You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 41 of 65 < 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 05 Apr 19 2.05pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

That’s an easy one.

Not being in a relegation fight every year.

So about six points more than we have at the moment, which we would have if we’d had a couple of half decent strikers all season.
What was the point of this thread again?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 2.16pm

Originally posted by Painter

To be in a relegation fight, you need to be near the relegation places, which we haven’t this year at any point.

That is nonsense, as you know.

We have been in the mix for relegation and been in the discussion all year.

If you never thought we were in danger of relegation, fair play to you.

Edited by Maine Eagle (05 Apr 2019 2.18pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 2.26pm

Originally posted by berlinpalace

So about six points more than we have at the moment, which we would have if we’d had a couple of half decent strikers all season.
What was the point of this thread again?

We could have had batistuta out there on Wednesday and we still wouldn’t have scored.

Strikers need service. Service means having a game plan which remotely supports the creation of goal chances.

Benteke was banging the goals in for us before Roy. Apparently Roy wanted Sorloth.

If you really believe that we would be pushing for Europe if only we had better strikers, and that Roy is absolved of all blame for our poor performances this year, then I say good luck to you.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 05 Apr 19 5.40pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We could have had batistuta out there on Wednesday and we still wouldn’t have scored.

Strikers need service. Service means having a game plan which remotely supports the creation of goal chances.

Benteke was banging the goals in for us before Roy. Apparently Roy wanted Sorloth.

If you really believe that we would be pushing for Europe if only we had better strikers, and that Roy is absolved of all blame for our poor performances this year, then I say good luck to you.

Just read back through the post match comments for this season, game after game fans complaining about reasonable chances missed. You want to ignore everything that’s happened before fine but it makes your position look ridiculous.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 5.49pm

Originally posted by berlinpalace

Just read back through the post match comments for this season, game after game fans complaining about reasonable chances missed. You want to ignore everything that’s happened before fine but it makes your position look ridiculous.

Many chances have been missed, mainly at home, which indicates some kind of mental issue which the manager needs to fix.

There were not many fans complaining about reasonable chances missed against Spurs, as we didnt have any.

Poor conversion rate is definitely a factor, dont get me wrong, but to absolve Hodgson and his defeatist negative rigid tactics and team selections from any blame for the malaise this year is quite ridiculous too.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Apr 19 6.49pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Many chances have been missed, mainly at home, which indicates some kind of mental issue which the manager needs to fix.

There were not many fans complaining about reasonable chances missed against Spurs, as we didnt have any.

Poor conversion rate is definitely a factor, dont get me wrong, but to absolve Hodgson and his defeatist negative rigid tactics and team selections from any blame for the malaise this year is quite ridiculous too.

Nobody is doing that. It's a results business and results have been disappointing. But people such as you want to lay all the blame for whatever doesn't satisfy you at Hodgson's door.

And if you want to talk about the ridiculous, then your assertion that you'd rather see Palace relegated playing good football than Hodgson continue certainly fits into that category.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

G O Eagle Flag 05 Apr 19 8.30pm

Interesting to see Southampton - a team placed below us - taking on Liverpool - a team placed above Spurs:

Trying to take on the game, playing well, leading 1 - 0.

They may end up loosing 1 - 2, but if they had been managed by Hodgson, they wouldn’t attack, defend with 11 players, and loose 0 - something!

To say nothing about entertainment...

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Apr 19 8.57pm

Originally posted by G O Eagle

Interesting to see Southampton - a team placed below us - taking on Liverpool - a team placed above Spurs:

Trying to take on the game, playing well, leading 1 - 0.

They may end up loosing 1 - 2, but if they had been managed by Hodgson, they wouldn’t attack, defend with 11 players, and loose 0 - something!

To say nothing about entertainment...

Home against Liverpool they cheated for pen in the 45th min and then at the death 93 mins got us on the break, we were unlucky the same as at their ground, stop trying to find things to hang on our very decent manager ..it is becoming very boring.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Apr 19 9.05pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We could have had batistuta out there on Wednesday and we still wouldn’t have scored.

Strikers need service. Service means having a game plan which remotely supports the creation of goal chances.

Benteke was banging the goals in for us before Roy. Apparently Roy wanted Sorloth.

If you really believe that we would be pushing for Europe if only we had better strikers, and that Roy is absolved of all blame for our poor performances this year, then I say good luck to you.

Benteke came to national attention for the bucket load of chances he missed last season and got the yips in front of goal. He’s also missed significant spells with injury both this and last. But Roy has ruined him by not providing enough service.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 10.37pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Benteke came to national attention for the bucket load of chances he missed last season and got the yips in front of goal. He’s also missed significant spells with injury both this and last. But Roy has ruined him by not providing enough service.

I agree, Roy has a lot to answer for regarding benteke’s woes

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 05 Apr 19 11.14pm

Please retire at the end of the season Roy.

You are a gentleman but your times up sadly.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 11.26pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Nobody is doing that. It's a results business and results have been disappointing. But people such as you want to lay all the blame for whatever doesn't satisfy you at Hodgson's door.

And if you want to talk about the ridiculous, then your assertion that you'd rather see Palace relegated playing good football than Hodgson continue certainly fits into that category.

I didnt say I would rather see us go down, playing better football, I said I have the ball strength to throw the dice on that for the sake of better football. But thats obvious, when Roy goes, we need a new manager, and if we find one quite as negative, defeatist and timid as Roy, I would be amazed.

If Hodgson was 45 years old, I might be inclined to agree that we should let him carry on, but he is not.

We have some players at the club who are being negatively affected by his overly cautious and boring approach to football games. Zaha springs to mind.

It boils down to ball strength, if we have enough then we should move on from Roy now, and try to get a younger manager in who is tactically more flexible and forward thinking.

Could that go tits up? You bet, but RH is leaving anyway at the end of next year, and we are kicking the can down the road - the issue needs to be dealt with.

If you are going to go to Tottenham, and play long ball, dont pick a small mobile striker who likes to run in behind, who cannot hold it up.

Its not rocket science.

Remember England under Hodgson? Shackled, timid, afraid, same s*** as most of the last 25 years or so.

Look at them now. Shackles off, free flowing, confident, enjoying their football.

We need some have some guts and move on from this soon to be retired manager.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Apr 19 11.27pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Please retire at the end of the season Roy.

You are a gentleman but your times up sadly.

Allow me to retort:

Blah blah Charlton, blah blah Curbishley...blah blah premier league money, blah no strikers, blah blah not Roy's fault, blah blah.

Saved some folks a post here.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 06 Apr 19 12.04am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I didnt say I would rather see us go down, playing better football, I said I have the ball strength to throw the dice on that for the sake of better football. But thats obvious, when Roy goes, we need a new manager, and if we find one quite as negative, defeatist and timid as Roy, I would be amazed.

If Hodgson was 45 years old, I might be inclined to agree that we should let him carry on, but he is not.

We have some players at the club who are being negatively affected by his overly cautious and boring approach to football games. Zaha springs to mind.

It boils down to ball strength, if we have enough then we should move on from Roy now, and try to get a younger manager in who is tactically more flexible and forward thinking.

Could that go tits up? You bet, but RH is leaving anyway at the end of next year, and we are kicking the can down the road - the issue needs to be dealt with.

If you are going to go to Tottenham, and play long ball, dont pick a small mobile striker who likes to run in behind, who cannot hold it up.

Its not rocket science.

Remember England under Hodgson? Shackled, timid, afraid, same s*** as most of the last 25 years or so.

Look at them now. Shackles off, free flowing, confident, enjoying their football.

We need some have some guts and move on from this soon to be retired manager.

Brilliant post.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Apr 19 5.36am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I didnt say I would rather see us go down, playing better football, I said I have the ball strength to throw the dice on that for the sake of better football. But thats obvious, when Roy goes, we need a new manager, and if we find one quite as negative, defeatist and timid as Roy, I would be amazed.

If Hodgson was 45 years old, I might be inclined to agree that we should let him carry on, but he is not.

We have some players at the club who are being negatively affected by his overly cautious and boring approach to football games. Zaha springs to mind.

It boils down to ball strength, if we have enough then we should move on from Roy now, and try to get a younger manager in who is tactically more flexible and forward thinking.

Could that go tits up? You bet, but RH is leaving anyway at the end of next year, and we are kicking the can down the road - the issue needs to be dealt with.

If you are going to go to Tottenham, and play long ball, dont pick a small mobile striker who likes to run in behind, who cannot hold it up.

Its not rocket science.

Remember England under Hodgson? Shackled, timid, afraid, same s*** as most of the last 25 years or so.

Look at them now. Shackles off, free flowing, confident, enjoying their football.

We need some have some guts and move on from this soon to be retired manager.

Very good ME, there can be no practical argument against what you say here. I would add to that by looking at the way the top 2 teams in the country currently play. High pressing, fast flowing football that relies on quick interplay between a flexible attack who can slot into each other’s positions. We unfortunately are a one trick pony insofar as we sit in a rigid formation that sinks deeper and deeper as we get under more and more pressure with the occasional relief of a counter attack where we look to try and nick a goal.

Roy without doubt has a system that works to get you a certain amount of points per season, but it is not forward thinking and is not entertaining. I believe we have good enough players to play in a more expansive manner and that’s where I 100% agree that if we want to improve as a team then we need a different approach and ultimately that means a different manager.

I don’t agree with the argument that we have tried this already with Pardew and FdeB, they were just the wrong people for the job. The former had no idea about defending and the latter, well, absolutely no idea about football at all based on his latest managerial history. If we can find a manager that can combine the defensive organisation of Roy with the forward play of Pardew then we will I believe progress to a different level. As Maine Eagle has pointed out, we are currently stifling the talent that we have and it isn’t pretty to watch.

The next managerial appointment is massive for Palace not only to improve us but to show the talented individuals within our squad that we want to play to their strengths. Over to you SP, it’s not going to be easy but the next appointment is critical and it has to come this summer.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Apr 19 8.14am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Very good ME, there can be no practical argument against what you say here. I would add to that by looking at the way the top 2 teams in the country currently play. High pressing, fast flowing football that relies on quick interplay between a flexible attack who can slot into each other’s positions. We unfortunately are a one trick pony insofar as we sit in a rigid formation that sinks deeper and deeper as we get under more and more pressure with the occasional relief of a counter attack where we look to try and nick a goal.

Roy without doubt has a system that works to get you a certain amount of points per season, but it is not forward thinking and is not entertaining. I believe we have good enough players to play in a more expansive manner and that’s where I 100% agree that if we want to improve as a team then we need a different approach and ultimately that means a different manager.

I don’t agree with the argument that we have tried this already with Pardew and FdeB, they were just the wrong people for the job. The former had no idea about defending and the latter, well, absolutely no idea about football at all based on his latest managerial history. If we can find a manager that can combine the defensive organisation of Roy with the forward play of Pardew then we will I believe progress to a different level. As Maine Eagle has pointed out, we are currently stifling the talent that we have and it isn’t pretty to watch.

The next managerial appointment is massive for Palace not only to improve us but to show the talented individuals within our squad that we want to play to their strengths. Over to you SP, it’s not going to be easy but the next appointment is critical and it has to come this summer.

There is one.

Parish lives year to year or 6 months to 6 months struggling to keep his investment in the premier league in the hope that somebody will buy the majority shareholding of the club or hopefully all of it.

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Apr 19 8.38am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Very good ME, there can be no practical argument against what you say here. I would add to that by looking at the way the top 2 teams in the country currently play. High pressing, fast flowing football that relies on quick interplay between a flexible attack who can slot into each other’s positions. We unfortunately are a one trick pony insofar as we sit in a rigid formation that sinks deeper and deeper as we get under more and more pressure with the occasional relief of a counter attack where we look to try and nick a goal.

Roy without doubt has a system that works to get you a certain amount of points per season, but it is not forward thinking and is not entertaining. I believe we have good enough players to play in a more expansive manner and that’s where I 100% agree that if we want to improve as a team then we need a different approach and ultimately that means a different manager.

I don’t agree with the argument that we have tried this already with Pardew and FdeB, they were just the wrong people for the job. The former had no idea about defending and the latter, well, absolutely no idea about football at all based on his latest managerial history. If we can find a manager that can combine the defensive organisation of Roy with the forward play of Pardew then we will I believe progress to a different level. As Maine Eagle has pointed out, we are currently stifling the talent that we have and it isn’t pretty to watch.

The next managerial appointment is massive for Palace not only to improve us but to show the talented individuals within our squad that we want to play to their strengths. Over to you SP, it’s not going to be easy but the next appointment is critical and it has to come this summer.

Re the 2nd paragraph I’ve seen little this season to suggest that a midfield with choices from (Luka aside) Kouyate, Meyer, Schlupp, McArthur, Riedewald is capable of bringing expansive football.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 06 Apr 19 9.15am

If you look at the table all the teams below us have scored fewer goals and Wolves, who are generally agreed to be entertaining, have scored two more than us. Exactly how much more entertaining do you expect us to be?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Apr 19 9.24am

Originally posted by berlinpalace

If you look at the table all the teams below us have scored fewer goals and Wolves, who are generally agreed to be entertaining, have scored two more than us. Exactly how much more entertaining do you expect us to be?

How many penalties have we scored this season? It feels like 80% of our goals at home are penalties. Is Luca top goal scorer?

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Apr 19 9.29am

Originally posted by berlinpalace

If you look at the table all the teams below us have scored fewer goals and Wolves, who are generally agreed to be entertaining, have scored two more than us. Exactly how much more entertaining do you expect us to be?

This is very true but I suspect those that are complaining are basing their opinions on our dire home form and performances.

We have scored 13 Home goals the second worst (Huddersfield worst) and quite a few have been penalties.Wolves by contrast have scored 24 home goals.

Edited by Willo (06 Apr 2019 9.36am)

 

Page 41 of 65 < 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread