You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Julian Assange
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Julian Assange


Page 5 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 12.22am

Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 8.34pm

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 8.09pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 8.04pm
Thing is he has certainly broken laws, both US and international, that he could be extradited on without it being deemed for military or political reasons.


How do you think they could frame it in a non-political, non-military way? I'm not being facetious at all, I'm genuinely curious what your thinking is.

Personally, I cannot see anything sticking that doesn't have some semblance of political motivation.


Theft, intellectual if not actual. Espionage, though I suppose that's political. Not sure if he released any corporate stuff? They could probably go for him on libel, slander, defamation etc? Probably got all sorts of other laws they could throw at him that I don't know about too.

They released so much stuff that he's bound to have left more than one avenue for them to persue, should they so wish don't forget. It's his belief only that this will occur. Which is a convenient way of not complying with our court's ruling and not facing trial in Sweden, until we're proven to otherwise.

The degree to which a free press can be regarded as espionage is debatable, especially considering the much of the information seems to have been things and events classed as National Security because they were embrassing to a government, rather than actual threats to national security.

When governments conspire and break laws (such as kidknapping and torture of citizens, start wars based on lies and control information for their own gain) is it really Assange who is the true criminal. Classing Assange in line with espionage is just another abuse of the laws that successive UK and US governments have utilised to silence their critics, because the truth is not on their side.

Wikileaks does what the press is supposed to do, expose hard truths nations don't want to hear.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (26 Feb 2013 12.25am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

banksy Flag Norwich 26 Feb 13 12.59am

I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that villified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 1.28am

Quote banksy at 26 Feb 2013 12.59am

I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that villified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!


Secrets?

Yeah....We simply had no idea that diplomats were two faced and said one thing to a foreign power and another to their own.

Yeah, we needed to know that....What a complete shock that was....I had to sit down for that one.

There was/is some merit is releasing news of atrocities that took place in war....Some benefit to that, though we all know it happens in war zones.

At the end of the day, who are Wikileaks to decide what information should and shouldn't be in the public domain?

Who elected them? Where does their mandate come from? There is a problem with farming out trust into web developers and their researchers.....You are just swapping agendas as far as I see.

What have they done to earn your faith in their honesty or integrity? You don't know what they don't tell you...How is that any different? You know them no better than the government officials you profess disdain for.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 26 Feb 13 2.12am

An interesting point was rised here on a TV programme last night. many draft dodgers from the USA decamped to Sweden during the Vietnam War and they did so as Swedens extradition rules made it impossible for them to be returned. Would this not mean that Assange would be safe to face his Swedish charges in safety and at worst enjoy the security of a Swedish prison?

 

banksy Flag Norwich 26 Feb 13 3.54am

To Stirlingsays: you raise a very good point about who to trust with data and its dissemination. That said, based upon my deep and extensive research I can only say that at the end of the day you have to trust those who are independent of governments and their tentacles of control. What is really going on behind the scenes is so diabolical that most people would not believe it. Whistle blowers and rebels in an age of increasing state/police/military control should be cherished. We need to encourage more people to stand up and be brave enough to say what's really going on.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Feb 13 10.50am

Quote banksy at 26 Feb 2013 12.59am

I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that vilified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!


Public service! All he's done is promote himself and his own self importance. He's not important, nor elected as Stirling has pointed out.

All he really is, is a serial law breaker hiding being a fake political stance.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 12.01pm

Quote Stuk at 26 Feb 2013 10.50am

Quote banksy at 26 Feb 2013 12.59am

I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that vilified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!


Public service! All he's done is promote himself and his own self importance. He's not important, nor elected as Stirling has pointed out.

All he really is, is a serial law breaker hiding being a fake political stance.

Isn't that what governments have done in their pursuit of him and the consequent media coverage? I'd never really paid much attention to wikileaks or Assange prior to the 'gulf war' revelations, and increasing persicution by assorted embrassed governments.

I'd suggest that since its inception in 2006, Wikileaks has served the public interest.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 12.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Feb 2013 8.48pm

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 8.31pm

You're tying yourself in knots here. You previously accused Assange of taking a pick and choose mentality to international law. So a state can bend international law whenever they choose to, but an individual subject to the same, loose, subjective law or treaty is not allowed an interpretation?

There is no maybe, maybe not on whether Sweden broke its own treaty on extradition. [Link] Guardian bias aside, it's a very well documented case of Extraordinary Rendition and the dismissal of international law as the basis for extradition.

An individual does not get to officially decide upon which laws they do or do not follow....Well, legally.

A democratic state however votes on and creates laws. It frames those laws and creates its extradition laws within its own parliament.

The nut of the problem, if a state acts illegally, they get away with it, if a person calls them to task by acting illegally, they get persicuted.

Wikileaks information on the gulf war presents further fuel to the arguement that a) the war was manufactured from the start b) that governments have broken their own laws in the 'war on terror' c) that war crimes have been committed.

When the government lacks the capacity to be lawful, then it should not be suprised when individuals act accordingly.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 12.09pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.22pm

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 9.16pm

Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.09pm
They could after all have beaten Sweden to the chase and applied to extradite him from us.

Once they have him, I presume they could try him on all sorts of petty matters the like of which i've mentioned.


No, America has not yet begun extradition with neither Sweden nor the UK. Here is a really good article with three legal opinions on the likelihood and frailties of the case. [Link]


I know, I've said this about 4 times in recent posts. They could have, were they going to do what Assange keeps telling us he thinks they'll do via Sweden.

As it stands there is no case, he should stop using that as his defence against A) going to Sweden and B) breaking our laws.

In all fairness the US could not extradite him until he's extradited to Sweeden, that would prevent the Sweedish extradition from the UK.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 12.09pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.01pm

I'd suggest that since its inception in 2006, Wikileaks has served the public interest.



It has no mandate. It is its own judge and executor with no accountability other than to itself.

I happily concede that there are good aspects to it, however this is surely not a healthy state of affairs.

There are practical reasons to keep some information confidential.

Who's judging Wikileaks?

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 12.21pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 12.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.05pm

The nut of the problem, if a state acts illegally, they get away with it, if a person calls them to task by acting illegally, they get persicuted.

Wikileaks information on the gulf war presents further fuel to the arguement that a) the war was manufactured from the start b) that governments have broken their own laws in the 'war on terror' c) that war crimes have been committed.

When the government lacks the capacity to be lawful, then it should not be suprised when individuals act accordingly.

All this is incredibly, hugely subjective.

In the case of saying that states break the law and get away with it that's factually not correct.

Firstly, there is the aspect of it's not you who decides the law is broken but an actual law court.....You show your bias by announcing pre-judgement.

This thread has already dealt with the fact that what people regard as illegal is mostly purely inside their own heads. The actual legal courts haven't given out verdicts for various reasons.

illegality has to be proven in a court of law.

While it's true that individuals break the law or bend it without being caught that is also the case with states.

However the legal system is available to lawyers to use against either and case law is littered with cases brought against aspects of government.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 12.22pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 2.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 12.09pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.01pm

I'd suggest that since its inception in 2006, Wikileaks has served the public interest.



It has no mandate. It is its own judge and executor with no accountability other than to itself.

I happily concede that there are good aspects to it, however this is surely not a healthy state of affairs.

There are practical reasons to keep some information confidential.

Who's judging Wikileaks?

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 12.21pm)

Arguably it is accountable, given the recent efforts of the US to single out wikileaks, and Assange.

Whilst there are practical reasons for some information to be kept confidential, in most cases this seems to have been to protect 'the cause and reputation of state' rather than to actual national security. Its worth noting that wikileaks redacts information from its leaks as well.

Wikileaks is simply doing the job the 4th Estate is supposed to have performed, holding the state accountable.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 2.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 12.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.05pm

The nut of the problem, if a state acts illegally, they get away with it, if a person calls them to task by acting illegally, they get persicuted.

Wikileaks information on the gulf war presents further fuel to the arguement that a) the war was manufactured from the start b) that governments have broken their own laws in the 'war on terror' c) that war crimes have been committed.

When the government lacks the capacity to be lawful, then it should not be suprised when individuals act accordingly.

All this is incredibly, hugely subjective.

In the case of saying that states break the law and get away with it that's factually not correct.

Firstly, there is the aspect of it's not you who decides the law is broken but an actual law court.....You show your bias by announcing pre-judgement.

This thread has already dealt with the fact that what people regard as illegal is mostly purely inside their own heads. The actual legal courts haven't given out verdicts for various reasons.

illegality has to be proven in a court of law.

While it's true that individuals break the law or bend it without being caught that is also the case with states.

However the legal system is available to lawyers to use against either and case law is littered with cases brought against aspects of government.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 12.22pm)

Governments have authority and influence beyond that attainable to the individual, and the capacity to protect itself through control of information that is prejudical, and routinely operates to do so (hence the need for whistleblowers and leaks).

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that the UK and US invasion of Iraq in 2003 was unlawful and in violation of international law, and even then predicated on wholely selectively presented and false information, and that as a result tens if not hundreds of thousands of people have lost their lives.

I'd be suprised if anyone else really thought otherwise, especially in hindsight.

Also, I think it would be wholely false to suggest that the UK and US were not actively involved in torture, and kidknapping (rendition) and imprisonment without trial, as well as illegal extraditions to states of individual for torture (or complicity to allow their airspace and resources to be used for such).

Thats established fact, and all are criminal actions in violation of UK undertakings under international and domestic laws. It'll never get to court, because ultimately political necessity means self protection.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 2.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 2.04pm

Arguably it is accountable, given the recent efforts of the US to single out wikileaks, and Assange.

Oh come on Jamie, that is risible. Besides most on the left argue that it's persecution and not accountability.

They don't have a mandate and holding them to account as you can a newspaper is very difficult....Not the same thing.

Your point about holding states to account I agree with, though if Wikileaks is the answer then it's a poor one.

Whistle blowing is a good thing......Organized whistle blowing with no accountability....Nope.

I would have more time for Wikileaks if their releases were independently vetted. Not by government but not by their supporters either. But of course that would defeat the purpose of Wikileaks.....Leaks are the operative word.

It's not about 'judgement' it's about free access to all information...It's an agenda, hiding behind a purpose that has some good aspects to it but also some poor ones....Both for a democracy and for fairness...In my view.

It's not fair that all information is open season, confidentially isn't always for malign purpose.....As I say Wikileaks have no mandate to be the 4th Estate or anything else.

Investigative but accountable journalism is a far better modus operandi.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 2.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 2.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 2.12pm


Governments have authority and influence beyond that attainable to the individual, and the capacity to protect itself through control of information that is prejudical, and routinely operates to do so (hence the need for whistleblowers and leaks).

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that the UK and US invasion of Iraq in 2003 was unlawful and in violation of international law, and even then predicated on wholely selectively presented and false information, and that as a result tens if not hundreds of thousands of people have lost their lives.

I'd be suprised if anyone else really thought otherwise, especially in hindsight.

Also, I think it would be wholely false to suggest that the UK and US were not actively involved in torture, and kidknapping (rendition) and imprisonment without trial, as well as illegal extraditions to states of individual for torture (or complicity to allow their airspace and resources to be used for such).

Thats established fact, and all are criminal actions in violation of UK undertakings under international and domestic laws. It'll never get to court, because ultimately political necessity means self protection.



I don't agree with much of your 'established facts'. You use the word 'illegal' out of context. It's not a fact, it's an opinion.

Cases based upon some of your arguments have been taken to different courts.

None of them have succeeded.

The wars were framed to be legal in the context of international law....Or to be more exact, framed to be difficult to prove as anything other than legal.

What is 'legal' in international law has the regular habit of changing to suit the agendas of those setting it.

The word, 'consequences' sufficed for war and in terms of legality that's pretty much that.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 3.13pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 2.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 2.04pm

Arguably it is accountable, given the recent efforts of the US to single out wikileaks, and Assange.

Oh come on Jamie, that is risible. Besides most on the left argue that it's persecution and not accountability.

They don't have a mandate and holding them to account as you can a newspaper is very difficult....Not the same thing.

Your point about holding states to account I agree with, though if Wikileaks is the answer then it's a poor one.

Whistle blowing is a good thing......Organized whistle blowing with no accountability....Nope.

I would have more time for Wikileaks if their releases were independently vetted. Not by government but not by their supporters either. But of course that would defeat the purpose of Wikileaks.....Leaks are the operative word.

It's not about 'judgement' it's about free access to all information...It's an agenda, hiding behind a purpose that has some good aspects to it but also some poor ones....Both for a democracy and for fairness...In my view.

It's not fair that all information is open season, confidentially isn't always for malign purpose.....As I say Wikileaks have no mandate to be the 4th Estate or anything else.

Investigative but accountable journalism is a far better modus operandi.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 2.38pm)

I'd agree, but when the state and fourth estate fails to live up to their responsibilities and duties, then its not suprising that a less accountable and responsible entity fills their place.


The UK media, for example, in the run up to the gulf war and aftermath have done little to restore the balance of faith in those institutions. We know that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction, the members of parliment and prime ministers either lied or presented very poorly sourced uncollaborated intelligence to present a case for war, and that even institutions within the UK and US government, including the CIA were distrustful of both the intelligence and viewed the sources as both distrustful and unreliable.

As for international law, the US and UK acted to fulfil their interpretation of an old security council resolution, without the sanction of the other members of the security council.

Call it what you will, but that war was entirely fabricated for ulteria motives, and those responsible were never held to account for those actions.

As for facts, court cases are still ongoing regarding torture, documented evidence of rendition and permission for rendition exist, along with the details of 'ghost prisons' operated by the US, and possibly UK. The US legalised torture as a means of interogation and stood by it, openly, and accounts of innocent people tortured by the state on cases of mistaken identity exist, and have been corrobroated.

The US has reinitiated assassination (using drones, that violate international airspace, and launch illegal strikes in numerous nations, that result in the death of forigen nationals as 'collateral damage'.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 13 3.18pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 2.51pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 2.12pm


Governments have authority and influence beyond that attainable to the individual, and the capacity to protect itself through control of information that is prejudical, and routinely operates to do so (hence the need for whistleblowers and leaks).

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that the UK and US invasion of Iraq in 2003 was unlawful and in violation of international law, and even then predicated on wholely selectively presented and false information, and that as a result tens if not hundreds of thousands of people have lost their lives.

I'd be suprised if anyone else really thought otherwise, especially in hindsight.

Also, I think it would be wholely false to suggest that the UK and US were not actively involved in torture, and kidknapping (rendition) and imprisonment without trial, as well as illegal extraditions to states of individual for torture (or complicity to allow their airspace and resources to be used for such).

Thats established fact, and all are criminal actions in violation of UK undertakings under international and domestic laws. It'll never get to court, because ultimately political necessity means self protection.



I don't agree with much of your 'established facts'. You use the word 'illegal' out of context. It's not a fact, it's an opinion.

Cases based upon some of your arguments have been taken to different courts.

None of them have succeeded.

The wars were framed to be legal in the context of international law....Or to be more exact, framed to be difficult to prove as anything other than legal.

What is 'legal' in international law has the regular habit of changing to suit the agendas of those setting it.

The word, 'consequences' sufficed for war and in terms of legality that's pretty much that.

Not really, the use of torture in the UK is illegal. Just because you do it overseas, doesn't make it legal.

Rendition and imprisonment without trial is unconstitutional in the US and UK, it violates the right to a fair trial. Rendition is a nice way of saying kidknapping, because the legal route is called extradition.

International Law forbids acts of aggression against soverign states, without security council approval (excepting the right to self defence of those aggressed or occupied).

Essentially when a lawful state abandons the idea of due process and legal rights, it resorts to tyranny.

All of these, where they being pursued against british citizens by an independent state, would be called crimes by the UK government (and in some cases acts of war - drone stikes).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 3.37pm

You know this 'illegal' tag is pretty silly.

The world isn't a state, international law doesn't operate like a national court.

Calling a war illegal in a way is just nonsense....All war is illegal in a sense. If it was officially proven to be 'illegal' which isn't going to happen then who is going to enforce this so called breaking of 'international law'?

Are we going to somehow jail a former president and Prime Minister? How about the other twenty of so countries involved, how culpable are they in this 'illegal war'?.....Sounds very French revolution to me.

Even if the US would let it happen...Which it won't The US, who basically fund the UN as we know it would isolate themselves far more. It would be just the excuse that many Republicans would like....The country that attracts all that hate feeds more poor children than most of the rest put together.

Everything is a balancing act, we can't have the world just as we'd like it.

Really, if the reality that some push for actually happened then I think the world would be far more dangerous than it currently is......Probably be forced to be Chinese within a generation if the world were run by 'world government' idealists like yourself.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 3.48pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 3.18pm

Not really, the use of torture in the UK is illegal. Just because you do it overseas, doesn't make it legal.

Rendition and imprisonment without trial is unconstitutional in the US and UK, it violates the right to a fair trial. Rendition is a nice way of saying kidknapping, because the legal route is called extradition.

International Law forbids acts of aggression against soverign states, without security council approval (excepting the right to self defence of those aggressed or occupied).

Essentially when a lawful state abandons the idea of due process and legal rights, it resorts to tyranny.

All of these, where they being pursued against british citizens by an independent state, would be called crimes by the UK government (and in some cases acts of war - drone stikes).


Yes, really.

It's already an 'established fact' that international law doesn't act as you think it should.

There's a lot of high minded language, but history has always been the justice of the victor and I don't see that changing anytime soon. In fact with China increasing in power and intent...To paraphrase Hitler to the Indians.....'you don't know how good you have it'.

To say it again, these are definitions of war.

All war is 'illegal' in the minds of one or both sides.

Definitions can be made to fit whatever you like......You can argue the toss all you like. The reality is that no state or individual is going to be convicted of bugger all in regards to the Gulf wars.

'illegal' is a pointless mantra.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Feb 13 4.06pm

Rendition and imprisonment without trial are both wrong. That's my position on that....What to do about it, well that's another question.

On the wider point I don't believe in letting possible threats knowingly walk the streets and I don't agree it's valid to spend large amounts of money keeping tabs on thousands of people.

We will unfortunately always have to spend some cash keeping tabs on those who who wish us ill. It's just one of the wonderful benefits of high immigration that the left keep telling us about.

I'd structure our law....Yeah, our law not the EU's to allow us to far more easily deport those we considered dangerous.....Though they deserve an independent hearing to ensure government has due cause for suspicion and can be overturned.

This is just my opinion, I'm well aware that this is all considered as beyond the pale by most on here.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 5 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Julian Assange