This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Dwight Gayle
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jcreedy 30 Apr 14 2.30pm |
|
|
Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.
It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.
- John Bostock (Nov 2007)
|
timmyb Banstead 30 Apr 14 2.50pm |
|
|
I seem to remember Mark Bright - a proven goalscorer in the old Div 2 - taking some months to open his account in the old Div One. Mercifully there was no social media then or he'd surely have been designated "not good enough at this level" by plenty of folk. The glory years of CPFC might have been rather different if Steve Coppell hadn't stuck with him.
I find all the folk urging Gayle's prompt departure, suggesting Murray is not up to it, and reckoning Zaha is a busted flush at Prem level all rather premature in their assertions. I have a little more faith in the Palace coaching staff to bring these folk on (including WZ if he returned.) In DG's case the key thing might be some improvement of his core strength - WZ started flying after a summer of intense physical work.
This club has a track record of nurturing talent stretching back decades...and went seriously into the doldrums when this stopped being the case.
|
Part Time James 30 Apr 14 2.57pm |
|
|
I tend to agree with assessments that we'd make a loss on him now selling for around £2m, but if anything that's why I'd like to see us keep him.
Yeah, he's a bit too old to be seen as a hot prospect but I do think he has more untapped potential (or at least I have my fingers crossed that he might).
I'd rather us risking all the rest of that last £2m we estimate he's worth now, in trying to cultivate him a bit more. The worst that happens is he goes for a free transfer after he turns out to be really pants and we lose the last £2m that we estimate we could get. On the flip side we could find that he really does cut the mustard in the Prem after some hard work and ends up with a £15m price tag on his head. I'm sure most of us would be reasonably happy to see Palace sign a player for £2m that shows a bit of potential so why not risk keeping on one we already have?
Edited by Part Time James (30 Apr 2014 2.57pm)
|
Andy_G Wimbledon 30 Apr 14 3.01pm |
|
Quote Gyro1780 at 30 Apr 2014 12.20am
Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm
We might all be eating our words come next season.
I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.
Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.
Wd snap hands off for 2M.
I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.
I'm joining you on the record and say he will be a very good player in the next couple of years.
The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years
|
sydtheeagle England 30 Apr 14 3.16pm |
|
Quote Esteban at 29 Apr 2014 11.48pm
Jesus, you lot are a miserable bunch of bumsniffers! This has got to be our best season in the Loadsadosh league and all you can do is pick on a player who you possibly watched for an hour all season and then you decide he's no good based on what? Nothing intelligent!
You've got to be a troll because the reasons this is an unbelievably dim-witted post are about ten miles long starting with the fact that most contributors to this thread also contribute to hundreds of other threads too so they are hardly and picking on Gayle as the only thing worth talking about and secondly because -- (you seem unaware of this so let me allow you into a really big secret )-- this is the Internet and it actually exists as a forum for people to air their opinions about subjects like Gayle.
Like I said, troll.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
slubglurge welling 30 Apr 14 3.51pm |
|
Quote Andy_G at 30 Apr 2014 3.01pm
Quote Gyro1780 at 30 Apr 2014 12.20am
Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm
We might all be eating our words come next season.
I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.
Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.
Wd snap hands off for 2M.
I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.
I'm joining you on the record and say he will be a very good player in the next couple of years.
Put me on that record as well!
|
Plane Bromley 30 Apr 14 4.00pm |
|
Quote slubglurge at 30 Apr 2014 3.51pm
Quote Andy_G at 30 Apr 2014 3.01pm
Quote Gyro1780 at 30 Apr 2014 12.20am
Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm
We might all be eating our words come next season.
I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.
Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.
Wd snap hands off for 2M.
I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.
I'm joining you on the record and say he will be a very good player in the next couple of years.
Put me on that record as well!
As if anyone had any doubts as to where I stand, I'll go on record with you guys, he won't be sold in the closed season either.
|
Kingvagabond London 30 Apr 14 4.06pm |
|
Quote Plane at 30 Apr 2014 4.00pm
Quote slubglurge at 30 Apr 2014 3.51pm
Quote Andy_G at 30 Apr 2014 3.01pm
Quote Gyro1780 at 30 Apr 2014 12.20am
Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm
We might all be eating our words come next season.
I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.
Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.
Wd snap hands off for 2M.
I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.
I'm joining you on the record and say he will be a very good player in the next couple of years.
Put me on that record as well!
As if anyone had any doubts as to where I stand, I'll go on record with you guys, he won't be sold in the closed season either.
Record me up baby.
Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation @KingvagabondHOL
Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am
He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........
|
sydtheeagle England 30 Apr 14 4.17pm |
|
|
One thing that's interesting is just how divisive Gayle is in terms of opinions. We have a few players whose popularity is somewhat "mixed" but with most of them -- KG for example -- many of us can see both sides of the coin. But where Gayle is concerned, most of us are firmly in one camp or the other (he'll develop or no, he won't). Not much point repeating what I've already said about my own view though I admire the faith of the pro-Gayle camp because there is certainly no real physical evidence to support the belief that he will become a Premiership striker at this point in time. Anyway, the summer will be revealing; I am genuinely fascinated to see whether we stick or twist.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
Happiness Stan Itchycoo Park 30 Apr 14 4.22pm |
|
|
To confirm : my statement is that he will not be one a proven premiership striker. I wd love to be proven wrong, but let's wait and see.
Saying he cd become like a new Defoe is crazy. Defoes positional sense, running off the ball and ability to lose his marker, has been brilliant for years. It's what's made him the player he is.
Gayle seems a good finisher but that's it. I have no idea what he's like on the training field, but unless he is incredibly dedicated and hard working, I dont see him catching up in the areas he is lacking in.
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"
|
Happiness Stan Itchycoo Park 30 Apr 14 4.29pm |
|
|
And on 20k per week, how long do you continue to hold out for a players potential?
If he was a local lad thru the youth team on 5k pw then great, keep him at the club as back up and to provide a but of pace off the bench.
But given we have already paid 4.5m last Summer, and 1.5m this jan (got this on v good authority), plus approximately 1m in wages, it really does look like a shocking bit of business.p
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"
|
eaglesmad Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 30 Apr 14 4.30pm |
|
|
Gayle has the X Factor, just needs tweaking (TP your on).
and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........
|
Ulysses 30 Apr 14 4.33pm |
|
|
I truly believe he'll come good. Based on Parish's interview, it certainly seems like Gayle has potentially a significant role next season. Look at how quickly Pulis shipped out players that he didn't fancy for one reason or another: Kebe, Garvan, Hunt, Phillips, Campana, not to mention the ones that can't even get on the bench.
I think it's safe to say that TP sees something very special in Gayle. And that's good enough for me.
|
coulsdoneagle London 30 Apr 14 4.39pm |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 4.17pm
One thing that's interesting is just how divisive Gayle is in terms of opinions. We have a few players whose popularity is somewhat "mixed" but with most of them -- KG for example -- many of us can see both sides of the coin. But where Gayle is concerned, most of us are firmly in one camp or the other (he'll develop or no, he won't). Not much point repeating what I've already said about my own view though I admire the faith of the pro-Gayle camp because there is certainly no real physical evidence to support the belief that he will become a Premiership striker at this point in time. Anyway, the summer will be revealing; I am genuinely fascinated to see whether we stick or twist.
Glen Murray played about 20 games this season including starts scored 0 goals from open play and 1 pen
Gayle Played about 20 games this season, all bit part appearences at the end of games scored 3 goals 2 open play and 1 pen
Scored against a top 4 side and scored the goal of the season for us
he clearly has ability but has been rushed from non league to the toughest league in the world.
|
sydtheeagle England 30 Apr 14 4.41pm |
|
Quote Ulysses at 30 Apr 2014 4.33pm
I truly believe he'll come good. Based on Parish's interview, it certainly seems like Gayle has potentially a significant role next season. Look at how quickly Pulis shipped out players that he didn't fancy for one reason or another: Kebe, Garvan, Hunt, Phillips, Campana, not to mention the ones that can't even get on the bench.
I think it's safe to say that TP sees something very special in Gayle. And that's good enough for me.
Leaving Gayle aside, I think the players you ship out is as much a matter of what offers you have and whether you think they're worth accepting as it is what you'd actually like to do in a more abstract sense. If there is a lot of interest in Gayle or any other player and that interest is expressed in, let's say, "generous" bids, then it makes it more likely that player will be sold even if that is not the initial plan or intention. I would imagine we do have maybe two or three "not for sale at (almost) any cost" players (Jedinak, Ward, and Dann would likely be on this list) but I seriously doubt Gayle is on it. Furthermore, managers see players in the context of what the money their sale raises could be used for. TP may like Gayle but if he is offered a sum that he could re-invest in another player he likes more (and who is more Premiership-proven) then you tell me what he will probably do? My only point here is that there are moving parts in the equation that none of us really understand but imaging a player could have a potentially significant role next season really doesn't mean much in the scheme of things when next season is three month's away. I would say the only certainty is that next season's team may look more different from this season's side than many of us think.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
seeweedhater London 30 Apr 14 4.42pm |
|
|
He gets a big yes from me,see it now.
Palace find a gem,chelski offer 20m
|
Icepick Tony Chester 30 Apr 14 4.56pm |
|
Quote Happiness Stan at 30 Apr 2014 4.22pm
To confirm : my statement is that he will not be one a proven premiership striker. I wd love to be proven wrong, but let's wait and see.
Saying he cd become like a new Defoe is crazy. Defoes positional sense, running off the ball and ability to lose his marker, has been brilliant for years. It's what's made him the player he is.
Gayle seems a good finisher but that's it. I have no idea what he's like on the training field, but unless he is incredibly dedicated and hard working, I dont see him catching up in the areas he is lacking in.
But that is the hardest part. Running channels and losing a marker can be taught. Having a sniff at goal and being able to stick the ball away is worth a lot more as you either have it or you don't.
I think Parish summed it up in his interview, the price tag, hype and expectation was all to much for a guy who was playing non league 2 seasons ago. A season being in the Prem and training with decent coaches will have boosted his confidence and with a decent pre-season and stronger team behind him, next season he could flourish. His goal at Villa and the way he brought the ball down and went past Ferdinand at Utd. showed me enough to realise he has enough about him to be a top player and certainly capable of getting double figures in this league. The biggest factor for me is whether our style of play and formation will suit him enough to achieve it.
"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway
|
Eagle Fever 30 Apr 14 4.59pm |
|
Quote Andy_G at 30 Apr 2014 3.01pm
Quote Gyro1780 at 30 Apr 2014 12.20am
Quote Happiness Stan at 29 Apr 2014 8.26pm
Quote Proper_Gander at 29 Apr 2014 4.07pm
We might all be eating our words come next season.
I'm going to go on record right now and say we won't.
Way too far behind in basic football intelligence, positional sense, off the ball runs and work rate. If he was 19/20 I'd say he's a prospect. At 24 it's just too late.
Wd snap hands off for 2M.
I'm going on record now to say that Gayle will have a big part to play next season & you'll all be glad we kept him.
I'm joining you on the record and say he will be a very good player in the next couple of years.
Me too, Tony Pullis is not trying to make us another Stoke and think we may see more of players like Gayle and Joniesta.
WE ARE ROLLING
|
Kermit8 Hevon 30 Apr 14 5.03pm |
|
Quote Happiness Stan at 30 Apr 2014 4.29pm
And on 20k per week, how long do you continue to hold out for a players potential?
If he was a local lad thru the youth team on 5k pw then great, keep him at the club as back up and to provide a but of pace off the bench.
But given we have already paid 4.5m last Summer, and 1.5m this jan (got this on v good authority), plus approximately 1m in wages, it really does look like a shocking bit of business.p
Preaching to the converted here.
I get the impression the cup half-full'ers were also the ones that thought Holloway was doing a good enoughd job throughout his tenure and should stay when it was obvious - to some of us anyway - that the team were under-performing.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Kingvagabond London 30 Apr 14 5.11pm |
|
Quote coulsdoneagle at 30 Apr 2014 4.39pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 4.17pm
One thing that's interesting is just how divisive Gayle is in terms of opinions. We have a few players whose popularity is somewhat "mixed" but with most of them -- KG for example -- many of us can see both sides of the coin. But where Gayle is concerned, most of us are firmly in one camp or the other (he'll develop or no, he won't). Not much point repeating what I've already said about my own view though I admire the faith of the pro-Gayle camp because there is certainly no real physical evidence to support the belief that he will become a Premiership striker at this point in time. Anyway, the summer will be revealing; I am genuinely fascinated to see whether we stick or twist.
Glen Murray played about 20 games this season including starts scored 0 goals from open play and 1 pen
Gayle Played about 20 games this season, all bit part appearences at the end of games scored 3 goals 2 open play and 1 pen
Scored against a top 4 side and scored the goal of the season for us
he clearly has ability but has been rushed from non league to the toughest league in the world.
Don't get me wrong, I agree about gayle but no idea where you get your stats from regarding Murray but they're completely erroneous - murray's played 20 games? I'll have what you're smoking.
Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation @KingvagabondHOL
Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am
He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........
|