You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 5 of 80 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Stirlingsays Flag 20 Nov 12 8.34pm

Hamas want to play David to Israel's Goliath, but then we get the huge, 'it's not fair' charge....No such thing as playing fair in war. In war if one man attacks you with a peashooter you respond with a tank.

If the people of Gaza had wanted peace they wouldn't have voted in Hamas, the blueprint is there, There are no Israeli attacks in the West Bank,

Israel voted in an aggressive government. The majority within both sets of people have the governments they have chosen. Until they have had enough blood letting they just need to get on with it.

Moderates aren't going to make any proper headway until there is a will for it. As Hamas are currently getting knocked without much coming the other way, I'm not surprised they want a ceasefire.....Not too sure there is anything in it for Israel though.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Nov 2012 9.03pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Nov 12 8.46pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Nov 2012 8.27pm

Quote pefwin at 20 Nov 2012 8.03pm

Quote crystal balls at 20 Nov 2012 8.01pm

Quote dannyh at 20 Nov 2012 4.54pm

Whats all this hulabalo did someone call someone else a big nose.


[Link]

"Blessed are the cheesemakers"


and any other manufacturers of dairy products.


Which reminds me. What's the latest on the cottage cheese protest in Israel?

A little known fact about me is I used to be a cheesemaker.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Nov 12 8.47pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Nov 2012 8.34pm

Hams want to play David to Israel's Goliath, but then we get the huge, 'it's not fair' charge....No such thing as playing fair in war. In war if one man attacks you with a peashooter you respond with a tank.

If the people of Gaza had wanted peace they wouldn't have voted in Hamas, the blueprint is there, There are no Israeli attacks in the West Bank,

Israel voted in an aggressive government. The majority within both sets of people have the governments they have chosen. Until they have had enough blood letting they just need to get on with it.

Moderates aren't going to make any proper headway until there is a will for it. As Hamas are currently getting knocked without much coming the other way, I'm not surprised they want a ceasefire.....Not too sure there is anything in it for Israel though.


Are Fatah any better?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 20 Nov 12 8.52pm

Quote nickgusset at 20 Nov 2012 8.47pm


Are Fatah any better?


In terms of being able to make progress with Israel yes.

Fatah, have recognised their right to exist. A Fatah dominated leadership would help.

But at the moment both sides have the leaderships they voted for.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Nov 12 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 20 Nov 2012 8.46pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Nov 2012 8.27pm

Quote pefwin at 20 Nov 2012 8.03pm

Quote crystal balls at 20 Nov 2012 8.01pm

Quote dannyh at 20 Nov 2012 4.54pm

Whats all this hulabalo did someone call someone else a big nose.


[Link]

"Blessed are the cheesemakers"


and any other manufacturers of dairy products.


Which reminds me. What's the latest on the cottage cheese protest in Israel?

A little known fact about me is I used to be a cheesemaker.

Make cheese, not war!

 


Optimistic as ever

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 20 Nov 12 9.16pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 20 Nov 2012 7.41pm

And another.

[Link]

Robert Fisk:
Holds more British and International Journalism awards than any other foreign correspondent. He has also been voted International Journalist of the Year seven times.

camera.org:
A right wing American pro-Israel media watchdog group who tries to censor and smear anything and everything that does not conform to their Zionist viewpoint.

Take your choice

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 20 Nov 12 9.21pm

Quote Oliver at 20 Nov 2012 9.16pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 20 Nov 2012 7.41pm

And another.

[Link]

Robert Fisk:
Holds more British and International Journalism awards than any other foreign correspondent. He has also been voted International Journalist of the Year seven times.

camera.org:
A right wing American pro-Israel media watchdog group who tries to censor and smear anything and everything that does not conform to their Zionist viewpoint.

Take your choice


Deserving of each other...I'll take neither thanks.

Fisk has an absolute agenda which is pacifist at heart and which he tries to cover with a veneer of journalistic neutrality. I have absolutely no faith in the accuracy of what he reports. If he gets awards for that, then it says something rather disturbing about those who voted for him.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

davidpercival Flag Croydon 20 Nov 12 9.26pm

No other country would be allowed to illegally occupy other peoples' land for forty five years. They decide how much power goes into Gaza, how much food, how much medical supplies etc. and turn the tap on and off as they please. Gaza is by far the biggest open air prison in the world.
On the analogy about what if the rockets were landing on Bristol, if we were persecuting the Welsh the way the Israelis are persecuting the Gazans, they would have every right to send rockets on Bristol.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 20 Nov 12 9.47pm

Quote davidpercival at 20 Nov 2012 9.26pm

No other country would be allowed to illegally occupy other peoples' land for forty five years. They decide how much power goes into Gaza, how much food, how much medical supplies etc. and turn the tap on and off as they please. Gaza is by far the biggest open air prison in the world.
On the analogy about what if the rockets were landing on Bristol, if we were persecuting the Welsh the way the Israelis are persecuting the Gazans, they would have every right to send rockets on Bristol.


Russia was and to several countries.

Gaza isn't a prison now, people within it can cross the Egyptian border and indeed are now doing so.

The Gazans voted in Hamas, all this was very predictable. If you are going to fight fire with fire, don't moan about getting burnt.

There will be no peace with Hamas (Iran's proxy) in charge.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Nov 2012 9.48pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

davidpercival Flag Croydon 20 Nov 12 9.57pm

Sterling is wrong. People cannot come and go into Egypt as they choose. Under pressure from Israel the Egyptians stop them unless they have specific permission to leave or return.

Even the Palestine football team cannot get in and out without Israel's permission. The west Bank is similarly controlled but allowed a little more freedom but only as long as Fatah fits in with what Israel wants. As soon as they do the slightest thing that Israel does not like, they send in troops.

It is part of the Israel - Egypt "peace" deal which merely perpetuates Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank.

Just imagine if it was the other way round. Would they be prepared to be dealt with like that. We would be hearing about it morning noon and night and you know we would.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 20 Nov 12 10.07pm

Quote davidpercival at 20 Nov 2012 9.57pm

Sterling is wrong. People cannot come and go into Egypt as they choose. Under pressure from Israel the Egyptians stop them unless they have specific permission to leave or return.

Even the Palestine football team cannot get in and out without Israel's permission. The west Bank is similarly controlled but allowed a little more freedom but only as long as Fatah fits in with what Israel wants. As soon as they do the slightest thing that Israel does not like, they send in troops.

It is part of the Israel - Egypt "peace" deal which merely perpetuates Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank.

Just imagine if it was the other way round. Would they be prepared to be dealt with like that. We would be hearing about it morning noon and night and you know we would.


I'm not wrong.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 20 Nov 12 10.09pm

Quote davidpercival at 20 Nov 2012 9.57pm

Sterling is wrong. People cannot come and go into Egypt as they choose. Under pressure from Israel the Egyptians stop them unless they have specific permission to leave or return.

Even the Palestine football team cannot get in and out without Israel's permission. The west Bank is similarly controlled but allowed a little more freedom but only as long as Fatah fits in with what Israel wants. As soon as they do the slightest thing that Israel does not like, they send in troops.

It is part of the Israel - Egypt "peace" deal which merely perpetuates Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank.

Just imagine if it was the other way round. Would they be prepared to be dealt with like that. We would be hearing about it morning noon and night and you know we would.


very largely agree, although I dont think that means that Ss is wrong. There have been many countries which occupied others' land - ask an Irish nationalist and they would argue that the UK still does. It is also true that the Palestinians voted for Hamas, knowing what they stand for.

But the fact that Egypt allows some passage in and out of Gaza does not negate the points you make nor does it justify the Israeli position.

Israel exists now because they had and have powerful allies and money. They were intended to be an island of stability, democracy and good sense in the region. Sadly they have enormously abused that privilege and exploited their position so that they are instead a source of instability and intollerance. One wonders if they will ever learn that real stability and security in that region will never come through military force.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 20 Nov 12 10.20pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 20 Nov 2012 10.09pm

Israel exists now because they had and have powerful allies and money. They were intended to be an island of stability, democracy and good sense in the region. Sadly they have enormously abused that privilege and exploited their position so that they are instead a source of instability and intollerance. One wonders if they will ever learn that real stability and security in that region will never come through military force.


Yup, this is why Israel still exists.

I don't agree with your last statement though. Israel has no choice but to fight, they have been surrounded by enemies since the modern state existed. There will never be any real security for them unless there is a radical re-alignment within the middle east. I can't see that happening.

The only choice for Israel is when do they fight, who they fight and how hard.

If both peoples managed to vote in moderates then we could maybe revisit the Clinton deal....But we know that isn't going to happen for a long time yet.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Nov 12 10.29pm

Mark Steel's take.

[Link]

 

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 20 Nov 12 10.31pm

Quote davidpercival at 20 Nov 2012 9.57pm

Sterling is wrong. People cannot come and go into Egypt as they choose. Under pressure from Israel the Egyptians stop them unless they have specific permission to leave or return.

Even the Palestine football team cannot get in and out without Israel's permission. The west Bank is similarly controlled but allowed a little more freedom but only as long as Fatah fits in with what Israel wants. As soon as they do the slightest thing that Israel does not like, they send in troops.

It is part of the Israel - Egypt "peace" deal which merely perpetuates Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank.

Just imagine if it was the other way round. Would they be prepared to be dealt with like that. We would be hearing about it morning noon and night and you know we would.

The charge/insinuation that Gaza is some sort of prison camp is erroneous. The citizens are not as disenfranchised as the apologists like to portray.

The population are quite free to leave via the Rafah-Egyptian Crossing. Gaza boasts a luxury mall and 5-star hotels. Gaza presides over it's own electrical and water grids. (N.b. Life expectancy in Glasgow East is lower than that of Gaza)

That is not to say that the general population does not suffer; but given the nature of their rulers Hamas, it is in their interest to prolong any suffering of the general population so as to harden their appeal to the Arab public at large.

The West Bank economy in recent years had considerable resurgence in part due to Fatah's embrace of business and free-market.

The sooner the Hamas are eradicated from the Palestinian cause, the sooner the Palestinians will be able to preside over their own state.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Nov 12 10.43pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 20 Nov 2012 10.31pm

Quote davidpercival at 20 Nov 2012 9.57pm

Sterling is wrong. People cannot come and go into Egypt as they choose. Under pressure from Israel the Egyptians stop them unless they have specific permission to leave or return.

Even the Palestine football team cannot get in and out without Israel's permission. The west Bank is similarly controlled but allowed a little more freedom but only as long as Fatah fits in with what Israel wants. As soon as they do the slightest thing that Israel does not like, they send in troops.

It is part of the Israel - Egypt "peace" deal which merely perpetuates Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank.

Just imagine if it was the other way round. Would they be prepared to be dealt with like that. We would be hearing about it morning noon and night and you know we would.

The charge/insinuation that Gaza is some sort of prison camp is erroneous. The citizens are not as disenfranchised as the apologists like to portray.

The population are quite free to leave via the Rafah-Egyptian Crossing. Gaza boasts a luxury mall and 5-star hotels. Gaza presides over it's own electrical and water grids. (N.b. Life expectancy in Glasgow East is lower than that of Gaza)

That is not to say that the general population does not suffer; but given the nature of their rulers Hamas, it is in their interest to prolong any suffering of the general population so as to harden their appeal to the Arab public at large.

The West Bank economy in recent years had considerable resurgence in part due to Fatah's embrace of business and free-market.

The sooner the Hamas are eradicated from the Palestinian cause, the sooner the Palestinians will be able to preside over their own state.

Palestine won't have any land to preside over soon the way things are going...

shrinking Palestine.png Attachment: shrinking Palestine.png (268.81Kb)

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 20 Nov 12 11.29pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Nov 2012 10.07pm

I'm not wrong.

[Link]


That links to a page from 2008, hardly relevant to what is happening now.

Even so, it says:

On Wednesday, Palestinian gunmen used land mines to blast down the border partition so Gazans could escape an Israeli closure imposed last week that was making food, fuel and other goods scarce. Tens of thousands of Gazans have rushed into Egypt without any border controls.

On the frontier, guards were patrolling access roads while helmeted police with sniffer dogs used batons to beat the hoods of private cars and pickups that massed at the border, trying to stop them from carrying Palestinians further into Egyptian territory.

Egyptian officials said the border would eventually "return to normal."

That happened because Israel closed the border and Palestinians were desperate. You or I would do the same if we lived under the harsh conditions Israel imposes on Gaza.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 Nov 12 11.32pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 20 Nov 2012 9.21pm

Quote Oliver at 20 Nov 2012 9.16pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 20 Nov 2012 7.41pm

And another.

[Link]

Robert Fisk:
Holds more British and International Journalism awards than any other foreign correspondent. He has also been voted International Journalist of the Year seven times.

camera.org:
A right wing American pro-Israel media watchdog group who tries to censor and smear anything and everything that does not conform to their Zionist viewpoint.

Take your choice


Deserving of each other...I'll take neither thanks.

Fisk has an absolute agenda which is pacifist at heart and which he tries to cover with a veneer of journalistic neutrality. I have absolutely no faith in the accuracy of what he reports. If he gets awards for that, then it says something rather disturbing about those who voted for him.

I'm not really sure you can class pacificism as a negative bias, typically I'd regard anyone who was actually pro-war as being dangerous, but I get where your coming from.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

corkery Flag Cork City 20 Nov 12 11.48pm

The only way to solve this once and for all is to have the two state solution with the 1947 borders. Until the yanks feck off and allow democracy in the region it will be chaos. When you keep people down and keep murdering them, they will continue to revolt.

If only they had oil.

 


We'll never die

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Nov 12 12.55am

Quote Seth at 20 Nov 2012 11.29pm

That links to a page from 2008, hardly relevant to what is happening now.

Even so, it says:

On Wednesday, Palestinian gunmen used land mines to blast down the border partition so Gazans could escape an Israeli closure imposed last week that was making food, fuel and other goods scarce. Tens of thousands of Gazans have rushed into Egypt without any border controls.

On the frontier, guards were patrolling access roads while helmeted police with sniffer dogs used batons to beat the hoods of private cars and pickups that massed at the border, trying to stop them from carrying Palestinians further into Egyptian territory.

Egyptian officials said the border would eventually "return to normal."

That happened because Israel closed the border and Palestinians were desperate. You or I would do the same if we lived under the harsh conditions Israel imposes on Gaza.


I was looking forward to you doing that.

The border restrictions have been considerably relaxed since the new Egyptian government took over.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 5 of 80 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine