ghosteagle 07 Jan 15 5.29pm |
|
Quote eagles2011 at 07 Jan 2015 5.23pm
I expect the supporters of other teams due to play Oldham are already composing appropriate chants
Makes you wonder why anybody would hire him, regardless of guilt, as the focus of every game will be him. Got to affect the rest of the team surely?
|
Old Chap Orpington 07 Jan 15 9.21pm |
|
Quote eagles2011 at 07 Jan 2015 5.23pm
I expect the supporters of other teams due to play Oldham are already composing appropriate chants
Bet HF could come up with some
Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 07 Jan 15 10.35pm |
|
Quote Sg Bilko at 07 Jan 2015 5.04pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm
Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm
Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm
Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.
so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.
Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.
Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???
The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.
Still a piece of sh*t given he obtain a key card to get into a room where his friend was having sex with a girl so that he could have sex with her.
You keep batting on about it, I hope you man enough to apologize if he wins the review, and that could well happen.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission(CCRC) is conducting an investigation into Evans's conviction, I just read an article about it and some legal experts are very uncomfortable about his conviction especially as there was no violence involved and the girl only complained sometime later, and if the CCRC are investigating there must be doubts as they don't do that lightly.
She complained the next day.
I could care less if he wins the review, anyone who even remotely thinks what he did was not premeditated and planned with his mate is naive. The CCRC are bound to review any case that's put before them.
If he gets away with it, he'll just join the ranks of countless other men who got away with raping a woman.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 07 Jan 15 10.38pm |
|
Quote LABoxers at 07 Jan 2015 3.14pm
Im still not really sure why drunkerly raping somebody is so much worse than drunkernly killing 2 children ala Luke McCormick.
EDIT:- I guess it is partly to do with accepting responsibility and showing remorse, after I've thought about it a little more.
Edited by LABoxers (07 Jan 2015 3.15pm)
Deliberate intent vs accident. For all of Luke McCormicks faults it would be erroneous to believe he had a deliberate attempt to kill two children. Where as Evans raped someone (and in all likelihood conspired to do so, with forethought and deliberate intention).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 07 Jan 15 10.41pm |
|
Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 1.21pm
Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 12.58pm
Quote black eagle. at 07 Jan 2015 12.32pm
Ched Evans served 2 and a half years for rape,he's victim will have to live with the rape for ever.
so for her it's a life sentence,probably still having nightmares,should he sign for Oldham attendances will drop and sponsors will no longer sponsor the latics.
Sad day for football if this piece off sh!t is allowed to continue playing football.
Is he a piece of sh*t if he is actually innocent or has a favourable case review though???
The problem with rape cases such as this is you have one drunk party claiming consensual sex and one drunken party claiming rape - physical evidence is very thin on the ground so its essentially down to a group of 12 member of the general public picking their favourite of two stories.
The evidance against Evans were very strong,if he plays football again i hope someone breaks he's leg in his first game and he never plays football again.
Not to mention that Evans, under caution to the police admitted to having sex with the victim. All they have to do then is show 'its reasonable' to believe she was incapable of giving reasonable consent.
Like the footage prior to the event, of her staggering, or the fact she was sick (something Evans acknowledge to the Night Manager on leaving).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
gambler Kent 07 Jan 15 10.41pm |
|
|
Someone should get him pissed then f*** him in the arse. See if he thinks its acceptable then.
|
Ray in Houston Houston 07 Jan 15 11.21pm |
|
|
The part that always get overlooked in these types of scenarios is any kind of motive for the victim to be lying. This girl has suffered an egregious personal indignity, had to endure the court system and all of its humiliating machinations (legitimate, in the pursuit of truth) and has since had her life turned into a living hell. Why the eff would she perpetuate a lie through all of that?
Meanwhile, Evans admits to having sex with a girl who he - by his own words - knew to be drunk. He has been defending his reputation, liberty and career ever since. To me, there is a massive imbalance between Evans and the girl as to who has motive to be lying. And it's not in Evans' favour.
Here's a simple tip for all of us with a Y chromosome: unless you get explicit consent, hopefully enthusiastically explicit consent, don't have sex with her. Also, she can withdraw her consent at any time up to and including during the vinegar strokes; your desire to nut does not override her personal rights. Basically, if you're not sure, go home and knock one out - everyone will be happier for it.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
Stirlingsays 08 Jan 15 1.53am |
|
Quote We are goin up! at 07 Jan 2015 3.39pm
Quote The Sash at 07 Jan 2015 1.51pm
Doesn't make him a rapist though.
If someone is convicted of rape you have to assume that he is a rapist otherwise our criminal justice system will always be completely undermined.
No you don't.
The criminal justice system is human and occasionally makes mistakes and any sensible person factors that into how they view it.
Just accepting all its verdicts as the complete 'truth' is to me unrealistic and has been proven so false many many times.
Where it can the justice system tries to correct mistakes......This isn't undermining the process but instead a recognition of its actual purpose.
Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2015 2.07am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 08 Jan 15 2.06am |
|
|
Being someone who helped run a pub for five years in their twenties and spent a time as a bouncer in nightclubs and in both instances saw quite a bit of stuff I'm inherently suspicious of the certainties that Jamie and others have as too this ladies capabilities.
This case to me is rife with possibilities.....What I can know from the evidence is that this guy Ched is a t***...I can say that it's possible that he raped this girl. What I can't say with reasonable certainty is that he did.....From what I've heard of the evidence this conviction should never have stood.
But it's atypical with where the courts are heading with rape.
Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2015 2.17am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 08 Jan 15 2.16am |
|
Quote Ray in Houston at 07 Jan 2015 11.21pm
The part that always get overlooked in these types of scenarios is any kind of motive for the victim to be lying. This girl has suffered an egregious personal indignity, had to endure the court system and all of its humiliating machinations (legitimate, in the pursuit of truth) and has since had her life turned into a living hell. Why the eff would she perpetuate a lie through all of that?
Meanwhile, Evans admits to having sex with a girl who he - by his own words - knew to be drunk. He has been defending his reputation, liberty and career ever since. To me, there is a massive imbalance between Evans and the girl as to who has motive to be lying. And it's not in Evans' favour.
Here's a simple tip for all of us with a Y chromosome: unless you get explicit consent, hopefully enthusiastically explicit consent, don't have sex with her. Also, she can withdraw her consent at any time up to and including during the vinegar strokes; your desire to nut does not override her personal rights. Basically, if you're not sure, go home and knock one out - everyone will be happier for it.
The motive could be money via compensation or newspaper/media money.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 08 Jan 15 2.20am |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Jan 2015 10.41pm
Not to mention that Evans, under caution to the police admitted to having sex with the victim. All they have to do then is show 'its reasonable' to believe she was incapable of giving reasonable consent.
Like the footage prior to the event, of her staggering, or the fact she was sick (something Evans acknowledge to the Night Manager on leaving).
Yeah Jamie, girls who have been staggering and have been sick don't remain conscious during sex shortly afterwards.
Blimey.....This happens all the bleeding time.
Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2015 2.21am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
derby eagle Derby 08 Jan 15 7.40am |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Jan 2015 2.06am
Being someone who helped run a pub for five years in their twenties and spent a time as a bouncer in nightclubs and in both instances saw quite a bit of stuff I'm inherently suspicious of the certainties that Jamie and others have as too this ladies capabilities.
This case to me is rife with possibilities.....What I can know from the evidence is that this guy Ched is a t***...I can say that it's possible that he raped this girl. What I can't say with reasonable certainty is that he did.....From what I've heard of the evidence this conviction should never have stood.
But it's atypical with where the courts are heading with rape.
Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2015 2.17am)
A jury seemed quite comfortable convicting him and they sat through all of the evidence. No one here did. There is jo new evidence, so there is very little chance of this being overturned and neither should it be. Unless of course every time a conviction is against our own inclination it gets overturned if the majority of the public don't like it as well. The arrogant cvnt is guilty, get over it and move on.
|
JohnB 08 Jan 15 8.20am |
|
|
Based on a lot of the posts in here deeming rape as girl gets drunk, stumbles, does a sick, gives a BJ and has a dirty wet put in her, I reckon there must be about 50 rapes a day in the summer months in just Ibiza, Magaluf and Malia alone.
I'm not saying he did or didn't rape her, I just think a lot of people are very quick to say he did with a real matter of fact attitude and then back it up with 'he was convicted'. There are a hell of a lot of wrong convictions, it's not unthinkable to think this may be one of them and the reason he shows little remorse is he is adamant he took part in consensual sex, whether his way of doing it was exceptionally sleazy or not.
|
derby eagle Derby 08 Jan 15 8.45am |
|
Quote JohnB at 08 Jan 2015 8.20am
Based on a lot of the posts in here deeming rape as girl gets drunk, stumbles, does a sick, gives a BJ and has a dirty wet put in her, I reckon there must be about 50 rapes a day in the summer months in just Ibiza, Magaluf and Malia alone.
I'm not saying he did or didn't rape her, I just think a lot of people are very quick to say he did with a real matter of fact attitude and then back it up with 'he was convicted'. There are a hell of a lot of wrong convictions, it's not unthinkable to think this may be one of them and the reason he shows little remorse is he is adamant he took part in consensual sex, whether his way of doing it was exceptionally sleazy or not.
It's not unthinkable. But where is the new evidence? I though Gerrard was a tad lucky to get away with the assault charge but in the eyes of the law he's not guilty. Without any new evidence nothing will change and nor should it. We live in jury based evidential system and the appeal system has said his conviction is safe. His latest attempt has about as much chance as any of us have of jumping liz hurley and her saying yes that was great.
|
Old Chap Orpington 08 Jan 15 9.00am |
|
|
In the Mirror it says Evans fiancee's dad has promised to make up any income lost by sponsors pulling out
Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?
|
rednblue4eva Norwood 08 Jan 15 9.27am |
|
|
Obviously can't know for sure, but perhaps the reason Macdonald didn't get charged was because he'd pulled, she may have been willing, she then got even more drunk but hadn't refused consent with Macdonald
Macdonald texted Evans who came round to the hotel by which time she was totally out of it so didn't give Evans consent
|
npn Crowborough 08 Jan 15 9.34am |
|
Quote derby eagle at 08 Jan 2015 8.45am
Quote JohnB at 08 Jan 2015 8.20am
Based on a lot of the posts in here deeming rape as girl gets drunk, stumbles, does a sick, gives a BJ and has a dirty wet put in her, I reckon there must be about 50 rapes a day in the summer months in just Ibiza, Magaluf and Malia alone.
I'm not saying he did or didn't rape her, I just think a lot of people are very quick to say he did with a real matter of fact attitude and then back it up with 'he was convicted'. There are a hell of a lot of wrong convictions, it's not unthinkable to think this may be one of them and the reason he shows little remorse is he is adamant he took part in consensual sex, whether his way of doing it was exceptionally sleazy or not.
It's not unthinkable. But where is the new evidence? I though Gerrard was a tad lucky to get away with the assault charge but in the eyes of the law he's not guilty. Without any new evidence nothing will change and nor should it. We live in jury based evidential system and the appeal system has said his conviction is safe. His latest attempt has about as much chance as any of us have of jumping liz hurley and her saying yes that was great.
That's why I think it's a bit naive to state "he's a rapist because the jury says so", because things change - if this case review decides there's scope for a retrial and he's then acquitted, what then "he's innocent because the jury says so"? Then where are we, an innocent man has been denied his liberty and subsequently his right to work.
I'm happy to say, as it stands, he's a convicted rapist, and treat him accordingly, but I'm afraid I can't be as certain of his guilt as some on here. It's like saying those scumbags who murdered Stephen Lawrence are all innocent (aside from the two currently inside) because a jury said so. I assume most people agree there's a good chance that they are guilty, even if it's not been proven sufficiently.
Not sure I'm making my point very well. I think I'm saying I agree that he should be treated as guilty or innocent based on his current legal status through the court system so as it stands today Evans is a rapist, but not necessarily that I will agree that that conviction/acquittal was correct (which makes you look a bit of a muppet when/if convictions are overturned)
|
JohnB 08 Jan 15 9.48am |
|
|
I would also hazard a bet that of all the people that have signed the petition to stop Evans playing for the relevant clubs, 90% of them milked themselves senseless over Tysons role in the Hangover movies despite being a convicted rapist....and biting a mans ear off.
|
Midlands Eagle 08 Jan 15 10.54am |
|
Quote derby eagle at 08 Jan 2015 7.40am
A jury seemed quite comfortable convicting him and they sat through all of the evidence. No one here did. There is no new evidence, so there is very little chance of this being overturned and neither should it be. Unless of course every time a conviction is against our own inclination it gets overturned if the majority of the public don't like it as well.
If the conviction is overturned it will be done on the basis of evidence and the rule of law and not on what the majority of the public want or don't want, which is completely irrelevant
|
Kingvagabond London 08 Jan 15 11.14am |
|
Quote derby eagle at 08 Jan 2015 7.40am
Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Jan 2015 2.06am
Being someone who helped run a pub for five years in their twenties and spent a time as a bouncer in nightclubs and in both instances saw quite a bit of stuff I'm inherently suspicious of the certainties that Jamie and others have as too this ladies capabilities.
This case to me is rife with possibilities.....What I can know from the evidence is that this guy Ched is a t***...I can say that it's possible that he raped this girl. What I can't say with reasonable certainty is that he did.....From what I've heard of the evidence this conviction should never have stood.
But it's atypical with where the courts are heading with rape.
Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2015 2.17am)
A jury seemed quite comfortable convicting him and they sat through all of the evidence. No one here did. There is jo new evidence, so there is very little chance of this being overturned and neither should it be. Unless of course every time a conviction is against our own inclination it gets overturned if the majority of the public don't like it as well. The arrogant cvnt is guilty, get over it and move on.
Here's the ironic thing, they didn't seem quite comfortable convicting him. There was no unanimous decision and so jury was informed that he would accept majority verdict. They were then told that both cases were completely different and despite it being a joint verdict they could give different outcomes for Donaldson and Evans. The judges summing up and directions to the jury was somewhat loaded and this was one of the things the original appeal focussed on. Eventually jury came back with unanimous decisions on both, innocent for Donaldson, guilty for Evans and thus avoided going into a fourth week.
Personally, its why I feel it may be time to go to trial by panel of judges as I feel they would achieve safer convictions or acquittals based on evidence not 'feelings'.
Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation @KingvagabondHOL
Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am
He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........
|