You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 49 of 65 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 24 Apr 19 2.08pm

Originally posted by CYPRUS GLAZIER

Totally agree Eddie Roy has a wealth of experience and knows how to bring out the best in the players he has got

Absolutely correct, 100%.

Half the time.........

When we are away, we often see some of the best of our players.

We don’t at home.

Roy’s wealth of experience has presided over a very poor home record this year, with players massively underperforming.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Apr 19 2.30pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Absolutely correct, 100%.

Half the time.........

When we are away, we often see some of the best of our players.

We don’t at home.

Roy’s wealth of experience has presided over a very poor home record this year, with players massively underperforming.

You do realise there is only so much Hodgson can do from the sidelines? - that is to pick the team, tactics, coach and motivate.

It's not Roy's fault that strikers are missing good chances. Was it Roy who told Tompkins to slip against Brighton? The crucial match winning moments are down to the players, not Roy.

We are 12th in the table, well organised, tight defensively, players look up for it, performances have been good (not results at home), we create chances. We're in a great place with Roy and long may it continue.

 

Buckspalace Flag Thornborough 24 Apr 19 2.34pm

Well said goal machine be grateful we are where we are and quite conceivably get to 50 points.
Look back through history and one of the more recent clubs Charlton saying similar things about Curbishley back in the day look what happened to them.
Be careful what you wish for.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 24 Apr 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by Buckspalace

Well said goal machine be grateful we are where we are and quite conceivably get to 50 points.
Look back through history and one of the more recent clubs Charlton saying similar things about Curbishley back in the day look what happened to them.
Be careful what you wish for.

FFS. I'm sick to death of hearing about charlton.....and be careful what you wish for...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Apr 19 2.55pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

You do realise there is only so much Hodgson can do from the sidelines? - that is to pick the team, tactics, coach and motivate.

It's not Roy's fault that strikers are missing good chances. Was it Roy who told Tompkins to slip against Brighton? The crucial match winning moments are down to the players, not Roy.

We are 12th in the table, well organised, tight defensively, players look up for it, performances have been good (not results at home), we create chances. We're in a great place with Roy and long may it continue.

So, are our strikers and our defenders lucky away and unlucky at home? I ask this because unless a strategic set up, (which is the responsibility of the manager) is to blame for our results then I cannot think of another reason, can you?

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Apr 19 3.19pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So, are our strikers and our defenders lucky away and unlucky at home? I ask this because unless a strategic set up, (which is the responsibility of the manager) is to blame for our results then I cannot think of another reason, can you?

No, of course not, nothing to do with luck. Away games suit our style better as we soak up pressure and can counter attack into the space.

At home it's completely different as teams set up defensively, happy to take a draw and the onus is on us to break them down which is difficult, yet we still create the chances. The first goal is so crucial for Palace at home because if we get it, the opposition have to come out. We're then more likely to get the 2nd and go on to win. The strategic setup at home is correct, not taking chances/scoring first goal has been the problem.

I would be interested to see some stats on our chance conversion home vs away. I am certain our home is far worse.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Apr 19 3.33pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

No, of course not, nothing to do with luck. Away games suit our style better as we soak up pressure and can counter attack into the space.

At home it's completely different as teams set up defensively, happy to take a draw and the onus is on us to break them down which is difficult, yet we still create the chances. The first goal is so crucial for Palace at home because if we get it, the opposition have to come out. We're then more likely to get the 2nd and go on to win. The strategic setup at home is correct, not taking chances/scoring first goal has been the problem.

I would be interested to see some stats on our chance conversion home vs away. I am certain our home is far worse.

You could well be right on conversion rates. Look, I'm not trying to argue with this, because I would like a solution to our home form as much as everyone else on here, however if it is down to strategy that we are not performing then the manager has to take a good look at some of his tactical decisions. Maybe it is better with our set up to invite other teams to come onto us even at home. After all, Leicester won the league doing it.


 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 24 Apr 19 3.47pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

You do realise there is only so much Hodgson can do from the sidelines? - that is to pick the team, tactics, coach and motivate.

It's not Roy's fault that strikers are missing good chances. Was it Roy who told Tompkins to slip against Brighton? The crucial match winning moments are down to the players, not Roy.

We are 12th in the table, well organised, tight defensively, players look up for it, performances have been good (not results at home), we create chances. We're in a great place with Roy and long may it continue.

Hear hear !]

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Apr 19 3.49pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You could well be right on conversion rates. Look, I'm not trying to argue with this, because I would like a solution to our home form as much as everyone else on here, however if it is down to strategy that we are not performing then the manager has to take a good look at some of his tactical decisions. Maybe it is better with our set up to invite other teams to come onto us even at home. After all, Leicester won the league doing it.


That could be a solution, but if a team comes to Selhurst looking for a draw, which they usually do, you'll end up with two teams sitting back, 0-0. That's when fans will really get frustrated.

I think what we're doing is right, we just can't get the crucial first goal, the whole pattern of the game changes in our favour after that (we can then sit back and counter attack).

I'm no master tactician, but the only other way I can think of is to keep the ball, play with width and find space/wait for a mistake when the opposition tire, although this is more of a top 6 tactic and I don't think we have that quality.

 

Den1923 Flag 24 Apr 19 3.50pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Den, surely away form is down to exactly the same squad and if we can only counter attack then why don’t we do this at home as well? If teams want to sit back and defend against us and we can’t break them down, then all things considered we should have picked up a lot of bore draws, however we didn’t, we lost way too many games at home playing pretty awful stuff in a large percentage of those games.

Eaglecoops, I do agree with your logic, except I think it is more down to the balance of our team, away from home we get more space because the way we play the breakaway, this suites us more as we do have fast forwards (Wilf & Andros), both of these players have good ball skills and they can score goals its our strikers that have let us down this season and when we are at home the game we play changes because teams drag us in to coming at them and whilst Wilf and Andross have less space to work with they still manage to put in a fair few good crosses each game but alas the so called strikers we have do not have the skills to attack the ball in the box or work defenders off the ball to create space and opportunities for others. I think Roy's tactics at home are limited because of the poor form of our sick note prone strikers in fairness to him. These strikers in the main are more SP choice than Roy's. Lets hope now that we are safe we can have a pro-active transfers market and get the teams balance right well in time for next season so that we can use the training period in the summer months to get the team to gel better, have a good summer!

 

dg1937 Flag 24 Apr 19 3.58pm

Wake me up when Maine Eagle posts a positive comment.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Apr 19 4.31pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You could well be right on conversion rates. Look, I'm not trying to argue with this, because I would like a solution to our home form as much as everyone else on here, however if it is down to strategy that we are not performing then the manager has to take a good look at some of his tactical decisions. Maybe it is better with our set up to invite other teams to come onto us even at home. After all, Leicester won the league doing it.


As sad as this is (nothing better to do this afternoon) , I’ve worked out the stats myself using the BBC match stats for the season. This is of course not entirely accurate on ‘missed chances’ as I have simply used the ‘shots’ statistics. This gives no indication towards how good the chances actually were. It’s the best I can do, but I feel it’s a fair representation to support my argument.

Home: 17 games, 269 shots, 14 goals.
= average of 15.8 shots per game, 0.82 goals per game. 5.2% of shots are goals.

Away: 18 games, 185 shots, 29 goals.
= average 10.27 shots per game, 1.61 goals per game, 15.67% of shots are goals.

The above includes the following highlights:
31 shots, 0 goals vs Cardiff (home)
29 shots, 2 goals vs Burnley (home)
5 shots, 3 goals vs Man City (away)
7 shots, 4 goals vs Leicester (away)

We’ve had 50% more shots per game at home than we do away, yet we have scored double the away goals. The conversion rate away is 3x better than it is at home.

My point is, we are creating chances at home which means Roy’s home tactics are working. Roy can’t be held responsible for sticking the ball in the net himself, the players have to do that.


Edited by Goal Machine (24 Apr 2019 4.31pm)

 

A89M Flag Streatham 24 Apr 19 4.55pm

All this talk about Roy and his negative tactics yet our shots on goal to date totals 447 for the season with 3 games to go, this puts us 7th out of the 20 clubs. The teams above us include 5 of the top 6 and Leicester.
Our highest recorded total is 476 which was last season under Roy.
We’ve also hit the woodwork 15 times which is the 4th highest this season, again the only teams above us are those that are in the top 6.

When you consider these stats and then cast your minds back to the opportunities the players have missed in games at home, Sakho’s missed header against Newcastle, MacArthur tap in against Watford, MacArthur again when he missed from 2 yards out. Take your pick of any player against Cardiff. A few of these go in and there would be a lot less disgruntled home fans wanting a change.
Key moments at home we have come up short and I don’t see what Roy can do, other than set the team up like he has done and hope his players have their shooting boots on.


Edited by A89M (24 Apr 2019 4.57pm)

 

davehuggins Flag 24 Apr 19 5.10pm

Spot on, we just haven't had that much luck in front of goal whilst IMO playing decent football for the majority of the season.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 24 Apr 19 5.47pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

You do realise there is only so much Hodgson can do from the sidelines? - that is to pick the team, tactics, coach and motivate.

It's not Roy's fault that strikers are missing good chances. Was it Roy who told Tompkins to slip against Brighton? The crucial match winning moments are down to the players, not Roy.

We are 12th in the table, well organised, tight defensively, players look up for it, performances have been good (not results at home), we create chances. We're in a great place with Roy and long may it continue.

Seems the team selections, tactics, and ability to motivate are a bit lacking at home this season eh?

Must just be a coincidence that player's make individual mistakes at home but not away from home?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Apr 19 7.32pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Absolutely correct, 100%.

Half the time.........

When we are away, we often see some of the best of our players.

We don’t at home.

Roy’s wealth of experience has presided over a very poor home record this year, with players massively underperforming.

Football is defined by small margins. The stats don't back up your relentless criticism of Roys tactics. We have had the 7th most shots in the Premier league, same position as last year. Previous seasons in order we were 20th, 15th, 12th and 12th.
The difference is, we have hit the woodwork 15 times, say 50% could of gone in with a bit more luck, the season at home would look different. I don't think anyone can justifiably blame Roy for hitting the woodwork.
You need to accept Roy isn't going anywhere, why would Parish consider letting him go, he is good at his job. The risk of change is too high, FDB fiasco would stop him drastically changing.

I am not sure, why you are so concerned at home performances, you don't go to matches, so either winning at home or away makes no difference. People with season tickets I can sort of understand.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Apr 19 8.00pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

You do realise there is only so much Hodgson can do from the sidelines? - that is to pick the team, tactics, coach and motivate.

It's not Roy's fault that strikers are missing good chances. Was it Roy who told Tompkins to slip against Brighton? The crucial match winning moments are down to the players, not Roy.

We are 12th in the table, well organised, tight defensively, players look up for it, performances have been good (not results at home), we create chances. We're in a great place with Roy and long may it continue.

You tell him! 100% correct.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Apr 19 8.15pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

As sad as this is (nothing better to do this afternoon) , I’ve worked out the stats myself using the BBC match stats for the season. This is of course not entirely accurate on ‘missed chances’ as I have simply used the ‘shots’ statistics. This gives no indication towards how good the chances actually were. It’s the best I can do, but I feel it’s a fair representation to support my argument.

Home: 17 games, 269 shots, 14 goals.
= average of 15.8 shots per game, 0.82 goals per game. 5.2% of shots are goals.

Away: 18 games, 185 shots, 29 goals.
= average 10.27 shots per game, 1.61 goals per game, 15.67% of shots are goals.

The above includes the following highlights:
31 shots, 0 goals vs Cardiff (home)
29 shots, 2 goals vs Burnley (home)
5 shots, 3 goals vs Man City (away)
7 shots, 4 goals vs Leicester (away)

We’ve had 50% more shots per game at home than we do away, yet we have scored double the away goals. The conversion rate away is 3x better than it is at home.

My point is, we are creating chances at home which means Roy’s home tactics are working. Roy can’t be held responsible for sticking the ball in the net himself, the players have to do that.


Edited by Goal Machine (24 Apr 2019 4.31pm)

The majority of people can understand this but sadly Mr Maine for whatever reason cannot, maybe he feels he will lose face if he just admits he has got it all wrong and Mr Hodgson is doing a damn good job with the players he has to work with at home and the actual results are down to the individual players misses and mistakes at crucial moments.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Apr 19 8.17pm

..good post again

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Apr 19 8.18pm

goal machine.

 

Page 49 of 65 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread