ve come out at Churchill’s statue but the mistake was made not doing that when the police were attacked on Saturday. That developed probably because they sense the weakness from bending the knee and generally being pussies and not true police. Well I knew that anyway. Standing in chip shop queues I could probably take a few of them without batons. No wonder they’re getting humiliated. I'm sorry, but this man who died 300 years ago has no bearing on anyone living today. No one has the right to damage public property because of some lame brained notion of political correctness.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.