You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 42 of 71 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 >
martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 17 Nov 18 9.08pm

If/When the HF move to E block and constantly stand and obscure views of others, take photos or videos then complain to the FA and the Sports Ground Safety Authority.

[Link]

Even the threat of this should make Parish & co sit up.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Nov 18 9.12pm

Originally posted by martin2412

If/When the HF move to E block and constantly stand and obscure views of others, take photos or videos then complain to the FA and the Sports Ground Safety Authority.

[Link]

Even the threat of this should make Parish & co sit up.

I think only the view of a small circumference from the furthest corner flag will be blocked from view so people will stand when we’re defending those as well as attacking down there.

 


COYP

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 17 Nov 18 9.20pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think only the view of a small circumference from the furthest corner flag will be blocked from view so people will stand when we’re defending those as well as attacking down there.

Rudi, do you honestly think that the HF are only going to stand so that they can see what's going on in the corner, and then sit down ? Come on.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Nov 18 9.29pm

.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Nov 2018 10.13pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Nov 18 9.30pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Rudi, do you honestly think that the HF are only going to stand so that they can see what's going on in the corner, and then sit down ? Come on.

No. They stand all game but they only block the sitters’ view of 1/4 of a circle from the Holmesdale corner flag area. Everyone stands up when we’re attacking in the box so this is just a bit more standing out of your seat. They’ll be standing in the back 20 rows.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Nov 2018 10.14pm)

 


COYP

.TUX. Flag 17 Nov 18 9.58pm

I can't wait for the 'changes' proposed for next season.
The HF have earned the right imo.

Bring it on and bring our atmosphere back.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Nov 18 10.09pm

Where are they ?
Every week goes by less credibility.

 

Lal Flag Thornton Heath 17 Nov 18 10.16pm

Joke where are they hiding away! No matter how the sing and waves their flags want make any difference to the score never did last season on our winless run. Earnt it no they have not, stay with the team through all ups and downs not when you throw a fit so you can get your own way.

 

.TUX. Flag 17 Nov 18 10.24pm

Originally posted by Lal

Joke where are they hiding away! No matter how the sing and waves their flags want make any difference to the score never did last season on our winless run. Earnt it no they have not, stay with the team through all ups and downs not when you throw a fit so you can get your own way.

Is not, and never has been the point.
Are you a 'Puncture fixer' apprentice?

 


Buy Litecoin.

bicycle repair man 17 Nov 18 11.31pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Is not, and never has been the point.
Are you a 'Puncture fixer' apprentice?


The score is not the point ?
Very odd.
Then what is the point ?

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 18 Nov 18 4.11am

Do you remember when the away fans sat up the other end of the AW? that was why the HFcongregated up that side of the Homesdale originally. Then the club decided to move the away fans up the other end of the AW that must have proved disruptive for some fans. So it’s been done before. I’m afraid I can’t remember the detail. Can anyone?

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Nov 18 4.57am

That is a very good point and first time I have seen it mentioned in the whole debate.

Unfortunately it meant the Family Stand corner where there is a higher proportion of families and kids gets appalling abuse from some of the visiting away fans

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Do you remember when the away fans sat up the other end of the AW? that was why the HFcongregated up that side of the Homesdale originally. Then the club decided to move the away fans up the other end of the AW that must have proved disruptive for some fans. So it’s been done before. I’m afraid I can’t remember the detail. Can anyone?

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Nov 18 6.07am

Originally posted by HKOwen

That is a very good point and first time I have seen it mentioned in the whole debate.

Unfortunately it meant the Family Stand corner where there is a higher proportion of families and kids gets appalling abuse from some of the visiting away fans

This is true but with regards moving people, it probably had to move 9 people out of those Arfur seats, and 3 of them got in free in the 2nd half.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (18 Nov 2018 6.08am)

 


COYP

becky Flag over the moon 18 Nov 18 7.49am

Originally posted by HKOwen

That is a very good point and first time I have seen it mentioned in the whole debate.

Unfortunately it meant the Family Stand corner where there is a higher proportion of families and kids gets appalling abuse from some of the visiting away fans

It has been mentioned before. That move was made to separate away fans from the most vocal home fans, and reduce the possibility of it all kicking off between the two sets ( rare, but not entirely unknown). This then meant that the internal security could be undertaken by club stewards, rather than having to pay the massive costs for policing inside the ground as well as outside.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

southnorwoodhill Flag 18 Nov 18 8.58am

Originally posted by Lal

Joke where are they hiding away! No matter how the sing and waves their flags want make any difference to the score never did last season on our winless run. Earnt it no they have not, stay with the team through all ups and downs not when you throw a fit so you can get your own way.

Post of the day.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Nov 18 9.28am

Originally posted by Lal

Joke where are they hiding away! No matter how the sing and waves their flags want make any difference to the score never did last season on our winless run. Earnt it no they have not, stay with the team through all ups and downs not when you throw a fit so you can get your own way.

Where are they hiding that’s such a joke?

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 18 Nov 18 2.08pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Where are they hiding that’s such a joke?

It's the HF who are a joke and sick one at that.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 18 Nov 18 2.09pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


The score is not the point ?
Very odd.
Then what is the point ?

You know full well that the point, from the pro singing section, is the atmosphere they help create. To many, perhaps not you, a good stadium atmosphere makes it more enjoyable.

You may not agree, that’s your choice and that’s fine. But maybe you should acknowledge others opinions and then you might be able to understand a different viewpoint from yours and then be able engage in the conversation/debate.

For the record, I, and I’m sure most, don’t feel that it’s necessarily right to move long term supporters from their seats, however it’s clear the atmosphere has suffered since HF have stopped attending as a group. SP agrees, hence why he’s now accommodating them. There has to be a halfway solution to satisfy all parties.

The original HF idea of resetting the whole lower tier was a fair one as the people who had been there longest would have got first choice of seats and remained in the Holmesdale. The box office obviously didn’t fancy the admin to do that.

Alternatively, if a suitable ‘compensation’ or good will gesture could be put together for those effected, perhaps that would be enough to keep both side happy? The reported 50% off next season plus 10% club shop voucher is an insult. If they were offered a free season ticket for next year, £100 club shop voucher and guaranteed first choice seats in the new stand, at the same price as the lower Holmesdale, I think there would less fuss over this. Ticket sales only represent a fraction of the clubs revenue, so this would be a drop in the ocean as far as Palaces finances go.

I don’t think they HF have covered themselves in glory in the way they have handled this, but if SP has made a promise to them which he hasn’t kept, this is probably the only way for the HF to make a stand and force his hand. The reality is that as a group they are very effective and do far more then any other fan group or individuals. For that reason I believe they have earned the special treatment they are receiving.

Apart from it being unfair and that you don’t like it, what do you think is the best solution to keep all sides happy?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Nov 18 2.57pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

You know full well that the point, from the pro singing section, is the atmosphere they help create. To many, perhaps not you, a good stadium atmosphere makes it more enjoyable.

You may not agree, that’s your choice and that’s fine. But maybe you should acknowledge others opinions and then you might be able to understand a different viewpoint from yours and then be able engage in the conversation/debate.

For the record, I, and I’m sure most, don’t feel that it’s necessarily right to move long term supporters from their seats, however it’s clear the atmosphere has suffered since HF have stopped attending as a group. SP agrees, hence why he’s now accommodating them. There has to be a halfway solution to satisfy all parties.

The original HF idea of resetting the whole lower tier was a fair one as the people who had been there longest would have got first choice of seats and remained in the Holmesdale. The box office obviously didn’t fancy the admin to do that.

Alternatively, if a suitable ‘compensation’ or good will gesture could be put together for those effected, perhaps that would be enough to keep both side happy? The reported 50% off next season plus 10% club shop voucher is an insult. If they were offered a free season ticket for next year, £100 club shop voucher and guaranteed first choice seats in the new stand, at the same price as the lower Holmesdale, I think there would less fuss over this. Ticket sales only represent a fraction of the clubs revenue, so this would be a drop in the ocean as far as Palaces finances go.

I don’t think they HF have covered themselves in glory in the way they have handled this, but if SP has made a promise to them which he hasn’t kept, this is probably the only way for the HF to make a stand and force his hand. The reality is that as a group they are very effective and do far more then any other fan group or individuals. For that reason I believe they have earned the special treatment they are receiving.

Apart from it being unfair and that you don’t like it, what do you think is the best solution to keep all sides happy?

They should have encouraged natural growth of the "singing section" from where they currently were. Eventually, if it caught on, it would migrate towards the middle as it expanded in any case.

Because the HF stand all match there will always be a problem if people around them are sitting. So just moving them lock stock and barrel into the middle is going to create problems. If just one person writes to the league and suggests CPFC are advocating standing within an all seater stadium then CPFC could well be on very thin ice.

The ultimate answer to this is to put forward a plan for safe standing for the whole of the LH and many of the problems disappear as the singers can gravitate to whatever part of the LH they like then. The capacity would increase for the ground and those displaced from seats who want to sit could be moved into the increased capacity of the new stand.

Obviously this all takes time to implement, so they should be encouraged for now to go back to where they were and to expand gradually whilst other plans are put in place. This is the only way everyone can be kept happy in the short term.


 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 18 Nov 18 3.54pm

What are we waiting for with this? Surely it's for the club to explain how people can apply?

I personally hope it's inclusive and we can start talking about this with the positivity the idea deserves! (this also frees up more seats for those moving out of block e right?)

A proper vocal section in the middle of the Holmesdale is going to be a gamechanger

 

Page 42 of 71 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic