You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are there plans to build a new stadium?
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are there plans to build a new stadium?


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 23 Apr 14 3.54pm

My own view, Crystal Palace park would be a good site. Plenty of room to build the stadium on the current footprint. 2 stations right by the park, with another 3 or 4 in walking distance. Services from Victoria, London Bridge, Norwood Junction & West Croydon, London Overground, plus lots of services further south, changing at Norwood junction for Penge West or CP. And a bus station right on the park, servicing about 10 routes.

However, as a former SE19 resident, I'm afraid it's just not going to happen. The local residents association will object on every possible ground and the onus would be on Palace to disprove them, or find solutions to them, costing lots of time and money. Frankly, I think it's a non-starter. And in the absence of any other suitable sites (to my knowledge), development of SP is the only option.

 

c_block_shedevil Flag London 23 Apr 14 5.19pm

Quote Catfish at 22 Apr 2014 7.54pm

Quote Halfwayline at 22 Apr 2014 7.38pm

small]

Wisbech!
That is a journey and a half. It raises a key question concerning the location of the stadium - where do Palace supporters live? I suspect that if you had a heat map from 1972 and now you would see that the first one was tightly packed around Norwood and Croydon. A present one is likely to show tat support has spread very widely. Palace must have this data from their membership and season ticket sales. It would be interesting to know what proportion of support now travels from outside Croydon.

I did a poll on the BBS 823 fan's responded to where they live. Just 16% live in Croydon.

Edited by Halfwayline (22 Apr 2014 7.38pm)

Quote That is an astonishingly small %. It begs the question of whether the club is drawing in support from the local community or is simply relying on next generation of exist g supporters. If we rely on people travelling a long way then any stadium must be close to a mainline station or major road junction.
But that % of local support has to grow or the clubs long term future is very bleak.


I think that the poll is flawed. Most if the palace fan base do not use the HOL or the BBS, and I bet most if the people that voted don't even go to matches. According to the poll, most palace fans live abroad and I doubt very much if that's true.

I remember on years ago on the BBS, I think it was but the guy who used to write the palace echo he said that the majority of people that ordered things from his website were from SE19, CR0 and BR something.


Edited by c_block_shedevil (23 Apr 2014 5.21pm)

Edited by c_block_shedevil (23 Apr 2014 5.22pm)

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

Windebank Flag East Preston 23 Apr 14 5.41pm

I hope to God we stay at Selhurst, it is our home! Been going for 55 years and driving up from the South Coast, know all the back doubles and best parking places.
The place has got character and this needs to be retained.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 23 Apr 14 6.08pm

Quote Seth at 22 Apr 2014 2.39pm

Quote adrian b at 22 Apr 2014 2.25pm


I heard the ground is being 'lowered' to build up the stands, a new semi-circular' main stand replacing the original rust bucket and a capacity higher than 30,000. Either a change or oblivion.


I can understand lowering the pitch, but a "semi-circular" stand? How the hell would that work?


Use the ol' imagination.

 

eagle52 Flag Shirley,Croydon 23 Apr 14 6.40pm

The rumour mill will grind on for a good while I should imagine. The story I heard was the pitch being rotated through 90 degrees, rebuild the Arthur which would then be behind a goal, rebuild the old stand in the car park, then extend the Holmesdale and Sainsburys stands towards the car park and towards the pitch as they would then be flanking the sides of the pitch. The serious work could only be done during May to August, so would take years to complete. As I said, the rumour mill grinds on.

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 23 Apr 14 7.10pm

Quote eagle52 at 23 Apr 2014 6.40pm

The rumour mill will grind on for a good while I should imagine. The story I heard was the pitch being rotated through 90 degrees, rebuild the Arthur which would then be behind a goal, rebuild the old stand in the car park, then extend the Holmesdale and Sainsburys stands towards the car park and towards the pitch as they would then be flanking the sides of the pitch. The serious work could only be done during May to August, so would take years to complete. As I said, the rumour mill grinds on.

The only way that that could work would be by the compulsory purchase of the houses behind the main stand to provide the room. It would also entail a Big Bang approach that would mean us moving out while the work was done. I think this rumour can be safely dismissed.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 23 Apr 14 8.09pm

When proposed, I thought moving back to the Crystal Palace, which we were kicked out of by the Admiralty nearly 100 years ago, would solve many of the problems that Selhurst Park has, such as being totally surrounded by residential development. However, the residents surrounding CPP have mobilized to such a degree against any new construction that moving there is a non-starter. Bromley Council has a long stated opposition as well. So Selhurst it is. The Main Stand (Members/Derrick Ormonde/Clifton) has to be the first priority as it still built of wood in the upper half and needs an annual waiver to operate. We have had planning permission off and on for many years only for it to lapse due to one thing or another. Given the profound competence (a major understatement) of the CPFC 2010 consortium, I have every confidence that things will get done and sooner rather than later.

Edited by kenbarr (25 Apr 2014 3.44pm)

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 23 Apr 14 8.37pm

Although a permanent move to CP park might have been ruled out I noted somewhere - wikapedia I think - that the official capacity is about 14,000 but this can be boosted up to 25,000 by use of temporary stands. This could provide solution to our problems by allowing a major rebuild of Selhurst, or part of Selhurst, while not affecting our overall attendance dramatically.

Update - it can hold 24,000 with temporary stands.

Edited by Catfish (23 Apr 2014 8.42pm)

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Apr 14 9.55pm

Quote Catfish at 23 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Although a permanent move to CP park might have been ruled out I noted somewhere - wikapedia I think - that the official capacity is about 14,000 but this can be boosted up to 25,000 by use of temporary stands. This could provide solution to our problems by allowing a major rebuild of Selhurst, or part of Selhurst, while not affecting our overall attendance dramatically.

Update - it can hold 24,000 with temporary stands.

Edited by Catfish (23 Apr 2014 8.42pm)


And you think the combination of a nimby and (frankly)unbelievably wealthy residents association will just nod that through?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 23 Apr 14 10.33pm

Quote bexleydave at 23 Apr 2014 9.55pm

Quote Catfish at 23 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Although a permanent move to CP park might have been ruled out I noted somewhere - wikapedia I think - that the official capacity is about 14,000 but this can be boosted up to 25,000 by use of temporary stands. This could provide solution to our problems by allowing a major rebuild of Selhurst, or part of Selhurst, while not affecting our overall attendance dramatically.

Update - it can hold 24,000 with temporary stands.

Edited by Catfish (23 Apr 2014 8.42pm)


And you think the combination of a nimby and (frankly)unbelievably wealthy residents association will just nod that through?


... compensation speaks, if only temporary.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

c_block_shedevil Flag London 23 Apr 14 10.56pm

Quote cornwalls palace at 23 Apr 2014 10.33pm

Quote bexleydave at 23 Apr 2014 9.55pm

Quote Catfish at 23 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Although a permanent move to CP park might have been ruled out I noted somewhere - wikapedia I think - that the official capacity is about 14,000 but this can be boosted up to 25,000 by use of temporary stands. This could provide solution to our problems by allowing a major rebuild of Selhurst, or part of Selhurst, while not affecting our overall attendance dramatically.

Update - it can hold 24,000 with temporary stands.

Edited by Catfish (23 Apr 2014 8.42pm)


And you think the combination of a nimby and (frankly)unbelievably wealthy residents association will just nod that through?


... compensation speaks, if only temporary.

In sure the residents would be fine with 1 season at the park.

The alternatives do not bear thinking about. A ground share with millwall or charlton!

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 23 Apr 14 11.36pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 23 Apr 2014 10.56pm

Quote cornwalls palace at 23 Apr 2014 10.33pm

Quote bexleydave at 23 Apr 2014 9.55pm

Quote Catfish at 23 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Although a permanent move to CP park might have been ruled out I noted somewhere - wikapedia I think - that the official capacity is about 14,000 but this can be boosted up to 25,000 by use of temporary stands. This could provide solution to our problems by allowing a major rebuild of Selhurst, or part of Selhurst, while not affecting our overall attendance dramatically.

Update - it can hold 24,000 with temporary stands.

Edited by Catfish (23 Apr 2014 8.42pm)


And you think the combination of a nimby and (frankly)unbelievably wealthy residents association will just nod that through?


... compensation speaks, if only temporary.

In sure the residents would be fine with 1 season at the park.

The alternatives do not bear thinking about. A ground share with millwall or charlton!

...Millwall would love it!

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 24 Apr 14 6.13am

Using CP park on a temporary basis would not require anything like the battle that a permanent change of use would cause. We would simply be using the stadium in its present form and for its intended use. There is no doubt that Bromley council would make us pay through the nose for the privilege. They have a need to develop and upkeep the park and no money to do it though so I think they will overrule residents objections.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

kkenny Flag South London 25 Apr 14 3.07pm

And i bet the local shops wouldn't mind the sudden windful for a season and then when we have gone be moaning about loss of trade with the fair trade raisin eating cnuts that spend round there.

 

west eagle Flag 25 Apr 14 3.14pm

still years away, would need to go through all the planning etc

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 25 Apr 14 3.24pm

there was talk, during the great AW days of moving to Purley Way. Then it was a big, empty space. What's it like nowadays?

 

AussieJedinak Flag Folkestone 25 Apr 14 3.26pm

Quote west eagle at 25 Apr 2014 3.14pm

still years away, would need to go through all the planning etc

What time frame would planning take?


 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 25 Apr 14 3.42pm

I hit quote instead of edit on my previous post by accident. No need to repeat myself, except that I'm having more and more senior moments these days.

Edited by kenbarr (25 Apr 2014 3.46pm)

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 25 Apr 14 3.48pm

Still can't see anything happening in the next five years, in fact I'd be surprised if we have a new/refurbished ground inside 10 years. To much negotiating, 'bribing' to be done for much to move on soon.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 25 Apr 14 3.58pm

Quote adrian b at 25 Apr 2014 3.24pm

there was talk, during the great AW days of moving to Purley Way. Then it was a big, empty space. What's it like nowadays?

Appears to be lots of open land between Beddington Lane
and London Road Hackbridge (beyond the sewagw works) with possible access from both and link to Hackbridge station. Always thought this a reasonable location for a 30K stadium with big car park and bus facilities but think most land is in Sutton rather than Croydon which may or not be a problem.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are there plans to build a new stadium?