This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
So it's the Police's fault? Or Cressida Dickhead’s or Sadiq Khant’s fault. They’re effectively in charge. Pathetic the pair of then. Or if you mean the morons who’ve been going on about Churchill being racist for the last couple of years, yes them too.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Absolutely. And people were defending it. Then the Police moved them on. And allowed it to be defaced. That statue could have been protected but they CHOSE not to. Not so much the cops on the ground, who are clearly being sacrificed hence them not being allowed to wear protective gear from the start, but their leadership are fully compromised. From that idiot Cop down in Bristol effectively giving his blessing to what happened with that statue to the Chief Constable of Kent taking the knee along with numerous other examples the leadership of those we expect to uphold law and order are in cahoots with the rioters. Helping them get away with literally murder. I share Matov's abhorrence to the feeble Police response acting on orders. The Government really need to have a long hard look at Policing in this country in response to reprobates hell-bent on wanton damage,violence and thuggery. Personally I would have been delighted to witness water-cannons showering the cowering oafs with plumes of liquid, tear-gas being deployed, or even rubber bullets and batons used with some force. I viewed with disgust a chap on the Cenotaph being urged (Or would encouraged be more appropriate) by Police to get down and this person was probably hurling bile in their faces.A few hefty thwacks on the legs with a baton would have had the desired effect. Police simply allowing thugs to deface buildings and statues and to dismantle a statue is certainly not what I like to see. It has been reported that those who committed acts of violence and thuggery will be held responsible. I won't hold my breath. A total of an 27 officers injured,images of an officer with blood running down his face, a lady officer lying on the ground after falling off her horse and taken to hospital with a broken collar bone and other injuries, a cycle being hurled at a Police horse etc etc. Totally and utter despicable. I don't have a proclivity to engage in such debates, in actual fact I rarely view any of the political threads as I engage in numerous such discussions outside of HOL.
Edited by Willo (08 Jun 2020 11.57am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Or Cressida Dickhead’s or Sadiq Khant’s fault. They’re effectively in charge. Pathetic the pair of then. Or if you mean the morons who’ve been going on about Churchill being racist for the last couple of years, yes them too. I suspect that any attempt to stop this idiocy would have ended in major disorder and injuries everywhere. Maybe it is better to see the moronic and destructive nature of these kinds of people in all it's glory. It will do them more damage than being arrested.
|
|
|
If you read the plaque that as an MP he defended the city’s ’right’ to trade in enslaved Africans you can see how people felt the statue should have been removed. It may have been legal, but it was highly immoral and he defended against people telling him it was immoral to trade human beings. In time nobody will give a toss that it’s been moved as nobody cared or knew it was there. Other more significant statues on the other hand...
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I suspect that any attempt to stop this idiocy would have ended in major disorder and injuries everywhere. Maybe it is better to see the moronic and destructive nature of these kinds of people in all it's glory. It will do them more damage than being arrested. My feelings exactly. We don't really need to be the USA.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I suspect that any attempt to stop this idiocy would have ended in major disorder and injuries everywhere. Maybe it is better to see the moronic and destructive nature of these kinds of people in all it's glory. It will do them more damage than being arrested. I suspect number 10 are in agreement to let them embarrass themselves. If it continues the batons have to come out and many won’t care. Owen Jones has missed his chance to criticise the government now because the police will be responding to rioters and not peaceful protesters after it’s got out of hand and his feeble attempt was to criticise the tactic of using horses on Saturday. Well if you hurl bricks and bicycles at a horse then the horse becomes dangerous. Before then all I saw of horses was them standing there. Funny that. The right to throw bricks and bicycles at buildings, police and defenceless animals. Sums him and these college age losers up for me.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
If you read the plaque that as an MP he defended the city’s ’right’ to trade in enslaved Africans you can see how people felt the statue should have been removed. It may have been legal, but it was highly immoral and he defended against people telling him it was immoral to trade human beings. In time nobody will give a toss that it’s been moved as nobody cared or knew it was there. Other more significant statues on the other hand... It's not really about Colston, it's about the slippery slope. There is no logic to destroying a statue but it is quite reasonable to question its suitability for public display.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
If you read the plaque that as an MP he defended the city’s ’right’ to trade in enslaved Africans you can see how people felt the statue should have been removed. It may have been legal, but it was highly immoral and he defended against people telling him it was immoral to trade human beings. In time nobody will give a toss that it’s been moved as nobody cared or knew it was there. Other more significant statues on the other hand... Just a little side point here. I kind of agree that Colston should have been removed some time ago. However, the statue should be in a museum, university, council building or something - in a back room yet preserved. Not all history can be 'good' or ethically 'correct' for today's standards. Ripping things down and chucking them in a river is not a decent way to go about things, in my book.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Slight difference is this statue is celebrating someone who hugely benefited from slavery. I’m just not that bothered by it. If it means that much to them for it not to be on public view then it’s a small price to pay I’d say. When you say where does it all end, I’d say when are the police going to get the batons out? That’s how you put a stop to things. Law enforcement. They haven’t gone in early to fall into a trap so now they can get equipped and stand for no more liberties being taken. I’ve heard quite a few people from Bristol speak. I haven’t heard anyone say it should remain there. Only people dotted around the country who’ve probably never seen or noticed it but stand by the principle that nothing historical ever gets moved. I heard about the moves to have it moved years ago and I thought it had been. Instead they were ignored. Loads of people think it should have been moved years ago, including conservatives. I’m far more concerned with police leaving statues of heroic figures of independence to be defaced than a statue a lot of people weren’t even aware of until yesterday. I’m all a bit meh about this one. It’s a small victory. The real issue is law and order where they’re half trying to enforce it. We differ on this. I have no care about a Bristol figure related to its past and I can understand why a percent will be against this statue. I am also against certain statues but I would never support mob rule in a democratic state.....Has state control broken down? In a democratic state, there are legal processes that are required and hence this is a criminal act and I'd restore this statue under armed guard if required. If enough people in Bristol want this statue removed they must do it legally. If the legal processes fail, well then the losers have to suck it up as that is the point of a democracy. If they succeed fine.....again, that's democracy.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Just a little side point here. I kind of agree that Colston should have been removed some time ago. However, the statue should be in a museum, university, council building or something - in a back room yet preserved. Not all history can be 'good' or ethically 'correct' for today's standards. Ripping things down and chucking them in a river is not a decent way to go about things, in my book. Absolutely agree. Should be in a museum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
We differ on this. I have no care about a Bristol figure related to its past and I can understand why a percent will be against this statue. I am also against certain statues but I would never support mob rule in a democratic state.....Has state control broken down? In a democratic state, there are legal processes that are required and hence this is a criminal act and I'd restore this statue under armed guard if required. If enough people in Bristol want this statue removed they must do it legally. If the legal processes fail, well then the losers have to suck it up as that is the point of a democracy. If they succeed fine.....again, that's democracy. This is where we go round in circles because the attempts at a democratic decision were ignored. I can imagine the reaction to riot police dealing with this statue removal yesterday. As I said, it’s a small victory they’re willing to let go because they probably also don’t feel it’s necessary he statue is there. Like you, I’m not that fussed about it and I reckon nobody will be in time either. It’s about more than this statue and this is my concern. When the young black people who are just like low income white people next have a reason to go on a rampage. Plenty have ability, glass ceilings, face subtle racist problems etc and that’s fine to deal with. The problem is when I hear about not having a father or an education.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
This is where we go round in circles because the attempts at a democratic decision were ignored. I can imagine the reaction to riot police dealing with this statue removal yesterday. As I said, it’s a small victory they’re willing to let go because they probably also don’t feel it’s necessary he statue is there. Like you, I’m not that fussed about it and I reckon nobody will be in time either. It’s about more than this statue and this is my concern. When the young black people who are just like low income white people next have a reason to go on a rampage. Plenty have ability, glass ceilings, face subtle racist problems etc and that’s fine to deal with. The problem is when I hear about not having a father or an education. So when democracy doesn't deliver what you want you go out and destroy property? One needs to separate arguments about the suitability of statues and mindless vandalism.
|
|
|
As previously posted this should be of more concern than a statue. Even if these figures are wrong by 50% they are still shocking.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Slight difference is this statue is celebrating someone who hugely benefited from slavery. I’m just not that bothered by it. If it means that much to them for it not to be on public view then it’s a small price to pay I’d say. When you say where does it all end, I’d say when are the police going to get the batons out? That’s how you put a stop to things. Law enforcement. They haven’t gone in early to fall into a trap so now they can get equipped and stand for no more liberties being taken. I’ve heard quite a few people from Bristol speak. I haven’t heard anyone say it should remain there. Only people dotted around the country who’ve probably never seen or noticed it but stand by the principle that nothing historical ever gets moved. I heard about the moves to have it moved years ago and I thought it had been. Instead they were ignored. Loads of people think it should have been moved years ago, including conservatives. I’m far more concerned with police leaving statues of heroic figures of independence to be defaced than a statue a lot of people weren’t even aware of until yesterday. I’m all a bit meh about this one. It’s a small victory. The real issue is law and order where they’re half trying to enforce it. Personally I don't think the statue should have been erected in the first place,however they had a referendum (we love those don't we children),and 11000 people said it should be taken down,the population of Bristol is over half a million...what's that 2%.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Originally posted by elgrande
Personally I don't think the statue should have been erected in the first place,however they had a referendum (we love those don't we children),and 11000 people said it should be taken down,the population of Bristol is over half a million...what's that 2%. There's that pesky democracy again. It's soooo unfair when they don't get their way.
One more point |
|
|
How do you all feel about this history being destroyed?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.